A presentation I created with my Operations Manager on how we built our 3d printing service at the University of Arizona Libraries. We presented this at the UA IT Summit, Access Services Conference, and AzLA.
2. What is 3d Printing?
• General overview of technology
• Terminology
• Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) – process of
melting layers together
• Slicing – turns digital 3D models (STL) into thin
layers
• Filament – material used to print (PLA and ABS)
• Extruder – draws layers at different “resolutions”
0.1mm – 0.3 mm; like a hot glue gun
• Build Plate – printing surface (tip: use painter’s
tape)
PS - If you like any of our wording, approaches, etc…, please
feel free to borrow/copy anything you see.
3. Initial Investigations: Environmental Scan
• Questions we asked:
• What’s available on campus
already?
• What does the community have
to offer?
• What are other institutions
doing?
4. Initial Investigations: User base
• Questions:
• Who will have access? When?
• What does your user base
need?
• Use these answers to
determine the best Service
Model
• Open
• Mediated
Photo: Jarret Liotta
5. Initial Investigations: Policies
• Policies
• Right to refuse service –
dangerous, harmful material,
poorly designed items
• To clean or not to clean; quality
guarantee
• Level of access to printers and
referrals
• Prioritizing requests –
academic versus personal
• Modeling Resources – http://
www.library.arizona.edu/servic
es/print/3D/about
6. Initial Investigations: Policies - copyright
Notice concerning copyright and other intellectual property restrictions
The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or
other reproductions of copyrighted material.
Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or
other reproduction. One of these specific conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be "used for
any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research." If a user makes a request for, or later uses, a
photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of "fair use," that user may be liable for copyright infringement.
This institution reserves the right to refuse to accept a copying order if, in its judgment, fulfillment of the order
would involve violation of copyright or other intellectual property laws.
I acknowledge, represent, and warrant as follows:
•I have read, understand, and will comply with the notice posted above.
•I grant permission to the University of Arizona and its agents to reproduce the photocopy or other reproduction
and return them to me, and I have the legal right and authority to grant this permission.
•I will use the photocopy or other reproduction only for private study, scholarship, or research.
•I will not use them for any commercial purpose or allow any third party to do so.
8. IMPLEMENTATION: Staffing
• Staff Support ~0.5 FTE - Job
Descriptions :
• ~0.25 FTE - 3D Printing training and
coordination of issues. Assessment and
benchmarking to make recommendations for
supply, refresh, changes in technology or
policy and procedures; provide software and
technology support and training for library
staff, part-time student employees and library
customers
• ~0.1 FTE - 3D printing support. Assists with
training of staff, part-time student employees,
and customers. Assists with managing
procedures.
• ~0.1 FTE – 3D printing queue processing
• Student Support – added to existing duties
9. Process workflows
• How will jobs be submitted?
• Where will the files be stored?
• Who will do the actual printing?
• How will we communicate with customers?
• What necessary data needs to be collected?
10.
11. IMPLEMENTATION: submission form
UA’s Form:
http://new.library.arizona.edu/visit/print/3D/
request
Key Elements:
•Contact Info
•Delivery Info – date needed, who will pick
up
•Print Specifications – dimensions, color,
infill, resolution
•Pre-authorization and agreement
•Metrics – what data do you need them to
supply?
INSERT SS OF SUBMISSION FORM
12. IMPLEMENTATION: Training
• Initial Training & Learning as we go
• Detailed written instructions
• Infographics
• Hands-on training
• FAQs
• Frequent email communication
Goal: Educate students & staff to make
informed decisions
13. Review: Metrics
• Demographics
• Affiliation (Undergraduate,
Graduate, Faculty, Staff,
Community, etc)
• College & Department
• Discrete users
• Amount saved
• Demonstrating value
What does this look like?
15. Review: User Stories
• 3d printing gave us
the unique opportunity
to work with other
departments outside
of our standard scope
16. A 3d printed brain
“I'm a doctoral student who
studies language in the
brain using functional MRI
for people who have had
strokes. And of course I've
been in the scanner myself
to test the paradigms, etc...
so, this happens to be a
high resolution scan of my
own brain, haha.”
17. “I don't want to exploit the Library services - I want any further
printing of these brains that I do to at least be aligned with the
Library goals and if possible actually *benefit* the library and/or
future of the printing services, if at all possible. Remember, I'm a
PhD student so the health of the library is fundamental to my career,
so I'm willing to do anything I can to support you guys with my
research/academic activities.”
18. Marketing
• Digital Signage
• Word of Mouth – make them visible!
• Slides
• Brochures
• Website
• Events
• Social Media – Maker Mondays
24. Next Steps: What is 3d scanning?
3D Scanning is taking a full set of
snapshots of an object and
stitching them together to create a
3D model. The model can then be
used for 3D printing, diagraming,
or analysis.
Travis/Jessica
Thanks for coming! Introduce ourselves.
Travis
There is a lot of text on some of our slides – We promise that we won’t spend our time together reading it to you. We just wanted to share some of the details for you to reference and copy.
Education and discovery – months just reading about 3D printing
Ikea – 1st Gen vs. 4th Gen
Hot Glue Gun
FDM, Extruder
Homo naledi and T-Rex – rafts, supports, shells, infill (pass around)
Travis
You can learn a lot from others and before we got started, that’s what we did. Starting locally…
Campus - You’d probably expect engineering to have a program, but there may be other groups when you start to reach out. Don’t review list too much for AzLA.
