Disjoint Path Discovery in CCN Networks Asanga Udugama, Xinyi Zhang, Yasir Zaki, Carmelita Goerg (University of Bremen), Andreas Timm-Giel (Hamburg University of Technology)

1. 01'2"1*&,3)&4,01'5"6%78,1*,!!$,
$%&9"7:' ,
(')*+),-./+)#)"#$%!&'()'!*+,(-"#$%!.,/'0!*,1'"#$%!2,0345'6,!
7840-"#$!,(9!:(904,/!;'33<7'45"=$ !
!
"#$!>('?40/'6)!8@!A0434(%!A0434(%!7403,()!
"=$!B,3CD0-!>('?40/'6)!8@!;4E+(858-)%!B,3CD0-%!7403,()!
!"#$%&'!

2. FD65'(4
! G08C543!H6,6434(6! ! G40@803,(E4!R?,5D,J8(!
! H6,64<8@<:06! ! R?,5D,J8(!HE4(,0'8/!
! ID5JK,6+!'(!22L!! ! G40@803,(E4!I460'E/!
! 28(/'940,J8(/!@80!ID5JK,6+!M460'4?,5!
H60,64-'4/!!
! 28(E5D/'8(!
! 28(E5D/'8(!
! H85DJ8(!G08K8/,5/!
! :KK4(9'S!
! G,6+!N'/E8?40)!
! M4@404(E4/!
! N'/O8'(6!G,6+!N'/E8?40)!H60,64-'4/!
! P//D4/!8@!N'/E8?40'(-!N'/O8'(6!G,6+/!
! G,6+!>J5'Q,J8(!,(9!I,'(64(,(E4!
!
!"#$%&'!

3. H4EJ8(!#
37";<%#,=&)&%#%*&
!"#$%&'!

4. H6,64<8@<:06
server
! N4@,D56!22L!@80T,09'(-!34E+,('/3!!
! H4(9!,(!'(6404/6!8(!,55!!"#$%&$'()$*$+,-!@,E4/!
6+4(%!'@!6+404!'/!(8!04/K8(/4%!68!60)!,55!6+4!86+40!
@,E4/!'(!/4UD4(E4V#W!
< RXE'4(6!T+4(!/4,0E+'(-!6+4!(4'-+C80+889!68!Y(9!
6+4!94/'049!E8(64(6!!
< B'-+!045',C'5'6)!
< 2,D/4!D((4E4//,0)!60,XE!!
! ZA4/6![,E4!@80T,09'(-!34E+,('/3V#W!
< M49DE4!6+4!60,XE!68!0460'4?4!8(4!E8(64(6!E+D(1 !
< ://D34!,!E8(64(6!K08?'940!E,(!K08?'94!E8(/4EDJ?4!
E8(64(6!E+D(1/!!
< I'-+6!E,D/4!@04UD4(6!'(6404/6!04/4(9/!
< 28(/'940,J8(!8@!54,/6!945,)!E,(!54,9!68!D(C,5,(E49! client
60,@YE!9'/60'CDJ8(! Distributed caching allow client to
retrieve the Content from the nearest
cache
4 !"#$%&'!

5. ID5JK,6+!'(!22L!
! ID5JK,6+!'3K08?4/!(46T801'(-!K40@803,(E4! server
! ]8,9!C,5,(E'(-%!,--04-,J8(!8@!C,(9T'96+!
! [,D56!68540,(E4^'(E04,/49!045',C'5'6)!
! ]4//!K,6+!9'/E8?40'4/!
! 22L!'(+404(65)!/DKK806/!3D5JK,6+!
! ]88K<@044!E8(64(6!945'?40)!34E+,('/3!
< P(6404/6!E,(!C4!/4(6!8D6!?',!3D5JK54!'(640@,E4/!T'6+8D6!
T800)'(-!,C8D6!588K/!
! N'/60'CD649!'(<(46T801!E,E+'(-!'(!22L!
< P3K08?4!6+4!945,)^6+08D-+KD6!K40@803,(E4!C)!K5,E'(-!
6+4!28(64(6!5<"'%7,&",&4%,/'%7',
< M49DE4!6+4!'(E83'(-!60,XE!@083!(4'-+C80'(-!PHG/!!
< L,6D0,55)!@,?80/!3D5J<K8'(6!68!3D5J<K8'(6!E833D('E,J8(!
! Multiple nodes can provide the same content
! ID5JK,6+!E8(64(6!945'?40)!,9,K6/!68!6+4!+'-+< client
9)(,3'E!ZE,E+4!68K858-)!
Multipath in CCN
5 !"#$%&'!

