SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 38
Download to read offline
1
A standard, yet very different PPI
Kempen Capital Management seminar ‘Hollands Glorie’
De toekomst van ons pensioenstelsel: In search of the Holy Grail
April 23, 2015
24/04/2015
Private and Confidential
3
And now for something completely
different...
• DC has the future
• ...as despite common myths..
• ...the underlying trend is unassailable
• PPI is the best vehicle
• ...supported by massive growth...
• ...and now breaking barriers....
• ...acting in the interest of participants
• Further improvement is on the way
• ...yet myths are tenacious...
• ... and participant interests should outweigh
providers’ interest.
4
And now for something completely
different...
• DC has the future
• ...as despite common myths..
• ...the underlying trend is unassailable
• PPI is the best vehicle
• ...supported by massive growth...
• ...and now breaking barriers....
• ...acting in the interest of participants
• Further improvement is on the way
• ...yet myths are tenacious...
• ... and participant interests should outweigh
providers’ interest.
5
1605
1st “pension”
State elderly
pension
1956
No more early
age retirement
2011 g
1st
fund
1970 -1990
Early
retirement
65 -> 67 72
DB to DC
1845
Final pay
avg. pay
2000 -2008
2004 2011 2011 g
PPI growth
2014
www.ingim.com
6
We look into the
future and we
see....
7
7
The current system
is merely scratched
8
...as despite common myths...
1. DC leads to unpredictable pension
2. DC does not contain collectivity and solidarity
3. DB has higher returns, because of
intergenerational solidarity
4. DC requires participant choices, and thus leads to
errors
5. DC is more expensive for it is often executed by
for-profit parties
9
...the underlying trend is unassailable.
2040
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1950196019701980199020002010202020302040205020602070208020902100
Number of workers per 65+
Bron: i-PensionSolutions, United Nations
10
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2015-04-16
2013-12-02
17-7-2012
3-3-2011
19-10-2009
4-6-2008
19-1-2007
6-9-2005
22-4-2004
9-12-2002
25-7-2001
10-3-2000
27-10-1998
12-6-1997
29-1-1996
14-9-1994
30-4-1993
17-12-1991
2-8-1990
20-3-1989
4-11-1987
20-6-1986
5-2-1985
22-9-1983
10-5-1982
24-12-1980
10-8-1979
10 Year Dutch bond yield
... the underlying trend is unassailable
Private and Confidential
0
3
6
9
12
15
18
21
Cost
Cost of € 1 annuity
>33x the price
Bron: i-PensionSolutions
11
...the underlying trend is unassailable.
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
700,000
800,000
900,000
1,000,000
1999 2005 2010 2014
Number of participants in DC (Netherlands)
0
5
10
15
20
25
1999 2005 2010 2014
AUM(€bln)
AUM in DC (Netherlands)
12
And now for something completely
different...
• DC has the future
• ...as despite common myths..
• ...the underlying trend is unassailable
• PPI is the best vehicle
• ...supported by massive growth...
• ...and now breaking barriers....
• ...acting in the interest of participants
• Further improvement is on the way
• ...yet myths are tenacious...
• ... and participant interests should outweigh
providers’ interest.
13
Rigid expense
management
14
PPI is the best vehicle (cost)
Source: LCP [2014] Source: LCP [2014]
Source: Towers Watson [2011 (!)]
15
PPI is the best vehicle
• Proven concept
• Lowest cost
• Inherently innovative
• Participant focused
• VAT exempt
• Ringfencing
• Regulated in The Netherlands
• Suitable for:
• DC scheme
• Net pension
• CDC scheme
• Run-off portfolio
• Separated account
• Europe
• (self employed, currently excluded by law)
16
...supported by massive growth
• Significant growth in AUM and premium
• Large corporations looking into PPI
• (political) perception has changed
€ 113 € 132 € 145 € 171
€ 241
€ 291
€ 380
€ 512
€ 658
€ 935
€ 1,241
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
2012K2 2012K3 2012K4 2013K1 2013K2 2013K3 2013K4 2014K1 2014K2 2014K3 2014K4
AUM(€mln)
PPI market
Bron: DNB
17
...and now breaking barriers
Private and Confidential
The first open architecture Premium Pension Institution
18
...and now breaking barriers
• i-PensionSolutions
• open platform
• serves the interest of participants
• Open platform facilitates:
• customers to create and maintain tailor made solutions
• asset managers and insurance companies to offer core
business products to their client base, integrated
within a total pension offering
• development of (optional) guarantees
• next generation DC products to be built
6
19
Strategic choices:
• IPS is set up as a foundation. Its sole purpose is to serve and
protect the interests of the pension scheme participants and is a
not-for-profit organization
• Only best-in-class partners,
• stringent due diligence and compliance
• Operational excellence
• Distribution through partners
• SwissRe offers re-insurance, Credit Suisse capital market
guarantees
• Initial start in The Netherlands, European ambition
• Optional guarantees (capital market and insurance)
Core values:
• Protect the interests of the participants
• Transparency
• Integrity
• Independent
• High standards for access to platform
• Strong compliance framework
• Clear governance
• Cost efficient
• Committed for the long term (and strongly capitalized)
...and now breaking barriers
20
Synergy from
cooperation
21
Committed, yet
open
22
Best of all worlds
• i-PensionSolutions offers Pension Savings Product
• Employer selects asset manager and investment strategy
• Employer can select Insurance Company and Insurance Cover
• Pension Administration and integrated communication is executed by i-
PensionSolutions
• The employer signs two agreements:
• [A] Pension Execution to cover Asset Accumulation (as described before)
and,
• [B] Insurance Policy Agreement (Pension Insurance Product) to cover
Biometric Risk insurance with an insurance company
Asset
Manager
Administrator
Stichting International Pension Solutions
(regulated pension entity)
