Talk delivered with Stephanie Quail and Meg Ecclestone at TRY Confence, May 6, 2014. Provides perspectives of two of the event's organizers and one participant.
No Talk, All Action: Lessons Learned from Startup Weekend: Library Edition
1. NO TALK, ALL ACTION:
LESSONS LEARNED FROM
STARTUP
WEEKEND
Stephanie Quail, Helen Kula, & Meg Ecclestone !
TRY Conference, Toronto, Ontario!
May 6, 2014!
2. INTRODUCTIONS
STARTUP
WEEKEND
Meg Ecclestone!
@mjecclestone!
!
Librarian!
Scott Research &
Collections, !
York University
Libraries!
!
Helen Kula!
@helenkula!
!
Librarian!
Institute for Management
& Innovation, !
University of Toronto
Mississauga!
!
Stephanie Quail!
@stephaniequail!
!
Business Librarian!
Rotman School of !
Management, !
University of Toronto!
!
3. !
• Overview of Startup Weekend!
!
• Startup Weekend Toronto EDU: Library Edition!
• Organizers’ Perspectives !
• A Participant’s Experience of Startup Weekend!
• Key Learnings and Takeaways for Academic Librarians!
• Q&A!
AGENDA
STARTUP
WEEKEND
4. OVERVIEW
STARTUP
WEEKEND
1,000+ events!
500+ cities!
100,000+ participants!
500+ cities!
1,000+ events!
100,000+ participants!
Industry
Professionals
(like us!)!
Designers! Developers!
Business
Development
Types!
Startup
Weekend!
5. • SW Toronto launched in 2010!
• 6 Startup Weekends held to date!
!
• SWEDU is SW’s education vertical!
• 1st SW Toronto EDU held in 2013!
• SWTOLib the first of its kind !
OVERVIEW
STARTUP
WEEKEND
6. Typical Startup Weekend Template!
Friday Night! Saturday! Sunday!
Registration, dinner! The work continues…!
• Customer validation!
• Business case development!
• Coders code; designers
design!
• Work winds down!
• Pitch prep begins!
• Prototypes are
(hopefully) ready and
working!
Initial 1-minute
pitches!
Mentors and observers coach
and provide guidance!
Judges arrive and meet ‘n
greet with teams!
Voting and team
formation!
5 minute pitches take place!
Q&A with judges!
Teams get to work!! Judges convene and
announce the winners! !
OVERVIEW
STARTUP
WEEKEND
7. M.J. D’Elia, Librarian!
University of Guelph!
Helen Kula, Librarian!
University of Toronto!
M.J’s ‘Startup Library’ workshops! Helen’s experience at MaRS!
ORGANIZING #SWTOLib
STARTUP
WEEKEND
8. And then there were five….
Helen Kula
Meg Ecclestone June Avila Emily Porta
M.J. D’Elia
ORGANIZING #SWTOLib
STARTUP
WEEKEND
9. • Offer new kind of experiential learning
opportunity for the library community !
!
• Expose library community to ‘startup thinking’
and tools, e.g.!
• Customer development - ‘get outside the
building’!
• Minimum viable product (MVP)!
!
• Build relationships between startup + library
communities!
!
• Empower library communities to build their own
solutions!
!
• Seed community of library professionals who
are committed to hands-on innovation!
!
#SWTOLib OBJECTIVES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
10. !
Photo curtsey of http://www.getyourbotoncom/ !
!
Date:!
March 28-30!!
!
!
Location:!
Mozilla
Community
Space!
!
!
THE EVENT
STARTUP
WEEKEND
12. BrookList!
First Place!!
HUB allows
public libraries to
include local
community
resources in their
library catalog,
alongside
traditional library
materials like
books. !
!
Second Place!!
SpaceValet helps
students find study
space on campus.
The mobile app
allows students to
select a library or
learning space on
campus and
determine the
availability of
student study
space. !
!
Third Place!!
Raisin Readers
is an app for
parents to track
reading by their
children aged
0-5, to celebrate
reading
milestones and
to better connect
parents with their
local library. !
!
Organizers’
Choice!!
BrookList embodied
the spirit of startup
weekend. They
focused improving
the holds system in
libraries. The team
had some early
setbacks and lost a
few team members,
but they still
presented a polished
pitch on Sunday.!
TEAM PROFILES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
13. TEAM PROFILES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
14. EVENT FEEDBACK:
THE GOOD
STARTUP
WEEKEND
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
14
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
5
4
10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
How likely are you to recommend Startup
Weekend to your friends or colleagues?
(0 unlikely, 10 likely)
How would you rate the overall
quality of the Organizing team?
15. Librarians enjoyed!
!
• Hands-on, experiential learning!
!
• DIY ethos: use what you got!
!
• Customer validation process!
!
• Team-based nature of the work!
• Focus on producing a MVP instead of perfection!
!
• Pivoting and iterative, fluid nature of design process!
EVENT FEEDBACK:
THE GOOD
STARTUP
WEEKEND
16. Great outcomes, such as!
!
• Connections formed between library
community and the startup
community!
!
• Librarians learned how much they
could accomplish in 54 hours!
!
• At least 3 teams from the weekend
continue to work on their products!
• Developers and designers
‘connected’ with library problems!
EVENT FEEDBACK:
THE GOOD
STARTUP
WEEKEND
17. Issues for the organizers!
!
• Limited diversity of library types!
• No school or special/corporate
library participants!
!
• Application of for-profit template to
non-profit library context!
