Someone emailed me "your slide says the government is supposed to step in and somehow manage the economy, so it hires a lot of people to do this."
I replied Bush et al have used an expansionary approach. Believe me they did when i studied this back in 2012 - & most don't believe my level of comprehension. What I said is not on the slide.
Since i just get doubt when i explain since i am a person that loves economics but dont have any high fancy jobs to show for it...
SO I am not going to write an article instead i will present an article by someone on what I already realized back in 2012. The article is written in April 2016
"Expansionary Fiscal Policy: Definition, Examples: What Sets Bush and Obama Apart From Clinton" Link
Link - https://www.thebalance.com/expansionary-fiscal-policy-purpose-examples-how-it-works-3305792
Keynes on Marshall
“Marshall… arrived very early at the point of view that the bare bones of economic theory are not worth much in themselves and do not carry one far in the direction of useful, practical conclusions.
--Keynes, John Maynard (1924). “Alfred Marshall, 1842-1924.” The Economic Journal. v34, n135 (September), p. 342
2. 11/09/2010
2
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Keep In Mind! Two Approaches
The Subjective or Ideological Approach
Begin with a conclusion and collect data that fits your belief.
The Objective Approach
Begin with the evidence and then work towards a conclusion.
“Good” academic research doesn’t know the conclusion of
the study before the study starts.
This distinction can be better understood by discussing
Alfred Marshall, Microeconomist 1842-2924
The price and output of a good are determined by both
SUPPLY and DEMAND: the two that intersect at equilibrium.
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Basic Economic Concepts
Production possibilities curve
Comparative advantage, absolute advantage,
specialization, and exchange
Demand, supply, and market equilibrium
Macroeconomic issues: business cycle, unemployment,
inflation, growth
1. Basic Economic Concepts
3. 11/09/2010
3
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Production Possibilities
Assumptions:
Full Employment
Fixed Resources and Technology
Movements
Along curve shows opportunity cost
Outward shift illustrates economic growth
Inward shift indicates destruction of resources
Producing Capital Goods will lead to greater economic
growth than producing consumer goods. (Butter will lead
to more growth than cell phones)
1. Basic Economic Concepts
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Supply and Demand Factors
Demand Changes when:
Income changes
Related Products, complements and substitutes, (price or
quality change)
Expectations (future price change)
Consumers (more or less added)
Tastes, Fads, Preferences change
1. Basic Economic Concepts
4. 11/09/2010
4
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Demand Increase: As Demand Increases, Price and
Quantity Increase as well.
P1
P2
Q1 Q2
S1
D1
D2
Price
Quantity
1. Basic Economic Concepts
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
8
Business Cycles
The increases and decreases in Real GDP consisting of
four phases:
Peak: highest point of Real GDP
Recession: Real GDP declining for 6 months
Trough: lowest point of Real GDP
Recovery: Real GDP increasing (trough to peak)
1. Basic Economic Concepts
5. 11/09/2010
5
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
9
Business Cycle
Peak -- Greatest spending and lowest unemployment.
Inflation becomes a problem.
Contraction/Recession -- Reduction of spending levels and
increasing unemployment. Some cyclical unemployment
begins.
Trough -- Least spending and highest unemployment
Expansion -- Spending increases and unemployment
decreases
Full Employment
1. Basic Economic Concepts
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Are Business Cycles Real?
1. Basic Economic Concepts
6. 11/09/2010
6
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
2010
Year
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14AnnualPercentChange
-60
-30
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
210
GDP Growth
Inflation
Oil Prices, Inflation, Unemployment and the US
Economy
Oil Price
1. Basic Economic Concepts – End Slide
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Measurement of Economic
Performance
National income accounts
Circular flow
Gross domestic product
Components of gross domestic product
Real versus nominal gross domestic product
B. Inflation measurement and adjustment
Price indices
Nominal and real values
Costs of inflation
C. Unemployment
Definition and measurement
Types of unemployment
Natural rate of unemployment
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
7. 11/09/2010
7
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Circular Flow of Economic Activity
Households supply resources (land, labor, capital,
entrepreneurial ability) to the resource market. Households
demand goods and services from businesses.