Administration
Asset
Management
[Employer] (Former) Employees
Pension Agreement
Pension
Execution
Agreement
Claim on
vested rights
Custodian
Management Board
Supervisory
Council
External
Advisors
Order
Execution/
Custody
Investment PolicyAdvise on:
Legal, Tax, Actuarial
Investment, Risk Mngt
Investment
Committee
Asset Liability
Committee
Insurance
company
Insurance
Insurane
Policy
Agreement
23
... acting in the interest of participants
Independent governance and
dedicated products
Standard Tailor made
Plain vanilla
Advanced
- Allocation based
on time to maturity.
General set-up
- Allocation based
on time to maturity
- Client specific
- Allocation depending
on (a.o) funding &
standard guarantee
Fully client specific,
both guarantee and
investment scheme
Level of tailoring
Levelofsophistication
SME, Corporates]
Large corporates, multinationals,
other collectives,
Corporates
Multinationals, large other
collectives
24
And now for something completely
different...
• DC has the future
• ...as despite common myths..
• ...the underlying trend is unassailable
• PPI is the best vehicle
• ...supported by massive growth...
• ...and now breaking barriers....
• ...acting in the interest of participants
• Further improvement is on the way
• ...yet myths are tenacious...
• ... and participant interests should outweigh
providers’ interest.
25
...yet myths are tenacious
• Lifecycle invests in equity for young people
because of ‘investment horizon’
• A longer ‘investment horizon’ leads to higher return
• Flywheel of disbursements
• With pension funds, retirees retain investment
exposure
• Longevity risk can be mitigated in a collective
26
What will
‘doorbeleggen’
bring us?
27
Prerequisite for
‘doorbeleggen’
• Prevent money death
• Individual economic ownership
• Executable
• Tailoring to individual
• Flexible
Risk attittude Risk capacity
Risk
position
28
... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest.
Source: i-PensionSolutions: “Doorbeleggen en verbeteringen in Defined Contribution” 2015. denationalepensioendialoog.nl/item/596
Risk willingness
Risk capacity
High
HighLow
Low
Annuity
Cash / Lump sum
ALDA | Partial annuity
Continue lifecycle
ALDA | Partial annuity
ALDA | Partial annuity
www.ingim.com
29
Within the next 5 years, my pension will be
with a PPI
A new road towards modern and innovative
pension solutions in Europe
Appendix: Various slides
32
Unfunded plan on
Balance Sheet
Partial buy-out /
LDI solution
Insurance Solutions
Transfer risk to insurance vehicle
Low
Required Initial funding (necessary liquidity for single premium)
HighLow
RiskReduction
High
Cash injection into pension plan/
traditional asset allocation
Change plan benefits
(DB DC)
Traditional full buyout
(Insured annuities)
Close fund to new
entrants and accruals
(hard freeze)
Close fund to
new entrants
Asset Management Solutions
Manage Risk-Return
Cash Injection/
LDI solution
Change in employee benefits
Transfer risk to employees
Insurance SolutionsAsset Management SolutionsPlan Design Solutions
Diagram 1: Illustrative Example of Pension Risk Management Solutions
Current
Current
... the underlying trend is unassailable
33
A longer ‘investment horizon’ leads to higher return
Private and Confidential
• Longest, reliable data goes back to
1871
• Only nine complete, independent
series of 15 year return
• Statistically infeasible to make valid
forward looking statements
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15 jaars rendementsperiodes
1871
1886
1901
1916
1931
1946
1961
1976
1991
2006
Bron: RobertShiller,i-PensionSolutions
34
Growth and Inflation are drivers of interest rate
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020
Real GDP growth (Euro)
Source:IMF World EconomicOutlookApril 2015
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020
Inflation ( Euro)
Source:IMF World EconomicOutlookApril 2015
35
Interest rate is rightfully low. But perhaps too low?
• The "Yuppie/Nerd Ratio"
compares the number of 25-to
34-year-olds ("Yuppies") to the
number of 45-to 54-year-olds
("Nerds").
• This ratio is said to do a good
job of tracking the demographic
pressures on long term interest
rates.
• Nerds buy bonds for retirement,
Yuppies borrow to buy houses,
cars, cribs, etc.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010 2013 2016 2019 2022 2025 2028 2031 2034 2037 2040 2043 2046 2049
10yearrate
YuppieNerdRatio
Yuppie Nerd Ratio (Netherlands)
Yuppie / Nerd (LHS)
10year rate (RHS)
Regressed value
Source: Datastream, Census Bureau, ING Investment Management
36
Risk of underfunding weighs heavily on sponsors (or whomever bears the risk)
Private and Confidential
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
85
87
88
90
91
93
94
96
97
99
100
102
103
105
106
108
109
111
112
114
115
117
118
120
121
123
124
126
Fundingratiopoints
Funding ratio
Estimated value 1 year guarantee of additional funding
Bron: i-PensionSolutions
©2014 IPS. All rights reserved. You are not permitted to create any modifications or derivatives of this presentation or
to use it for commercial or other public purposes without the prior written permission of IPS.
This presentation is for information purposes only and contains non-binding indications as well as personal judgement.
It does not contain any recommendation, advice, solicitation, offer or commitment to effect any transaction or to
conclude any legal act. IPS makes no warranties or representations as to this presentation’s accuracy, completeness,
timeliness or suitability for a particular purpose. Anyone who interprets and employs this presentation shall do so at his
or her own risk without relying on it in isolation.
In no event shall IPS or any of its affiliates be liable for any loss or damages of any kind, including any direct, indirect
or consequential damages, arising out of or in connection with the use of this presentation.
Important Information
Tjb hulshoff i pension solutions kcm presentations 23 april 2015-v20150421th

