SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 56
Download to read offline
ASSURING
             ASSURING
EFFECTIVE ANTIMALARIAL TREATMENT:
EFFECTIVE ANTIMALARIAL TREATMENT:
    A PLAN FOR MOVING FORWARD
   A PLAN FOR MOVING FORWARD




      CAROL HOPKINS SIBLEY
      CAROL HOPKINS SIBLEY
       ATELIER PALUDISME
       ATELIER PALUDISME
          MADAGASGAR
         MADAGASGAR
         MARCH 19, 2007
         MARCH 19, 2007
MALARIA MORTALITY IN AFRICA
MALARIA MORTALITY IN AFRICA
      HAS INCREASED
      HAS INCREASED
WHAT ARE THE PRACTICAL CONSEQUENCES?
WHAT ARE THE PRACTICAL CONSEQUENCES?




     ESTIMATED ALL- CAUSE CHILD MORTALITY
     ESTIMATED ALL- CAUSE CHILD MORTALITY
          SNOW, TRAPE AND MARSH, 2001
          SNOW, TRAPE AND MARSH, 2001
ESTIMATED MALARIA MORTALITY
ESTIMATED MALARIA MORTALITY
WHY THE OPPOSITE TRENDS ?
WHY THE OPPOSITE TRENDS ?
    MALARIA




    ALL CAUSE
RESISTANCE TO THREE
  RESISTANCE TO THREE
         COMMON
         COMMON
       INEXPENSIVE
      INEXPENSIVE
    WELL TOLERATED
    WELL TOLERATED
          DRUGS
          DRUGS
      HAS EVOLVED
      HAS EVOLVED


•• CHLOROQUINE
   CHLOROQUINE

•• SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
   SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE

•• MEFLOQUINE
   MEFLOQUINE
WHO SUMMARY
WHO SUMMARY

        WHO/RBM
        WHO/RBM
         REPORT
         REPORT

         PASCAL
         PASCAL
        RINGWALD
        RINGWALD
           2004
           2004
2005 MAP OF RESISTANCE
2005 MAP OF RESISTANCE
    3 CURRENT DRUGS
   3 CURRENT DRUGS
HOW DO WE DEFINE DRUG RESISTANCE
    HOW DO WE DEFINE DRUG RESISTANCE


•• IN VIVO
     IN VIVO
          DOES A PROPERLY TREATED PATIENT RECOVER?
         DOES A PROPERLY TREATED PATIENT RECOVER?
•• IN VITRO
    IN VITRO
          HOW SENSITIVE IS A PARASITE ISOLATE
         HOW SENSITIVE IS A PARASITE ISOLATE
                TO DRUG ?
               TO DRUG ?
•• MOLECULAR
    MOLECULAR
          ARE MUTATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH
         ARE MUTATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH
                RESISTANCE COMMON IN THE REGION?
               RESISTANCE COMMON IN THE REGION?
•• PHARMACOKINETICS
    PHARMACOKINETICS
          DID THE PATIENT HAVE A CORRECT LEVEL OF
         DID THE PATIENT HAVE A CORRECT LEVEL OF
                DRUG IN THE BLOOD?
               DRUG IN THE BLOOD?
HOW DO WE MONITOR
         HOW DO WE MONITOR
           DRUG EFFICACY?
           DRUG EFFICACY?

PATIENT RESPONSE TO TREATMENT
PATIENT RESPONSE TO TREATMENT
     FOLLOW UP 28 DAYS ++
    FOLLOW UP 28 DAYS ++

        SYMPTOMS AND PARASITES GONE
   ACPR SYMPTOMS AND PARASITES GONE
             ALL 28 DAYS
            ALL 28 DAYS

          SYMPTOMS REAPPEAR
          SYMPTOMS REAPPEAR
               WITHIN 3 DAYS
          ETF WITHIN 3 DAYS
               WITHIN 28 DAYS
          LTF WITHIN 28 DAYS

   LPF    PARASITES ONLY REAPPEAR
          PARASITES ONLY REAPPEAR
               WITHIN 28 DAYS
              WITHIN 28 DAYS
WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE THE
WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE THE
    CLINICAL RESPONSE?
   CLINICAL RESPONSE?
  •• PRIOR EXPOSURE
     PRIOR EXPOSURE

  •• OTHER INFECTIONS
     OTHER INFECTIONS

  •• NUTRITIONAL STATUS
     NUTRITIONAL STATUS

  •• POSSIBILITY OF REINFECTION
     POSSIBILITY OF REINFECTION

  •• OTHER DRUG USE
     OTHER DRUG USE
HOW IS THIS INFORMATION USED?
    HOW IS THIS INFORMATION USED?


