Presentation by Ms. Charlotte Ruhe, Director, SME Finance and Development, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development - SME financing in the EU enlargement region, at the Launch of the SME Policy Index for the Western Balkans and Turkey 2016. 28 April 2016, OECD, Paris, France.
Sustainability by Design: Assessment Tool for Just Energy Transition Plans
SME Financing in the EU Enlargement countries
1. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
SME Financing in the EU enlargement countries
Charlotte Ruhe, Head, SME Finance and Development, EBRD
Launch of the SME Policy Index for the Western Balkans and Turkey 2016
Paris, April 2016
2. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
Setting the scene… SME access to finance
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
Informalsector
Accesstofinance
Electricity
Corruption
Taxadmin.
Politicalinstability
Workforceskills
Crime
Transport
Accesstoland
Customs&trade
Labourregulations
Courts
Telecoms
Businesslicensing
Western Balkans (unweighted average)
Turkey
• Access to Finance 2nd most severely
perceived obstacle to business in the WB,
5th most severe obstacle inTurkey
• Banks are very liquid, but in light of high
NPL levels (esp. in the WBs), banks are
very risk averse
• Lack of creditworthy borrowers
• Bank lending remains expensive, and
especially long-term financing is difficult
to access
• Non-bank finance virtually non-existent
• Financial inclusion remains a key
challenge
BEEPS 2012, perceived business obstacles (0-5)
3. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
• Limited awareness of SMEs about the variety of financing opportunities available in
addition to standard bank-lending.
• Incomplete legal and regulatory framework that ensures investors’ confidence and
reduces legal uncertainties.
• Need for local buy-in and support to market-friendly incentives to increase lending
appetite of banks.
• Lack of investment readiness of SMEs, including sound financial management and
transparency.
Additional challenges
4. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
The EBRD Small Business Initiative
Financing
through financial
institutions
Direct financing
for small
business
Policy dialogue
Co-financing
with financial
institutions
Business advice
• 200+ partner
financial
institutions
• €1+ billion of
finance each year
• Benefitting
hundreds of
thousands of
small businesses
• Providing direct
financing for
small businesses,
coupled with
business advice
• Instilling higher
standards of
corporate
governance and
financial
transparency
• Taking targeted
policy actions
alongside our
investments
• Engaging
effectively with
policy-makers
across our region
• Lessening the
risk of financing
small businesses
• Helping partner
financing
institutions to
make their
money go further
• Providing
business advice
• Ranging from
strategy to
operations,
financial
reporting, energy
efficiency and
much more.
5. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
Almost 55,000 SMEs reached annually inTurkey and theWestern Balkans
SME credit lines channelled through partner financial institutions to provide long-
term financing (EUR 1.8 bn inTurkey and EUR 1.1 bn in the Western Balkans)
Facilities and integrated programmes targeted sub-segments in agribusiness, energy
efficiency, trade finance and competitiveness (planned)
Dedicated SME instruments for debt, equity and quasi-equity investments
Advice for Small Businesses activities to improve competitiveness in enterprises at
pre- and post-investment stage (over 340 SMEs and 4330 SMEs assisted inTurkey and
theWestern Balkans)
Targeted policy dialogue to strengthen financial sector legislation
Close coordination with partner organisations under the multi-donorWestern Balkans
Enterprise Development and Innovation Facility, EDIF
EBRD response in facts and figures
6. Finance and Advice for Small Businesses
• Strong focus of the EBRD on financial inclusion, with a view to decrease regional
disparities and increase access to finance for underserved groups such as women
entrepreneurs and refugee-impacted communities
Dedicated integrated product to close the gender inclusion gap through the EBRD’s
flagship Women in Business Programme
EUR 175 mn in credit lines for women-led enterprises inTurkey and EUR 20
mn in the Western Balkans to date
Incentives to partner financial institutions to promote lending to new segment
Business advice for women-led SMEs, training, mentoring and coaching
Technical assistance to partner financial institutions
Strong focus on underserved regions, especially inTurkey, where activities largely
focus on the south and east regions
A comprehensive refugee response package forTurkey and surrounding countries
currently under preparation
Financial inclusion
87% of banks surveyed in the last EBRD bank survey (2011) point to a lack of creditworthy loan applicants
Some microfinance is available, and esp. in Turkey, leasing has gained momentum in recent years
Legal framework: For instance, ensure creditors’ rights, legislation in place for non-bank finance activities such as leasing and factoring
Incentives: Credit guarantee schemes or comprehensive credit bureaus, cadastre and systems of movable assets
An integrated toolbox addressing SME needs, with broad geographic availability of instruments and innovative products
A country-focused approach to ensure appropriate mix of activities
Add on the importance on leveraging access to finance with access to advice to help enterprises build internal capacities.
Info on direct investments:
ongoing investments of in a total of 13 SMEs in Turkey and 26 SMEs in the Western Balkan at an average investment of EUR 3.6 mn and a total portfolio of EUR 165 mn
Info on EDIF
SME Platform for the Western Balkans that brings together all major institutional investors, including the European Commission, EBRD, EIB, EIF, DEG, the World Bank, OECD, Austria and Italy
Launched in 2011 with a view to channel around EUR 300 million directly to SMEs in the region
Pillars include:
- Enterprise Innovation Fund (ENIF) for early to development stage equity financing in innovative SMEs;
Enterprise Expansion Fund (ENEF) for the provision of development and expansion capital to established high-growth potential SMEs
a regional Guarantee Facility to provide SME loan portfolio guarantees to financial intermediaries
Technical Assistance, including policy support to governments, facilitate business advice for SMEs and support to research (including for the SME Policy Index)
Overall conclusion: Overcoming access to finance is not only a question of swamping markets with finance, but requires a holistic approach that works both on the supply and demand side:
1.) Governments need to ensure a comprehensive and credible legal framework
2.) Banks lending can be incentivised with targeted policies and measures
3.) Financial instruments must be promoted and SMEs need to be educated about them
3.) Enterprises must work to increase internal capacities to become bankable
Multilateral initiatives that bring together both the donor community and beneficiary countries around one table, such as the EDIF, can support such a holistic but coordinated approach.