SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Methodology
 Samples were recovered from ODP Hole 757B located on the Ninety East
Ridge in the Indian Ocean during ODP Leg 121 (1988).
 Ostracods of the genus Krithe were identified under a microscope and
removed from samples (Fig. 1).
 Valves were weighed and transferred to 0.5 mL microcentrifuge tubes.
 Valves underwent chemical cleaning to remove clays, metal oxides and
organic matter (method modified from Boyle, 1981).
 Samples were then analysed for trace metals using inductively coupled
plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) .
Earth's Greenhouse-Icehouse Transition Across the Eocene/ Oligocene Boundary
J.S. Crowe1 and H.K. Coxall2
1. School of Earth and Ocean Science, Cardiff University
2. Department of Geological Sciences, Stockholm University
Background
 The earliest indication of Eastern Antarctic glaciation at sea level occurs
at c. 45.5 Ma during the Eocene Epoch.
 By c. 36 Ma glaciation had significantly strengthened with the creation of
the Eastern Antarctic ice sheet.
 The Eastern Antarctic continent was entirely buried under ice by the
onset of the Oligocene at 33.9 Ma (Ehrmann and Mackensen, 1992)
 The Mg/Ca ratio found in shells of the deep-sea ostracod genus Krithe
has been used here to infer bottom water temperature (BWT).
 Ostracods are a type of bi-valved crustacean.
 Their shells are formed of calcite (CaCO3) and contain co-precipitated
magnesium.
 Concentration of magnesium with respect to calcium is known to be
temperature dependant (Burton and Walter, 1991).
Results Conclusions
 Average valve weight significantly decreases from 19.5 to 15.5 µg the
late Eocene to the early Oligocene (fig. 2).
 Magnesium calcium ratios found within ostracods from ODP Hole 757B
show a significant positive trend across the Eocene/ Oligocene (E/O)
boundary (Fig.3).
 These ratios correspond to a 1.5°C increase in bottom water temperature
between 30 and 36 million years (Fig.3).
 Increases in magnesium calcium ratios occur simultaneously with a
distinct rise δ18O ‰ (Fig. 2-3).
 Bottom water temperatures found here are outside the range of the
commonly used calibrations (Cronin et al., 1996., 2005., Dwyer et
al.,1995., 2002.)
References & Acknowledgments
Boyle, E.A., 1981. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 53, 11–35. Burton, E. A. & Walter, L.M., 1991. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 55,777.
Cronin, T.M., et al., 1996. Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ.111,117-134 Cronin, T.M. et al., 2005. Marine Micropaleontology. 54, 249-261.
Dwyer, G.S., et al., 1995. Science. 270 (5240), 1347-1351. Dwyer, G.S, et al, 2002. Geophys. Monogr.Ser. 131, 205-225.
Ehrmann, W.U., et al., 1992. Palaeogeo, Palaeoclim, Palaeoecol. 93, 85 Elmore, A.C., et al., 2012. Geochem, Geiphys. Geosys. 13(9).
Many thanks: to: CUROP, C.H. Lear, E.M. Mawbey and A. Morte-Ródenas
Figure 1. A light microscope image of a selected ostracod.
Questions for Further Research
 Are bottom water temperatures calibrated using Dwyer et al., 1995
accurate over this temperature range?
 Does a ∆[CO3
2-]- corrected calibration (designed for low temperatures)
yield more accurate bottom water temperature estimates (Elmore et al.,
2012)?
 Do bottom water temperatures calculated using Mg/Ca or Sr/Ca ratios in
benthic foraminifera correlate with those found using ostracods?
 Why do Mg/Ca ratios increase when a cooling effect linked to glaciation
is expected?
 Is the increase in Mg/Ca ratio significant in regard to a reduction in valve
weight?
Figure 2. Valve weight per ostracod across the E/O boundary.
Figure 3. Mg/Ca ratios and calibrated BWT across the E/O boundary.
Figure 4. Oxygen isotope record across the E/O boundary.

