SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 33
Download to read offline
•What is the Psychological Impact
on Women who had an Abortion?
by: Sandra Persaud Tellini
November 30th, 2012
1
MY “I” STATEMENT
One of the most common surgical procedures in US
My interest stems from my personal experience
 I volunteered as a peer counselor for ten yrs at women in
crisis centers
 I have facilitated many support groups for post abortion
women who came forward to reconcile suppressed feelings
of the impact
 Many women need to be educated before
making any rash decisions and what to expect after
 High success rate of women finding holistic healing and
closure and free from internal negative self-talk to live fuller
lives 2
Why many women experience psychological
reaction to their abortion decision
• Colbert (as cited in, Koterski, 2004 p.79) commented, “Post
Abortion Stress Disorder brings together many symptoms, signs,
and behaviors with which women that experience after abortion
present for help.”
• Colbert further explains that what causes the psychological
symptoms of this disorder is, what Freud describes as, “the
resulting guilt which is often repressed within the person’s
unconscious in order to protect the personality from conflict.”
• This, Freud said, is the mental mechanisms of defense that keep
intact the personality that is in conflict.
• Abandonment upon discovery of the pregnancy often leaves
women feeling forced and backed into a corner to abort the
baby (Kimport, Foster, & Weitz, 2011). 3
Four Fundamental Factors of PASD
• Exposure to or participation in an abortion
experience, which is perceived as the traumatic
and deliberate destruction of one’s unborn child.
• An uncontrolled negative re-experiencing of the
abortion event.
• Unsuccessful attempts to avoid or deny painful
abortion recollections, resulting in reduced
responsiveness.
• Experiencing associated symptoms not present
before the abortion, including guilt about
surviving (Speckhard & Rue, 1992, p. 95).
4
Definitions
 Abortion: The word “abortion” is the intentional termination of
gestation by any means and at any time during pregnancy from
conception to full term. (Mohr, 1979)
 A “flashback” as relates to mental health is when memories of past
traumas feel as if they are taking place in the current moment.
 Acute Stress Disorder (ASD) is a psychological dysfunction which
results from a traumatic experience and characterized by the
development of severe anxiety, dissociative, and other symptoms
that occurs within one month after exposure to an extreme
traumatic stressor and last 2 days to four weeks. It overwhelms a
person’s normal mechanisms resulting in intense fear, feelings of
helplessness or being trapped, or loss of control.
 PTSD is similar to ASD except the duration of experiencing the
above symptomology is greater than one month (Bowles et al.,
2006, p. 970).
5
Definitions Cont’d
• (DSM-IV-TR) changed its language from
mental illness or disease to mental disorder. “a
clinical significant behavior or psychological syndrome or pattern that
occurs in an individual and is associated with present distress and
disability. It must be a manifestation of a behavioral, psychological or
biological dysfunction in the individual”. (CDC, 2008)
• Rue, as cited in Colbert (2003), first described PASD falls under PTSD
which is a sub-category of Anxiety Disorder
• PTSD is not a disease; it describes symptom clusters and behaviors and
recurrent events associated with severe trauma.
6
Delimitations
•To exclude women who have experienced an
abortion due to rape or for medical reasons.
•The implications including moral, theological and
political concerns are not be part of my research.
Limitation
• For the purpose of this research we will only
focus on women and the psychological impact
of the abortion.
7
Significance of the Study
My hope is that through this project I can make my
findings available to women in crisis centers so that
they can either determine the need for closure
and/or healing while equipping others to make an
informed choice.
 Awareness to the sensitivity of the impact of an
past abortion on a client …so that clinicians can
probe and determine if presenting problem is
primary or secondary.
8
Literature Review
Risk factors by the American Psychological Association Task
Force on Mental Health and Abortion in their 2008 report:
• Terminating a pregnancy that is wanted or meaningful.
• Perceived pressure from others to terminate a
pregnancy.
• Perceived opposition to the abortion from partners,
family, and/or friends.
• Lack of perceived social support from others.
• Various personality traits (e.G., Low self-esteem, a
pessimistic outlook, low-perceived control over life).
• A history of mental health problems prior to the
pregnancy.
• Feelings of stigma.
• Perceived need for secrecy. 9
Literature Review Cont’d
Risk factors by the American Psychological Association Task
Force on Mental Health and Abortion in their 2008 report:
• Exposure to anti-abortion picketing
• Use of avoidance and denial coping strategies
• Feelings of commitment to the pregnancy
• Ambivalence about the abortion decision
• Low perceived ability to cope with the abortion
• History of prior abortion
• Late term abortion
• Being an adolescent (not an adult)
• Having a non-elective (therapeutic or coerced) abortion
• Prior history of abortion (having a second or third abortion,
or more)
10
Statistics from US Census of Bureau
11,270, 1%
1,700, 0%
19,500, 2%
4,890, 0%
California 214,190
15,960, 1%
17,030, 1%
7,070, 1%
4,450, 0%
FLorida 94,360
39,820,
3%
5,630, 0%
1,800, 0%
54,920, 5%
NJ
10,680, 1%
6,560, 1%
9,770, 1%
4,430, 0%14,860,
1%
2,800, 0%
34,290, 3%
24,900, 2%
36,790, 3%
13,060,
1%2,770, 0%
7,440, 1%2,230, 0%
2,840, 0%13,450,
1%
3,200, 0%
54,160,
4%
Illinios6,150, 1%
New York 153,110 37.6%
33,140, 3%
1,400, 0%
33,550, 3%
7,160, 1%
12,920, 1% 41,000, 3%
5,000, 0%
7,300, 1%
850, 0%
19,550, 2%
84,610, 7%
Texas
4,000, 0%
1,510,
0%
28,520, 2%
24,320, 2% 2,280,
0%
8,230, 1% 90,
0%
Abortions by State of Occurrence and Residence 2008
1 2
3 4
5 6
7 8
9 10
11 12
13 14
15 16
17 18
19 20
21 22
23 24
25 26
27 28
29 30
31 32
33 34
35 36
37 38
39 40
41 42
43 44
45 46
47 48
49 50
51
11
Age of woman: %
.Less than 15 years old 3.0%
..15 to 19 years old 18.7%
..20 to 24 years old 38.8%
..25 to 29 years old 28.7%
..30 to 34 years old 18.1%
..35 to 39 years old 10.1%
..40 years old and over 3.4%
Race and ethnicity of woman in 2008:
Abortion rate per 1,000 women
..White 13.8%
..Black 48.2%
..Other 21.6%
..Hispanic 26.0%
..Non-Hispanic White 10.6%
12
58%
14.20%
19.00%
8.50%
Whites
Black
Hispanics or Latino
Other
Literature Review Cont’d – Low Risk for
post-abortion psychological maladjustments
Can be described as a woman who has
• maturely,
• thoughtfully,
• and freely arrived at her abortion decision and
• has no emotional, social, or moral conflicts
which challenge that decision..
13
Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post-
abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities
• I. CONFLICTED DECISION
A) Difficulty making the decision, ambivalence,
unresolved doubts
• 1. Moral beliefs against abortion
• 2. Conflicting maternal desires
• 3. Second or third trimester abortion
• 4. Low coping expectancy
14
Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post-
abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities Cont’d
• B. Feels pressured or coerced
– a. Feels decision is not her own, or is “her only
choice”
– b. Feels pressured to choose too quickly
• C. Decision is made with biased, inaccurate,
or inadequate information
15
Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post-
abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities Cont’d
II . PSYCHOLOGICAL OR DEVELOPMENTAL
LIMITATIONS
A. Adolescence, emotional immaturity
B. Prior emotional or psychiatric problems
C. Lack of social support
D. Prior abortion(s)
E. Prior miscarriage
F. Less education
16
Literature Review Cont’d –
Resources available
• Counseling - one-on-one or group therapy or a
combination of both.
• In-person support (attending a weekend retreat,
working with a therapist, a clergyperson or a peer
counselor, or going to a weekly group)
• Online support (online chats, internet message
boards, e-mail groups). Several organizations