More Related Content

What's hot

Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...
Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...
Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...enterpriseresearchcentre
 
Debt & Equity - Wouter Haerick
Debt & Equity - Wouter HaerickDebt & Equity - Wouter Haerick
Debt & Equity - Wouter HaerickFrank Gielen
 
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)Turlough Guerin GAICD FGIA
 
Introduction flight to simplicity
Introduction flight to simplicityIntroduction flight to simplicity
Introduction flight to simplicityChrisJCook
 
Caroline Mason
Caroline MasonCaroline Mason
Caroline Masonwalescva
 
Financing energybeyond Peak Credit
Financing energybeyond Peak CreditFinancing energybeyond Peak Credit
Financing energybeyond Peak CreditChrisJCook
 
Chapter 1 BUS 315
Chapter 1 BUS 315Chapter 1 BUS 315
Chapter 1 BUS 315igrewal17
 
2013symposium_Oikocredit2
2013symposium_Oikocredit22013symposium_Oikocredit2
2013symposium_Oikocredit2ARUN_LLC
 
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family Offices
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family OfficesPrivate Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family Offices
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family OfficesRajaa Mekouar
 
Planning and Development of a Trust for First Nations
Planning and Development of a Trust for First NationsPlanning and Development of a Trust for First Nations
Planning and Development of a Trust for First Nationsmarienationtalk
 
Met life Business Development Presentation
Met life Business Development PresentationMet life Business Development Presentation
Met life Business Development PresentationBerlinBear69
 
20 Investments You Should Know
20 Investments You Should Know20 Investments You Should Know
20 Investments You Should KnowJenny Hubbard
 
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds Floyd Saunders
 
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo Andrez
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo AndrezEuropean Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo Andrez
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo AndrezMoldova ICT Summit
 
Offshore Tax Efficient Vehicles
Offshore Tax Efficient VehiclesOffshore Tax Efficient Vehicles
Offshore Tax Efficient VehiclesAli Kazimi
 
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"Rajaa Mekouar
 
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseImpact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseThe Long Run
 

What's hot (20)

Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...
Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...
Rural firms’ Finance for growth needs - Tim Powell, Senior Business Executive...
 