6. 28(/'940,J8(/!@80!ID5JK,6+!M460'4?,5!H60,64-'4/!
! 22L!'/!,!+8/6!",9904//$!D(,T,04!(46T801'(-!,0E+'64E6D04!!
! GD04!/8D0E4!08DJ(-!,/!'(!PG!'/!'(@4,/'C54!'(!22L!
! 22L!+,/!(8!'94,!8@!6+4!K,6+/!CD6!8(5)!@,E4/!
! 2,((86!3,14!-58C,5!94E'/'8(/!
! 2,(!8(5)!946403'(4!T+'E+!@,E4!68!945'?40!,(!P(6404/6!
! :9+404(E4!68!@80T,09'(-!K0'(E'K54/!8@!22L!!
! _44K!6+4!C,5,(E4!8@!60,XE!"8(4<68<8(4!E8004/K8(94(E4$!
! :?8'9!08DJ(-!588K/!!
6 !"#$%&'!

7. H4EJ8(!=
="</>"*,37"?"')<'
!"#$%&'!

8. G,6+!N'/E8?40)!
! B8T!3,()!K,6+/!,04!(44949`!!
! ;2G^PGa!!6T8!80!6+044!K,6+/!,04!
4(8D-+!VbWV=W!
< I8/6!8@!6+4!K40@803,(E4!!
'3K08?434(6/!E,(!C4!!,E+'4?49!T'6+!,!
@4T!K,6+/!VbW!
< I804!K,6+/!04UD'04/!3804!8?40+4,9!68!
E8(6085!V=W!
< P(E04,/4/!6+4!E83K54S'6)!8@!60,XE!
9'/60'CDJ8(!/E+434V=W!!
! 22La!/J55!,(!8K4(!'//D4!
! F(5)!E8(/'940!6T8!K,6+/!@80!
/'3K5'E'6)!
Impact of shared links on the end-to-end video quality:
! B8T!68!/454E6!6+4/4!K,6+/`!! Multiple Descriptions (MD, using two paths) distortion vs.
Single Description (SD, using single path) distortion as
! N45,)! the number of joint links between two paths varies. [12]
! N'?40/'6)!
< M4/8D0E4!,--04-,J8(!
< B'-+40!@,D56<68540,(E4!
8 !"#$%&'!

9. G,6+!N'/E8?40)
! I46+89/!a!!
! #c!L894<9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!
< Fd40!6+4!38/6!04/8D0E4!,--04-,J8(! Content
< Fd40!6+4!+'-+4/6!94-044!8@!@,D56<68540,(E4!
< ]4,/6!E8338(!
! =c!]'(1<9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!
< ]8T40!04/8D0E4!,--04-,J8(!6+,(!L894<
9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!
< ]8T40!94-044!8@!@,D56<68540,(E4!
< :!-889!E83K083'/4!C46T44(!L894<9'/O8'(6! Client
,(9!L8(<9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!
! bc!L8(<9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!
Four types of node-or link-Disjoint Paths between a
< ]8T4/6!04/8D0E4!,--04-,J8(! client-Content pair
< ]8T4/6!94-044!8@!@,D56<68540,(E4!
! A single link or node failure can cause
multiple paths to fail
< 2,(!C4!4,/'5)!9'/E8?4049!
9 !"#$%&'!

10. N'/E8?40!L894<9'/O8'(6!G,6+/
! ;+4!@D(9,34(6,5!22L!@80T,09'(-!/60,64-'4/!-D,0,(644!6+,6!)&,#"'&,
"*%,5"?8,"@,)*8,?1%5%,"@,.)&),+"%',"6%7,)*8,<1*:,
or
Fundamental CCN forwarding strategy aggregates duplicate Interests and suppresses duplicate Contents
! P@!E5'4(6!/4(9/!8D6!,(!P(6404/6!8?40!,55!@,E4/%!6+4!046D0('(-!28(64(6!
6+,6!Y(,55)!,00'?4/!,6!6+4!E5'4(6!E,(!8(5)!6,14!K,6+/!,/!@8558T/a!
!
(a) (b) (c) (d)
There are four kinds of multiple paths taken by the returning Content in response to path-discovery Interests
10 !"#$%&'!