offer a combination of email or internet-based
group support and in-person support.
Finding the right resources that is best suited to the
individual woman is important.
17
Methodology
• Participatory action research
• Survey – population targeted - post-abortion women who sought help at
crisis pregnancy centers.
• Characteristics – various cultural backgrounds, socio-economic levels,
varying age ranging from twelve years old to mid seventies and from various
religious backgrounds at the time of the abortion
• Who responded to a community service invitation, in Broward and Volusia
counties in Fl to attend a support group for post-abortion women seeking
healing and closure.
• I contacted the participants by either telephone or emailed and then email
the questionnaire and consent form.
• Random sample population of 20 post-abortion participants in Fl
• 13 questions - 2 open ended questions & 11 closed-ended questions. (8
closed ended dichotomous questions, 2 numerical questions, 2 Likert-scale
questions, 1 Likert scaled question which comprised of twenty-eight parts.
• Designed to uncover attitudes, opinions, knowledge and experience 18
Results of the Questionnaire
The first question was a rule out question in case my survey did not reach
my target population.
1. Have you experienced an abortion in the past?
Yes No In bold letters it stated
IF YES, PLEASE CONTINUE. IF NO, PLEASE STOP HERE. THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TIME.
100% =yes.
2. What is your age? Under 18 yrs 18- 25 yrs 26 – 40
yrs 40 and over
10% were between 18-25 years old, 30% were between 26-40 years old,
60% were between 40 and over years old.
3. (If you had more than one abortion) at what stage of the pregnancy did
you have the abortion that affected you the most?
<6 wks 7-10 wks 11-15 wks 16 - 20 wks > 20 wks
<6 wks =20% 7-10 wks = 40% 11-15 weeks = 40% 4.What is
your ethnic background? ___
70% were Caucasian, 20% were Hispanic, and 10% were Black.
5. Please rate your feelings/experience from 0-3 (0= No Effect; 1 = Some
Effect; 2 = Great Effect; 3 = Very Intense). The first column (1) applies to
the weeks immediately following the abortion experience. The second
column (2) applies to how you feel now or felt at the time you sought help
to cope with the any distressful feelings from the past abortion. 19
COL#1
results %
0 1 2 3
Measures their psychological
experience in each below
category
COL#2
results
%
0
1 2 3
5 0 5 90 Guilt 0 10 55 35
5 0 45 50 Emotional ‘Numbing’ 10 10 35 45
30 15 30 25 Dreams/Nightmares 30 20 20 30
5 15 25 55 Change In Relationships 10 40 25 25
5 15 30 50 Inferiority Feeling 5 30 25 40
70 5 20 5 Dizziness/Fainting 80 10 10 0
20 40 30 10 Sleep Disturbances 45 35 20 5
25 30 35 10 Can’t Make Friends 25 35 30 10
15 20 20 45 Preoccupation With Abortion 20 60 20 0
5 10 30 55 Sexual Problems 0 20 60 20
5 15 75 5 Relief 0 20 60 20
15 25 15 45 Depressed 10 45 20 25
5 10 40 45 Sad 20 35 30 15
25 35 20 25 Anxiety 35 40 15 10
30 15 30 25 Suicidal Ideas 40 20 30 10
Results of Questionnaire Q 5
20
Results of Questionnaire Q 5
25 20 15 40 Alcohol/Drugs 45 20 15 20
5 35 22 25 Loneliness 5 40 30 25
5 15 25 55 Sense Of Loss 40 40 10 10
5 10 25 60 Secretive 0 15 35 50
10 25 15 50 Crying Spells 15 40 35 10
5 20 15 60 Regret 0 0 50 50
10 35 20 35 Angry 15 35 25 25
25 25 20 30 Helplessness 35 30 25 10
45 30 10 15 Headaches 60 30 10 0
25 25 25 25 Eating Disorder 60 20 15 5
40 35 15 10 Panic Feelings 50 40 10 0
10 40 35 15 Unable To Relax 40 30 30 0
5 25 55 15 Fear Of Failure 0 50 35 15 21
Results of Survey
6. Did you feel pressured into having an abortion? Yes No 70%= yes and
30%= no.
7.Do you experience a disconnect with bonding with your children since
having the abortion? Yes No NA 40% = yes, 50% = no and 10% = NA
8. Have you experienced in the past recurring "flashbacks" of the abortion
episode, with no apparent explanation for what is causing them? Yes No
70% = yes 30% = no.
9. Since the abortion have you experienced anxiety over fertility issues?
Yes No 70% = yes, and 30% = no.
10. Since the abortion have you experienced anxiety over childbearing issues?
Yes No 65% = yes and 35% = no.
11. Since the abortion have found you had difficulty with intimacy?
Yes No 80% = yes and 20% = no.
12. Did you have a change of mind about the abortion just before the event?
Yes No 50% = yes and 50% = no. 22
Question 13 – last words
“Public awareness of the after effects of an abortion & a high risk on a woman’s
fertility”.
“Once it is done, it’s done and can’t be undone. check your options and be sure about
your decision
Women need to be valued & supported as they r presented all options and allowed to
ponder.
“The abortion had a profound impact on my life and everything including my
relationship with others and created sexual issues and how I viewed my partner”.
You need to pause and take a deep breath, explore all your choices and after listening to
everyone around you, process it then you make your own decision. It is a final decision
that can’t be undone”.
“I was quite functional because I buried it for years. When I finally went through a
support group and had to name the unborn baby to bring closure … it was then I realized
I had never acknowledged his personhood. It opened the door for me to grieve and
finally be healed. For years I lived with secret shame.
“I was for abortion because I thought women should be in charge of their bodies. I had
managed to hide away a lot of hurt and pain from my own abortions for a long time, but
the cost in other areas of my life was too much.
23
Discussion
The Survey says:….
• Even though all abortions occurred in a woman’s fertility cycle, most
unplanned pregnancies occurred prior to age thirty
• 60% of sample were over 40yrs old - most women sought help many years
after the abortion experience.
• Cultural biases was reflected in those who sought help 70% Caucasian , 20%
Hispanic, 10% Black
• First Column - Soon after the event very intense feelings were:
#1 Guilt, Regret (90%), #2 Secretive (60%),
#3 Change in Relationships, Sexual Problems, & Sense of Loss (55%),
#4 Emotional Numbing, Inferiority feeling, & Crying Spells (50%)
No Effect –
# 1 Dizziness/Fainting (70%), #2 Headaches (45%), #3 Panic Feelings (40%)
2nd column Feedback -Recently or at the time they sought help
• Very Intense feelings –
• #1 Regret” and “Secretive(50%) #2 Emotional Numbing (45%), #3 Inferiority
Feeling (40%), #4 Guilt (35%)
No Effect, #1 Dizziness/Fainting (80%), #2 Headaches & Eating Disorder (60%)
#3 Panic Feelings (50%).
Not one of them was left unaffected by their abortion experience. 24
Q uestion#6 70% - felt pressured into having an abortion.
Q #7 Regarding whether the woman experienced a disconnect with bonding with
their children since having the abortion
40 % YES,
50 % NO
10 % NOT APPLICABLE
Question #8
Whether the participants had experienced in the past recurring "flashbacks" of the
abortion episode, with no apparent explanation for what is causing them?
70 % YES
30 % NO.
• Question #9 asked, since the abortion have you experienced
anxiety over fertility issues?
• 70 % YES
• 30 % NO
• Question #10 a response to anxiety over childbearing issues. The
response was very similar to question 9 as
65 % YES
35% NO .
25
• Q#11 asked whether since the abortion, the
participant found has had difficulty with intimacy;
• 80 % YES , 20 % NO.
• Q #12 asked did she have a change of mind about the
abortion just before the event.
• 50 % YES , 50 % NO.
• Q#13 Comments: Revealed that their regret about
their abortion decision and had many words of advice
to those who may be in a crisis pregnancy and still
looking to explore their choices.
• Though they could not reverse their prior decision
had gotten pass the blaming on to others,
• Seemed to have reached a place where they
took responsibility for their actions,
• Made peace with their past and experienced closure
26
A few common threads…
• Firstly, unexpected pregnancies are always stressful.
• And stress is a major cause of both mental illness and
physical illness.
• Real need for emotional adjustments after abortion.
• Strong link between abortion and mental health problems
in women.
• Repression as a coping means, may be a long period of
denial before a woman seeks psychiatric care
