Dynamic Learning Maps (DLM) began as a project funded as part of the JISC Transforming Curriculum Delivery through Technology programme. The project developed navigable curriculum maps (https://learning-maps.ncl.ac.uk/). The maps are interactive and learners can add notes and reflections to topics (stored in the students’ ePortfolio), make personal extensions to their maps and share, rate and tag resources. This presentation aims to describe the journey of DLM after the initial project and share lessons learned from its embedding and application in new contexts with a view to long-term sustainability.
Following piloting in Medicine during the initial JISC project, DLM was embedded in the VLE from September 2011. Now over 2,200 students and staff have accessed DLM at Newcastle University. University funding was granted for an Innovations project pilot DLM in Geography with aims to evaluate its use in modular programmes and for different purposes:
1. Further embed reflection and personal development planning in the curriculum.
2. Help students to be better informed about module selection – clearly showing pre-requisites / requirements, skills, and potential career paths.
3. Stimulating ‘cross-modular’ learning
Curricula were mapped drawing on existing data, such as Module catalogue information and other sources. In addition specialties and sub-specialties in Geography were also mapped and linked to modules, as these can be important in selection of optional modules and eventual career paths. The map also included transferable skills and selected careers. We will report on formative evaluation with over 300 Stage 2 and Stage 3 students during 2012.
Other aspects of continuity are also addressed. The DLM software has now been made available to the JISC community and we will discuss interest and initial uptake in partner institutions along with new JISC rapid innovation projects in Open Educational Resources, which have a DLM component.
This presentation describes the journey of DLM and shares evaluation and lessons learned relating to continuity and embedding the benefits following initial project funding.
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
Dynamic Learning Maps - Presentation: ALT-C 2012
1. Project funded by
Dynamic Learning Maps:
the journey after the project
Simon Cotterill, Tony McDonald, Gordon Skelly, John Peterson, Alison
Williams, Steve Juggins
http://learning-maps.ncl.ac.uk
2. Life after the Project?
Photo by Kevint3141, available under a Creative Commons CC BY 2.0 License
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kevint3141/3763863511/
3. Reviewing Continuity
2 years after the initial project
• Summary of DLMs / embedding at Newcastle
• Innovations project: Geography
– Demo / Evaluation
• JISC projects (since DLMs)
– 4 x OER related projects
– JISC Benefits Realisation funding
• Summary / Reflections
4. Dynamic Learning Maps
Key curriculum drivers for the project: Part of the Curriculum
Delivery Programme
1: Modular courses
- promoting cross-modular learning
- mapping to transferable graduate skills / careers
2: Medicine: Communicating Complex Curricula
Understanding linkages
within the spiral curriculum
(students & teachers)
Occasional Teachers
-some unintended duplication in
teaching
5. Embedding at Newcastle
• Embedded in VLEs used by Medicine
• 2,446 individuals have used DLM at Newcastle University (494 staff)
• 13,000 topics in the map
• 122,000 topics viewed
New use in Dentistry
• Module leaders workshop
• Mapping course outcomes to professional standards (GDC outcomes)
6. Evaluating Dynamic Learning Maps
in Geography
• Innovations Fund (Newcastle University)
– Better informed module choice
– Linking curriculum to skills / careers
– Embedding reflection/PDP in the curriculum
– Evaluating DLM in a non health-related subject
8. Summary of Learning Maps
Personal Learning
Personalised, sharing , reflective
notes and evidencing outcomes
Curriculum Maps
Overview , Prior
learning, Current Linking Learning
& Future learning Resources
Add links to resources
Rate and add
Skills and Careers comments
Browse skills and career paths
Make links between curriculum and skill
and careers
9. Open Educational Resources
OER Bookmarking (JISC-CETIS Rapid Innovation project)
RIDLR & SupOERGlue (2 x JISC funded OER Rapid Innovation projects)
Harvest OERs /Paradata
LR
DLM
Node
Return Paradata
PublishOER (HEA/JISC UKOER Phase 3 project)
• Investigating new business models for embedding publishers content in OERs
• Partnership with Elsevier, JISC Collections, Rightscom and education providers
• Some DLM-related activities
Project blog posts at: : http://www.medev.ac.uk/
10. Project funded by
Embedding Benefits of Dynamic Learning Maps
May 2012 to April 2013
Evaluating DLM with School of Pharmacy
New curriculum QA/QM
Evaluating DLM with School of Healthcare Sciences