11. N'/E8?40!L894<9'/O8'(6!G,6+/
! P(6404/6!K,E146/!E8(6,'(!,!0,(983!(8(E4!?,5D4!/8!6+,6!9DK5'E,64/!
04E4'?49!8?40!9'd404(6!K,6+/!3,)!C4!9'/E,0949!V#W!
! P(!38/6!E,/4/%!!6+4!/'6D,J8(!'(!E,/4!"9$!E8D59!C4!,?8'949!/'(E4!6+4!9DK5'E,64!
'(6404/6!T'55!C4!9'/E,0949!,6!6+4!!(894!8@!'(640/4EJ8(!!
! RSE4KJ8(a!!P@!6+404!,504,9)!4S'/6!GP;!4(60'4/!!'(!6+4!'(640349',64!(894/%!6+4!
046D0('(-!E8(64(6!3,)!6,14!(8(<9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!!!
! H85DJ8(a!!R?40)!J34!6+4!E8(64(6!K08?'940!/4(9/!8D6!,!E8(64(6!E+D(1!6+08D-+!,!!
!!!!!,(!'(640@,E4%!,e,E+!,!(8(E4!8(!6+4!E8(64(6c!
PIT entry
PIT entry
Once an Interest meets an existing PIT
entry, the returning Contents may take
overlapped routes
11 !"#$%&'!

12. N'/E8?40!L894<9'/O8'(6!G,6+/
! P(!K,6+!9'/E8?40)!/6,-4%!@80E4! Nonce
6+4!E5'4(6!68!,EE4K6!K,6+/!6,14(!C)! 0056 Nonce
0024
28(64(6!E,00)'(-!D('UD4!(8(E4!
?,5D4/! PIT entry
! 28(64(6!K08?'940!!
< R,E+!E8(64(6!K08?'940!3,01/!,(!8D6-8'(-!
E8(64(6!T'6+!,!0,(983!(8(E4!?,5D4!
! 25'4(6! PIT entry
< :5T,)/!6,14!6+4!Y0/6!04E4'?49!E8(64(6!! Nonce
< 283K,04!6+4!(8(E4!?,5D4!8@!6+4!5,640! Nonce 0024
,00'?'(-!E8(64(6!T'6+!6+,6!8@!6+4!Y0/6! 0056
E8(64(6!04E4'K6! Client 1
Nonce
! :(!'(640349',64!(894!T'55!/46!6+4! 0056
9'/E8?4049!8D6-8'(-!@,E4!,/!6+4!ZA4/6!
Client 2
[,E4!,(9!D/4!'6!68!945'?40!6+4!
@8558T'(-!P(6404/6/! Discover node-disjoint Paths
12 !"#$%&'!

13. N'/E8?40!]'(1<9'/O8'(6!G,6+/
! P(!6+4!K,6+!9'/E8?40)!/6,-4%!,!346+89!'/!04UD'049!68!-D,0,(644!6+,6!!
! :()!'(640349',64!(894!9'/60'CD64/!6+4!046D0('(-!28(64(6/!68!9'd404(6!@,E4/!
! R,E+!28(64(6!'/!945'?4049!68!,6!38/6!8(4!8D6-8'(-!@,E4!
pending
The principles of the route discovery method for link-disjoint paths discovery
13 !"#$%&'!

14. N'/E8?40!]'(1<9'/O8'(6!G,6+/
! P(!K,6+!9'/E8?40)!/6,-4%!
! :e,E+!,!0,(983!(8(E4!,(9!,!f,-!68!6+4!'(6404/6! I
H
4?40)!J34!6+4!E5'4(6!/4(9!'6!8D6!6+08D-+!,(!
'(640@,E4!
! g+4(!6+4!'(640349',64!(894!04E4'?4/!,(!P(6404/6!
T'6+!,!f,-%!'6!T'55!
E F G
< P@!6+4!P(6404/6!T,/!(4?40!/44(!C4@804!h!E04,64!GP;!
4(60)!
< P@!6+4!P(6404/6!E,00'4/!,!9'd404(6!(8(E4!,(9!E834/!
@083!,!9'd404(6!@,E4!T'6+!6+4!'(6404/6/!K4(9'(-!
6+404!<<!57%)&%,),'%?)7)&%,3AB,%*&78,@"7,&4%,A*&%7%'&,, A B C D
< F6+40T'/4!<<!.1'5)7.,&4%,A*&%7%'&,
! R,E+!046D0('(-!28(64(6!E+D(1!E8(/D34/!8(5)!8(4!
GP;!4(60),CD7'&,57%)&%.,%*&78,1',5"*'/#%.,D7'&E!
< ;+4!/4E8(9!04E4'?49!28(64(6!E,(!E8(/D34!6+4!
/4E8(9!GP;!4(60)! client
! :(!P(640349',64!(894!T'55!/46!6+4!9'/E8?4049! Discover link-disjoint Paths
6T8!8D6-8'(-!@,E4/!,/!Z7889![,E4/!,(9!D/4!
6+43!68!945'?40!6+4!/DC/4UD4(6!P(6404/6/!
14 !"#$%&'!