• Repressed feelings may cause psychosomatic illnesses and
psychiatric or behavior in other areas causing her to
seeking therapy for apparently unrelated problems.
•
•
27
Why should you care?
• Everyone knows someone directly affected, no
one is untouched
• Women represents > ½ population
• An average of fifty percent of pregnancies are
unwanted and
• 4 in 10 of these are terminated by abortion. 22 %
of all pregnancies end in abortion (CDC)
• An unacknowledged post-abortion distress may
be contributory – Clinician can probe and
determine if presenting problem is primary or
secondary
28
Recommendations
Based on these findings, most of which have been published by
researchers who favor legalized abortion, it would appear
reasonable to expect, and demand, that abortion providers:
1) Provide pre-consent information.
2) Provide adequate pre-abortion screening using the criteria
outlined above.
3) Provide individualized counseling to high risk patients.
4) Assist women who have pre-identifying high risk factors in
evaluating and choosing lower risk solutions to their social,
economic, and health needs.
29
Closing Statement
The significance of this study is to identify that a considerable
number of women who experienced an abortion did not walk
away unharmed by their decision.
Rather, the psychological effects they sustain require the
necessity to make available a safe place for them to find
healing; whether in a group or individual setting.
To this end, this study is important to the field of mental health
counseling.
30
•References
Adler, N.E., et al., “Psychological Factors in Abortion: A Review” American Psychologist47(10):1194-1204 (1992).
Adler, N.E., et al., “Psychological Responses After Abortion,” Science, 248:41-44 (1990).
Ashton, J.R. “The Psychosocial Outcome of Induced Abortion”, British Journal of Ob&Gyn., 87:1115-1122 (1980).
Babikian & Goldman, “A Study in Teen-Age Pregnancy,” Am. J. Psychiatry, 755 (1971).
Barnard, C.A., The Long-Term Psychosocial Effects of Abortion (Portsmouth, NH: Institute for Pregnancy Loss, 1990).
Belsey, E.M., et al., “Predictive Factors in Emotional Response to Abortion: King’s Termination Study – IV,” Soc. Sci. & Med., 11:71-
82 (1977).
Blumberg,B.D., et al., “The Psychological Sequelae of Abortion Performed for a Genetic Indication,” Am. J. of Obstetrics and
Gynecology 122(7):799-808 (1975).
Bracken, M.B., et al., “The Decision to Abort and Psychological Sequelae” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 158:154-162
(1974).
Bracken, M.B. “A Causal Model of Psychosomatic Reactions to Vacuum Aspiration Abortion,” Social Psychiatry, 13:135-145 (1978).
Campbell, N.B., et al., “Abortion in Adolescence,” Adolescence 23:813-823 (1988).
Cohen, L. & Roth, S., “Coping With Abortion,” Journal of Human Stress 10:140-145 (1984).
Council on Scientific Affairs, American Medical Association, “Induced Termination of Pregnancy Before and After Roe v Wade:
Trends in Mortality and Morbidity of Women,” JAMA, 268(22):3231-3239 (1992).
David, H.P., “Post-abortion and Post-partum Psychiatric Hosptialization,” 1985 Abortion: Medical Progress and Social
Implications (London: Ciba Foundation Symposium 115, 1985) 150-64.
De Veber, L.L., et.al., “Post-Abortion Grief: Psychological Sequelae of Induced Abortion,”Humane Medicine,7(3):203-8 (1991).
Dunlop, “Counseling of Patients Requesting an Abortion,” The Practitioner, 220:847-852 (1978).
Franz, W., Reardon, D., “Differential Impact of Abortion on Adolescents and Adults,”Adolescence, 27(105):161-172 (1992).
Friedman, C.M. et al., “The Decision-Making Process and the Outcome of Therapeutic Abortion,” Am J of Psychiatry, 131(12):1332-
1337 (1974).
Furlong, R. & Black, R., “Pregnancy Termination for Genetic Indications: The Impact on Families,” Social Work in Health
Care, 10(1):17 (1984).
Lazarus, A., Stern, R., “Psychiatric Aspects of Pregnancy Termination,” Clinics in Obs/Gyn,13(1):125-134 (1986).
31
References
Gold, D., et.al., The Abortion Choice: Psychological Determinants and Consequences (Montreal: Concordia University Department
of Psychology, 1984).
Heath, D.S., “Psychiatry and Abortion,” Can Psychiatr Assoc J, 16:55-63 (1971).
Hern, W. Abortion Practice, (Boulder, CO: Alpenglo Graphics, Inc., 1990).
Landy, U. “Abortion Counseling – A New Component of Medical Care,” Clinics in Obs/Gyn, 13(1):33-41 (1986).
Lask, B. “Short-term Psychiatric Sequelae to Therapeutic Termination of Pregnancy,”Br J Psychiatry, 126: 173-177 (1975).
Lazarus, A. “Psychiatric Sequelae of Legalized Elective First Trimester Abortion”,Journal of Psychosomatic Ob&Gyn 4:141-150
(1985).
Lemkau, J.P., “Emotional Sequelae of Abortion,” Psychology of Women Quarterly, 12:461-472 (1988).
Lloyd, J. & Laurence, K.M., “Sequelae and Support After Termination of Pregnancy for Fetal Malformation,” British Medical Journal,
290:907-909 (1985).
Major, B. & Cozzarelli,C., “Psychosocial Predictors of Adjustment to Abortion,” Journal of Social Issues, 48(3):121-142 (1992).
Major, B., et al., “Attributions, Expectations and Coping with Abortion,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48:585-599
(1985).
Mahkorn, S. K., “Pregnancy & Sexual Assault,” The Psychological Aspects of Abortion, Mall, D., & Watts, W.F., eds., (Washington,
D.C.: University Publications of America, 1979) pp.53-72.
Margolis, A.J.,et.al., “Therapeutic Abortion Follow-up Study,” Am J Obstet Gynecol, 110:243-9 (1971).
Martin, C.D., “Psychological Problems of Abortion for Unwed Teenage Girls,” Genetic Psychology Monographs 88:23-110 (1973).
Miller, W.B., “An Empirical Study of the Psychological Antecedents and Consequences of Induced Abortion,” Journal of Social
Issues, 48(3):67-93 (1992).
Moseley, D.T., et al., “Psychological Factors That Predict Reaction to Abortion,” J. of Clinical Psychology, 37:276-279 (1981).
Mueller, P. & Major, B., “Self-blame, Self-efficacy and Adjustment to Abortion,” Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology 57:1059-1068 (1989).
Ney, P.G. & Wickett, A.R., “Mental Health and Abortion: Review and Analysis,” Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa, 14(4):506-16 (1989).
Osofsky J.D. & Osofsky, H.J., “The Psychological Reaction of Patients to Legalized Abortion,” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,
42:48-60 (1972).
Osofsky, J.D., et al., “Psychological Effects of Abortion: with Emphasis upon the Immediate Reactions and Followup,” in H. J.
Osofsky & J.D. Osofsky, eds., The Abortion Experience (Hagerstown, MD: Harper & Row, 1973), 189-205.
Payne, E.C., et al., “Outcome Following Therapeutic Abortion,” Archives of General Psychiatry, 33:725-33 (1976).
32
References
Rayburn, W. & Laferla, J.,“Mid-gestational Abortion for Medical or Genetic Indications,” Clin Obstet Gynaecol
13:71-82 (1986).
Rosenfeld, J. “Emotional Responses to Therapeutic Abortion,” American Family Physician, 45(1):137-140,
(1992).
Rue, V. & Speckhard, A., “Informed Consent & Abortion: Issues in Medicine & Counseling,” Medicine & Mind
7:75-95 (1992).
Senay, E., “Therapeutic Abortion: Clinical Aspects,” Arch Gen Psychiatry 23:408-15, (1970).
Shusterman, L.R., “Predicting the Psychological Consequences of Abortion,” Social Science and Medicine,
13A:683-689 (1979).
Sim, M., Neisser, R., “Post-abortive Psychoses: A Report From Two Centers,” The Psychological Aspects of
Abortion, Mall, D. and Watts W.F.(eds)(Washington, DC: University Publications of America, 1979).
Speckhard, A. & Rue, V., “Postabortion Syndrome: An Emerging Public Health Concern,” Journal of Social Issues,
48(3):95-119 (1992).
Vaughan, H.P., Canonical Variates of Post Abortion Syndrome (Portsmouth, NH: Institute for Pregnancy Loss,
1990).
Wallerstein, J.S. et.al.,”Psychological Sequelae of Therapuetic Abortion in Young Unmarried Women,” Arch Gen
Psychiatry 27:828-32 (1972).
Zakus, G. & Wilday, S., “Adolescent Abortion Option,” Social Work in Health Care, 12(4):77-91 (1987).
Zimmerman, M., Passage Through Abortion (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1977).
Zimmerman, M. “Psychosocial and Emotional Consequences of Elective Abortion: A Literature Review”, in Paul
Sachdev, ed., Abortion: Readings and Research (Toronto:Butterworth, 1981).
Zolese, G. & Blacker, C.V.R., “The Psychological Complications of Therapeutic Abortion” British J Psych 160:742-
749 (1992).
33

