3. 3
Conceptualizing Corporate Governance
Corporate Governance means -
A set of standards, which aims to improve the
Company's image, efficiency, effectiveness and social
responsibility.
The concept of Corporate Governance primarily
emphasis on complete Fairness, Transparency,
and Accountability of the management, with an
increasingly greater focus on investor protection and
public interest.
Broader Perspective - Beneficiary of good
governance- Every Stakeholder
Jaladhi Shukla, FCS, Ahmedabad
6. 6
At least one Women Director.
At least fifty percent of the Board should be comprised of Non-
Executive Directors.
If the chairman of the Board is Executive Director or Promoter, then at
least half of the Board should be comprised of Independent Directors.
If the Chairman of the Board of Board is Non – Executive Director then
at least one – third of the Board should be comprised of Independent
Director.
Composition of Board
7. 7
Board Meetings
At least FOUR times a year with a
maximum time gap of one hundred
and twenty days between any two
meetings.
Director – maximum membership
in TEN committees.
Director – maximum Chairmanship
in FIVE COMMITTEES.
Director to Notify committee
positions & changes to company.
8. 8
Independent Director
Non-Executive Director
Nominee Director is excluded
who, in the opinion of the Board, is
a person of integrity and possesses
relevant expertise and experience
who is or was not a promoter of
the company or its holding,
subsidiary or associate company.
who is not related to promoters or
directors in the company, its
holding, subsidiary or associate
company
9. 9
Independent Director
No pecuniary relationship apart from
Directors’ Remuneration.
No KMP or employee in any of the three
preceding financial year.
No employee, proprietor or partner of
Auditors, Secretarial Auditor or Cost Auditor.
Holds 2% or more voting power.
CEO of non-profit organisation.
Material Supplier
Less than 21 years of age.
10. 10
Independent Director
No. of Directorships
maximum number of Boards an independent director
can serve on listed companies be restricted to 7.
Maximum number of directorship serving as Whole
Time Director is maximum 3.
Tenure & formal letter of appointment as per
Companies Act 2013
The terms and conditions of appointment shall be
disclosed on the website of the Company.
11. 11
Separate Meeeting of Independent Director
at least one meeting in a year.
All the independent directors of the
company shall strive to be present
at such meeting.
to review the performance of non-
independent directors and the
Board as a whole.
to review the performance of the
Chairperson of the company.
to assess the quality, quantity and
timeliness of flow of information
between the company
management and the Board that is
necessary for the Board to
effectively and reasonably perform
their duties.
INDEPENDENT
DIRECTORS ONLY
12. 12
Vacancy of Independent Director
Any Vacancy arising in the
office of any Independent
Director whether due to :
Resignation, or
Removal by Board
Should be replaced at
earliest BUT Not later than
the immediate next Board
Meeting OR three months
from the date of such
vacancy (whichever is
later)
13. 13
Person who reports the
following
• MISCONDUCT
• FRAUD
• ILLEGAL ACTIVITY
• MISAPPROPRIATION
happening
within the organization.
15. 15
AUDIT COMMITTEE
Constitution of a Qualified and Independent Audit Committee.
MINIMUM : THREE DIRECTORS as members and Two – Third of
the members should be independent.
All Members of Audit Committee shall be financially literate and at
least one members shall have accounting or related financial
management expertise.
CHAIRMAN OF AUDIT COMMITTEE should be INDEPENDENT
DIRECTOR.
CHAIRMAN should be present at the A.G.M. to answer shareholder
queries.
Company Secretary shall act as the Secretary to the committee.
MEETING OF AUDIT COMMITTEE :
– At least FOUR times in a year
– Maximum gap between two meeting : Four months
QUORUM :
– TWO members OR one third of the members of the audit
committee ( whichever is greater)
– Minimum TWO INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR must be present.
16. 16
NOMINATION & REMUNERATION
COMMITTEE
MINIMUM STRENGTH : at least THREE Directors.
All the members should be of Non – Executive Category.
At least half of them should be Independent.
CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE should be INDEPENDENT
DIRECTOR.
Chairperson of the Company may be appointed as a member of
the NRC but shall not chair such committee.
Chairperson should be present at AGM
Role – Remuneration Policy, Formulate evaluation criteria,
recommend appointment of Directors to the Board.
17. 17
Constitution of
Stakeholders’ Relationship Committee
Under the chairmanship of
Non – Executive Director,
Stakeholders Relationship
Committee should be
constituted to resolve the
grievances of the security
holders of the company
including complaints
related to transfer of
shares, non-receipt of
balance sheet, non-receipt
of declared dividends.
18. 18
Subsidiary Companies
Minutes of the Board meetings of the unlisted subsidiary
company shall be placed at the Board meeting of the listed
holding company for review.
The company shall formulate a policy for determining ‘material’
subsidiaries and such policy shall be disclosed to Stock Exchanges
and in the Annual Report.
