Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Was ist 4chan.org?  Refugium der Redefreiheit im Netz? Spielplatz für Dauerpubertierende?  Oder ein ultimativer Turing-Tes...
 
Zur Größenordnung 4chan.org ORF-Seiten t-online.de Unique Users  Per Month 8.2 million 4.7 million 458 million Pages loade...
Zur Größenordnung 4 chan: Kein redaktioneller Content (außer FAQ & Rules) 800,000 einzelne Diskussions-beiträge / Tag 4cha...
 
 
Leichter Einstieg? <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ There’s no barred entry, there’s no reg...
 
 
Anonymität bis zur Anti-Identität <ul><li>Reguläre Internetforen: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Nicknames statt Real Names </li></...
Zerstörung von Interaktionskonventionen und Identitätserwartungen
 
 
 
Verzicht auf Speicherung… <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ And there’s no archiving, there’...
… als Qualitätsgarantie? <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ The lack of retention is also imp...
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Anonymous has therefore decided that your organization s...
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Yet for all that we are not as monstrous as you are; sti...
Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Knowledge is free. We are Anonymous. We are Legion. We d...
4chan als verbesserter Turing-Test? <ul><li>_Test (1950) zur Unterscheidbarkeit von menschlicher & künstlicher Intelligenz...
4chan als verbesserter Turing-Test? <ul><li>Simulierbarkeit menschl. Beteiligung? </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Bilder posten und ...
Beispiel für Repertoire als körperliche Praxis <ul><li>Krumping ( RIZE , David LaChapelle) </li></ul>
Beispiel für Repertoire als körperliche Praxis <ul><li>4chan: Stete Entleerung des Archivs erfordert stete menschliche Bet...
Bilddiskussionen: Beispiele <ul><li>Kollektive Beschwörung und zugleich Zerstörung  von Identität: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>I...
Anonymous:  ITT, take this blank map in Mspaint and draw the borders to the best fo your memory, no kooking at maps/google...
Anonymous:  from france
Anonymous:  from france Anonymous: you forgot to put „faggots“ in french territory you racist cunt
Anonymous:  from france Anonymous: you forgot to put „faggots“ in french territory you racist cunt Anonymous: why don't yo...
Anonymous:  Easy.  I‘m from the US
Anonymous:  Easy.  I‘m from the US Anonymous:
Anonymous:  American
Anonymous:  How am I the first?
Anonymous:  How am I the first? Anonymous: You placed Vichy France wrong.
Anonymous:  How am I the first? Anonymous: You placed Vichy France wrong. Anonymous: Hey be glad I included it at all.
Anonymous:  Britfag here.
Anonymous:  MURKA MURKA FUCK YEAH
Anonymous:  MURKA MURKA FUCK YEAH Anonymous: Ignorant cunt
Anonymous:
Anonymous:  I don‘t even
Anonymous:  I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say?
Anonymous:  I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the Ge...
Anonymous:  I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the Ge...
Anonymous:  I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the Ge...
Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo :
Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo :  Anonymous: nice theme
Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo :  Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style?
Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo :  Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style? Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo : I‘m a little ...
Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo :  Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style? Mr.  !WAHZOOo2zo : I‘m a little ...
Anonymous:         Newfags Can‘t triforce Durch Nutzung der Plattform erworbenes (an Körper gebundenes) Wissen als Dist...
Anonymous:         Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous:  Vegan Folded Seven
Anonymous:         Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous:  Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce?
Anonymous:         Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous:  Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce? Anonymous: ...
Anonymous:         Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous:  Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce? Anonymous: ...
Anonymous:  It‘s Caturday. Poast YOUR cats.  I don‘t want to see a picture of you, any pussies you think are cute, some ra...
 
Was ist 4chan.org? <ul><ul><li>Refugium der Redefreiheit?  </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>Jein: Da dass sich Äußern aus de...
Was ist 4chan.org? <ul><ul><li>Ultimativer Turing-Test? Zumindest ein Hinweis auf:  </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>den ver...
Was nicht gesagt wurde  in dieser Session....
From Liminality to Liminoidity <ul><li>Phases of a Rite of Passage (Turner) </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Separation: demarcation ...
From Liminality to Liminoidity <ul><li>Phases of a Rite of Passage (Turner) </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Separation: demarcation ...
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Separation: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Demarcation of ritual time and space </li></...
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Optional Anonymity: e....
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Suppressed Anonymity: ...
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Suppressed Anonymity: ...
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Encouraged Anonymity: ...
Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Encouraged Anonymity: ...
Liminoid play w/ identity <ul><li>Play with identity ≠subversion of a ‘physical’ or ‘material’ identity: </li></ul><ul><ul...
...kann nachgelesen werden:
<ul><li>„ Fluktuierende Kollektive, hybrides Archiv: Semiologische Praktiken im Imageboard 4chan“, in:  Inzenierung von „W...
ENDE Jana Herwig a.k.a. @digiom http://tinyurl.com/herwig
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Was ist 4chan.org? Zwischen Redefreiheit, Anonymität und ultimativem Turing-Test