More Related Content

What's hot

Mental Health Risk Assessment
Mental Health Risk AssessmentMental Health Risk Assessment
Mental Health Risk AssessmentEwen McPhee
 
Mental Health Project
Mental Health ProjectMental Health Project
Mental Health ProjectSteven Gates
 
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depression
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - DepressionAgeing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depression
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depressionanne spencer
 
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...NationalBurnsCentre2000
 
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11CORE Group
 
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model Denice Colson
 
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernan
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernanEmotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernan
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernanIrish Cancer Society
 
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...ADAMH Board of Franklin County
 
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next Door
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next DoorKids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next Door
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next DoorStephen Grcevich, MD
 
DV Survivors health poster FINAL
DV Survivors health poster FINALDV Survivors health poster FINAL
DV Survivors health poster FINALShannon Corcoran
 
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...ErikaAGoyer
 
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programs
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and ProgramsARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programs
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programskwatkins13
 

What's hot (20)

Trauma and trauma-informed care
Trauma and trauma-informed careTrauma and trauma-informed care
Trauma and trauma-informed care
 
Mental Health Risk Assessment
Mental Health Risk AssessmentMental Health Risk Assessment
Mental Health Risk Assessment
 
Mental Health Project
Mental Health ProjectMental Health Project
Mental Health Project
 
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depression
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - DepressionAgeing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depression
Ageing & Mental Health : Beyond Dementia - Depression
 
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...
Psychological assessment of burns by Suhasini Oliveira, National Burns Centre...
 
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11
More than baby blues_Senefeld, Reider, Schooley_10.13.11
 
Shame, addiction & chronic pain
Shame, addiction & chronic painShame, addiction & chronic pain
Shame, addiction & chronic pain
 
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model
Becoming a Trauma Informed Addictions Counselor using a Source-Focused Model
 
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernan
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernanEmotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernan
Emotional effects of a cancer diagnosis in younger women - Dee McKiernan
 
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury a...
 
Bruce Perry
Bruce PerryBruce Perry
Bruce Perry
 
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next Door
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next DoorKids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next Door
Kids With "Issues"...The Mission Field Next Door
 
High net worth clients power, prestige, problems
High net worth clients  power, prestige, problemsHigh net worth clients  power, prestige, problems
High net worth clients power, prestige, problems
 
2015 Childhood Cancer Symposium - Post-Traumatic Stress
2015 Childhood Cancer Symposium - Post-Traumatic Stress2015 Childhood Cancer Symposium - Post-Traumatic Stress
2015 Childhood Cancer Symposium - Post-Traumatic Stress
 
DV Survivors health poster FINAL
DV Survivors health poster FINALDV Survivors health poster FINAL
DV Survivors health poster FINAL
 
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...
Descriptive Assessment of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in an Outpatient Ob...
 
6. final
6. final6. final
6. final
 
Suicide Medical Conference Oct 2019
Suicide Medical Conference Oct 2019Suicide Medical Conference Oct 2019
Suicide Medical Conference Oct 2019
 
High wealth high touch
High wealth  high touchHigh wealth  high touch
High wealth high touch
 
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programs
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and ProgramsARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programs
ARGEC Depression: Treatment and Programs
 

Viewers also liked

Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3
Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3
Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3cslonern
 
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtg
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtgSwanson rfo-pres-grp-mtg
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtgDelroy Cameron
 
Perinatal loss 2012
Perinatal loss 2012 Perinatal loss 2012
Perinatal loss 2012 cslonern
 
Radio Documentary Pitch
Radio Documentary PitchRadio Documentary Pitch
Radio Documentary PitchRoshan Roberts
 
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point Presentation
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point PresentationEmotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point Presentation
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point PresentationNbecker4
 
ultrasonic images of abortion
ultrasonic images of abortionultrasonic images of abortion
ultrasonic images of abortionaishaibad
 
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...Irish Hospice Foundation
 
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...Irish Hospice Foundation
 
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICU
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICUIdentifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICU
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICUKirsti Dyer MD, MS
 
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving Parents
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving ParentsGrief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving Parents
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving ParentsKirsti Dyer MD, MS
 
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...Irish Hospice Foundation
 
Perinatal Loss And Grief
Perinatal Loss And GriefPerinatal Loss And Grief
Perinatal Loss And Griefemk10t
 
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...British Sociological Association
 
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And Dads
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And DadsDemystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And Dads
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And DadsSummit Health
 
Abortions and Post Abortion Care
Abortions and Post Abortion CareAbortions and Post Abortion Care
Abortions and Post Abortion CareMubarak Yusuf
 
Teen Pregnancy Powerpoint
Teen Pregnancy PowerpointTeen Pregnancy Powerpoint
Teen Pregnancy Powerpointmarcginsberg
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Depression
DepressionDepression
Depression
 
Sr Paper Presentation - SP14
Sr Paper Presentation - SP14Sr Paper Presentation - SP14
Sr Paper Presentation - SP14
 
Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3
Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3
Perinatal loss 2010 review day 3
 
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtg
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtgSwanson rfo-pres-grp-mtg
Swanson rfo-pres-grp-mtg
 
Perinatal loss 2012
Perinatal loss 2012 Perinatal loss 2012
Perinatal loss 2012
 
Radio Documentary Pitch
Radio Documentary PitchRadio Documentary Pitch
Radio Documentary Pitch
 
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point Presentation
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point PresentationEmotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point Presentation
Emotional Consequences Of Post Abortion Power Point Presentation
 
ultrasonic images of abortion
ultrasonic images of abortionultrasonic images of abortion
ultrasonic images of abortion
 
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...
The Experiences of Mothers as They Suppress Lactation Following Late Miscarri...
 