• Monetization? Revenue streams?!
!
• Pitches!
• Over-time, not quite ‘on target’!
!
• More design/UX participants needed!
!
• Sustaining momentum after the
weekend: where do we go?!
EVENT FEEDBACK:
THE CHALLENGES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
18. ?
!
• Interested in Startup Weekend movement!
!
• Passion for creating digital library services!
!
...and I had my own idea I wanted to pitch!
!
A PARTICIPANT’S
PERSPECTIVE
STARTUP
WEEKEND
19. My event expectations!
!
• Create a product that solves a library-
specific problem!
!
• Be part of an iterative design process!
!
• Meet other librarians, developers,
and designers !
!
• Have a fun time and…!
• Be exhausted by the end of the
weekend!!
A PARTICIPANT’S
PERSPECTIVE
STARTUP
WEEKEND
20. My pitch idea!
!
• The Library Sandbox!
• Didn’t make it past the voting stage!
!
Pitch problems!
!
• Not a convincing elevator speech!
• Didn’t resonate with designers and
developers!
!
Learning outcomes?!
!
• Practice your pitch!!
• Sell your ideas!
• Make it relatable!
#SWTOLib – DAY 1
STARTUP
WEEKEND
21. Second round of pitches!
!
• Give winning pitches a chance to
expand on their ideas!
!
Forming teams!
!
• Organic process!
• Attempted to form groups with
designers, developers, and
librarians!
#SWTOLib – DAY 1
STARTUP
WEEKEND
22. !
• Early literacy app !
• Connect parents with reading
lists and children’s librarians!
• Gamify reading experience!
!
!
Team composition!
3 public librarians & !
2 academic/media
librarians!
2 developers!
1 designer!
#SWTOLib – DAY 1
STARTUP
WEEKEND
23. Setting our agenda!
Librarians validate !
hypotheses &
generate content!
Developers & designers
develop use cases and
create wireframes!
#SWTOLib – DAY 2
STARTUP
WEEKEND
24. Customer validation!
!
• 100 completed surveys
by end of Saturday; 170
completed surveys by
end of Sunday!
Outcomes?!
!
• Validated many
hypotheses, but not all!
Next step!
!
• Wo(man) on the
street validation!
#SWTOLib – DAY 2
STARTUP
WEEKEND
25. After refueling with coffee !
and dinner…!
• Developers & designers
demoed their working
prototype!
• Began working with
librarians to refine use
cases and information
architecture!
• Librarians refined
information architecture!
• Continued generating
content !
• Started developing
business model !
#SWTOLib – DAY 2
STARTUP
WEEKEND
26. Analysis of survey results!
Finalize business model! Competitor research!
Further development !
of MVP!
Happening
simultaneously !
#SWTOLib – DAY 3
STARTUP
WEEKEND
27. Final pitch prep!
!
Challenge: present market
research, customer validation,
business model and do a
prototype demo in 5 minutes!!
Outcome?!
!
• Overtime!
• Judges had to ask us about our
revenue model during the Q&A!
• We still won 3rd place!!
#SWTOLib – DAY 3
STARTUP
WEEKEND
28. My original event expectations!
!
• Create a product that solves a library-specific problem!
• Be part of an iterative design process!
• Meet other librarians, developers, and designers!
• !
• Have a fun time and…!
• Be exhausted by the end of the weekend!!
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
EXPECTATIONS MET?
STARTUP
WEEKEND
29. Problems my team faced!
!
• Monetization of our product!
!
• Inability to validate all of our
hypotheses!
!
• Difficulties creating working
prototype!
!
• Lack of check-in with
different team members!
!
CHALLENGES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
30. During the weekend, mentors provided our team with invaluable
advice on:!
!
• Pricing our product!
!
• Tech help!
!
• Recommendations for customer validation!
!
• Helping us validate our hypotheses by telling us stories about
reading to their own children!
FINDING MENTORS
STARTUP
WEEKEND
Mentors are an important part of the Startup Weekend model!
31. • Project management!
!
• Customer validation !
• Embracing iterative design
process!
• ‘Getting things done’; not
necessarily being perfect !
• The importance of working
with experts from other fields!
KEY LEARNINGS
STARTUP
WEEKEND
32. Startup Weekend
Learnings!
Academic Libraries!
Embrace project
management!
• Planning by committee can b cumbersome!
• Select a ‘project manager’ that balances results and
consensus building!
Customer validation
is king!
• Library services and products need to get feedback at all
stages of development!
Iterative design
process!
• The first iteration of a service shouldn’t be its last!
• Learn to be nimble and change elements of your projects !
‘Getting things done’! • Being perfect rarely occurs; it’s better to work quickly and
make prototypes to generate as much feedback as
possible!
Outsider perspective! • Embrace and seek out feedback from outsiders!
• Use different language when discussing your solutions to
library problems!
#SWTOLib &
ACADEMIC LIBRARIES
STARTUP
WEEKEND
33.
STARTUP
WEEKEND
QUESTIONS?!
34. Q: Does this event resonate with you? Would you attend? If not,
why not?!
!
Q: Does ‘Startup Weekend’s focus on venture creation align with
‘library values’? If a conflict exists, does it decrease the learning
value of this event?!
!
Q: How should we keep the momentum going? How can
projects started be sustained and/or adopted by others?!
!
Q: Would this model work for solving problems specific to just
your institution?!
!
Q: Are there alternatives to Startup Weekend for solving library
problems?!
OUR QUESTIONS
STARTUP
WEEKEND