Introducing concepts of Injury Prevention to mid-level Emergency Care Providers in the District Hospital setting in rural Sub-Saharan Africa.
An interactive lecture made for the Global Emergency Care Collaborative.
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
Â
Introduction to Injury Prevention - An interactive discussion for senior and qualified ECPs at Nyakibale Hospital in Rukungiri Uganda
1. Introduction to
Injury Prevention
An interactive discussion for senior and
qualified ECPs
Nyakibale Hospital
Rukungiri, Uganda
Farooq Khan MDCM,
PGY4 Emergency Medicine
McGill University, Montreal, Canada
2. The learning contract
• We are all equal and deserve respect
• We are all knowledgeable in some areas
and deficient in others
• We are all here to learn from each other
• No question is a bad question
• Feel free to participate in the discussion
with your questions and comments
3. Goals
• After this session you should be able to:
1. Define 2 different types of prevention
2. Understand why injury prevention is
important in your region
3. List 5 simple but effective injury prevention
measures for road safety
4. Identify 5 basic areas of injury prevention for
children
5. Appreciate how you can be involved in injury
prevention
6. International statistics
• RTAs are #9 cause of death worldwide in
2004 and expected to rise to #5 by 2030.
• 20% of these deaths are in Africa (even
though it has <2% of vehicles)
• #4 leading cause of death in age 5-44 in
Africa
• More males affected than females
7.
8.
9. National statistics
• 2800 reported deaths/year due to RTAs in
Uganda
• Estimate is closer to 7600 due to lack of
reporting
• 12 000 non-fatal injuries/year due to RTA
13. Treatment in the ED
• What are the limitations of your environment?
14. Treatment outside the ED
• Prehospital care – no system in place yet to
bring patients emergently to hospital after
accidents
• Referral for specialized care
– Shortage of general surgeons, only 75 for 27 million
people
– Specialists few and concentrated in major cities
(Mbarara/Kampala) e.g. only 6 neurosurgeons
– Costly and difficult to access
• May not be able to reach in timely manner even if affordable
16. What are risk factors for
injuries?
Take the example of RTAs
17. 5 simple but effective injury
prevention measures
For RTAs
18.
19. Seatbelts
• Save more lives than any other
intervention
– Reduce the risk of death by 61%
– Child restraint reduces death by 71%
• Very little use in East Africa (close to 1%)
• Mandatory by law for all passengers in
Uganda
– Poorly enforced, especially in rural areas
• Community education is needed
20.
21. Alcohol
• Drinking and driving increases risk of
death x17
• Especially in young drivers
• Legal limit in Uganda = 0.08 g/dl
– Poor enforcement
• Community education is needed
22.
23. Speeding
• A pedestrian hit by a car at 30km/h has
90% chance of survival
– <50% chance at 45 km/h
– Almost 0% at 80 km/h
• Death increases x20 from 30-80 km/h
• Speed limits also poorly enforced in region
• Community education is needed
24.
25. Helmets
• Reduce risk of fatal or serious head injury
by 45% in riders of bicycles and boda-
bodas
• Few people wear helmets in Uganda
despite police enforcement
– Availability, cost, weight, heat, discomfort,
impaired hearing, cosmetics
– Lack of education about risks
• Community education is needed
26.
27. Visibility
• Daytime-running lights in boda-bodas and
cars reduce accidents by 15%
• Brake lights reduce accidents up to 50%
• Bicycle lights reduce collisions by 30%
• Wearing white helmets and brightly
colored or reflective clothing reduces
collisions by up to 45%
• Community education is needed
31. Burns
• In Africa, child death from burns is 6x
more than high income countries
• In rural areas it is associated with:
– Use of cooking pots on ground level near
toddlers and young children
– Use of open wood fire
– Use of paraffin stoves and lamps that can be
knocked over and ignite
– Wearing of loose cotton clothing around fire
32. Burns
• Families should be encouraged to:
– Build enclosures around open fires
– Use safer stoves or lamps if possible
– Wear tighter or less flammable clothing
around the fire
– Learn about basic first aid for burns and how
to access emergency services
33.
34. Falls
• Parent education should include:
– Increased supervision of younger children
• i.e. Do not leave unattended on high surfaces
– Modifying the home environment
• e.g. Floor padding/barriers on windows
• Advocacy at the community level should include:
– Encouragement of safer play areas
• e.g. Discourage climbing of tall trees
– Barriers around hazardous environments
• i.e. Tall trees, wells, pits, ditches, walls
35. Falls
• One of the leading causes of death and
disability in children in Africa
• Most often due to head or spinal cord
injury
• Children who can walk/run are at higher
risk
– Young children fall more at home
– Older children fall in outside the home i.e. in
schools, public/recreational areas
36.
37. Drowning
• Rate of drowning is 6x higher in Africa
• Greatest in age 1-4
• Need to educate community about safety
– Placing barriers around water sources
• Ponds/irrigation ditches
– Covering wells
– Have escape mechanism (ropes)
– Teach basic resuscitation skills
38.