Businesses demand household resources and supply goods
and services to the product (factor) market.
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
The total dollar (market) value of all final goods and
services produced in a given year.
Expenditure Formula:
Consumption (C) +
Business Investment (I) +
Government Spending (G) +
Net Exports (Xn)
Gross Domestic Product
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
8. 11/09/2010
8
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
GDP: What Counts:
Goods Produced but not Sold (I)
Goods produced by a foreign country (Japan) in the
U.S. (Honda, Toyota)
Government spending on the military
Increase in business inventories
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
GDP: What DOES NOT count:
Intermediate Goods (Tires sold by Firestone to Ford)
Used Goods
Non-Market Activities (Illegal, Underground)
Transfer Payments (Social Security)
Stock Transactions
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
9. 11/09/2010
9
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Inflation
Rise in the general level of prices
Reduces the purchasing power of money
Measured with the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
Reports the price of a market basket , more than 300
goods that are typically purchased by an urban
household
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Types of Inflation
Demand Pull Inflation: ‘too much money chasing too few
goods.”
AD Curve will shift to the right, resulting in a higher
Price Level and greater Output (until reaching Y*
Cost-Push Inflation: Major cause is a supply shock-
OPEC cutting back on oil production
AS Curve will shift to the left resulting in a higher Price
Level and a decrease in Real GDP.
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
10. 11/09/2010
10
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Inflation: Winners & Losers
Winners:
Debtors who borrow money that will be repaid with
“cheap” dollars.
Those who have anticipated inflation
Losers:
Savers (especially savings accounts)
Creditors (Banks will be repaid with those “cheap”
dollars
Fixed-Income Recipients (retirees receiving the same
monthly pension)
2. Measurement of Economic Performance
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
National Income and Price
Determination
Aggregate demand
Determinants of aggregate demand
Multiplier and crowding-out effects
Aggregate supply
Short-run and long-run analyses
Sticky versus flexible wages and prices
Determinants of aggregate supply
Macroeconomic equilibrium
Real output and price level
Short and long run
3. Actual versus full-employment output
3. National Income and Price Determination
11. 11/09/2010
11
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Aggregate Supply/Demand Curve
It is based on the theory of John Maynard Keynes
The AD/AS model is used to illustrate the Keynesian model of
the business cycle.
3. National Income and Price Determination
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
4. Financial Sector (Money and
Banking)
Money, banking, and financial markets
Time value of money (present and future value)
Measures of money supply
Banks and creation of money
Money market
Loanable funds market
Central bank and control of the money supply
Tools of central bank policy
Quantity theory of money
Real versus nominal interest rates
4. Financial Sector (Money and Banking)
13. 11/09/2010
13
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
The Federal Reserve System (FED)
Control Monetary Policy
Headquartered in Washington D.C.
12 Federal Reserve Districts
Board of Governors (7 members) is the central authority
Members are appointed by the President and confirmed
by the Senate with staggerred 12 year terms
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
26
Banks and Balance Sheets
Assets Liabilities
Reserves $15,000 in Checkable Deposits $100,000
Securities $15,000
Loans $70,000
If the current reserve requirement is 10%:
1. What is the amount of new loans this bank can generate?
Checkable deposits $100,000 with a 10% reserve requirement =
$10,000.
2. The bank has $15,000 in reserves, $5,000 of those are excess reserves
and can be loaned out.