Debt & Equity - Wouter Haerick
Debt & Equity - Wouter HaerickDebt & Equity - Wouter Haerick
Debt & Equity - Wouter Haerick
 
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)
Asset owners rethink their strategies (BNP 2016)
 
Governance, cost and sustainable investing
Governance, cost and sustainable investingGovernance, cost and sustainable investing
Governance, cost and sustainable investing
 
Introduction flight to simplicity
Introduction flight to simplicityIntroduction flight to simplicity
Introduction flight to simplicity
 
Caroline Mason
Caroline MasonCaroline Mason
Caroline Mason
 
Financing energybeyond Peak Credit
Financing energybeyond Peak CreditFinancing energybeyond Peak Credit
Financing energybeyond Peak Credit
 
Chapter 1 BUS 315
Chapter 1 BUS 315Chapter 1 BUS 315
Chapter 1 BUS 315
 
Raintree Brochure
Raintree BrochureRaintree Brochure
Raintree Brochure
 
Tse sources of_capital_2014 (1)
Tse sources of_capital_2014 (1)Tse sources of_capital_2014 (1)
Tse sources of_capital_2014 (1)
 
2013symposium_Oikocredit2
2013symposium_Oikocredit22013symposium_Oikocredit2
2013symposium_Oikocredit2
 
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family Offices
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family OfficesPrivate Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family Offices
Private Equity 1.0 - Introduction to Family Offices
 
Planning and Development of a Trust for First Nations
Planning and Development of a Trust for First NationsPlanning and Development of a Trust for First Nations
Planning and Development of a Trust for First Nations
 
Met life Business Development Presentation
Met life Business Development PresentationMet life Business Development Presentation
Met life Business Development Presentation
 
20 Investments You Should Know
20 Investments You Should Know20 Investments You Should Know
20 Investments You Should Know
 
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds
Asset Mgmt Private Equity & Hedge Funds
 
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo Andrez
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo AndrezEuropean Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo Andrez
European Experience developing Business Angel Ecosystem by Paulo Andrez
 
Offshore Tax Efficient Vehicles
Offshore Tax Efficient VehiclesOffshore Tax Efficient Vehicles
Offshore Tax Efficient Vehicles
 
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"
Fuchs & Associes - LPEA: "Private Equity, the Long Term Investor Journey"
 
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseImpact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
 

Viewers also liked

130124 michigan assn of realtors generation now national association of rea...
130124 michigan assn of realtors   generation now national association of rea...130124 michigan assn of realtors   generation now national association of rea...
130124 michigan assn of realtors generation now national association of rea...Holly Duckworth
 
Innovation Day Post Event Report Conceptia (2)
Innovation Day   Post Event Report Conceptia (2)Innovation Day   Post Event Report Conceptia (2)
Innovation Day Post Event Report Conceptia (2)Cherian Joseph
 
Customer development at Value Hub
Customer development at Value HubCustomer development at Value Hub
Customer development at Value HubValueHub
 
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivr
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivrPromotional strategic vision for sms & ivr
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivrMohamed Salah Aldeen
 
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2Michela Visciola
 
Representation of class
Representation of classRepresentation of class
Representation of classhjgoldsmith
 
Alternative education.britishopenuniversity
Alternative education.britishopenuniversityAlternative education.britishopenuniversity
Alternative education.britishopenuniversityJoem Magante
 
Murthy vaddadi
Murthy vaddadiMurthy vaddadi
Murthy vaddadipniklesh
 
Manning park presentation int
Manning park presentation intManning park presentation int
Manning park presentation intbyrnecreekleoclub
 
Chapter 3 Migration
Chapter 3 MigrationChapter 3 Migration
Chapter 3 MigrationMooreGeo
 
Book fair
Book fairBook fair
Book fairyhen06
 
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Update
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology UpdateOctober 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Update
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Updatebudtheteacher
 
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januari
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januariFiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januari
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januariAuto Verkopen
 
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp hòa bình
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp   hòa bìnhToán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp   hòa bình
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp hòa bìnhViệt Nam Tổ Quốc
 
телеконференция
телеконференциятелеконференция
телеконференцияgibadullina
 
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτη
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτηπαναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτη
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτηstkarapy
 

Viewers also liked (20)

130124 michigan assn of realtors generation now national association of rea...
130124 michigan assn of realtors   generation now national association of rea...130124 michigan assn of realtors   generation now national association of rea...
130124 michigan assn of realtors generation now national association of rea...
 