WHO GUIDELINES- 2006
WHO GUIDELINES- 2006

>15% CLINICAL/PARASTIOLOGICAL
>15% CLINICAL/PARASTIOLOGICAL
      FAILURES-
     FAILURES-

     CHANGE TO NEW DRUG
     CHANGE TO NEW DRUG
WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED ABOUT THE
 WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED ABOUT THE
  EVOLUTION OF DRUG RESISTANCE?
  EVOLUTION OF DRUG RESISTANCE?
••TWO IMPORTANT PHASES OF RESISTANCE
  TWO IMPORTANT PHASES OF RESISTANCE
   •• SELECTION OF RESISTANCE
      SELECTION OF RESISTANCE
   •• PROPAGATION OF RESISTANCE
      PROPAGATION OF RESISTANCE




FOCI OF CLINICAL RESISTANCE ARISE
 RELATIVELY RARELY TO CQ AND SP
BUT RESISTANCE STRAINS CAN
BUT RESISTANCE STRAINS CAN
    RAPIDLY PREDOMINATE
   RAPIDLY PREDOMINATE
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                  1978
                            HUMAN
                            HUMAN
                          MIGRATION
                          MIGRATION
                             IS KEY
                            IS KEY
                               TO
                               TO
                         RESISTANCE
                         RESISTANCE
                           SPREAD
                           SPREAD


                            ADAPTED FROM
                           ADAPTED FROM
                         CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                         CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1981
                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
        1978
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA

                 1982
                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1983
                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
        1978
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1984

                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1985

                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1986

                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1987

                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
                 1988

                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
FIRST REPORTS OF
       FIRST REPORTS OF
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA
CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA

                 1989
                           HUMAN
                           HUMAN
                         MIGRATION
                         MIGRATION
                            IS KEY
                           IS KEY
                              TO
                              TO
                        RESISTANCE
                        RESISTANCE
                          SPREAD
                          SPREAD


                           ADAPTED FROM
                          ADAPTED FROM
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
                        CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
DATA SUMMARIES ARE BY COUNTRY
DATA SUMMARIES ARE BY COUNTRY
BUT …. RESISTANCE IS NOT UNIFORM
BUT …. RESISTANCE IS NOT UNIFORM
        WITHIN COUNTRIES
        WITHIN COUNTRIES
TREATMENT FAILURE = RESISTANCE?
TREATMENT FAILURE = RESISTANCE?
        DOSE OF DRUG ADEQUATE?
        DOSE OF DRUG ADEQUATE?

         NO
         NO                  YES
                             YES

                        RESISTANCE?
                        RESISTANCE?
 MAY NOT
 MAY NOT
    BE
    BE
RESISTANCE
RESISTANCE        IN VITRO       GENETIC
                                GENETIC
                 IN VITRO
                RESPONSE
               RESPONSE          ANALYSIS
                                ANALYSIS
              OF PARASITES
              OF PARASITES     OF PARASITE
                               OF PARASITE
                TO DRUGS
                TO DRUGS


              HIGHER THAN        MARKERS
                                MARKERS
              HIGHER THAN        OF DRUG
               STANDARD?
               STANDARD?         OF DRUG
                               RESISTANCE?
                               RESISTANCE?
MEASUREMENT OF PARASITE DRUG SENSITIVITY
MEASUREMENT OF PARASITE DRUG SENSITIVITY
                 IN VITRO
                IN VITRO
  INFECTED BLOOD + PBS
                                               AVOIDS MAJOR
                                CF11 column
                                               HOST FACTORS:
                                                 IMMUNITY
                                                 NUTRITION
                                                  CALCULATE
                                                DRUG RESPONSE
 RESUSPEND IN MEDIUM AND
         SERUM
    PATIENT ISOLATE




                      A
                      B
                      C
                                               MEASURE GROWTH
                      D
                      E
                      F
                      G
                      H
                                                INCUBATE 37 O C
                          DRUG CONCENTRATION
                                                    24-36 H
DRUG RESPONSE OF FIELD SAMPLES
                      DRUG RESPONSE OF FIELD SAMPLES
                        SCREENED BY GROWTH IN VITRO
                       SCREENED BY GROWTH IN VITRO

                120
                110
                100
RELAT IVE GROWT H




                 90
                 80
                 70       Y5D3
                 60       S108
                 50       S108N
                 40       S108N + N51I
                 30
                          F.S. 7 E4
                 20
                 10       F.S. C1
                  0
                      0     1E -9        1E -8        1E -7           1E -6            1E -5
                                          [PYRIMETHAMINE

                                    IC50 3.4 x 10-8   IC50 4 x 10-7    IC50 9 x 10-7
MOLECULAR MARKERS
     MOLECULAR MARKERS
     OF DRUG RESISTANCE
     OF DRUG RESISTANCE

CQ
CQ       Pfcrt
         Pfcrt     SNPs
                   SNPs
         Pfmdr1
         Pfmdr1    SNPs
                   SNPs

SP
SP       Pfdhfr
         Pfdhfr    SNPs
                   SNPs
         Pfdhps
         Pfdhps    SNPs
                   SNPs