15. P//D4/!8@!N'/E8?40'(-!N'/O8'(6!G,6+/!'(!22L
! ;+4!,5-80'6+3/!E,((86!-D,0,(644!6+,6!6+4!
9'/E8?4049!K,6+/!,04!#iij!9'/O8'(6!!
! :!E8(64(6!0460'4?49!C)!8(4!'(6404/6!3'-+6!C4!E,E+49!
,58(-!6+4!K,6+%!,(9!6+4(!C4!0460'4?49!,-,'(!C)!6+4! A
/,34!P(6404/6!@083!6+4!/,34!E5'4(6!!
< ;+4!E5'4(6!984/(k6!6,14!,!K,6+!T+'E+!+,/!5,0-4!945,)!
The algorithms cannot guarantee that the
! 28(/60,'('(-!6+4!/DC/4UD4(6!60,XE!8@!8(4! discovered paths are 100% disjoint
E5'4(6!68!6+4!9'/E8?4049!K,6+/!3,)C4!
E+,554(-'(-!
! ND0'(-!6+4!60,(/3'//'8(%!6+4!ZN'/E8?4049![,E4/!8@!
,(!'(640349',64!(894!E,(!E+,(-4!9D4!68!6+4!58E,5!
/60,64-)!5,)40!C4'(-!'(fD4(E49!C)!86+40!E5'4(6/! Discovered Face
It is challenging to constraint the
subsequent traffic of one client to the
discovered paths
15 !"#$%&'!

16. G,6+!>J5'Q,J8(!,(9!I,'(64(,(E4
! HE+49D5'(-!/E+434!
! M8D(9!M8C'(!
! :PIN!C,/49!0,J8!,9OD/634(6!!
! G,6+!M4<9'/E8?40)!!
! 25'4(6!
< g+4(!,!GP;!4(60)!4SK'04/%!0438?4!6+4!E8004/K8(9'(-!P(6404/6!945'?40)!@,E4!@083!6+4!P(6404/6!
945'?40)!/E+49D540c!H4(9!6+4!/DC/4UD4(6!P(6404/6/!68!6+4!86+40!@,E4c!P@!C86+!@,E4/!@,'5%!
049'/E8?40!6+4!,?,'5,C54!@,E4/c!
! P(640349',64!L894!
< ZA4/6![,E4!,5-80'6+3a!!g+4(!,!GP;!4(60)!4SK'04/%!0438?4!6+4!E8004/K8(9'(-!ZA4/6!@,E4!,(9!
049'/E8?40!6+4!,?,'5,C54!@,E4/c!
< Z7889![,E4/!,5-80'6+3a!g+4(!,!GP;!4(60)!4SK'04/%!0438?4!6+4!E8004/K8(9'(-!Z7889!@,E4c!
H4(9!6+4!/DC/4UD4(6!P(6404/6/!68!6+4!86+40!@,E4c!P@!C86+!@,E4/!@,'5%!049'/E8?40!6+4!,?,'5,C54!
@,E4/c!
16 !"#$%&'!

17. H4EJ8(!b
3%7@"7#)*5%,F6)</)>"*
!"#$%&'!

18. R?,5D,J8(!HE4(,0'8/
! R?,5D,J8(!;885/a!FGLR;!/'3D5,680!
! 2+D(1!/'Q4a!#i_A!VlW!
! ['54!/'Q4a!,?40,-49!#il!E+D(1/!"#iIA$!VmW!
! 2,E+4!/'Q4a!#i7A!VlW!
! 2,6,58-!/'Q4a!,!.8D;DC4<5'14!E,6,58-!
E8(/'/J(-!8@!#in!8CO4E6/!">K!68!#GA$!VoW!
! 28(64(6!K8KD5,0'6)!38945a!!*'K@!5,T!VmWVpW! OPNET-CCN node model
! ;+4!#in!Y54/!,04!4UD,55)!K,0JJ8(49!'(!#im!
E5,//4/!8@!K8KD5,0'6)%!28(64(6!'643/!8@!E5,//!1!"!1
!!!V#!%!#imW!$!,04!04UD4/649!T'6+!K08C,C'5'6)!qU1r
1s#%=ccccc%#i %!T+'E+!'/!
m!
!
OPNET-CCN process model
! 18 !"#$%&'!
!