More Related Content

What's hot

The climate system from a polar perspective
The climate system from a polar perspective The climate system from a polar perspective
The climate system from a polar perspective Bayer
 
Emma Hutchinson SESUR poster
Emma Hutchinson SESUR posterEmma Hutchinson SESUR poster
Emma Hutchinson SESUR posterEmma Hutchinson
 
Cogci Presentation
Cogci PresentationCogci Presentation
Cogci Presentationhexin912
 
Climate Change - How We Know What We Know
Climate Change - How We Know What We KnowClimate Change - How We Know What We Know
Climate Change - How We Know What We KnowMichael DeLapa
 
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali Jones
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali JonesInternational Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali Jones
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali JonesAlison Jones
 
Marine isotope stages short doc
Marine isotope stages short docMarine isotope stages short doc
Marine isotope stages short docJGGOKULAKRISHNAN
 
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...Alexander Jueterbock
 
Climate Change Effects -- Grand Junction
Climate Change Effects -- Grand JunctionClimate Change Effects -- Grand Junction
Climate Change Effects -- Grand JunctionConservationColorado
 
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915Aaron Munsart
 
Ccss j merrill_overview-1
Ccss j merrill_overview-1Ccss j merrill_overview-1
Ccss j merrill_overview-1riseagrant
 
Anthropomorphic, climate change
Anthropomorphic, climate changeAnthropomorphic, climate change
Anthropomorphic, climate changenybergjohn
 
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...Sérgio Sacani
 
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)Paige Whitfield
 
Climate history of the Earth
Climate history of the EarthClimate history of the Earth
Climate history of the EarthLars Occhionero
 
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip Fearnside
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip FearnsideLa foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip Fearnside
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip FearnsideInstituto Humboldt
 
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon Storage
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon StorageAir-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon Storage
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon StorageAndreas Schmittner
 

What's hot (20)

The climate system from a polar perspective
The climate system from a polar perspective The climate system from a polar perspective
The climate system from a polar perspective
 
Thomas Lovejoy, WILD9
Thomas  Lovejoy, WILD9Thomas  Lovejoy, WILD9
Thomas Lovejoy, WILD9
 
Natural environmental change
Natural environmental changeNatural environmental change
Natural environmental change
 
Emma Hutchinson SESUR poster
Emma Hutchinson SESUR posterEmma Hutchinson SESUR poster
Emma Hutchinson SESUR poster
 
Cogci Presentation
Cogci PresentationCogci Presentation
Cogci Presentation
 
Climate Change - How We Know What We Know
Climate Change - How We Know What We KnowClimate Change - How We Know What We Know
Climate Change - How We Know What We Know
 
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali Jones
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali JonesInternational Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali Jones
International Coral Reef Society Conference 2008 - Dr Ali Jones
 
Marine isotope stages short doc
Marine isotope stages short docMarine isotope stages short doc
Marine isotope stages short doc
 
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...
Climate change impact on seaweed meadow distribution in the North Atlantic ro...
 
Climate Change Effects -- Grand Junction
Climate Change Effects -- Grand JunctionClimate Change Effects -- Grand Junction
Climate Change Effects -- Grand Junction
 
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915
ResearchPaper_PastClimates_DrRoark_AaronMunsart_050915
 
Earth and space science year at a glance
Earth and space science year at a glanceEarth and space science year at a glance
Earth and space science year at a glance
 
FinalDraft
FinalDraftFinalDraft
FinalDraft
 
Ccss j merrill_overview-1
Ccss j merrill_overview-1Ccss j merrill_overview-1
Ccss j merrill_overview-1
 
Anthropomorphic, climate change
Anthropomorphic, climate changeAnthropomorphic, climate change
Anthropomorphic, climate change
 
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...
Site of asteroid impact changed the history of life on Earth: the low probabi...
 
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)
PaigeWhitfield_GEOG3700_ResearchPaper(Final)
 
Climate history of the Earth
Climate history of the EarthClimate history of the Earth
Climate history of the Earth
 
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip Fearnside
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip FearnsideLa foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip Fearnside
La foresta amazónica y el cambio climático - Philip Fearnside
 
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon Storage
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon StorageAir-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon Storage
Air-Sea Disequilibrium Enhances Glacial Ocean Carbon Storage
 

Viewers also liked

EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNS
EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNSEPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNS
EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNSMichael Blanco Designs
 
Spark Video How To
Spark Video How ToSpark Video How To
Spark Video How Tonmyers3
 
Props and costume
Props and costumeProps and costume
Props and costumepatc2121
 
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambiente
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambienteProcesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambiente
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambienteJose Cosmer Sanchez Troncos
 