MEF
MEF      Pfmdr1
         Pfmdr1    COPY
                   COPY
                   NUMBER
                   NUMBER
ONE GENE IS NECESSARY FOR CQ-R
ONE GENE IS NECESSARY FOR CQ-R
         In P. falciparum
        In P. falciparum




   But probably is not sufficient!
   But probably is not sufficient!
DHFR MUTATIONS THAT CONFER
       DHFR MUTATIONS THAT CONFER
PYRIMETHAMINE RESISTANCE IN FIELD ISOLATES
PYRIMETHAMINE RESISTANCE IN FIELD ISOLATES

PYRS           Asn Cys       Ser     Ile

               51 59 Pf DHFR 108    164

PYRR           Asn Cys       ASN     Ile


               ILE Cys      ASN      Ile


               ILE ARG       ASN     Ile

               ILE ARG       ASN    LEU
MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS
       MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS
          PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE
         PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE
                                         DHFR
                                        DHFR
                                         AND
                                         AND
                                         DHPS
                                        DHPS
                                       ALLELES
                                      ALLELES
                                      TANZANIA
                                      TANZANIA
                                       2002-2004
                                      2002-2004
TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr
TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr
DOUBLE MUTANT dhps
DOUBLE MUTANT dhps




         Mugittu et al 2004
Pfmdr1 COPY NUMBER
          Pfmdr1 COPY NUMBER
       IS MARKER OF MEFLOQUINER
      IS MARKER OF MEFLOQUINER




                    1.0
      2.0
                                 MQS

MQR               1.1


       2.3
                        Wongsrichanalai C., 2005
STUDIES IN PATIENTS ARE
STUDIES IN PATIENTS ARE
      EXPENSIVE
      EXPENSIVE
          AND
          AND
   TIME CONSUMING
   TIME CONSUMING
      KEY QUESTION:
      KEY QUESTION:
     MOLECULAR MARKERS
    MOLECULAR MARKERS
               OR
               OR
       IN VITRO ANALYSIS
      IN VITRO ANALYSIS
      GOOD SURROGATES
      GOOD SURROGATES
           TO PREDICT
          TO PREDICT
CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE?
CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE?
MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS
MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS
   PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE
  PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE
                                  DHFR
                                 DHFR
        TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr
        DOUBLE MUTANT dhps        AND
                                  AND
                                  DHPS
                                 DHPS
                                ALLELES
                               ALLELES
                               TANZANIA
                               TANZANIA
                                2002-2004
                               2002-2004
CLINICAL FAILURE




 Mugittu et al 2004
MOLECULAR MARKERS OF SP RESISTANCE
                    MOLECULAR MARKERS OF SP RESISTANCE
                      CORRLEATE WITH CLINICAL FAILURE
                      CORRLEATE WITH CLINICAL FAILURE
                   1.0
                             Observed-14
                             Observed-28
                             Observed-42
                   0.8       Fit-14
CLINICAL FAILURE




                             Fit-28
                             Fit-42
                   0.6



                   0.4



                   0.2


                     0
                         0   0.1      0.2    0.3    0.4    0.5     0.6
                                   PREVALENCE OF "TRIPLE/DOUBLE"
HOW CAN WE FIT THIS TOGETHER?
                                               HOW CAN WE FIT THIS TOGETHER?

EARLY WARNINGS OF CLINICAL FAILURE
  100%
       DATA FROM
PREVALENCE OF RESISTANT P[ARASITES (%)

                                         90%        ALEXIS NZILA




                                                                                                                                                      TRIPLE MUTANTS DHFR
                                                EDWARD MBERU KAMAU
                                                   CAROL SIBLEY
                                                                                                                                    X




                                                                                                        ro
                                                                                                                                               70%




                                                                                                    vit


                                                                                                                        S
                                                                                                                   NT
                                                                                                in
                                                                                              CE



                                                                                                                    A
                                                                                                                                               60%




                                                                                                                 UT
                                                                                           AN



                                                                                                              EM
                                                                                                                                           o




                                                                                         ST
                                         50%
                                                                                                                                         iv 50% 50%




                                                                                                          IPL
                                                                                                                                        v




                                                                                       SI
                                                                                                                                   in




                                                                                   RE




                                                                                                      TR
                                                                                                                               E
                                                                                                                           C




                                                                                  PM




                                                                                                     %
                                                                                                                       N
                                                                                                                   A                       30% 30%
                                                                                                          X      ST
                                                                                                               SI
                                                                                                           E
                                                                                                          R                                20% 20%
                                                                           X                        /S
                                                                                                      D
                                         10%                                                   PM                                          10% 10%


                                                                  90-93   93-95        95-97          97-99                00-02
                                                 UNTIL LATE 80s

                                                                  PM/SD INTRODUCED KILIFI, KENYA
WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED?
       WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED?
•• RESISTANCE ARISES RARELY, BUT
   RESISTANCE ARISES RARELY, BUT
      SPREADS RELATIVELY QUICKLY
      SPREADS RELATIVELY QUICKLY

•• CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE IS THE LAST
   CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE IS THE LAST
       STEP IN A LONG SERIES OF CHANGES
      STEP IN A LONG SERIES OF CHANGES

•• EARLY WARNING OF RESISTANCE
   EARLY WARNING OF RESISTANCE
    •• SLOWER TIME TO CLEAR PARASITES
       SLOWER TIME TO CLEAR PARASITES

  •• IN VITRO INCREASES IN IC50 VALUE
      IN VITRO INCREASES IN IC50 VALUE

  •• INCREASING PREVALENCE OF
      INCREASING PREVALENCE OF
        “RESISTANT” ALLELES
       “RESISTANT” ALLELES
WHAT DATA ARE MISSING?
  WHAT DATA ARE MISSING?
    •• SURVEILLANCE SPOTTY
       SURVEILLANCE SPOTTY
    •• REPORTS LONG AFTER FACT
       REPORTS LONG AFTER FACT




BUT THIS IS IMPROVING RAPIDLY
1986
                               VERY LONG
                              VERY LONG
                                   LAG
                                   LAG
                                BETWEEN
                               BETWEEN
                                 SEEING
                                 SEEING
   4-5 years                  RESISTANCE
                              RESISTANCE
   6-7 years                       AND
                                   AND
   8 years                     CHANGING
                               CHANGING
                                  DRUG
                                  DRUG
                                 POLICY
                                 POLICY
Charmot et al 1991


 NEED FAR BETTER COORDINATION AMONG GROUPS
NEED FAR BETTER COORDINATION AMONG GROUPS
 INVOLVED IN RESISTANCE DETERMINATION
INVOLVED IN RESISTANCE DETERMINATION
WE HAVE ALWAYS PLAYED CATCH UP
 WE HAVE ALWAYS PLAYED CATCH UP




                          FROM WHITE, 1999

AS DRUGS FAIL, WE CHRONICLE THE FAILURES
WE NEED COORDINATED, OPEN ACCESS
WE NEED COORDINATED, OPEN ACCESS
DATABASE FROM ALL ENDEMIC AREAS
DATABASE FROM ALL ENDEMIC AREAS




 NEEDS TO CONNECT WITH ROUTINE
         SURVEILLANCE
WHAT MUST WE DO NOW?
        WHAT MUST WE DO NOW?
•• CONSOLIDATE RECENT DATA ON “OLD”
   CONSOLIDATE RECENT DATA ON “OLD”
      DRUGS
      DRUGS

•• CREATE AND MAINTAIN AN OPEN ACCESS
   CREATE AND MAINTAIN AN OPEN ACCESS
      DATABASE OF RESISTANCE DATA
      DATABASE OF RESISTANCE DATA
      WORLDWIDE
      WORLDWIDE

•• WHERE DID RESISTANCE ARISE?
   WHERE DID RESISTANCE ARISE?

•• OVER WHAT ROUTES DID SPREAD OCCUR?
   OVER WHAT ROUTES DID SPREAD OCCUR?

•• HOW DO SURROGATE MARKERS RELATE TO
   HOW DO SURROGATE MARKERS RELATE TO
      CLINICAL OUTCOMES?
     CLINICAL OUTCOMES?
THINGS USED TO BE SIMPLE…
THINGS USED TO BE SIMPLE…

CHLOROQUINE
CHLOROQUINE
SULFADOXINE/PYRIMETHAMINE
SULFADOXINE/PYRIMETHAMINE

QUININE
QUININE
MEFLOQUINE
MEFLOQUINE

MEFLOQUINE/ARTESUNATE
MEFLOQUINE/ARTESUNATE
RESISTANCE TO OLD DRUGS….
         RESISTANCE TO OLD DRUGS….
       CHANGE TO COMBINATION THERAPY
       CHANGE TO COMBINATION THERAPY




2003                                   2006
2006 ACT ADOPTIONS
2006 ACT ADOPTIONS




      Countries which need ACT policy
      Countries which adopted ACT
MANY ACTs ARE IN USE OR IN TRIAL
  MANY ACTs ARE IN USE OR IN TRIAL
•• ARTESUNATE-MEFLOQUINE
   ARTESUNATE-MEFLOQUINE

•• ARTEMETHER-LUMEFANTRINE
   ARTEMETHER-LUMEFANTRINE

•• ARTESUNATE-AMODIAQUINE
   ARTESUNATE-AMODIAQUINE

•• DIHYDROARTEMISININ-PIPERAQUINE
   DIHYDROARTEMISININ-PIPERAQUINE

•• CHLORPROGUANIL-DAPSONE-ARTESUNATE
   CHLORPROGUANIL-DAPSONE-ARTESUNATE

•• ARTESUNATE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
   ARTESUNATE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE

 AND…..
AND…..
•• CHLOROQUINE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
   CHLOROQUINE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE

•• AMODIAQUINE -- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
   AMODIAQUINE SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
ACTs CURRENTLY EFFECTIVE,
ACTs CURRENTLY EFFECTIVE,
         BUT……..
        BUT……..