Innovation Day Post Event Report Conceptia (2)
Innovation Day   Post Event Report Conceptia (2)Innovation Day   Post Event Report Conceptia (2)
Innovation Day Post Event Report Conceptia (2)
 
Ms photo
Ms photoMs photo
Ms photo
 
Tugas plkj
Tugas plkjTugas plkj
Tugas plkj
 
Customer development at Value Hub
Customer development at Value HubCustomer development at Value Hub
Customer development at Value Hub
 
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivr
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivrPromotional strategic vision for sms & ivr
Promotional strategic vision for sms & ivr
 
Albert Einstein 1
Albert  Einstein 1 Albert  Einstein 1
Albert Einstein 1
 
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2
Tecnicalità e Strumenti per sviluppare Piani Industriali Value Oriented - 2
 
Representation of class
Representation of classRepresentation of class
Representation of class
 
Alternative education.britishopenuniversity
Alternative education.britishopenuniversityAlternative education.britishopenuniversity
Alternative education.britishopenuniversity
 
Murthy vaddadi
Murthy vaddadiMurthy vaddadi
Murthy vaddadi
 
Live Your Dream JCI konferencija 2012
Live Your Dream JCI konferencija 2012Live Your Dream JCI konferencija 2012
Live Your Dream JCI konferencija 2012
 
Manning park presentation int
Manning park presentation intManning park presentation int
Manning park presentation int
 
Chapter 3 Migration
Chapter 3 MigrationChapter 3 Migration
Chapter 3 Migration
 
Book fair
Book fairBook fair
Book fair
 
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Update
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology UpdateOctober 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Update
October 22nd, 2009 School Board Technology Update
 
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januari
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januariFiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januari
Fiscale wijzigingen voor auto's vanaf 1 januari
 
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp hòa bình
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp   hòa bìnhToán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp   hòa bình
Toán 2 ab 2012 thpt công nghiệp hòa bình
 
телеконференция
телеконференциятелеконференция
телеконференция
 
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτη
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτηπαναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτη
παναγιώτης τσικνοπεπτη
 

Similar to Tjb hulshoff i pension solutions kcm presentations 23 april 2015-v20150421th

Crowd4 ovo pitch v02
Crowd4 ovo pitch v02Crowd4 ovo pitch v02
Crowd4 ovo pitch v02cgossye
 
Igc value for moneyv6 (1)
Igc   value for moneyv6 (1)Igc   value for moneyv6 (1)
Igc value for moneyv6 (1)Henry Tapper
 
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRAND
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRANDOECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRAND
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRANDOECD Governance
 
Career Opportunities The Investors Group Advantage
Career Opportunities  The Investors Group AdvantageCareer Opportunities  The Investors Group Advantage
Career Opportunities The Investors Group Advantagesaidae1
 
Indjic Fintech Module 7
Indjic Fintech Module 7Indjic Fintech Module 7
Indjic Fintech Module 7Drago Indjic
 
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial services
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial servicesProduct strategy and distribution strategy of financial services
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial servicesRoy Thomas
 
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good? Insights from Hong Kong & B...
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good?  Insights from Hong Kong & B...Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good?  Insights from Hong Kong & B...
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good? Insights from Hong Kong & B...The Digital Insurer
 
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13HACThousing
 
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...Stephan Cronje
 
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...Kiran M
 
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 Review
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 ReviewExec InsurTech cologne 2019 Review
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 ReviewThe Digital Insurer
 
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEW
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEWGlobal Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEW
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEWThe Digital Insurer
 
Igc value for money
Igc   value for moneyIgc   value for money
Igc value for moneyHenry Tapper
 
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014Camilo A. Pieschacón
 
OurCrowd - NOAH17 Berlin
OurCrowd - NOAH17 BerlinOurCrowd - NOAH17 Berlin
OurCrowd - NOAH17 BerlinNOAH Advisors
 