across multiple programmes with shared content
Centre for the Development & Enhancement of Professional
Practice - Evaluation DLM in distance learning
• https://learning-maps.ncl.ac.uk/download/
DLM • Updated documentation
Community • New training/help materials
• Updated information/materials in the Design Studio
• National workshop
11. Initial Evaluation (Geography)
• January 2012
– Evaluation with Stage 2 students (n=121)
• February 2012
– Evaluation with Stage 3 students (n=81)
12. Formative Evaluation
Geography Year 3
Initial response to closed questions
after a 10 minute overview and demo of DLM
7th February 2012
81 Respondents
http://learning-maps.ncl.ac.uk
14. The map will help me better understand
the Geography curriculum
1. Strongly Agree
57%
2. Agree 90%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral 25%
5. Somewhat Disagree
9%
8%
6. Disagree 0%
2%
0%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
15. It looks easy to use
1. Strongly Agree
32% 32%
2. Agree 76%
3. Somewhat Agree
18%
4. Neutral
12%
5. Somewhat Disagree
6. Disagree 4%
2%
0%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
16. The map would benefit my learning
1. Strongly Agree
36%
2. Agree 62%
3. Somewhat Agree 28%
22%
4. Neutral
5. Somewhat Disagree 10%
6. Disagree 4%
0% 0%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
17. It is useful to see connections
between different modules
1. Strongly Agree
46%
2. Agree 94%
3. Somewhat Agree
26%
4. Neutral 22%
5. Somewhat Disagree
6. Disagree 4%
0% 0%
2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
18. The maps would have helped me with
my module selection
1. Strongly Agree
2. Agree 83% 29%
31%
3. Somewhat Agree 23%
4. Neutral
5. Somewhat Disagree
6% 6% 6%
6. Disagree 0%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
19. I would find it useful to add personal
notes and reflections to the map
1. Strongly Agree
27%
2. Agree 52% 25% 25%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral
10%
5. Somewhat Disagree 8%
6. Disagree 2% 2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
20. It is useful having Skills
linked into the maps
1. Strongly Agree
46%
2. Agree 80%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral 20%
5. Somewhat Disagree 14%
12%
6. Disagree 4%
2% 2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
21. It is useful having Careers
linked into the maps
1. Strongly Agree 45%
2. Agree 92%
33%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral
14%
5. Somewhat Disagree
6. Disagree 2%
0%
4%
2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
22. Having the map will be useful for
Revision
1. Strongly Agree 30%
2. Agree 52%
26%
3. Somewhat Agree
16%
4. Neutral 12%
10%
5. Somewhat Disagree
4%
6. Disagree 2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
23. Conclusions (Geography)
Initial student reaction was positive:
• Useful to see connections between modules:
– Stage 2: 76% Stage 3: 94%
• Could help with module selection:
– Stage 2: 74% Stage 3: 83%
• Useful to embed Skills:
– Stage 2: 64% Stage 3: 80%
• Useful to embed Careers:
– Stage 2: 81% Stage 3: 92%
• Not as interested in use for reflection:
– Stage 3 52% Stage 3 53%
– Would need a clear purpose (students don’t currently use ePortfolio)
• Limitations of results: needs further evaluation and full pilot
24. Summary / Reflections
• Continuity strategy – meeting real needs
• Growing uptake / embedding
• Can be disruptive
• Dissemination (internal / external)
• Further funding helps! – but needs to be in your direction of travel
27. I frequently supplement my learning
with external resources on the web
1. Strongly Agree
37%
2. Agree 84%
35%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral
5. Somewhat Disagree 12%
8%
6%
6. Disagree 2% 2%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
28. How often would you envisage using
the map (once complete) ?
1. daily 50%
2. weekly 40%
3. monthly
4. never
8%
2%
ily
ly
r
ly
ve
th
k
da
ee
ne
on
w
m
29. Having the map will be useful for
reviewing and reflecting on my learning
1. Strongly Agree
2. Agree 53%
31%
29%
3. Somewhat Agree
4. Neutral 18%
14%
5. Somewhat Disagree
6. Disagree 4% 4%
0%
7. Strongly Disagree
ee
e
al
e
ee
ee
ee
re
e
r
gr
gr
gr
r
r
ut
Ag
Ag
Ag
i sa
isa
sa
Ne
t
Di
ly
tD
D
ha
ng
ly
ew
ha
ro
ng
ew
m
St
ro
So
m
St
So
30. Aims
• To further embed reflection and personal development
planning in the curriculum.
• Helping students to be better informed about module
selection – clearly showing pre-requisites / requirements,
and potential career paths.
• Improving ‘cross-modular’ learning and teaching of
research methods and techniques across the curriculum.
• Evaluate and disseminate use and applicability of DLM in
non-health related contexts.
31. Initial interfaces & user preferences
Text-based interface
Mind-map style interface
Forthcoming focus groups:
explore options e.g. colour coding
terminology e.g. ‘nodes’ or topics