    HOW CAN WE SUSTAIN
    HOW CAN WE SUSTAIN
          MAXIMUM
         MAXIMUM
  USEFUL THERAPEUTIC LIFE
  USEFUL THERAPEUTIC LIFE
          OF ACTs?
          OF ACTs?


       HOW CAN WE
       HOW CAN WE
    STAY AHEAD OF THE
   STAY AHEAD OF THE
  EVOLUTIONARY CURVE?
  EVOLUTIONARY CURVE?
NETWORK MUST BE PROSPECTIVE
  NETWORK MUST BE PROSPECTIVE
•• CURRENT TOOLS ARE ADEQUATE
   CURRENT TOOLS ARE ADEQUATE

•• MANY WELL PLACED SENTINAL SITES
   MANY WELL PLACED SENTINAL SITES

•• REAL TIME REPORTING MORE COMMON
   REAL TIME REPORTING MORE COMMON

•• NEW INITIATIVES WITH COMPLEMENTARY
   NEW INITIATIVES WITH COMPLEMENTARY
       OBJECTIVES
      OBJECTIVES


   •• GLOBAL FUND REQUIREMENTS
       GLOBAL FUND REQUIREMENTS
   •• ACT CONSORTIUM
       ACT CONSORTIUM
   •• IPTp
       IPTp
   •• IPTi
       IPTi
WORLD ANTIMALARIAL
        WORLD ANTIMALARIAL
        RESISTANCE NETWORK
        RESISTANCE NETWORK



              CLINICAL
               DRUG
              EFFICACY
                          MOLECULAR
PHARMACO-
                           MARKERS
  LOGICAL
                              OF
ASSESSMENT
                          RESISTANCE
               IN VITRO
                DRUG
             ASSESSMENT
PHARMACOLOGICAL
        PHARMACOLOGICAL
      ASSESSMENT OF DRUGS
      ASSESSMENT OF DRUGS



              CLINICAL
              CLINICAL
                DRUG
               DRUG
              EFFICACY
              EFFICACY

PHARMACO-
  LOGICAL    WHY DID THE PATIENT
             WHY DID THE PATIENT
ASSESSMENT    FAIL TREATMENT?
              FAIL TREATMENT?
             WAS THE DRUG LEVEL
             WAS THE DRUG LEVEL
                 ADEQUATE?
                 ADEQUATE?
CLINICAL FAILURE
 CLINICAL FAILURE
WITH ADEQUATE DRUG
WITH ADEQUATE DRUG



    PRESUMPTIVE
   PRESUMPTIVE
RESISTANT PARASITES
RESISTANT PARASITES




  IN VITRO ANALYSIS
 IN VITRO ANALYSIS
PATIENT ISOLATES WITH INCREASED
PATIENT ISOLATES WITH INCREASED
    DRUG RESISTANCE IN VITRO
    DRUG RESISTANCE IN VITRO



 CANDIDATES FOR INTENSIVE GENETIC
 CANDIDATES FOR INTENSIVE GENETIC
             ANALYSIS
            ANALYSIS



  IDENTIFICATION OF LOCI ASSOCIATED
 IDENTIFICATION OF LOCI ASSOCIATED
      WITH RESISTANCE TO EACH
      WITH RESISTANCE TO EACH
            PARTNER IN ACT
           PARTNER IN ACT
HOW TO MOVE TO
      HOW TO MOVE TO
  EVIDENCE BASED DRUG USE
  EVIDENCE BASED DRUG USE

                WE’RE HERE
                               WE NEED
                               TO MOVE
                               TO HERE




Don deSavigny and Fred Binka
Don deSavigny and Fred Binka
DRUG RESISTANCE IN VIVO
DRUG RESISTANCE IN VIVO

More Related Content

More from Institut Pasteur de Madagascar

More from Institut Pasteur de Madagascar (20)

Rapport audit 2007
Rapport audit 2007Rapport audit 2007
Rapport audit 2007
 
Bilan evaluations 2007
Bilan evaluations 2007Bilan evaluations 2007
Bilan evaluations 2007
 
Exemple evaluation 2007
Exemple evaluation 2007Exemple evaluation 2007
Exemple evaluation 2007
 
Presentation atelier paludisme 2007
Presentation atelier paludisme 2007Presentation atelier paludisme 2007
Presentation atelier paludisme 2007
 
Comparaison entre les premières et les dernières évaluations - 2006
Comparaison entre les premières et les dernières évaluations - 2006Comparaison entre les premières et les dernières évaluations - 2006
Comparaison entre les premières et les dernières évaluations - 2006
 
Exemple grille evaluation 2006
Exemple grille evaluation 2006Exemple grille evaluation 2006
Exemple grille evaluation 2006
 