19. R?,5D,J8(!HE4(,0'8/
! P(!8(4!K8KD5,0'6)!E5,//%!4,E+!28(64(6!'/!D('@8035)!E+8/4(!,38(-!#iii!28(64(6/%!
/8!6+4!K08C,C'5'6)!@80!,!Y54!68!C4!04UD4/649!qK1%3r!1s#%=ccccc%#i %!3s#%=tt%#iii!!'/!a!
m!
! L,3'(-!
! ;+4!E5'4(6!-4(40,64/!,(!P(6404/6!T+'E+!@8558T/!6+4!*'K@<5,T!
! [803,6!
uni-bremen/!!!!/!!!dummy.avi
0000 000
Generate a random 4-digit Generate a random 3-digit
number according to Zipf-law 0001 001 number uniformly
!! !!
9999 999
! 2,E+4!94E'/'8(!K85'E)!
! :]g:.Ha!(4T!28(64(6!'/!,5T,)/!E,E+49!
! [P&"G$a!E,E+'(-!94E'/'8(/!,04!6,14(!T'6+!,!YS49!K08C,C'5'6)!.!VicpmuicvW!VnW!
19 !"#$%&'!

20. R?,5D,J8(!HE4(,0'8/
! 2,E+4!04K5,E434(6!K85'E)!
! ]M>a!6+4!54,/6!04E4(65)!D/49!E+DE1!'/!04K5,E49!
! [P[Fa!6+4!8594/6!'(/40649!E+D(1!'/!04K5,E49!
! >LP[a!,!E+D(1!/454E649!D('@8035)!,6!0,(983!'/!04K5,E49VnW!
! ;8K858-'4/!
! F(4^/4?40,5!E5'4(6/!
! PHG!C,E1C8(4!(46T801!68K858-'4/Vv%!#i%!##W!,(9!38C'54!(46T801/!
! [80T,09'(-!H60,64-)!
! L894<9'/O8'(6!
! ]'(1<9'/O8'(6!
! ZA4/6![,E4!/60,64-)!V#W!
! N4@,D56!22L!@80T,09'(-!/60,64-)!V#W!
< H4(9!,(!P(6404/6!8(!,55!!"#$%&$'()$*$+,-!@,E4/%!'@!6+404!'/!(8!04/K8(/4%!60)!,55!6+4!86+40!@,E4/!
'(!/4UD4(E4!
20 !"#$%&'!

21. G40@803,(E4!I460'E/
! :?40,-4!N8T(58,9!;'34!
! P(6404/6^28(64(6!N45'?40)!M,J8!!
! M,J8!8@!/4(6<68<04E4'?49!
! G,6+!N'/E8?40)!RXE'4(E)!
! HDEE4//<68<@,'5D04!0,J8!8@!9'/E8?40'(-!K,6+/!
! B8K!N'/6,(E4/!
! ]8(-40!K,6+/!/D/E4KJC54!68!K,6+!C04,1/!V#bW!
! GP;!RSK'0,J8(!M,J8!
! RSK'049<68<E8(/D349!0,J8!
21 !"#$%&'!

22. H4EJ8(!l
!"*5</'1"*
!"#$%&'!

23. 28(E5D/'8(
! I8J?,J8(!
! ;+4!94@,D56!22L!@80T,09'(-!/E+434!V#W!E,D/4/!688!3DE+!D((4E4//,0)!60,XE!
! ZA4/6![,E4!,5-80'6+3!V#W!3,)!54,9!68!D(C,5,(E49!60,@YE!9'/60'CDJ8(!,(9!3,)!
049'/E8?40!K,6+/!3804!8w4(!'(!6+4!K04/4(E4!8@!@04UD4(6!68K858-'E,5!E+,(-4/!
! G,6+!/454EJ8(!/E+434/!E8(/'94049!
! L894!9'/O8'(6!
! ]'(1!9'/O8'(6!
! N4/'-(49!,!/E4(,0'8!,(9!3460'E/!@80!K40@803,(E4!4?,5D,J8(!!
! H'3D5,64!04,5!(46T801!4(?'08(34(6/!
! H4?40,5!K40@803,(E4!34,/D0434(6!3460'E/!
23 !"#$%&'!