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1jack congdon
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Incitement in the Palestinian Authority
Incitement in the Palestinian AuthorityIncitement in the Palestinian Authority
Incitement in the Palestinian Authority
 
EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNS
EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNSEPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNS
EPIC Freight Solutions Pitch Deck Created by MICHAEL BLANCO DESIGNS
 
Spark Video How To
Spark Video How ToSpark Video How To
Spark Video How To
 
Summary
SummarySummary
Summary
 
Props and costume
Props and costumeProps and costume
Props and costume
 
Rameez Rangrez(3)
Rameez Rangrez(3)Rameez Rangrez(3)
Rameez Rangrez(3)
 
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambiente
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambienteProcesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambiente
Procesos didacticos del área de ciencia y ambiente
 
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1
Conventions of cd advertising.pptx 1
 

Similar to Earth's Greenhouse-Icehouse Transition Across the Eocene-Oligocene Boundary

Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & Life
Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & LifePlanetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & Life
Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & LifePaul H. Carr
 
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...Sérgio Sacani
 
Planetary Atmospheres & Life
Planetary Atmospheres & LifePlanetary Atmospheres & Life
Planetary Atmospheres & LifePaul H. Carr
 
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice ages
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice agesLong-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice ages
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice agesProf Simon Haslett
 
Eh2 unit checks questions
Eh2 unit checks questionsEh2 unit checks questions
Eh2 unit checks questionsRobin Seamon
 
Complete the evidence for climate change
Complete the evidence for climate changeComplete the evidence for climate change
Complete the evidence for climate changeWill Williams
 
The causes of climate change
The causes of climate changeThe causes of climate change
The causes of climate changeWill Williams
 
The Toba super-eruption: micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?
The Toba super-eruption:  micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?The Toba super-eruption:  micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?
The Toba super-eruption: micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?Kim Cobb
 
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacity
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacityCorrelation_of_the_methylating_capacity
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacityMiltiadis Nimfopoulos
 
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdf
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdfIntroduction to the principles of 18O.pdf
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdfFeyzaAkgnlDiner
 
Evolution of Planet Earth and Life
Evolution of Planet Earth and LifeEvolution of Planet Earth and Life
Evolution of Planet Earth and LifeS.Shafiqur Rehman
 
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...Abdullah Khan Zehady
 
Age of the Earth
Age of the EarthAge of the Earth
Age of the EarthJohn Lynch
 
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15Thamasha (Mash) Perera
 
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdf
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdfLec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdf
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdffakefoxman
 

Similar to Earth's Greenhouse-Icehouse Transition Across the Eocene-Oligocene Boundary (20)

Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & Life
Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & LifePlanetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & Life
Planetary Vacuums, Atmospheres, & Life
 
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
 
Planetary Atmospheres & Life
Planetary Atmospheres & LifePlanetary Atmospheres & Life
Planetary Atmospheres & Life
 
Climppf1
Climppf1Climppf1
Climppf1
 
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice ages
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice agesLong-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice ages
Long-term palaeoclimate: the origin of the ice ages
 
Eh2 unit checks questions
Eh2 unit checks questionsEh2 unit checks questions
Eh2 unit checks questions
 
Global Warming
Global WarmingGlobal Warming
Global Warming
 
Complete the evidence for climate change
Complete the evidence for climate changeComplete the evidence for climate change
Complete the evidence for climate change
 
The causes of climate change
The causes of climate changeThe causes of climate change
The causes of climate change
 
Overview of evolution
Overview of evolutionOverview of evolution
Overview of evolution
 
Global Warming
Global WarmingGlobal Warming
Global Warming
 
The Toba super-eruption: micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?
The Toba super-eruption:  micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?The Toba super-eruption:  micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?
The Toba super-eruption: micro-scale traces of a global-scale climate event?
 
Lectures2
Lectures2Lectures2
Lectures2
 
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacity
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacityCorrelation_of_the_methylating_capacity
Correlation_of_the_methylating_capacity
 
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdf
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdfIntroduction to the principles of 18O.pdf
Introduction to the principles of 18O.pdf
 
Evolution of Planet Earth and Life
Evolution of Planet Earth and LifeEvolution of Planet Earth and Life
Evolution of Planet Earth and Life
 
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...
Data mining and_visualization_of_earth_history_datasets_to_find_cause_effect_...
 