Präsentation fürs BarCamp 2010 - Zusammenfassung einiger plattformanalytischer Aspekte, für weiteres siehe http://bit.ly/digiompapers (u.a. Downloadmöglichkeit von Artikeln)

  • Login to see the comments

Was ist 4chan.org? Zwischen Redefreiheit, Anonymität und ultimativem Turing-Test

  1. 1. Was ist 4chan.org? Refugium der Redefreiheit im Netz? Spielplatz für Dauerpubertierende? Oder ein ultimativer Turing-Test? Jana Herwig a.k.a. @digiom http: //tinyurl . com/herwig
  2. 3. Zur Größenordnung 4chan.org ORF-Seiten t-online.de Unique Users Per Month 8.2 million 4.7 million 458 million Pages loaded (impressions) 600 million 270 million 4.4 billion Average time spent on site 19 minutes 9.5 minutes n/a Average Page loads 30 pages 6.7 pages 9.7 pages Source: C. Poole, NYT Interview Source: Oewa.at, 03/2010 Source: ivwonline.de 03/2010
  3. 4. Zur Größenordnung 4 chan: Kein redaktioneller Content (außer FAQ & Rules) 800,000 einzelne Diskussions-beiträge / Tag 4chan.org ORF-Seiten t-online.de Unique Users Per Month 8.2 million 4.7 million 458 million Pages loaded (impressions) 600 million 270 million 4.4 billion Average time spent on site 19 minutes 9.5 minutes n/a Average Page loads 30 pages 6.7 pages 9.7 pages Source: C. Poole, NYT Interview Source: Oewa.at, 03/2010 Source: ivwonline.de 03/2010
  4. 7. Leichter Einstieg? <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ There’s no barred entry, there’s no registration or anything, not captcha, which is something I think we’re all very used to these days. Pretty much every site on the net now wants a piece of information from you, an email address, a name, an age, something like that, and we don’t require you to submit any of that. It is an emphasis on anonymity.“ </li></ul>
  5. 10. Anonymität bis zur Anti-Identität <ul><li>Reguläre Internetforen: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Nicknames statt Real Names </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>zeitl. Horizont der Aktivitäten </li></ul></ul><ul><li>4chan.org: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>keine Registrierung, kein/e Profil/ierung </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>‘ Projekt Online-Identität’ scheitert </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>‘ Abweichung’ v. On- & Offline entzieht sich </li></ul></ul>
  6. 11. Zerstörung von Interaktionskonventionen und Identitätserwartungen
  7. 15. Verzicht auf Speicherung… <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ And there’s no archiving, there’s no retention on the site. The boards are limited to a set number of pages and so, for example if we had a board with ten pages, ten threads a page, you can only have a hundred threads at any given time, so if somebody posts a new thread, at least one thread is being bumped off, so there’s just no retention on the site.“ </li></ul>
  8. 16. … als Qualitätsgarantie? <ul><li>_Moot (Gründer; Paraflows 11.9.09): </li></ul><ul><li>“ The lack of retention is also important because, on a site where you can just bump up all content, um, the way kind of threads work on 4chan is that if you post something and it’s crap, it’s washed away. […] And if it’s a genuinely good idea or something that people identify with then either somebody will save it and repost it and that’s how we get memes “ </li></ul>
  9. 17. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
  10. 18. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
  11. 19. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
  12. 20. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
  13. 21. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur
  14. 22. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Anonymous has therefore decided that your organization should be destroyed. For the good of your followers, for the good of mankind--for the laughs--we shall expel you from the Internet and systematically dismantle the Church of Scientology in its present form. “
  15. 23. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Yet for all that we are not as monstrous as you are; still our methods are a parallel to your own. Doubtless you will use the Anon's actions as an example of the persecution you have so long warned your followers would come; this is acceptable. In fact, it is encouraged. We are your SPs.“
  16. 24. Rolle in der Internet-Kultur _Message to Scientology (21.1.08): “ Knowledge is free. We are Anonymous. We are Legion. We do not forgive. We do not forget. Expect us.“