At least one independent director on the Board of Directors of the
holding company shall be a director on the Board of Directors of
a material non-listed Indian subsidiary company.
Audit Committee of the listed holding company shall also review
the financial statements, in particular, the investments made by
the unlisted subsidiary company.
Prior Special Resolution required for disposal of more than 50%
shares or 20% assets of material non-listed Indian Subsidiary.
19. 19
Risk Management
The company shall lay down
procedures to inform Board
members about the risk
assessment and minimization
procedures.
The Board shall be responsible for
framing, implementing and
monitoring the risk management
plan for the company.
The company shall also constitute
a Risk Management Committee.
The Board shall define the roles
and responsibilities of the Risk
Management Committee and may
delegate monitoring and reviewing
of the risk management plan to the
committee
The majority members of the RMC
shall be Board of Directors.
20. 20
MEANING :
RELATED PARTY
TRANSACTION Transfer of
resources, services or obligations
between a company and a related
party, regardless of whether a price
is charged.
RELATED PARTY - Entity related
under Section 2(76) of the
Companies Act 2013 or under
applicable accounting standards.
21. WIDENED THE SCOPE OF RELATED PARTY
TRANSATION
AS – 18 Companies
Act, 2013
Definition of Related
Party
22. 22
Related Party Transactions
o The Company shall formulate a policy on material RPT and
also on dealing with RPTs.
o All RPTs shall require prior approval of Audit Committee.
• Omnibus approval subject to certain conditions. Valid for one year.
• Exemption for transactions of holding co. with its WOS.
o Quarterly review of all RPTs by Audit Committee
o All material related party transactions shall require
approval of the shareholders through ordinary resolution
and the related parties shall abstain from voting on such
resolutions.
• Exemption for transactions of holding co. with its WOS.
• Material if transaction or transactions during a FY, exceeds ten
percent of the annual consolidated turnover of the company as per
the last audited financial statements of the company.
• Quarterly disclosure in the CG report to Stock Exchanges.
24. 24
SEBI Listing Regulations - Introduction
• SEBI has recently notified the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure
Requirements) Regulations, 2015 replacing the Listing Agreement.
• SEBI Listing Regulations have come into force w.e.f. 1st December 2015
• The Regulations are consisting of 11 chapters and 10 schedules as against
55 clauses of the Listing Agreement.
• The Regulations have been structured by consolidating into one single
document across various types of securities listed on Stock Exchanges (i.e.
Equity Share, NCDs, NCRPS, IDRs, Debt Instruments etc)
• Shortened version of Listing Agreement required to be executed within 6
months from notification.
25. 25
SEBI Listing Regulations
SN Particulars Prior Intimation –
No. of days
1. Financial results viz. quarterly, half yearly or annually 5 days
2. Fund raising by way of any means (New) 2 days
3. o Declaration / recommendation of dividend, bonus shares
o issue of convertible securities including convertible debentures
or of debentures carrying a right to subscribe to equity shares
or the passing over of dividend. (New)
2 days
4. Intention to raise funds through new non-convertible securities or
non-convertible redeemable preference shares it proposes to list
either through a public issue or on private placement basis; prior
to issuance of such securities. (New)
2 days
5. Any alteration in the date on which, the interest on debentures or
bonds, or the redemption amount of amount of redeemable
shares or of debentures or bonds, shall be payable. (New)
11 days
• Salient Features – Prior Board Meeting intimations
26. 26
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Disclosure of events or information (Reg. 30)
Entity to make disclosure of any events or information which, in the
opinion of Board is material.
Events specified in Part A of Schedule III deemed to be material events.
Entity to make disclosure of same. In other cases, the Company to
authorise KMP to determine materiality.
The guidelines for materiality to be approved by Board.
Any disclosure to Stock Exchanges to be updated immediately on
company website & to be kept for 5 years.
Disclosure of all events or information with respect to subsidiaries which
are material for the listed entity.
Update material developments on regular basis.
27. 27
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Acquisition(s), Scheme of Arrangement, or sale or disposal of any unit(s),
division(s) or Subsidiary of the listed entity or any other restructuring
o Issuance of Securities (including debentures), split or consolidation of
shares, redemption of securities.
o Revision in Rating(s) – New rating, revision in rating etc. to any scheme
involving mobilization of funds whether in India or abroad.
o Schedule of analyst or institutional investor meet and presentations on
financial results made to analysts or institutional investors.
o Material Events
28. 28
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Material Events
o Agreements viz. shareholder agreement, joint venture agreement, family
settlement agreements, revision(s) or amendment(s) & termination(s)
thereof.
o Change in directors, Key Managerial Personnel, Auditor and Compliance
Officer
o Outcome of meetings of the board of directors held to consider or decide
dividend, buy-back of securities, fund raising proposed to be undertaken,
issue of bonus share, alteration of capital, financial results.
o Appointment or discontinuation of share transfer agent.
o Corporate debt restructuring
o Proceedings of AGM, EGM & Voting pattern
29. 29
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Dissemination of Information at Website of the Company
(Reg. 46)
• Schedule of analyst or institutional investor meet and presentations
made by the listed entity to analysts or institutional investors
simultaneously with submission to stock exchange.