Présentation Atelier Paludisme 2006
Présentation Atelier Paludisme 2006Présentation Atelier Paludisme 2006
Présentation Atelier Paludisme 2006
 
Rapport evaluations 1an 2 ans - 2005
Rapport evaluations 1an 2 ans - 2005Rapport evaluations 1an 2 ans - 2005
Rapport evaluations 1an 2 ans - 2005
 
Synthese 2005
Synthese 2005Synthese 2005
Synthese 2005
 
Grille d'evalution 2005
Grille d'evalution 2005Grille d'evalution 2005
Grille d'evalution 2005
 
Participants tables rondes 2005
Participants tables rondes 2005Participants tables rondes 2005
Participants tables rondes 2005
 
Diaporama 2003
Diaporama 2003Diaporama 2003
Diaporama 2003
 
Certificat 2003
Certificat 2003Certificat 2003
Certificat 2003
 
Grilles d'évaluations 2004
Grilles d'évaluations 2004Grilles d'évaluations 2004
Grilles d'évaluations 2004
 
Synthèse des Grilles Evaluations 2003
Synthèse des Grilles Evaluations 2003Synthèse des Grilles Evaluations 2003
Synthèse des Grilles Evaluations 2003
 
Guide pour le suivi et l'évaluation des programmes
Guide pour le suivi et l'évaluation des programmesGuide pour le suivi et l'évaluation des programmes
Guide pour le suivi et l'évaluation des programmes
 
Monitoring and Evaluation Toolkit
Monitoring and Evaluation ToolkitMonitoring and Evaluation Toolkit
Monitoring and Evaluation Toolkit
 
Développement nouveaux médicaments
Développement nouveaux médicamentsDéveloppement nouveaux médicaments
Développement nouveaux médicaments
 
Diagnostic biologique du paludisme
Diagnostic biologique du paludismeDiagnostic biologique du paludisme
Diagnostic biologique du paludisme
 
Guide d’élaboration d’un plan de gestion des achats et des stocks (Global Fun...
Guide d’élaboration d’un plan de gestion des achats et des stocks (Global Fun...Guide d’élaboration d’un plan de gestion des achats et des stocks (Global Fun...
Guide d’élaboration d’un plan de gestion des achats et des stocks (Global Fun...
 

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟   9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟   9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
 
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Rishikesh Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Independent Call Girls In Jaipur { 8445551418 } ✔ ANIKA MEHTA ✔ Get High Prof...
Independent Call Girls In Jaipur { 8445551418 } ✔ ANIKA MEHTA ✔ Get High Prof...Independent Call Girls In Jaipur { 8445551418 } ✔ ANIKA MEHTA ✔ Get High Prof...
Independent Call Girls In Jaipur { 8445551418 } ✔ ANIKA MEHTA ✔ Get High Prof...
 
Russian Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️PALLAVI VIP Jaipur Call Gir...
Russian Call Girls Service  Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️PALLAVI VIP Jaipur Call Gir...Russian Call Girls Service  Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️PALLAVI VIP Jaipur Call Gir...
Russian Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️PALLAVI VIP Jaipur Call Gir...
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For G...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For G...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For G...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For G...
 
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
 
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
 
Mumbai ] (Call Girls) in Mumbai 10k @ I'm VIP Independent Escorts Girls 98333...
Mumbai ] (Call Girls) in Mumbai 10k @ I'm VIP Independent Escorts Girls 98333...Mumbai ] (Call Girls) in Mumbai 10k @ I'm VIP Independent Escorts Girls 98333...
Mumbai ] (Call Girls) in Mumbai 10k @ I'm VIP Independent Escorts Girls 98333...
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
 
Call Girls Shimla Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Shimla Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Shimla Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Shimla Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any TimeTop Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
 
Jogeshwari ! Call Girls Service Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 90042684...
Jogeshwari ! Call Girls Service Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 90042684...Jogeshwari ! Call Girls Service Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 90042684...
Jogeshwari ! Call Girls Service Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 90042684...
 
Manyata Tech Park ( Call Girls ) Bangalore ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy...
Manyata Tech Park ( Call Girls ) Bangalore ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy...Manyata Tech Park ( Call Girls ) Bangalore ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy...
Manyata Tech Park ( Call Girls ) Bangalore ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy...
 
Call Girls Vadodara Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Vadodara Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Vadodara Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Vadodara Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
 
Night 7k to 12k Navi Mumbai Call Girl Photo 👉 BOOK NOW 9833363713 👈 ♀️ night ...
Night 7k to 12k Navi Mumbai Call Girl Photo 👉 BOOK NOW 9833363713 👈 ♀️ night ...Night 7k to 12k Navi Mumbai Call Girl Photo 👉 BOOK NOW 9833363713 👈 ♀️ night ...
Night 7k to 12k Navi Mumbai Call Girl Photo 👉 BOOK NOW 9833363713 👈 ♀️ night ...
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 

Comment procéder pour traquer les marqueurs génétiques de résistance aux artemisinines et autres nouvelles molécules antipaludiques ?