24. H4EJ8(!m
(??%*.1G
!"#$%&'!

25. M4@404(E4/
! V#W!x,E8C/8(%!yc%!H34e40/%!Nc_c%!;+80(68(%!xcNc%!G5,//%!Ic%!A0'--/%!Lc%!A0,)(,09%!Mc%!!L46T801'(-!L,349!28(64(6%!P(!28L4S6%!
=iiv!
! V=W!L45,1D9'J%!Hc!,(9!*+,(-%!*c]c%!F(!/454EJ8(!8@!K,6+/!@80!3D5JK,6+!08DJ(-%!'(!zD,5'6)!8@!H40?'E4{Pgz8H%!=ii#%!KKc!
#pi<<#nl!
! VbW!!I,8%!Hc%!AD/+3'6E+%!Nc%!L,0,),(,(%!Hc!,(9!G,(T,0%!HcHc%!!IM;Ga!:!3D5J<f8T!04,5<
J34!60,(/K806!K0868E85!@80!,9!+8E!(46T801/%!'(!G08E449'(-/!8@!mn6+!PRRR!y4+'ED5,0!;4E+(858-)!28(@404(E4%!?85c!l%!FE68C40!
=iib%!KKc!=o=v<=oblc!
! VlW!M8//'%!Nc%!M8//'('%!7c%!!2,E+'(-!K40@803,(E4!8@!28(64(6!E4(60'E!(46T801/!D(940!3D5J<K,6+!08DJ(-!",(9!3804$!c!;4E+('E,5!
04K806%!;454E83!G,0'/;4E+%!=i##c!
! VmW!7'55%!Gc%!:05'e%!]'%!Ic%!*c%!,(9!I,+,(J%!:c%!.8D;DC4!60,XE!E+,0,E640'Q,J8(a!,!?'4T!@083!6+4!49-4%!'(!:2I!PI2%!=iip%!KKc!
#mh=n!
! VoW!2+,%!Ic%!_T,1%!Bc%!M890'-D4Q%!Gc%!:+(%!.c%!,(9!I88(%!Hc%!ZP!6DC4%!)8D!6DC4%!4?40)C89)!6DC4/a!,(,5)Q'(-!6+4!T8059k/!5,0-4/6!
D/40!-4(40,649!E8(64(6!?'948!/)/643%!'(!:2I!PI2%!=iip%!KKc!#h#lc!
! VpW!2,08Y-5'8%!7c%!7,558%!Ic%!,(9!ID/E,0'4558%!]c%!ZA,(9T'96+!,(9!H680,-4!H+,0'(-!G40@803,(E4!'(!P(@803,J8(!24(60'E!
L46T801'(-%!'(!:2I!HP72FII%!P2L!g801/+8K%!=i##%!KKc!#hoc!
! VnW!:0',(@,0%!Hc!,(9!L'1,(940%!Gc%!ZG,E146<54?45!2,E+'(-!@80!P(@803,J8(<E4(60'E!L46T801'(-%!'(!:2I!HP72FII%!M4:0E+!
g801/+8K%!=i#ic!
! VvW!:C'54(4!L46T801%!+eKa^^TTTc'(640(46=c49D^KDC/^=iimi=<PH<:LcK9@!
! V#iW!7R:L;!6+4!K,(<RD08K4,(!04/4,0E+!,(9!49DE,J8(!(46T801%!+eKa^^TTTc-4,(6c(46^I49',|24(604^I49',|]'C0,0)^
GDC5'/+'(-P3,-4/^#inlj=i7R:L;j=i;8K858-)j=iI:Mj=i#=cK9@!
! V##W!HK0'(-%!Lc%!I,+,O,(%!Mc%!,(9!g46+40,55%!Nc%!ZI4,/D0'(-!PHG!68K858-'4/!T'6+!M8E14}D45%!'(!:2I!HP72FII%!=ii=!
! V#=W!I,8%!Hc!46!,5c%!ZID5JK,6+!y'948!;0,(/K806!8?40!:9!B8E!L46T801/%!g'0454//!2833D('E,J8(/%!PRRR%!?85c!#=%!(8c!l%!=iim%!
KKc!l=hlvc!
! V#bW!]44%!Hcxc!,(9!7405,%!Ic%~HK5'6!3D5JK,6+!08DJ(-!T'6+!3,S'3,55)!9'/O8'(6!K,6+/!'(!,9!+8E!(46T801/%~!P22!=ii#%!KKc
b=i#<b=imc
25 !"#$%&'!

26. Thank you!
Questions?
26 !"#$%&'!