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...
'Why did my baby die? Perinatal Post-mortem information from the Pregnancy Lo...
 
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICU
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICUIdentifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICU
Identifying, Understanding and Working with Grieving Parents in the NICU
 
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving Parents
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving ParentsGrief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving Parents
Grief in the NICU: Identifying, Understanding and Helping Grieving Parents
 
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...
'The Butterfly Room, A Space for Bereaved Familes, at Our Lady of Lourdes Hos...
 
Teenage pregnancy (2)
Teenage pregnancy (2)Teenage pregnancy (2)
Teenage pregnancy (2)
 
Perinatal Loss And Grief
Perinatal Loss And GriefPerinatal Loss And Grief
Perinatal Loss And Grief
 
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...
We ARE Family: disenfranchised grief, griefwork and perinatal loss by Gayle L...
 
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And Dads
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And DadsDemystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And Dads
Demystifying Postpartum Depression And Anxiety For Moms And Dads
 
Abortion.
Abortion.Abortion.
Abortion.
 
Abortions and Post Abortion Care
Abortions and Post Abortion CareAbortions and Post Abortion Care
Abortions and Post Abortion Care
 
Teen Pregnancy Powerpoint
Teen Pregnancy PowerpointTeen Pregnancy Powerpoint
Teen Pregnancy Powerpoint
 

Similar to What is the Psychological Impact on Women who had an Abortion

Depression in reproductive age women
Depression in reproductive age womenDepression in reproductive age women
Depression in reproductive age womenNirsuba Gurung
 
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014Joy Burkhard
 
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla Coleman
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla ColemanMujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla Coleman
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla ColemanMario Guillermo Simonovich
 
The Role of Counselling in IVF
The Role of Counselling in IVFThe Role of Counselling in IVF
The Role of Counselling in IVFSujoy Dasgupta
 
Counselling/ human behavior /
Counselling/ human behavior / Counselling/ human behavior /
Counselling/ human behavior / AbhilashKrishna1
 
Postpartum Depression Policy Brief
Postpartum Depression Policy BriefPostpartum Depression Policy Brief
Postpartum Depression Policy BriefPhylicia Morgan
 
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptx
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptxIntroduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptx
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptxCarolinaOrtega619481
 
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...AkashBhagatsingYadav
 
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERSREACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERSdivya2709
 
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18Nick Szubiak, MSW, LCSW
 
Hmns10085 mod8(1)
Hmns10085 mod8(1)Hmns10085 mod8(1)
Hmns10085 mod8(1)Mark Felvus
 
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and Shame
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and ShameNormalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and Shame
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and ShameHer Smart Choice
 
Challenges and dillema
Challenges and dillemaChallenges and dillema
Challenges and dillemachaimingcheng
 
Understanding mental health and mental illness
Understanding mental health and mental illnessUnderstanding mental health and mental illness
Understanding mental health and mental illnessMD. Rifat Hossain
 
Rose childpsy ppt
Rose childpsy pptRose childpsy ppt
Rose childpsy pptrosaliekp
 
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptx
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptxMy-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptx
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptxFranzToledo5
 
Counseling anxiety disorders brochure
Counseling anxiety disorders brochureCounseling anxiety disorders brochure
Counseling anxiety disorders brochureBeloit Health System
 
Mental illness in pregnancy
Mental illness in pregnancyMental illness in pregnancy
Mental illness in pregnancynabinabhas
 

Similar to What is the Psychological Impact on Women who had an Abortion (20)

Depression in reproductive age women
Depression in reproductive age womenDepression in reproductive age women
Depression in reproductive age women
 
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014
Maternal Mental Health: CA Department of Public Health Nov 6, 2014
 
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla Coleman
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla ColemanMujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla Coleman
Mujeres que sufrieron con el aborto - Priscilla Coleman
 
The Role of Counselling in IVF
The Role of Counselling in IVFThe Role of Counselling in IVF
The Role of Counselling in IVF
 
Counselling/ human behavior /
Counselling/ human behavior / Counselling/ human behavior /
Counselling/ human behavior /
 
Postpartum Depression Policy Brief
Postpartum Depression Policy BriefPostpartum Depression Policy Brief
Postpartum Depression Policy Brief
 
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptx
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptxIntroduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptx
Introduction to psychology health psychology Intro to Psych Powerpoint 6.pptx
 
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...
Mental health includes our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. I...
 
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERSREACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
REACTION TO STRESS DISORDER AND ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
 
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18
Connecting the dots trauma and addiction natcon18
 
Hmns10085 mod8(1)
Hmns10085 mod8(1)Hmns10085 mod8(1)
Hmns10085 mod8(1)
 
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and Shame
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and ShameNormalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and Shame
Normalizing Post-Abortion Care: Addressing Stigma and Shame
 
Challenges and dillema
Challenges and dillemaChallenges and dillema
Challenges and dillema
 
Understanding mental health and mental illness
Understanding mental health and mental illnessUnderstanding mental health and mental illness
Understanding mental health and mental illness
 
Rose childpsy ppt
Rose childpsy pptRose childpsy ppt
Rose childpsy ppt
 
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptx
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptxMy-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptx
My-Mental-Health-is-Important.pptx
 
Safeguarding ppt
Safeguarding pptSafeguarding ppt
Safeguarding ppt
 
HEALTH ASSESSEMENT
HEALTH ASSESSEMENTHEALTH ASSESSEMENT
HEALTH ASSESSEMENT
 
Counseling anxiety disorders brochure
Counseling anxiety disorders brochureCounseling anxiety disorders brochure
Counseling anxiety disorders brochure
 
Mental illness in pregnancy
Mental illness in pregnancyMental illness in pregnancy
Mental illness in pregnancy
 