  • 1. ASSURING ASSURING EFFECTIVE ANTIMALARIAL TREATMENT: EFFECTIVE ANTIMALARIAL TREATMENT: A PLAN FOR MOVING FORWARD A PLAN FOR MOVING FORWARD CAROL HOPKINS SIBLEY CAROL HOPKINS SIBLEY ATELIER PALUDISME ATELIER PALUDISME MADAGASGAR MADAGASGAR MARCH 19, 2007 MARCH 19, 2007
  • 2. MALARIA MORTALITY IN AFRICA MALARIA MORTALITY IN AFRICA HAS INCREASED HAS INCREASED
  • 3. WHAT ARE THE PRACTICAL CONSEQUENCES? WHAT ARE THE PRACTICAL CONSEQUENCES? ESTIMATED ALL- CAUSE CHILD MORTALITY ESTIMATED ALL- CAUSE CHILD MORTALITY SNOW, TRAPE AND MARSH, 2001 SNOW, TRAPE AND MARSH, 2001
  • 5. WHY THE OPPOSITE TRENDS ? WHY THE OPPOSITE TRENDS ? MALARIA ALL CAUSE
  • 6. RESISTANCE TO THREE RESISTANCE TO THREE COMMON COMMON INEXPENSIVE INEXPENSIVE WELL TOLERATED WELL TOLERATED DRUGS DRUGS HAS EVOLVED HAS EVOLVED •• CHLOROQUINE CHLOROQUINE •• SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE •• MEFLOQUINE MEFLOQUINE
  • 7. WHO SUMMARY WHO SUMMARY WHO/RBM WHO/RBM REPORT REPORT PASCAL PASCAL RINGWALD RINGWALD 2004 2004
  • 8. 2005 MAP OF RESISTANCE 2005 MAP OF RESISTANCE 3 CURRENT DRUGS 3 CURRENT DRUGS
  • 9. HOW DO WE DEFINE DRUG RESISTANCE HOW DO WE DEFINE DRUG RESISTANCE •• IN VIVO IN VIVO DOES A PROPERLY TREATED PATIENT RECOVER? DOES A PROPERLY TREATED PATIENT RECOVER? •• IN VITRO IN VITRO HOW SENSITIVE IS A PARASITE ISOLATE HOW SENSITIVE IS A PARASITE ISOLATE TO DRUG ? TO DRUG ? •• MOLECULAR MOLECULAR ARE MUTATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH ARE MUTATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH RESISTANCE COMMON IN THE REGION? RESISTANCE COMMON IN THE REGION? •• PHARMACOKINETICS PHARMACOKINETICS DID THE PATIENT HAVE A CORRECT LEVEL OF DID THE PATIENT HAVE A CORRECT LEVEL OF DRUG IN THE BLOOD? DRUG IN THE BLOOD?
  • 10. HOW DO WE MONITOR HOW DO WE MONITOR DRUG EFFICACY? DRUG EFFICACY? PATIENT RESPONSE TO TREATMENT PATIENT RESPONSE TO TREATMENT FOLLOW UP 28 DAYS ++ FOLLOW UP 28 DAYS ++ SYMPTOMS AND PARASITES GONE ACPR SYMPTOMS AND PARASITES GONE ALL 28 DAYS ALL 28 DAYS SYMPTOMS REAPPEAR SYMPTOMS REAPPEAR WITHIN 3 DAYS ETF WITHIN 3 DAYS WITHIN 28 DAYS LTF WITHIN 28 DAYS LPF PARASITES ONLY REAPPEAR PARASITES ONLY REAPPEAR WITHIN 28 DAYS WITHIN 28 DAYS
  • 11. WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE THE WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE THE CLINICAL RESPONSE? CLINICAL RESPONSE? •• PRIOR EXPOSURE PRIOR EXPOSURE •• OTHER INFECTIONS OTHER INFECTIONS •• NUTRITIONAL STATUS NUTRITIONAL STATUS •• POSSIBILITY OF REINFECTION POSSIBILITY OF REINFECTION •• OTHER DRUG USE OTHER DRUG USE
  • 12. HOW IS THIS INFORMATION USED? HOW IS THIS INFORMATION USED? WHO GUIDELINES- 2006 WHO GUIDELINES- 2006 >15% CLINICAL/PARASTIOLOGICAL >15% CLINICAL/PARASTIOLOGICAL FAILURES- FAILURES- CHANGE TO NEW DRUG CHANGE TO NEW DRUG
  • 13. WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED ABOUT THE WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED ABOUT THE EVOLUTION OF DRUG RESISTANCE? EVOLUTION OF DRUG RESISTANCE? ••TWO IMPORTANT PHASES OF RESISTANCE TWO IMPORTANT PHASES OF RESISTANCE •• SELECTION OF RESISTANCE SELECTION OF RESISTANCE •• PROPAGATION OF RESISTANCE PROPAGATION OF RESISTANCE FOCI OF CLINICAL RESISTANCE ARISE RELATIVELY RARELY TO CQ AND SP
  • 14. BUT RESISTANCE STRAINS CAN BUT RESISTANCE STRAINS CAN RAPIDLY PREDOMINATE RAPIDLY PREDOMINATE