4. Financial Sector (Money and Banking)
14. 11/09/2010
14
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Balance Sheet Description: The
Banks
Citibank
∆R -$100 ∆D -$100
Chase
∆R +$100 ∆D +$100
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
∆R +$100 (Chase)
∆R - $100 (Citibank)
Any change in Bank Reserves is noted on the liability side of the
Federal Reserve
4. Financial Sector (Money and Banking)
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Federal Reserve
4. Financial Sector (Money and Banking)
Working
balance
in spending
and
tax revenues
Fed’s most important tool to alter reserves
15. 11/09/2010
15
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Fed Exchange Market Intervention
Suppose that the Federal Reserve is
concerned about an excessive
downward movement of the US
exchange rate. It intervenes by
using its holdings of foreign
currency to buy dollars (then
remove the dollars from the system).
4. Financial Sector (Money and Banking)
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Inflation, Unemployment, and
Stabilization Policies
Fiscal and monetary policies
Demand-side effects
Supply-side effects
Policy mix
Government deficits and debt
Inflation and unemployment
Types of inflation
Demand-pull inflation
Cost-push inflation
The Phillips curve: short run versus long run
Role of expectations
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
16. 11/09/2010
16
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Fiscal Policy
Using Taxes and Government spending to stabilize the
economy.
Controlled by the President and Congress
Discretionary Fiscal Policy: Congress must take action
(change the tax rates) in order for the action to be
implemented.
Automatic Stabilizers: Unemployment benefits,
Progressive Tax System, these changes are implemented
automatically to help the economy.
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Types of Fiscal Policy
Expansionary - TODAY?
Used to Fight a Recession
LOWER TAXES
INCREASE GOVERNMENT SPENDING
Contractionary
Used to fight Inflation
RAISE TAXES
DECREASE GOVERNMENT SPENDING
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
17. 11/09/2010
17
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Recession
Mainstream economists must decide whether to target
the Price Level or Unemployment, before taking any
action.
Classical economists would argue to DO NOTHING.
Eventually, wages and resource prices must decrease
and when they do the SRAS curve will shift back to
the right, restoring the economy to its full-
employment output level and the original Price Level.
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Decide Price Level - Expansionary
Fiscal Policy
Goal > Move the aggregate demand curve to the left.
Government spending leads to an increase in interest
rates.
Foreigners demand more U.S. dollars to invest in bonds
Results in appreciation of the U.S. dollar
Decrease in Net Exports
Decreases Investment
Decreases AD
PriceLevel
Real GDP
AD1
P1
P2
AD2
AS
When Supply increases
(productivity surge in 90s)
more than demand,
Prices will fall.
GDP and employment go up
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
18. 11/09/2010
18
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Fight Unemployment
(Prof.) Phillips curve relates change in wages
and unemployment.
Short-Run Phillips Curve Inverse relationship
between inflation rate to the unemployment rate.
Pull Inflation
Prices rise, people demand higher wages
High unemployment reduces inflation
Inflation
Rate
(percent)
Unemployment Rate (percent)
A
B
7
2
4 6
SRPC1
5
OPEC decreasing Oil
supply causes shift
of Line
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Economic Philosophies
Classical: Believe that the GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT
interfere in the economy and in self-correction.
Keynesian: Believe that GOVERNMENT SHOULD interfere
in the economy. Most “mainstream” economists are Keynesians.
Central role is peoples expectations.
Rational Expectations: (More a model) Believe that any
consistent monetary and fiscal policy will be learned and
anticipated by the population. Thus, the outcome depends partly
on what people expect to happen So manipulate the economy to
induce false expectations(Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition).
5. Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization
Policies
19. 11/09/2010
19
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
The Marshall Way
Step One: Math can be used, but only as a “shorthand
language.”
Step Two: Any math should be translated into words.
Step Three: A theory should be illustrated by examples
that are “important in real life.”
Step Four: With words and real world illustrations in
hand, you can now “burn the mathematics.”
Step Five: If you cannot find any real world examples,
burn the theory.
Marshall’s Lesson: Analysis must relate to the world we
observe.
AIChE Annual Conference, 2012, Pittsburgh, D. Matonis
Questions