Age of the Earth
Age of the EarthAge of the Earth
Age of the Earth
 
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15
Thamasha Perera Poster (Mosasaur Evolution) 03.11.15
 
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdf
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdfLec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdf
Lec # 02, 03 (Universe, Earth's Structure).pdf
 

Earth's Greenhouse-Icehouse Transition Across the Eocene-Oligocene Boundary

  • 1. Methodology  Samples were recovered from ODP Hole 757B located on the Ninety East Ridge in the Indian Ocean during ODP Leg 121 (1988).  Ostracods of the genus Krithe were identified under a microscope and removed from samples (Fig. 1).  Valves were weighed and transferred to 0.5 mL microcentrifuge tubes.  Valves underwent chemical cleaning to remove clays, metal oxides and organic matter (method modified from Boyle, 1981).  Samples were then analysed for trace metals using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) . Earth's Greenhouse-Icehouse Transition Across the Eocene/ Oligocene Boundary J.S. Crowe1 and H.K. Coxall2 1. School of Earth and Ocean Science, Cardiff University 2. Department of Geological Sciences, Stockholm University Background  The earliest indication of Eastern Antarctic glaciation at sea level occurs at c. 45.5 Ma during the Eocene Epoch.  By c. 36 Ma glaciation had significantly strengthened with the creation of the Eastern Antarctic ice sheet.  The Eastern Antarctic continent was entirely buried under ice by the onset of the Oligocene at 33.9 Ma (Ehrmann and Mackensen, 1992)  The Mg/Ca ratio found in shells of the deep-sea ostracod genus Krithe has been used here to infer bottom water temperature (BWT).  Ostracods are a type of bi-valved crustacean.  Their shells are formed of calcite (CaCO3) and contain co-precipitated magnesium.  Concentration of magnesium with respect to calcium is known to be temperature dependant (Burton and Walter, 1991). Results Conclusions  Average valve weight significantly decreases from 19.5 to 15.5 µg the late Eocene to the early Oligocene (fig. 2).  Magnesium calcium ratios found within ostracods from ODP Hole 757B show a significant positive trend across the Eocene/ Oligocene (E/O) boundary (Fig.3).  These ratios correspond to a 1.5°C increase in bottom water temperature between 30 and 36 million years (Fig.3).  Increases in magnesium calcium ratios occur simultaneously with a distinct rise δ18O ‰ (Fig. 2-3).  Bottom water temperatures found here are outside the range of the commonly used calibrations (Cronin et al., 1996., 2005., Dwyer et al.,1995., 2002.) References & Acknowledgments Boyle, E.A., 1981. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 53, 11–35. Burton, E. A. & Walter, L.M., 1991. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 55,777. Cronin, T.M., et al., 1996. Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ.111,117-134 Cronin, T.M. et al., 2005. Marine Micropaleontology. 54, 249-261. Dwyer, G.S., et al., 1995. Science. 270 (5240), 1347-1351. Dwyer, G.S, et al, 2002. Geophys. Monogr.Ser. 131, 205-225. Ehrmann, W.U., et al., 1992. Palaeogeo, Palaeoclim, Palaeoecol. 93, 85 Elmore, A.C., et al., 2012. Geochem, Geiphys. Geosys. 13(9). Many thanks: to: CUROP, C.H. Lear, E.M. Mawbey and A. Morte-Ródenas Figure 1. A light microscope image of a selected ostracod. Questions for Further Research  Are bottom water temperatures calibrated using Dwyer et al., 1995 accurate over this temperature range?  Does a ∆[CO3 2-]- corrected calibration (designed for low temperatures) yield more accurate bottom water temperature estimates (Elmore et al., 2012)?  Do bottom water temperatures calculated using Mg/Ca or Sr/Ca ratios in benthic foraminifera correlate with those found using ostracods?  Why do Mg/Ca ratios increase when a cooling effect linked to glaciation is expected?  Is the increase in Mg/Ca ratio significant in regard to a reduction in valve weight? Figure 2. Valve weight per ostracod across the E/O boundary. Figure 3. Mg/Ca ratios and calibrated BWT across the E/O boundary. Figure 4. Oxygen isotope record across the E/O boundary.