6. EVALUATION METHODS
๏ Payback (Payback Period = Cost of Project / Annual Cash Inflows)
๏ Discounted Payback (DCF = Actual Cash flows / [1 + i]^n)
๏ Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 0 = P0 + P1/(1+IRR) + P2/(1+IRR)2 +
P3/(1+IRR)3 + . . . +Pn/(1+IRR)n
๏ Modified Internal Rate of Return (MIRR) = number of periods (โ Sum
of Terminal Cash Flows other than Initial Investment / Initial
Investment ) โ 1
๏ Profitability Index (PI) = Present Value of Future Cash Flows
/Initial Investment Required
๏ Net Present Value (NPV)
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran6
7. Projectโs Cash Flows
(CFt)
Market
interest rates
Projectโs
business risk
Market
risk aversion
Projectโs
debt/equity capacity
Projectโs risk-adjusted
cost of capital
(r)
The Big Picture:
The Net Present Value of a Project
NPV = + + ยทยทยท + โ Initial cost
CF1 CF2 CFN
(1 + r )1
(1 + r)N(1 + r)2
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran7
8. CAPITAL BUDGETING FOR
FOREIGN PROJECTS
๏ MORE COMPLICATIONS
๏ Multiple currencies
๏ Multiple tax rates
๏ Multiple tax systems
๏ Exchange rate fluctuations
๏ Capital flow restrictions
๏ Project specific subsidization โ host government
๏ Project specific penalties โ host government
๏ Valuing and investing โ local currency of host vs
domestic currency of parent
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran8
9. Issues in Foreign Investment
Analysis
1. Parent Vs. Project Cash Flows
2. Tax Issue
3. Exchange Control
4. Subsidized Finance
5. Knock-on Effects
6. Exchange Rate Changes and Inflation
7. Loss due to lost Exports
8. International Diversification Benefits
9. Political Risk
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran9
10. 1. Project cash flows computed from subsidiaries
side (separate entity)
2. Specific forecasts concerning the amounts,
timing of distributable cash expenses that will
be incurred in the process of transfer from
parent side
3. Indirect benefits and costs , such as an
increase or decrease in export sales by
another partner
Parent
VS
Project
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran10
13. Host country and home
country tax
Earnings - host country tax
net + withholding tax
(distribution)
Earnings - further taxed in
home country
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran13
After tax cash flows
14. Repatriation of earnings to
parent
Government
and
international
agencies
Add value of loan to
project at the time of
investment decision
Financing
below market
rates 6/30/2014Anu Damodaran14
15. There are knock-on effects from
one country to another. For
example, investment in a
subsidiary in country X affects
cash flows of a subsidiary in
country Y
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran15
16. For proper evaluation of expected cash flows
from overseas project first the impact of
offsetting inflation and exchange rate
exchanges needs to be removed 6/30/2014Anu Damodaran16
18. Take care of in case of
marginal project or a project
that is not acceptable on the
basis of merits, benefits
should be quantified and
taken care of 6/30/2014Anu Damodaran18
19. RISK ANALYSIS
Political risk
Financial risk (Exchange rate
Risk, Inflation/Purchasing power
risk, Interest rate risk)
Other risks (Cost overruns and bad
management)
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran19
20. Expropriation element contributes to divergence in cash flows of the
project and cash flows available to the parent company
In case of funds to be blocked in perpetuity, the time value of the
project is zero
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran20
Political risk
21. METHODS IN INCORPORATION
OF RISKS
Associate local government with the
project, insurance
Shortening the payback period
Raising the required IRR
Adjusting cash flows to reflect the specific impact of a
given risk
Take and pay/ take or pay contracts, guarantees of loan
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran21
22. EVALUATION OF OVERSEAS
PROJECTS โ INFORMATION
REQUIRED
๏ Net Investment Outlay
๏ Estimating Streams of Cash Benefits
๏ Estimating Operating Cash Outflows
๏ Salvage Value
๏ Lifespan of the Projects
๏ Restrictions on Transfer of Funds
๏ Tax Laws
๏ Exchange Rates
๏ Required Rate of Return
6/30/2014Anu Damodaran22