  17. 25. 4chan als verbesserter Turing-Test? <ul><li>_Test (1950) zur Unterscheidbarkeit von menschlicher & künstlicher Intelligenz: </li></ul><ul><li>Person A stellt Person B und Rechner C über eine Tastatur ohne Sicht-/Hörkontakt Fragen. B und C sollen A überzeugen, dass sie Menschen sind. Wenn A nicht sicher entscheiden kann, dann soll die Ebenbürtigkeit der Denkleistung von Rechner und Mensch bewiesen sein. </li></ul>
  18. 26. 4chan als verbesserter Turing-Test? <ul><li>Simulierbarkeit menschl. Beteiligung? </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Bilder posten und kommentieren als ‘Über-Captcha’ -> kaum simulierbar </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Archiv vs. Repertoire (Diana Taylor): materielle Fixierung bzw. Stillstellung von Wissen (Archiv) vs. Verkörpertes, flüchtiges, kollektives Wissen (Repertoire) </li></ul></ul>
  19. 27. Beispiel für Repertoire als körperliche Praxis <ul><li>Krumping ( RIZE , David LaChapelle) </li></ul>
  20. 28. Beispiel für Repertoire als körperliche Praxis <ul><li>4chan: Stete Entleerung des Archivs erfordert stete menschliche Beteiligung </li></ul><ul><li>Von wegen online: Ohne die Körper und deren Wissen vor dem Bildschirm geht gar nichts </li></ul>
  21. 29. Bilddiskussionen: Beispiele <ul><li>Kollektive Beschwörung und zugleich Zerstörung von Identität: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Identität hinterm Bildschirm wird in Inter-netforen generell schnell thematisiert </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Auch auf 4chan sind solche Versuche zu verzeichnen – und werden regelmäßig in kürzester Zeit ad absurdum geführt </li></ul></ul>
  22. 30. Anonymous: ITT, take this blank map in Mspaint and draw the borders to the best fo your memory, no kooking at maps/google earth or other posts in the thead. Also tell where you‘re from
  23. 31. Anonymous: from france
  24. 32. Anonymous: from france Anonymous: you forgot to put „faggots“ in french territory you racist cunt
  25. 33. Anonymous: from france Anonymous: you forgot to put „faggots“ in french territory you racist cunt Anonymous: why don't you go fuck yourself you filthy piece of crap. faggots us? lol your women want our cocks because they know you can't please them
  26. 34. Anonymous: Easy. I‘m from the US
  27. 35. Anonymous: Easy. I‘m from the US Anonymous:
  28. 36. Anonymous: American
  29. 37. Anonymous: How am I the first?
  30. 38. Anonymous: How am I the first? Anonymous: You placed Vichy France wrong.
  31. 39. Anonymous: How am I the first? Anonymous: You placed Vichy France wrong. Anonymous: Hey be glad I included it at all.
  32. 40. Anonymous: Britfag here.
  33. 41. Anonymous: MURKA MURKA FUCK YEAH
  34. 42. Anonymous: MURKA MURKA FUCK YEAH Anonymous: Ignorant cunt
  35. 43. Anonymous:
  36. 44. Anonymous: I don‘t even
  37. 45. Anonymous: I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say?
  38. 46. Anonymous: I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the German is correctly written)
  39. 47. Anonymous: I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the German is correctly written) Anonymous: Shit, wrong one.
  40. 48. Anonymous: I don‘t even Anonymous: Finlandia, you say? Anonymous: Now in glorious Nazi glory (I don‘t even know if the German is correctly written) Anonymous: Shit, wrong one. Anonymous: actually this looks like a map of the roman empire:|
  41. 49. Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo :
  42. 50. Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : Anonymous: nice theme
  43. 51. Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style?
  44. 52. Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style? Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : I‘m a little late but it‘s SLANXP for 7
  45. 53. Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : Anonymous: nice theme Anonymous: Whats the name of that visual style? Mr. !WAHZOOo2zo : I‘m a little late but it‘s SLANXP for 7 Anonymous: Holy shit an Aero thema that actually changes something besides Colors. Fuck yes nor more rounded corners and unnecessarily large window borders. Thanks.
  46. 54. Anonymous:    Newfags Can‘t triforce Durch Nutzung der Plattform erworbenes (an Körper gebundenes) Wissen als Distinktionsmerkmal
  47. 55. Anonymous:    Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous: Vegan Folded Seven
  48. 56. Anonymous:    Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous: Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce?
  49. 57. Anonymous:    Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous: Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce? Anonymous:   
  50. 58. Anonymous:    Newfags Can‘t triforce Anonymous: Vegan Folded Seven Anonymous: Lol what‘s a triforce? Anonymous:    Anonymous:   