Engineering – of course; however, we later learned that they only have one printer and they’ve already started sending students to us because they can’t keep up with demand.
SBS/SIRLS - School of Information: Science, Technology, and Arts (SISTA) – combining as part of iSchool; design/use of technology
Business – McGuire Center in Eller; use for rapid prototyping
Architecture – use for creating models (along with laser cutters)
Medical – use to print cells; prosthetics
School of Theatre, Film, and Television – set pieces, props, costumes (they purchased a MakerBot Z-18)
Why the library? Centralized and only certain students access?
Local – There may already be resources in your community. In Tucson, we have Xerocraft, which is a maker/hackerspace open to the community; good for referrals. Also CoLab, Maker House (now closed)
Benchmarking - carried out in the form of a spreadsheet that compiled information such as Institutions’ 3d printing websites, costs, hours of operations, printer models, customer groups, staffing, and certifications for use.
Travis – Cut for AzLA
Decide on type of service you have set up will drive your policies, staffing, and costs.
Mediated?
Affiliates versus Community?
Special needs? Resolution? Build Size? Material Type?
Come to agreement with administration and any other stakeholders.
Travis
Lots of details with any new service. Specifics for 3D…
Reject – we’ve turned down a couple of jobs to date: Knife (weapon free zone); prop gun (in black)
Cleaning jobs – don’t.
Hands-on access to printers – if mediated, where can you send them? Us: Xerocraft and iSpace
Prioritizing – based on need and use
Modeling – link to resources; in-person help (OSCR)
Travis
DON’T READ THIS!!
Collective brain shutdown…
Please Borrow and Modify
Attorneys at UA; work with yours
ALA – better not to mediate; okay if from Thingiverse
Travis
Primary Cost – equipment
Printer = MakerBot Replicator 2
– work horse; anti-5th Gen
– cheaper models, but probably not as reliable (other okay models, but all in this price point). I would do more market research if I were to purchase today (constantly changing).
Glass build plate – less leveling; longer lasting
Painter’s Tape – better bonding surface; easier to remove object; protects build plate
Other incidentals ($100+):
Spatulas, palette knives, tweezers, paintbrushes, cutters, scale
We bought a lot of stuff we didn’t need also, like files, sandpaper, various picks, safety equip
LIS 559 (Marketing) – if you want to experience planning and costing out a service.
Travis
Staff – about ½ an FTE
Oversee the service; backup
Queue processing – electronic files; user contact
Students – on desk
Printing
They have other responsibilities - equipment lending/reimaging, troubleshooting and managing access to public computers, but they had downtime and printers are SLOW so they only interact with them periodically.
Jessica was appointed the lead of this process and she’ll describe what she’s done.
Jessica
Spent some time getting acquainted with the printers in order to develop a workflow
Work with what we already have
Storage on Box
Web form on the website
Students will do the printing
Communication thru LibAnswers
Jessica
Brainstorm session
Jessica
Print Specifications
Many files (especially from commercial vendors) will open in all sorts of different sizes…
Do you want to allow other people to pick up objects
Infill/Resolution – we decided to keep this simple for us and used the defaults (.2mm, 10% infill) – this is fairly standard, though we frequently get more specific requests, especially as the number of original submissions grows. These objects are usually very complex and may require specific settings to print.
Pre-authorization – after a lot of initial back and forth e-mails, we decided to ask up front about payment and turnaround expectations.
Jessica
Initial training we found focused on how to calibrate the machines & how the printing process worked
As the service grew & we learned as we went along, updates went out with both detailed instructions and general overviews
Students feedback is important
Jessica
Gathering detailed demographic information allows us to be able to demonstrate value & more easily communicate the goals & accomplishments of the program in easily-digestible formats
Leadership can go to departments and speak about the work that we are doing FOR THEM & their students
Also lets us know who our audience really is
Practically, this looks like….
Jessica
A lot of Excel wrangling & false starts
Learning about formulas
Jessica
Other possible examples:
Drones and Hack Arizona
Phone cases
Board Game Pieces – started with Thingiverse and ultimately designed own objects
iSTEM – public libraries might be interested in this…
Jessica
Jesscia
Jessica
Jessica
Never underestimate the power of visibility
3d printing desk located next to reference desk
Not under glass or removed, students can walk right up and take a look
TFOB
Jessica
Working with our social media teams to reach larger audiences & find engaging content
Not just taking photos of submissions, but
Jessica
Telling stories
Bring 3d printing in libraries to life
Something concrete to relate to
Jessica
Going outside of your comfort zone is key – I had no experience with this kind of technology but the only way to learn is to play & fail
Don’t be afraid to get your hands dirty – it’s what the Maker movement is all about
It’s okay to make changes to your service model if what you have isn’t working
Seek out feedback from everyone! Customers, students, leadership, staff, etc. I spend a lot of time asking about what doesn’t work.
You’ll find yourself saying “I don’t know, but I’ll investigate that” a lot
Everyone you know will send you 3d printing news
Your desk will get messy
Think about ways to use what you have
Travis
Since we don’t all have access to an MRI machine (like our student who scanned his own brain), we decided to purchase portable scanners (Occipital Structure Sensor) so that you can at least scan the outside of your body.
Photogrammetry
– better than free versions
- instant results
- considerably faster…
Travis
QR code link goes to UA Library’s 3d printing site
A lot of great staff helped make this possible and if you plan to do this, make sure that you get the right people together and give them time to work.