39. Poisoning
• Child death by accidental poisoning is 3-4x
higher in Africa than the rest of the world and is
due to:
– Medicines (belonging to other family members)
– Illegal drugs/alcohol
– Fuels and solvents
– Pesticides/Household chemicals
– Poisonous plants/Animals/insects (snake) bites
– Carbon monoxide (indoor fires)
40. Poisoning
• Education of parents and communities
should include
– Removing toxic agents from the community
– Reducing the quantity/concentration of toxic
substances
– Using safe packaging techniques
– Encouraging safe storage of
substances/medications
– Using protective clothing around pesticides
44. ECPs are unique because:
• Regional experts in emergency care
• Real-life experience in ED with multiple
patients
• Understanding of impact of environment
and behavior on health
• Understanding of life and challenges of
Rukungiri community
• Respected by the community
45. How can you help?
• Educate and counsel patients at the time of
injury
– Prevent the next one! (Secondary Prevention)
• Outreach to community
– Talk to the right people
• Village elders
• Village health teams
• Schools, churches, community centers
• Boda-boda drivers
– Distribute posters/materials
• Collaborate with other health centers or
departments
– They may already be doing similar work
46.
47.
48. How can you help in the right way?
• Focus your efforts on the intervention that
is most important to do in your area
– Check the data in your trauma registry
• Which injuries are most frequent?
• Which are most severe?
49. How can you help in the right way?
• Choose intervention that is most likely to
work
– Low cost
– Requires few human resources
– Utilizes existing networks
– High chance of acceptance by society
50. How can you help in the right way?
• Check if the intervention is successful
– Collect injury surveillance data and follow it
– Analyze and publish the data to prove to
hospital administration that it can be effective
– Use the same data to prove to ministries and
other organizations that it is worth funding and
expanding
51. Reminder of Goals
Can you:
1. Define 2 different types of prevention
2. Understand why injury prevention is
important in your region
3. List 5 simple but effective injury prevention
measures for road safety
4. Identify 5 basic areas of injury prevention for
children
5. Appreciate how you can be involved in injury
prevention
How is prevention different from treatment? What kind of prevention do you do in the ED? e.g. malaria Treatment of malaria (coartem or quinine) 2’ Prevention of complications (fever control, seizure control, hydration, etc.) 1’ prevention counseling, bed nets, reduce standing water sources etc. E.g. cut wound Treatment STS 2’ prevention, irrigation of wound, TT 1’ prevention? What caused this cut wound? e.g. head injury Treatment: repair of laceration and control of bleeding, in severe cases neurosurgery 2’ prevention, give oxygen prevent hypoxia, give NS or blood, prevent hypotension, give diazepam, prevent post-traumatic epilepsy
Status report on road safety in countries of the WHO African Region 2009
Examples of conditions whose definitive treatment is not possible in the district hospital setting
Limitations: Delay in seeking treatment: due to alcohol, difficulties in rescuing/extracting people, lack of transport/means to come to Nyakibale, patients’ lack of knowledge about services Certain surgical services cannot be offered here: requirement of intubation and ventilation, hemorrhage in the brain, severe pelvic bleeding, If too many patients come at the same time, then you may not be able to attend to all them in time to give life-saving treatment
Lancet Feb 2008 - Africa ’s neglected surgical workforce crisis
So if treatment is not enough, perhaps prevention is what is needed How does one figure out what interventions can prevent injuries? Think about risk factors
What do you think causes more severe injuries? Pick a type of RTA Pedestrian (speed, visibility, behavior, alcohol) Bodaboda/bicycle (helmets, speed, behaviors, alcohol) Cars/trucks (seatbelts, speed, behaviors, alcohol) Who is more at risk? People on the road. Children, youths, adults, elderly? Risky behavior, untrained drivers, poor judgement (age, maturity, substances), poor eyesight/reflexes, strength/fragility of the body People who drive a vehicle for work, boda boda driver Use of mobile phones What kind of environment causes more deaths? Poor road conditions, darkness, rain, roadwork, damage, objects in the road
fact sheet
Fact sheet
Fact sheet
Helmet use in commercial motorcyclists in Kampala: prevalence, associated factors and outcomes of motorcycle related injuries, Jan 2007
Children playing unsupervised next to an open road with no barriers
Pedestrian walking in the same direction as traffic on narrow road with no barriers and no speed limit. Motorcyclist carrying wide load. Well left uncovered with no fence around elevated area where children could potentially fall in, and no rope or post nearby to allow self extraction
So now that we know that: 1 Injuries are a big problem in Uganda (and the rest of the Africa and even the world) 2 It is better to prevent them (at least until you have the resources to treat properly) 3 it is fairly easy to prevent a great number of them through simple measures However some of you might be thinking: but this is not my job, why should I care?
Because you know how serious the problem is: You see it every day You experience the suffering of the people You see the consequences it has on your society Not many other people have this perspective it is not likely many other people will try and make a difference because they lack the knowledge and resources that you have
Even if you do not have time to invest in outreach and posters etc. because of your family life and your clinical duties, each one of you can still take the time to tell your boda-boda driver who is in the ED with a head injury that next time he should wear his helmet, or tell the parents of the child with the burns that they should keep their other children away from the open fire, or tell parents to lock up the medicines when you have a child with a poisoning, etc. This is a simple thing, and only takes 2 more minutes of explanation. And you may think that is does not work, but it is during these stressful times that people remember things better, this sort of intervention is proven to work in a significant proportion of people (e.g. smoking cessation in patients with MI)
No need to reinvent the wheel. Use tools that are already made Use your own experience and common sense to guide your counseling Examples of educational tools for children from WHO
Examples of cartoons that are easily understandable by children
For those who are interested in doing more, there is much to learn, but it can make a great project for senior and qualified ECPs to take on as they become more and more experienced and are looking for new ways to help people!
This requires planning and help
This requires determination, perseverance, and hard work But the benefits of this work can be plentiful!