Similar to Tjb hulshoff i pension solutions kcm presentations 23 april 2015-v20150421th (20)

Crowd4 ovo pitch v02
Crowd4 ovo pitch v02Crowd4 ovo pitch v02
Crowd4 ovo pitch v02
 
Igc value for moneyv6 (1)
Igc   value for moneyv6 (1)Igc   value for moneyv6 (1)
Igc value for moneyv6 (1)
 
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRAND
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRANDOECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRAND
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Virginie GRAND
 
Career Opportunities The Investors Group Advantage
Career Opportunities  The Investors Group AdvantageCareer Opportunities  The Investors Group Advantage
Career Opportunities The Investors Group Advantage
 
Indjic Fintech Module 7
Indjic Fintech Module 7Indjic Fintech Module 7
Indjic Fintech Module 7
 
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial services
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial servicesProduct strategy and distribution strategy of financial services
Product strategy and distribution strategy of financial services
 
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good? Insights from Hong Kong & B...
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good?  Insights from Hong Kong & B...Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good?  Insights from Hong Kong & B...
Webinar:Blockchain in Insurance - Here for Good? Insights from Hong Kong & B...
 
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
 
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...
C.Y Actuaries Conference 2014: The Future of Asset Management in Cyprus and G...
 
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...
RMI Unit 6 Management of Insurance Companies Functions and Organization of In...
 
LECTURE TWO.pptx
LECTURE TWO.pptxLECTURE TWO.pptx
LECTURE TWO.pptx
 
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 Review
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 ReviewExec InsurTech cologne 2019 Review
Exec InsurTech cologne 2019 Review
 
Cytonn investments
Cytonn investmentsCytonn investments
Cytonn investments
 
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEW
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEWGlobal Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEW
Global Insurtech Roadshow 2018 – REVIEW
 
CBO Peer Learning Event: Employment, housing & crime: Working with investors
CBO Peer Learning Event: Employment, housing & crime: Working with investorsCBO Peer Learning Event: Employment, housing & crime: Working with investors
CBO Peer Learning Event: Employment, housing & crime: Working with investors
 
Igc value for money
Igc   value for moneyIgc   value for money
Igc value for money
 
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014
Presentación Corporativa PréstamoVida - octubre 2014
 
OurCrowd - NOAH17 Berlin
OurCrowd - NOAH17 BerlinOurCrowd - NOAH17 Berlin
OurCrowd - NOAH17 Berlin
 
Erasmus college
Erasmus collegeErasmus college
Erasmus college
 
GIA Essential Tips for Increasing Efficiency of Intelligence
GIA Essential Tips for Increasing Efficiency of IntelligenceGIA Essential Tips for Increasing Efficiency of Intelligence
GIA Essential Tips for Increasing Efficiency of Intelligence
 