What is the Psychological Impact on Women who had an Abortion

  • 1. •What is the Psychological Impact on Women who had an Abortion? by: Sandra Persaud Tellini November 30th, 2012 1
  • 2. MY “I” STATEMENT One of the most common surgical procedures in US My interest stems from my personal experience  I volunteered as a peer counselor for ten yrs at women in crisis centers  I have facilitated many support groups for post abortion women who came forward to reconcile suppressed feelings of the impact  Many women need to be educated before making any rash decisions and what to expect after  High success rate of women finding holistic healing and closure and free from internal negative self-talk to live fuller lives 2
  • 3. Why many women experience psychological reaction to their abortion decision • Colbert (as cited in, Koterski, 2004 p.79) commented, “Post Abortion Stress Disorder brings together many symptoms, signs, and behaviors with which women that experience after abortion present for help.” • Colbert further explains that what causes the psychological symptoms of this disorder is, what Freud describes as, “the resulting guilt which is often repressed within the person’s unconscious in order to protect the personality from conflict.” • This, Freud said, is the mental mechanisms of defense that keep intact the personality that is in conflict. • Abandonment upon discovery of the pregnancy often leaves women feeling forced and backed into a corner to abort the baby (Kimport, Foster, & Weitz, 2011). 3
  • 4. Four Fundamental Factors of PASD • Exposure to or participation in an abortion experience, which is perceived as the traumatic and deliberate destruction of one’s unborn child. • An uncontrolled negative re-experiencing of the abortion event. • Unsuccessful attempts to avoid or deny painful abortion recollections, resulting in reduced responsiveness. • Experiencing associated symptoms not present before the abortion, including guilt about surviving (Speckhard & Rue, 1992, p. 95). 4
  • 5. Definitions  Abortion: The word “abortion” is the intentional termination of gestation by any means and at any time during pregnancy from conception to full term. (Mohr, 1979)  A “flashback” as relates to mental health is when memories of past traumas feel as if they are taking place in the current moment.  Acute Stress Disorder (ASD) is a psychological dysfunction which results from a traumatic experience and characterized by the development of severe anxiety, dissociative, and other symptoms that occurs within one month after exposure to an extreme traumatic stressor and last 2 days to four weeks. It overwhelms a person’s normal mechanisms resulting in intense fear, feelings of helplessness or being trapped, or loss of control.  PTSD is similar to ASD except the duration of experiencing the above symptomology is greater than one month (Bowles et al., 2006, p. 970). 5
  • 6. Definitions Cont’d • (DSM-IV-TR) changed its language from mental illness or disease to mental disorder. “a clinical significant behavior or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in an individual and is associated with present distress and disability. It must be a manifestation of a behavioral, psychological or biological dysfunction in the individual”. (CDC, 2008) • Rue, as cited in Colbert (2003), first described PASD falls under PTSD which is a sub-category of Anxiety Disorder • PTSD is not a disease; it describes symptom clusters and behaviors and recurrent events associated with severe trauma. 6
  • 7. Delimitations •To exclude women who have experienced an abortion due to rape or for medical reasons. •The implications including moral, theological and political concerns are not be part of my research. Limitation • For the purpose of this research we will only focus on women and the psychological impact of the abortion. 7
  • 8. Significance of the Study My hope is that through this project I can make my findings available to women in crisis centers so that they can either determine the need for closure and/or healing while equipping others to make an informed choice.  Awareness to the sensitivity of the impact of an past abortion on a client …so that clinicians can probe and determine if presenting problem is primary or secondary. 8
  • 9. Literature Review Risk factors by the American Psychological Association Task Force on Mental Health and Abortion in their 2008 report: • Terminating a pregnancy that is wanted or meaningful. • Perceived pressure from others to terminate a pregnancy. • Perceived opposition to the abortion from partners, family, and/or friends. • Lack of perceived social support from others. • Various personality traits (e.G., Low self-esteem, a pessimistic outlook, low-perceived control over life). • A history of mental health problems prior to the pregnancy. • Feelings of stigma. • Perceived need for secrecy. 9
  • 10. Literature Review Cont’d Risk factors by the American Psychological Association Task Force on Mental Health and Abortion in their 2008 report: • Exposure to anti-abortion picketing • Use of avoidance and denial coping strategies • Feelings of commitment to the pregnancy • Ambivalence about the abortion decision • Low perceived ability to cope with the abortion • History of prior abortion • Late term abortion • Being an adolescent (not an adult) • Having a non-elective (therapeutic or coerced) abortion • Prior history of abortion (having a second or third abortion, or more) 10
  • 11. Statistics from US Census of Bureau 11,270, 1% 1,700, 0% 19,500, 2% 4,890, 0% California 214,190 15,960, 1% 17,030, 1% 7,070, 1% 4,450, 0% FLorida 94,360 39,820, 3% 5,630, 0% 1,800, 0% 54,920, 5% NJ 10,680, 1% 6,560, 1% 9,770, 1% 4,430, 0%14,860, 1% 2,800, 0% 34,290, 3% 24,900, 2% 36,790, 3% 13,060, 1%2,770, 0% 7,440, 1%2,230, 0% 2,840, 0%13,450, 1% 3,200, 0% 54,160, 4% Illinios6,150, 1% New York 153,110 37.6% 33,140, 3% 1,400, 0% 33,550, 3% 7,160, 1% 12,920, 1% 41,000, 3% 5,000, 0% 7,300, 1% 850, 0% 19,550, 2% 84,610, 7% Texas 4,000, 0% 1,510, 0% 28,520, 2% 24,320, 2% 2,280, 0% 8,230, 1% 90, 0% Abortions by State of Occurrence and Residence 2008 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 11
  • 12. Age of woman: % .Less than 15 years old 3.0% ..15 to 19 years old 18.7% ..20 to 24 years old 38.8% ..25 to 29 years old 28.7% ..30 to 34 years old 18.1% ..35 to 39 years old 10.1% ..40 years old and over 3.4% Race and ethnicity of woman in 2008: Abortion rate per 1,000 women ..White 13.8% ..Black 48.2% ..Other 21.6% ..Hispanic 26.0% ..Non-Hispanic White 10.6% 12 58% 14.20% 19.00% 8.50% Whites Black Hispanics or Latino Other
  • 13. Literature Review Cont’d – Low Risk for post-abortion psychological maladjustments Can be described as a woman who has • maturely, • thoughtfully, • and freely arrived at her abortion decision and • has no emotional, social, or moral conflicts which challenge that decision.. 13
  • 14. Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post- abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities • I. CONFLICTED DECISION A) Difficulty making the decision, ambivalence, unresolved doubts • 1. Moral beliefs against abortion • 2. Conflicting maternal desires • 3. Second or third trimester abortion • 4. Low coping expectancy 14
  • 15. Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post- abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities Cont’d • B. Feels pressured or coerced – a. Feels decision is not her own, or is “her only choice” – b. Feels pressured to choose too quickly • C. Decision is made with biased, inaccurate, or inadequate information 15
  • 16. Literature Review Cont’d - Risk Factors Predictive of Greater Post- abortion Psychological Sequelae with Citations to Authorities Cont’d II . PSYCHOLOGICAL OR DEVELOPMENTAL LIMITATIONS A. Adolescence, emotional immaturity B. Prior emotional or psychiatric problems C. Lack of social support D. Prior abortion(s) E. Prior miscarriage F. Less education 16
  • 17. Literature Review Cont’d – Resources available • Counseling - one-on-one or group therapy or a combination of both. • In-person support (attending a weekend retreat, working with a therapist, a clergyperson or a peer counselor, or going to a weekly group) • Online support (online chats, internet message boards, e-mail groups). Several organizations offer a combination of email or internet-based group support and in-person support. Finding the right resources that is best suited to the individual woman is important. 17
