Learning Exchange: High Impact Practices as Signature Pedagogies
1. High Impact Practices as
Signature Pedagogies
CPED June 2015 Convening
CSU Fullerton
June 9, 2015
Audrey Hovannesian, EdD
Associate Director of Assessment
CSU Office of the Chancellor
2. AGENDA
Overview of CSU Student Success Climate
High Impact Practice Implementation Rationale
High Impact Practices (HIP)
Doctoral Signature Pedagogies
HIP and Signature Pedagogy Definition Sort
HIP and Signature Pedagogy Comparison
CSU HIP Implementation Model
Bridging Terminology and Practice
3.
4. Fall Enrollments in U.S. Degree-granting Institutions
source: National Center for Education Statistics
1869
52,286
1909
355,213
1949
2,659,021
1979
11,569,899
1999
14,791,224
today
20 million+
1910s
credit hour
5. whom we teach
1970
top 26%
2009
top 41%
enrollment rates of 18- to 24-year-olds
in degree-granting institutions
enrollment by Hispanics, African-Americans, and Asians:
enrollment by students eligible for financial aid:
15% 19%
1976 1990 2009
34%
30%
1976
46%
1990 2009
66%
Source: National Center for Education Statistics
6. Jobs have become more
intellectually demanding.
almost everything
portion of U.S. jobs requiring at least a two-year degree
1973
28%
2018
45%
Source: Georgetown Center on Education
and the Workforce
“Organizations are looking for employees
to use a broader set of skills and have
higher levels of learning and knowledge
than in the past.”
89%
rising expectations of employers
Source: Raising the Bar, Hart Research Associates
1973
28%
“Organizations are looking for employees
to use a broader set of skills and have
higher levels of learning and knowledge
than in the past.”
coordination
complexity
“Organizations are looking for employees
to use a broader set of skills and have
higher levels of learning and knowledge
than in the past.”
7. • Established in 1887
• 23 Campuses
• Over 440,000
students
• Over 40,000 staff
and faculty
• Largest campus
enrollment 37,000
9. baseline 2025 target
Six-year graduation rate 51% 60%
Four-year graduation rate 16% 24%
Gap by ethnicity 14 points 7 points
Gap by Pell eligibility 11 points 5 points
Transfer four-year rate 70% 76%
Transfer two-year rate 27% 35%
10. 0 01 12 23+ 3+
Latino/a not Latino/a
38%
55%
49%
63%
65%
68%
73%
69%
Source: CSU Northridge
Institutional Research
August, 2010
Graduation Rates by Ethnicity and participation in High-Impact Practices
11.
12. Participation in HIPs CSU Systemwide
Study
Abroad
Research
with Faculty
Service
Learning
Internship Capstone
Native
Transfer
Source: AAC&U and
NSSE Special Analysis
May, 2009
17
12
10
7
53
44
51
39
34
25
13. First-Year Seminars and Experiences
Intrusive Advising
Learning Communities
Undergraduate Research
Service Learning, Community-Based Learning
Internships
Capstone Courses and Projects
Common Intellectual Experiences
Diversity/Global Learning/Study Abroad
Collaborative Assignments and Projects
Writing-Intensive Courses
Early Alert
Mentor Services
Summer Bridge
Summer Transition (non-EOP summer bridge experiences)
Supplemental Instruction
Coordinated Student On-Campus Employment
Pedagogy Sphere
High Impact Practices (HIPs) are
techniques and designs for
teaching and learning that are
proven to be beneficial for student
engagement and successful
learning among students from
many backgrounds.
14. Shulman, 2005
Types of teaching that organize
the fundamental ways in which
future practitioners are educated
for their new professions.
Brown-Welty, Cohn, Rodriguez, 209
Zambo, 2010
Golde, 2007
Osterman, Furman, Sernak, 2014
Carnegie Foundation, 2006
Byrk,
Gomez,
Gruno
w, 2010
Englebart,
2003
The Journal Club
Action Research
Community Engagement
Leader–Scholar Community
Networked Improvement Communities
Completion of Dissertation
Embedded Fieldwork
The Professional Seminar
Research and Writing Seminar Sequence
The List
15. High Impact Practices Doctoral Signature
Pedagogies
First-Year Seminars and Experiences
Intrusive Advising
Learning Communities
Undergraduate Research
Service Learning, Community-Based Learning
Internships
Capstone Courses and Projects
Common Intellectual Experiences
Diversity/Global Learning/Study Abroad
Collaborative Assignments and Projects
Writing-Intensive Courses
Early Alert
Mentor Services
Summer Bridge
Summer Transition (non-EOP summer bridge
experiences)
Supplemental Instruction
Coordinated Student On-Campus Employment
Pedagogy Sphere
16. Definition Sort
High Impact Practices EdD Application
First-Year Seminars and Experiences
Intrusive Advising
Learning Communities
Undergraduate Research
Service Learning, Community-Based Learning
Internships
Capstone Courses and Projects
Common Intellectual Experiences
Diversity/Global Learning/Study Abroad
Collaborative Assignments and Projects
Writing-Intensive Courses
Early Alert
Mentor Services
Summer Bridge
Summer Transition (non-EOP summer bridge
experiences)
Supplemental Instruction
Coordinated Student On-Campus Employment
Pedagogy Sphere
17. Doctoral Signature Pedagogies
Doctoral Signature Pedagogies Undergraduate/Graduate
Application
First-Year Seminars and Experiences
Intrusive Advising
Learning Communities
Undergraduate Research
Service Learning, Community-Based Learning
Internships
Capstone Courses and Projects
Common Intellectual Experiences
Diversity/Global Learning/Study Abroad
Collaborative Assignments and Projects
Writing-Intensive Courses
Early Alert
Mentor Services
Summer Bridge
Summer Transition (non-EOP summer bridge experiences)
Supplemental Instruction
Coordinated Student On-Campus Employment
Pedagogy Sphere
20. First Year
High Impact Practice Delivery
Second Year
Third Year
Fourth Year…
Sixth Year
HIP Concerns
Selection Bias
Lack Valid
Metrics
Too Quick to
Label HIPs
Programs too
small to scale
21. CMS
capture store display
Academic and Student Success Programs (“ASSP”)
Gates-funded “Preparing to Scale High-Impact Practices”
Student Success Data Dashboard
“Data Readiness” and “Action Research” grants
Support for campus-based “Dashboard Leaders”
22. JAN
Preparing to Scale High Impact Practices (HIPs) Project
Timeframe: Short-term 8 month project
Goal: Scale HIPs and track HIP participation and
levels of engagement in baseline student data
23. JAN
Academic & Student Success Programs (ASSP)
15 CSU Campuses
Over 40 distinct student success programs
Timeframe: $7.2 million Annual Funding
Goals:
• Better define HIP
• Identify HIP effectiveness
• Identify common metrics
• Create best practice scaleable HIPs
24. JAN MAR
Pilot Partners
CSU/Gates
Foundation Preparing
to Scale High Impact
Practices Project
Model Campus
Inform initial tracking
process
Project Campuses
Academic &
Student Success
Programs
(ASSP)