Tjb hulshoff i pension solutions kcm presentations 23 april 2015-v20150421th

  • 1. 1
  • 2. A standard, yet very different PPI Kempen Capital Management seminar ‘Hollands Glorie’ De toekomst van ons pensioenstelsel: In search of the Holy Grail April 23, 2015 24/04/2015 Private and Confidential
  • 3. 3 And now for something completely different... • DC has the future • ...as despite common myths.. • ...the underlying trend is unassailable • PPI is the best vehicle • ...supported by massive growth... • ...and now breaking barriers.... • ...acting in the interest of participants • Further improvement is on the way • ...yet myths are tenacious... • ... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest.
  • 4. 4 And now for something completely different... • DC has the future • ...as despite common myths.. • ...the underlying trend is unassailable • PPI is the best vehicle • ...supported by massive growth... • ...and now breaking barriers.... • ...acting in the interest of participants • Further improvement is on the way • ...yet myths are tenacious... • ... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest.
  • 5. 5 1605 1st “pension” State elderly pension 1956 No more early age retirement 2011 g 1st fund 1970 -1990 Early retirement 65 -> 67 72 DB to DC 1845 Final pay avg. pay 2000 -2008 2004 2011 2011 g PPI growth 2014
  • 6. www.ingim.com 6 We look into the future and we see....
  • 7. 7 7 The current system is merely scratched
  • 8. 8 ...as despite common myths... 1. DC leads to unpredictable pension 2. DC does not contain collectivity and solidarity 3. DB has higher returns, because of intergenerational solidarity 4. DC requires participant choices, and thus leads to errors 5. DC is more expensive for it is often executed by for-profit parties
  • 9. 9 ...the underlying trend is unassailable. 2040 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1950196019701980199020002010202020302040205020602070208020902100 Number of workers per 65+ Bron: i-PensionSolutions, United Nations
  • 11. 11 ...the underlying trend is unassailable. 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 900,000 1,000,000 1999 2005 2010 2014 Number of participants in DC (Netherlands) 0 5 10 15 20 25 1999 2005 2010 2014 AUM(€bln) AUM in DC (Netherlands)
  • 12. 12 And now for something completely different... • DC has the future • ...as despite common myths.. • ...the underlying trend is unassailable • PPI is the best vehicle • ...supported by massive growth... • ...and now breaking barriers.... • ...acting in the interest of participants • Further improvement is on the way • ...yet myths are tenacious... • ... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest.
  • 14. 14 PPI is the best vehicle (cost) Source: LCP [2014] Source: LCP [2014] Source: Towers Watson [2011 (!)]
  • 15. 15 PPI is the best vehicle • Proven concept • Lowest cost • Inherently innovative • Participant focused • VAT exempt • Ringfencing • Regulated in The Netherlands • Suitable for: • DC scheme • Net pension • CDC scheme • Run-off portfolio • Separated account • Europe • (self employed, currently excluded by law)
  • 16. 16 ...supported by massive growth • Significant growth in AUM and premium • Large corporations looking into PPI • (political) perception has changed € 113 € 132 € 145 € 171 € 241 € 291 € 380 € 512 € 658 € 935 € 1,241 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200 1,400 2012K2 2012K3 2012K4 2013K1 2013K2 2013K3 2013K4 2014K1 2014K2 2014K3 2014K4 AUM(€mln) PPI market Bron: DNB
  • 17. 17 ...and now breaking barriers Private and Confidential The first open architecture Premium Pension Institution
  • 18. 18 ...and now breaking barriers • i-PensionSolutions • open platform • serves the interest of participants • Open platform facilitates: • customers to create and maintain tailor made solutions • asset managers and insurance companies to offer core business products to their client base, integrated within a total pension offering • development of (optional) guarantees • next generation DC products to be built 6
  • 19. 19 Strategic choices: • IPS is set up as a foundation. Its sole purpose is to serve and protect the interests of the pension scheme participants and is a not-for-profit organization • Only best-in-class partners, • stringent due diligence and compliance • Operational excellence • Distribution through partners • SwissRe offers re-insurance, Credit Suisse capital market guarantees • Initial start in The Netherlands, European ambition • Optional guarantees (capital market and insurance) Core values: • Protect the interests of the participants • Transparency • Integrity • Independent • High standards for access to platform • Strong compliance framework • Clear governance • Cost efficient • Committed for the long term (and strongly capitalized) ...and now breaking barriers
  • 22. 22 Best of all worlds • i-PensionSolutions offers Pension Savings Product • Employer selects asset manager and investment strategy • Employer can select Insurance Company and Insurance Cover • Pension Administration and integrated communication is executed by i- PensionSolutions • The employer signs two agreements: • [A] Pension Execution to cover Asset Accumulation (as described before) and, • [B] Insurance Policy Agreement (Pension Insurance Product) to cover Biometric Risk insurance with an insurance company Asset Manager Administrator Stichting International Pension Solutions (regulated pension entity) Administration Asset Management [Employer] (Former) Employees Pension Agreement Pension Execution Agreement Claim on vested rights Custodian Management Board Supervisory Council External Advisors Order Execution/ Custody Investment PolicyAdvise on: Legal, Tax, Actuarial Investment, Risk Mngt Investment Committee Asset Liability Committee Insurance company Insurance Insurane Policy Agreement