• Details of agreements entered into with the media companies and / or
their associates, etc.
• Details of directors’ familiarization programmes.
• New name and old name of listed entity for continuous one year.
• Details of business, composition of board and committees, policies
• Financial information, Shareholding pattern, board meeting notice
• Contact information of designated officials. Investor e-mail id.
• All disclosures under Regulation 30 (material events) for 5 years.
• Update website within 2 working days of disclosure.
30. 30
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Name Change (Reg. 45)
• Mandatory name change (within 6 months) in case company
change its activities which is not reflected in its name.
• Prior approval of SE is mandatory before application to ROC.
o Salient Features – Other New Provisions
o Website link to be given in news paper publications (Reg. 47)
o Non compliance to be disclosed in Annual Report [Sch V(10)]
31. 31
SEBI Listing Regulations
• NEW POLICIES framed under LODR Regulations
Regulations Policies
Regulation 9 Policy on Preservation of Documents
Regulation 30 Material Events Policy
Regulation 30 Website content Archival
32. 32
SEBI Listing Regulations
o Liability for contravention of the Act, Rules or the Regulations
(Reg. 98)
o Liability for contravention of the Act, Rules or the
Regulations (Reg. 98)
• The listed entity or any other person thereof who contravenes
any of the provisions of these regulations, shall in addition to the
liability for action in terms of the securities laws, be liable for the
following actions by the SEs –
• Imposition of fines (daily basis)
• Suspension of trading
• Freezing of promoter / promoter group holding
• Any other action as may be specified by the Board
33. 33
Mapping of Listing Agreement with LR
Particulars Compliance
Timeline
Clause in LA Listing
Regulation
Book Closure /
Record date
Event based Clause 16 42
Intimation of BM Event based 19 & 41 29
Outcome of BM Event based 20, 21 & 41 30 & 33
In-principle
approval
Event based 24(a) 28
Scheme of
Arrangement
Event based 24(f) & 24(g) 11 & 37
Change in KMP &
Auditors
Event based 30 30
Annual Report Annually 31 34
Form A / B Annually 31 33
34. 34
Mapping of Listing Agreement with LR
Particulars Compliance
Timeline
Clause in LA Listing
Regulation
Name Change Event based 32 45
MOA / AOA Event based 33 30
Shareholding
pattern
Quarterly & Event
Based
35 31
Disclosure of voting
pattern & E-voting
Event based 35A 44
Disclosure of
Information
Event based 36 30
Payment of Listing
Fees
Annually 38 14
Minimum Public
Shareholding
Event Based 40A 38
Financial Results Quarterly /
Annually
41 33
35. 35
Mapping of Listing Agreement with LR
Particulars Compliance
Timeline
Clause in LA Listing
Regulation
Certificate from
PCS
Half yearly 47C 40(9)
Corporate
Governance
Quarterly &
Annually
49 & 31 17 to 27
Website of the
Company
Continuous
Compliance
54 46
Agreement with
media Company
Event based 53 30
BRR Annually 55 34
36. 36
Quick Takeaways
o Replacement of Listing Agreement with Listing Regulations
now provide for a more consolidated framework for the
disclosures to be made by all listed entities and give
statutory recognition to the listing norms in India.
39. 39
Appointment of two
Independent Directors in XYZ Ltd.
Name Particulars
Mr. A Non Executive Director. Receives sitting fees only.
Mr. B Ex. KMP upto 2012
Ms. C CEO - NGO
Mr. D Supplier
40. Technical Scrutiny of
Related Party Transactions of ABC Ltd. –
Particulars Subsidiary
Companies /
WOS
Associate /
Joint
Control
Companies
Directors Relatives of
Directors
Funds
Given /
Received
XYZ P. LTD. PQR LTD. MR. A
MR. B
MRS. A
MRS. B
Jaladhi Shukla, FCS,
Ahmedabad
41. 41
Practical Aspects
Drafting of polices & code of conduct
Tracking compliances & disclosures of leading companies –
• Corporate Websites,
• Annual Reports,
• Stock Exchange Announcements
Meeting Management – attend General Meetings
Professional reading – English newspapers, circulars etc
Professional Networking
42. 42
Some Useful websites
http://www.sebi.gov.in/ - Securities and Exchange
Board of India
http://www.bseindia.com/ - Bombay Stock Exchange Limited
http://www.nfcgindia.org/library_int.htm - National
Foundation for Corporate Governance
http://www.ita.doc.gov/goodgovernance/ -International Trade
Administration
http://www.oecd.org/ -Organisation for Economic
Co-operation and Development
http://www.corpgov.net/ - Corporate governance network
Jaladhi Shukla, FCS, Ahmedabad