  • 18. Methodology • Participatory action research • Survey – population targeted - post-abortion women who sought help at crisis pregnancy centers. • Characteristics – various cultural backgrounds, socio-economic levels, varying age ranging from twelve years old to mid seventies and from various religious backgrounds at the time of the abortion • Who responded to a community service invitation, in Broward and Volusia counties in Fl to attend a support group for post-abortion women seeking healing and closure. • I contacted the participants by either telephone or emailed and then email the questionnaire and consent form. • Random sample population of 20 post-abortion participants in Fl • 13 questions - 2 open ended questions & 11 closed-ended questions. (8 closed ended dichotomous questions, 2 numerical questions, 2 Likert-scale questions, 1 Likert scaled question which comprised of twenty-eight parts. • Designed to uncover attitudes, opinions, knowledge and experience 18
  • 19. Results of the Questionnaire The first question was a rule out question in case my survey did not reach my target population. 1. Have you experienced an abortion in the past? Yes No In bold letters it stated IF YES, PLEASE CONTINUE. IF NO, PLEASE STOP HERE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. 100% =yes. 2. What is your age? Under 18 yrs 18- 25 yrs 26 – 40 yrs 40 and over 10% were between 18-25 years old, 30% were between 26-40 years old, 60% were between 40 and over years old. 3. (If you had more than one abortion) at what stage of the pregnancy did you have the abortion that affected you the most? <6 wks 7-10 wks 11-15 wks 16 - 20 wks > 20 wks <6 wks =20% 7-10 wks = 40% 11-15 weeks = 40% 4.What is your ethnic background? ___ 70% were Caucasian, 20% were Hispanic, and 10% were Black. 5. Please rate your feelings/experience from 0-3 (0= No Effect; 1 = Some Effect; 2 = Great Effect; 3 = Very Intense). The first column (1) applies to the weeks immediately following the abortion experience. The second column (2) applies to how you feel now or felt at the time you sought help to cope with the any distressful feelings from the past abortion. 19
  • 20. COL#1 results % 0 1 2 3 Measures their psychological experience in each below category COL#2 results % 0 1 2 3 5 0 5 90 Guilt 0 10 55 35 5 0 45 50 Emotional ‘Numbing’ 10 10 35 45 30 15 30 25 Dreams/Nightmares 30 20 20 30 5 15 25 55 Change In Relationships 10 40 25 25 5 15 30 50 Inferiority Feeling 5 30 25 40 70 5 20 5 Dizziness/Fainting 80 10 10 0 20 40 30 10 Sleep Disturbances 45 35 20 5 25 30 35 10 Can’t Make Friends 25 35 30 10 15 20 20 45 Preoccupation With Abortion 20 60 20 0 5 10 30 55 Sexual Problems 0 20 60 20 5 15 75 5 Relief 0 20 60 20 15 25 15 45 Depressed 10 45 20 25 5 10 40 45 Sad 20 35 30 15 25 35 20 25 Anxiety 35 40 15 10 30 15 30 25 Suicidal Ideas 40 20 30 10 Results of Questionnaire Q 5 20
  • 21. Results of Questionnaire Q 5 25 20 15 40 Alcohol/Drugs 45 20 15 20 5 35 22 25 Loneliness 5 40 30 25 5 15 25 55 Sense Of Loss 40 40 10 10 5 10 25 60 Secretive 0 15 35 50 10 25 15 50 Crying Spells 15 40 35 10 5 20 15 60 Regret 0 0 50 50 10 35 20 35 Angry 15 35 25 25 25 25 20 30 Helplessness 35 30 25 10 45 30 10 15 Headaches 60 30 10 0 25 25 25 25 Eating Disorder 60 20 15 5 40 35 15 10 Panic Feelings 50 40 10 0 10 40 35 15 Unable To Relax 40 30 30 0 5 25 55 15 Fear Of Failure 0 50 35 15 21
  • 22. Results of Survey 6. Did you feel pressured into having an abortion? Yes No 70%= yes and 30%= no. 7.Do you experience a disconnect with bonding with your children since having the abortion? Yes No NA 40% = yes, 50% = no and 10% = NA 8. Have you experienced in the past recurring "flashbacks" of the abortion episode, with no apparent explanation for what is causing them? Yes No 70% = yes 30% = no. 9. Since the abortion have you experienced anxiety over fertility issues? Yes No 70% = yes, and 30% = no. 10. Since the abortion have you experienced anxiety over childbearing issues? Yes No 65% = yes and 35% = no. 11. Since the abortion have found you had difficulty with intimacy? Yes No 80% = yes and 20% = no. 12. Did you have a change of mind about the abortion just before the event? Yes No 50% = yes and 50% = no. 22
  • 23. Question 13 – last words “Public awareness of the after effects of an abortion & a high risk on a woman’s fertility”. “Once it is done, it’s done and can’t be undone. check your options and be sure about your decision Women need to be valued & supported as they r presented all options and allowed to ponder. “The abortion had a profound impact on my life and everything including my relationship with others and created sexual issues and how I viewed my partner”. You need to pause and take a deep breath, explore all your choices and after listening to everyone around you, process it then you make your own decision. It is a final decision that can’t be undone”. “I was quite functional because I buried it for years. When I finally went through a support group and had to name the unborn baby to bring closure … it was then I realized I had never acknowledged his personhood. It opened the door for me to grieve and finally be healed. For years I lived with secret shame. “I was for abortion because I thought women should be in charge of their bodies. I had managed to hide away a lot of hurt and pain from my own abortions for a long time, but the cost in other areas of my life was too much. 23
  • 24. Discussion The Survey says:…. • Even though all abortions occurred in a woman’s fertility cycle, most unplanned pregnancies occurred prior to age thirty • 60% of sample were over 40yrs old - most women sought help many years after the abortion experience. • Cultural biases was reflected in those who sought help 70% Caucasian , 20% Hispanic, 10% Black • First Column - Soon after the event very intense feelings were: #1 Guilt, Regret (90%), #2 Secretive (60%), #3 Change in Relationships, Sexual Problems, & Sense of Loss (55%), #4 Emotional Numbing, Inferiority feeling, & Crying Spells (50%) No Effect – # 1 Dizziness/Fainting (70%), #2 Headaches (45%), #3 Panic Feelings (40%) 2nd column Feedback -Recently or at the time they sought help • Very Intense feelings – • #1 Regret” and “Secretive(50%) #2 Emotional Numbing (45%), #3 Inferiority Feeling (40%), #4 Guilt (35%) No Effect, #1 Dizziness/Fainting (80%), #2 Headaches & Eating Disorder (60%) #3 Panic Feelings (50%). Not one of them was left unaffected by their abortion experience. 24
  • 25. Q uestion#6 70% - felt pressured into having an abortion. Q #7 Regarding whether the woman experienced a disconnect with bonding with their children since having the abortion 40 % YES, 50 % NO 10 % NOT APPLICABLE Question #8 Whether the participants had experienced in the past recurring "flashbacks" of the abortion episode, with no apparent explanation for what is causing them? 70 % YES 30 % NO. • Question #9 asked, since the abortion have you experienced anxiety over fertility issues? • 70 % YES • 30 % NO • Question #10 a response to anxiety over childbearing issues. The response was very similar to question 9 as 65 % YES 35% NO . 25
  • 26. • Q#11 asked whether since the abortion, the participant found has had difficulty with intimacy; • 80 % YES , 20 % NO. • Q #12 asked did she have a change of mind about the abortion just before the event. • 50 % YES , 50 % NO. • Q#13 Comments: Revealed that their regret about their abortion decision and had many words of advice to those who may be in a crisis pregnancy and still looking to explore their choices. • Though they could not reverse their prior decision had gotten pass the blaming on to others, • Seemed to have reached a place where they took responsibility for their actions, • Made peace with their past and experienced closure 26
  • 27. A few common threads… • Firstly, unexpected pregnancies are always stressful. • And stress is a major cause of both mental illness and physical illness. • Real need for emotional adjustments after abortion. • Strong link between abortion and mental health problems in women. • Repression as a coping means, may be a long period of denial before a woman seeks psychiatric care • Repressed feelings may cause psychosomatic illnesses and psychiatric or behavior in other areas causing her to seeking therapy for apparently unrelated problems. • • 27