  51. 59. Anonymous: It‘s Caturday. Poast YOUR cats. I don‘t want to see a picture of you, any pussies you think are cute, some random picture you found on the internet. I want your cat.
  52. 61. Was ist 4chan.org? <ul><ul><li>Refugium der Redefreiheit? </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>Jein: Da dass sich Äußern aus dem Bezug zu Identitäten entlassen wird, ist alles nur Denkbare auch sagbar – nicht zu verwechseln mit Meinungsäußerung! </li></ul></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Spielplatz für Dauerpubertierende? </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>Nur insofern, als es zum ‘typischen pubertären Witz’ gehört, keine Gelegen-heit zum ‘Witzeln’ auszulassen </li></ul></ul></ul>
  53. 62. Was ist 4chan.org? <ul><ul><li>Ultimativer Turing-Test? Zumindest ein Hinweis auf: </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>den vermutbaren Zusammenhang von Kreativität und der Frage der Nicht-Simulierbarkeit durch IT oder KI </li></ul></ul></ul><ul><ul><ul><li>die Stillstellung von Bedeutung in Archiven (welcher Art auch immer) – nur was zirkuliert wird, entwickelt sich weiter </li></ul></ul></ul>
  54. 63. Was nicht gesagt wurde in dieser Session....
  55. 64. From Liminality to Liminoidity <ul><li>Phases of a Rite of Passage (Turner) </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Separation: demarcation of ritual time and space, elimination of social status </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Liminality: ‘betwixt and between’, ‘non-status’, anonymity, chaos, play with the elements of culture, egalitarian spirit (‘communitas’) </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Reintegration as elevated subject </li></ul></ul>
  56. 65. From Liminality to Liminoidity <ul><li>Phases of a Rite of Passage (Turner) </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Separation: demarcation of ritual time and space, elimination of social status </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Liminality: ‘betwixt and between’, ‘non-status’, anonymity, chaos, play with the elements of culture, egalitarian spirit (‘communitas’) </li></ul></ul><ul><ul><li>Reintegration as elevated subject </li></ul></ul>“ Optation pervaded the liminoid phenomenon, obligation the liminal”
  57. 66. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Separation: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Demarcation of ritual time and space </li></ul></ul>
  58. 67. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Optional Anonymity: e.g. Twitter </li></ul></ul><ul><li>Text only (140 chars) </li></ul><ul><li>Limited archiving: </li></ul><ul><li>Search results only available for approx. 1.5 weeks </li></ul><ul><li>Only up to 3200 messages per profile can be accessed manually </li></ul>
  59. 68. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Suppressed Anonymity: e.g. Facebook </li></ul></ul>
  60. 69. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Suppressed Anonymity: e.g. Facebook </li></ul></ul>Society as Structure & Hierachy vs. Communitas as Communion of Equal Subjects (through communal submission)
  61. 70. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Encouraged Anonymity: e.g. 4chan </li></ul></ul>
  62. 71. Social Media as a Liminoid Practice <ul><li>Creation of the Liminoid Subject: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Encouraged Anonymity: e.g. 4chan </li></ul></ul>Anonymity No data retention A collective liminoid subject position Greatest distance to instances of social control on the social web
  63. 72. Liminoid play w/ identity <ul><li>Play with identity ≠subversion of a ‘physical’ or ‘material’ identity: </li></ul><ul><ul><li>Play with the means of cultural signification in general - including the material that subject positions, identity and social meanings are generated from </li></ul></ul>
  64. 73. ...kann nachgelesen werden:
  65. 74. <ul><li>„ Fluktuierende Kollektive, hybrides Archiv: Semiologische Praktiken im Imageboard 4chan“, in: Inzenierung von „Weiblichkeit“ , Loecker 2010, im Erscheinen (Preview via [email_address] ) </li></ul><ul><li>„‘ Post your Desktop!‘ Negotiating proximity and distance in an anonymous online environment on 4chan“, in: Media and Proximity / Medialität der Nähe, Tagungsband, im Erscheinen (Preview via [email_address] ) </li></ul><ul><li>„ Die 140-Zeichen-Frage: Microblogging, Twitter und die liminoide Verhandlung des Sozialen im Web 2.0“, in: Netcultures. Communities im Social Web , Nomos 2010, im Erscheinen (Download Pre-Print http://bit.ly/digiompapers ) </li></ul>
  66. 75. ENDE Jana Herwig a.k.a. @digiom http://tinyurl.com/herwig

×