  • 23. 23 ... acting in the interest of participants Independent governance and dedicated products Standard Tailor made Plain vanilla Advanced - Allocation based on time to maturity. General set-up - Allocation based on time to maturity - Client specific - Allocation depending on (a.o) funding & standard guarantee Fully client specific, both guarantee and investment scheme Level of tailoring Levelofsophistication SME, Corporates] Large corporates, multinationals, other collectives, Corporates Multinationals, large other collectives
  • 24. 24 And now for something completely different... • DC has the future • ...as despite common myths.. • ...the underlying trend is unassailable • PPI is the best vehicle • ...supported by massive growth... • ...and now breaking barriers.... • ...acting in the interest of participants • Further improvement is on the way • ...yet myths are tenacious... • ... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest.
  • 25. 25 ...yet myths are tenacious • Lifecycle invests in equity for young people because of ‘investment horizon’ • A longer ‘investment horizon’ leads to higher return • Flywheel of disbursements • With pension funds, retirees retain investment exposure • Longevity risk can be mitigated in a collective
  • 27. 27 Prerequisite for ‘doorbeleggen’ • Prevent money death • Individual economic ownership • Executable • Tailoring to individual • Flexible Risk attittude Risk capacity Risk position
  • 28. 28 ... and participant interests should outweigh providers’ interest. Source: i-PensionSolutions: “Doorbeleggen en verbeteringen in Defined Contribution” 2015. denationalepensioendialoog.nl/item/596 Risk willingness Risk capacity High HighLow Low Annuity Cash / Lump sum ALDA | Partial annuity Continue lifecycle ALDA | Partial annuity ALDA | Partial annuity
  • 29. www.ingim.com 29 Within the next 5 years, my pension will be with a PPI
  • 30. A new road towards modern and innovative pension solutions in Europe
  • 32. 32 Unfunded plan on Balance Sheet Partial buy-out / LDI solution Insurance Solutions Transfer risk to insurance vehicle Low Required Initial funding (necessary liquidity for single premium) HighLow RiskReduction High Cash injection into pension plan/ traditional asset allocation Change plan benefits (DB DC) Traditional full buyout (Insured annuities) Close fund to new entrants and accruals (hard freeze) Close fund to new entrants Asset Management Solutions Manage Risk-Return Cash Injection/ LDI solution Change in employee benefits Transfer risk to employees Insurance SolutionsAsset Management SolutionsPlan Design Solutions Diagram 1: Illustrative Example of Pension Risk Management Solutions Current Current ... the underlying trend is unassailable
  • 33. 33 A longer ‘investment horizon’ leads to higher return Private and Confidential • Longest, reliable data goes back to 1871 • Only nine complete, independent series of 15 year return • Statistically infeasible to make valid forward looking statements 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 jaars rendementsperiodes 1871 1886 1901 1916 1931 1946 1961 1976 1991 2006 Bron: RobertShiller,i-PensionSolutions
  • 34. 34 Growth and Inflation are drivers of interest rate -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 Real GDP growth (Euro) Source:IMF World EconomicOutlookApril 2015 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 Inflation ( Euro) Source:IMF World EconomicOutlookApril 2015
  • 35. 35 Interest rate is rightfully low. But perhaps too low? • The "Yuppie/Nerd Ratio" compares the number of 25-to 34-year-olds ("Yuppies") to the number of 45-to 54-year-olds ("Nerds"). • This ratio is said to do a good job of tracking the demographic pressures on long term interest rates. • Nerds buy bonds for retirement, Yuppies borrow to buy houses, cars, cribs, etc. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010 2013 2016 2019 2022 2025 2028 2031 2034 2037 2040 2043 2046 2049 10yearrate YuppieNerdRatio Yuppie Nerd Ratio (Netherlands) Yuppie / Nerd (LHS) 10year rate (RHS) Regressed value Source: Datastream, Census Bureau, ING Investment Management
  • 36. 36 Risk of underfunding weighs heavily on sponsors (or whomever bears the risk) Private and Confidential 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 85 87 88 90 91 93 94 96 97 99 100 102 103 105 106 108 109 111 112 114 115 117 118 120 121 123 124 126 Fundingratiopoints Funding ratio Estimated value 1 year guarantee of additional funding Bron: i-PensionSolutions
  • 37. ©2014 IPS. All rights reserved. You are not permitted to create any modifications or derivatives of this presentation or to use it for commercial or other public purposes without the prior written permission of IPS. This presentation is for information purposes only and contains non-binding indications as well as personal judgement. It does not contain any recommendation, advice, solicitation, offer or commitment to effect any transaction or to conclude any legal act. IPS makes no warranties or representations as to this presentation’s accuracy, completeness, timeliness or suitability for a particular purpose. Anyone who interprets and employs this presentation shall do so at his or her own risk without relying on it in isolation. In no event shall IPS or any of its affiliates be liable for any loss or damages of any kind, including any direct, indirect or consequential damages, arising out of or in connection with the use of this presentation. Important Information