  • 28. Why should you care? • Everyone knows someone directly affected, no one is untouched • Women represents > ½ population • An average of fifty percent of pregnancies are unwanted and • 4 in 10 of these are terminated by abortion. 22 % of all pregnancies end in abortion (CDC) • An unacknowledged post-abortion distress may be contributory – Clinician can probe and determine if presenting problem is primary or secondary 28
  • 29. Recommendations Based on these findings, most of which have been published by researchers who favor legalized abortion, it would appear reasonable to expect, and demand, that abortion providers: 1) Provide pre-consent information. 2) Provide adequate pre-abortion screening using the criteria outlined above. 3) Provide individualized counseling to high risk patients. 4) Assist women who have pre-identifying high risk factors in evaluating and choosing lower risk solutions to their social, economic, and health needs. 29
  • 30. Closing Statement The significance of this study is to identify that a considerable number of women who experienced an abortion did not walk away unharmed by their decision. Rather, the psychological effects they sustain require the necessity to make available a safe place for them to find healing; whether in a group or individual setting. To this end, this study is important to the field of mental health counseling. 30
  • 31. •References Adler, N.E., et al., “Psychological Factors in Abortion: A Review” American Psychologist47(10):1194-1204 (1992). Adler, N.E., et al., “Psychological Responses After Abortion,” Science, 248:41-44 (1990). Ashton, J.R. “The Psychosocial Outcome of Induced Abortion”, British Journal of Ob&Gyn., 87:1115-1122 (1980). Babikian & Goldman, “A Study in Teen-Age Pregnancy,” Am. J. Psychiatry, 755 (1971). Barnard, C.A., The Long-Term Psychosocial Effects of Abortion (Portsmouth, NH: Institute for Pregnancy Loss, 1990). Belsey, E.M., et al., “Predictive Factors in Emotional Response to Abortion: King’s Termination Study – IV,” Soc. Sci. & Med., 11:71- 82 (1977). Blumberg,B.D., et al., “The Psychological Sequelae of Abortion Performed for a Genetic Indication,” Am. J. of Obstetrics and Gynecology 122(7):799-808 (1975). Bracken, M.B., et al., “The Decision to Abort and Psychological Sequelae” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 158:154-162 (1974). Bracken, M.B. “A Causal Model of Psychosomatic Reactions to Vacuum Aspiration Abortion,” Social Psychiatry, 13:135-145 (1978). Campbell, N.B., et al., “Abortion in Adolescence,” Adolescence 23:813-823 (1988). Cohen, L. & Roth, S., “Coping With Abortion,” Journal of Human Stress 10:140-145 (1984). Council on Scientific Affairs, American Medical Association, “Induced Termination of Pregnancy Before and After Roe v Wade: Trends in Mortality and Morbidity of Women,” JAMA, 268(22):3231-3239 (1992). David, H.P., “Post-abortion and Post-partum Psychiatric Hosptialization,” 1985 Abortion: Medical Progress and Social Implications (London: Ciba Foundation Symposium 115, 1985) 150-64. De Veber, L.L., et.al., “Post-Abortion Grief: Psychological Sequelae of Induced Abortion,”Humane Medicine,7(3):203-8 (1991). Dunlop, “Counseling of Patients Requesting an Abortion,” The Practitioner, 220:847-852 (1978). Franz, W., Reardon, D., “Differential Impact of Abortion on Adolescents and Adults,”Adolescence, 27(105):161-172 (1992). Friedman, C.M. et al., “The Decision-Making Process and the Outcome of Therapeutic Abortion,” Am J of Psychiatry, 131(12):1332- 1337 (1974). Furlong, R. & Black, R., “Pregnancy Termination for Genetic Indications: The Impact on Families,” Social Work in Health Care, 10(1):17 (1984). Lazarus, A., Stern, R., “Psychiatric Aspects of Pregnancy Termination,” Clinics in Obs/Gyn,13(1):125-134 (1986). 31
  • 32. References Gold, D., et.al., The Abortion Choice: Psychological Determinants and Consequences (Montreal: Concordia University Department of Psychology, 1984). Heath, D.S., “Psychiatry and Abortion,” Can Psychiatr Assoc J, 16:55-63 (1971). Hern, W. Abortion Practice, (Boulder, CO: Alpenglo Graphics, Inc., 1990). Landy, U. “Abortion Counseling – A New Component of Medical Care,” Clinics in Obs/Gyn, 13(1):33-41 (1986). Lask, B. “Short-term Psychiatric Sequelae to Therapeutic Termination of Pregnancy,”Br J Psychiatry, 126: 173-177 (1975). Lazarus, A. “Psychiatric Sequelae of Legalized Elective First Trimester Abortion”,Journal of Psychosomatic Ob&Gyn 4:141-150 (1985). Lemkau, J.P., “Emotional Sequelae of Abortion,” Psychology of Women Quarterly, 12:461-472 (1988). Lloyd, J. & Laurence, K.M., “Sequelae and Support After Termination of Pregnancy for Fetal Malformation,” British Medical Journal, 290:907-909 (1985). Major, B. & Cozzarelli,C., “Psychosocial Predictors of Adjustment to Abortion,” Journal of Social Issues, 48(3):121-142 (1992). Major, B., et al., “Attributions, Expectations and Coping with Abortion,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48:585-599 (1985). Mahkorn, S. K., “Pregnancy & Sexual Assault,” The Psychological Aspects of Abortion, Mall, D., & Watts, W.F., eds., (Washington, D.C.: University Publications of America, 1979) pp.53-72. Margolis, A.J.,et.al., “Therapeutic Abortion Follow-up Study,” Am J Obstet Gynecol, 110:243-9 (1971). Martin, C.D., “Psychological Problems of Abortion for Unwed Teenage Girls,” Genetic Psychology Monographs 88:23-110 (1973). Miller, W.B., “An Empirical Study of the Psychological Antecedents and Consequences of Induced Abortion,” Journal of Social Issues, 48(3):67-93 (1992). Moseley, D.T., et al., “Psychological Factors That Predict Reaction to Abortion,” J. of Clinical Psychology, 37:276-279 (1981). Mueller, P. & Major, B., “Self-blame, Self-efficacy and Adjustment to Abortion,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 57:1059-1068 (1989). Ney, P.G. & Wickett, A.R., “Mental Health and Abortion: Review and Analysis,” Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa, 14(4):506-16 (1989). Osofsky J.D. & Osofsky, H.J., “The Psychological Reaction of Patients to Legalized Abortion,” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 42:48-60 (1972). Osofsky, J.D., et al., “Psychological Effects of Abortion: with Emphasis upon the Immediate Reactions and Followup,” in H. J. Osofsky & J.D. Osofsky, eds., The Abortion Experience (Hagerstown, MD: Harper & Row, 1973), 189-205. Payne, E.C., et al., “Outcome Following Therapeutic Abortion,” Archives of General Psychiatry, 33:725-33 (1976). 32
  • 33. References Rayburn, W. & Laferla, J.,“Mid-gestational Abortion for Medical or Genetic Indications,” Clin Obstet Gynaecol 13:71-82 (1986). Rosenfeld, J. “Emotional Responses to Therapeutic Abortion,” American Family Physician, 45(1):137-140, (1992). Rue, V. & Speckhard, A., “Informed Consent & Abortion: Issues in Medicine & Counseling,” Medicine & Mind 7:75-95 (1992). Senay, E., “Therapeutic Abortion: Clinical Aspects,” Arch Gen Psychiatry 23:408-15, (1970). Shusterman, L.R., “Predicting the Psychological Consequences of Abortion,” Social Science and Medicine, 13A:683-689 (1979). Sim, M., Neisser, R., “Post-abortive Psychoses: A Report From Two Centers,” The Psychological Aspects of Abortion, Mall, D. and Watts W.F.(eds)(Washington, DC: University Publications of America, 1979). Speckhard, A. & Rue, V., “Postabortion Syndrome: An Emerging Public Health Concern,” Journal of Social Issues, 48(3):95-119 (1992). Vaughan, H.P., Canonical Variates of Post Abortion Syndrome (Portsmouth, NH: Institute for Pregnancy Loss, 1990). Wallerstein, J.S. et.al.,”Psychological Sequelae of Therapuetic Abortion in Young Unmarried Women,” Arch Gen Psychiatry 27:828-32 (1972). Zakus, G. & Wilday, S., “Adolescent Abortion Option,” Social Work in Health Care, 12(4):77-91 (1987). Zimmerman, M., Passage Through Abortion (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1977). Zimmerman, M. “Psychosocial and Emotional Consequences of Elective Abortion: A Literature Review”, in Paul Sachdev, ed., Abortion: Readings and Research (Toronto:Butterworth, 1981). Zolese, G. & Blacker, C.V.R., “The Psychological Complications of Therapeutic Abortion” British J Psych 160:742- 749 (1992). 33