  • 15. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1978 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 16. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1981 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE 1978 SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 17. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1982 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 18. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1983 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE 1978 SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 19. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1984 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 20. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1985 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 21. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1986 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 22. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1987 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 23. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1988 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 24. FIRST REPORTS OF FIRST REPORTS OF CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE IN AFRICA 1989 HUMAN HUMAN MIGRATION MIGRATION IS KEY IS KEY TO TO RESISTANCE RESISTANCE SPREAD SPREAD ADAPTED FROM ADAPTED FROM CHARMOT ET AL, 1991 CHARMOT ET AL, 1991
  • 25. DATA SUMMARIES ARE BY COUNTRY DATA SUMMARIES ARE BY COUNTRY
  • 26. BUT …. RESISTANCE IS NOT UNIFORM BUT …. RESISTANCE IS NOT UNIFORM WITHIN COUNTRIES WITHIN COUNTRIES
  • 27. TREATMENT FAILURE = RESISTANCE? TREATMENT FAILURE = RESISTANCE? DOSE OF DRUG ADEQUATE? DOSE OF DRUG ADEQUATE? NO NO YES YES RESISTANCE? RESISTANCE? MAY NOT MAY NOT BE BE RESISTANCE RESISTANCE IN VITRO GENETIC GENETIC IN VITRO RESPONSE RESPONSE ANALYSIS ANALYSIS OF PARASITES OF PARASITES OF PARASITE OF PARASITE TO DRUGS TO DRUGS HIGHER THAN MARKERS MARKERS HIGHER THAN OF DRUG STANDARD? STANDARD? OF DRUG RESISTANCE? RESISTANCE?
  • 28. MEASUREMENT OF PARASITE DRUG SENSITIVITY MEASUREMENT OF PARASITE DRUG SENSITIVITY IN VITRO IN VITRO INFECTED BLOOD + PBS AVOIDS MAJOR CF11 column HOST FACTORS: IMMUNITY NUTRITION CALCULATE DRUG RESPONSE RESUSPEND IN MEDIUM AND SERUM PATIENT ISOLATE A B C MEASURE GROWTH D E F G H INCUBATE 37 O C DRUG CONCENTRATION 24-36 H
  • 29. DRUG RESPONSE OF FIELD SAMPLES DRUG RESPONSE OF FIELD SAMPLES SCREENED BY GROWTH IN VITRO SCREENED BY GROWTH IN VITRO 120 110 100 RELAT IVE GROWT H 90 80 70 Y5D3 60 S108 50 S108N 40 S108N + N51I 30 F.S. 7 E4 20 10 F.S. C1 0 0 1E -9 1E -8 1E -7 1E -6 1E -5 [PYRIMETHAMINE IC50 3.4 x 10-8 IC50 4 x 10-7 IC50 9 x 10-7
  • 30. MOLECULAR MARKERS MOLECULAR MARKERS OF DRUG RESISTANCE OF DRUG RESISTANCE CQ CQ Pfcrt Pfcrt SNPs SNPs Pfmdr1 Pfmdr1 SNPs SNPs SP SP Pfdhfr Pfdhfr SNPs SNPs Pfdhps Pfdhps SNPs SNPs MEF MEF Pfmdr1 Pfmdr1 COPY COPY NUMBER NUMBER
  • 31. ONE GENE IS NECESSARY FOR CQ-R ONE GENE IS NECESSARY FOR CQ-R In P. falciparum In P. falciparum But probably is not sufficient! But probably is not sufficient!
  • 32. DHFR MUTATIONS THAT CONFER DHFR MUTATIONS THAT CONFER PYRIMETHAMINE RESISTANCE IN FIELD ISOLATES PYRIMETHAMINE RESISTANCE IN FIELD ISOLATES PYRS Asn Cys Ser Ile 51 59 Pf DHFR 108 164 PYRR Asn Cys ASN Ile ILE Cys ASN Ile ILE ARG ASN Ile ILE ARG ASN LEU
  • 33. MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE DHFR DHFR AND AND DHPS DHPS ALLELES ALLELES TANZANIA TANZANIA 2002-2004 2002-2004 TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr DOUBLE MUTANT dhps DOUBLE MUTANT dhps Mugittu et al 2004
  • 34. Pfmdr1 COPY NUMBER Pfmdr1 COPY NUMBER IS MARKER OF MEFLOQUINER IS MARKER OF MEFLOQUINER 1.0 2.0 MQS MQR 1.1 2.3 Wongsrichanalai C., 2005
  • 35. STUDIES IN PATIENTS ARE STUDIES IN PATIENTS ARE EXPENSIVE EXPENSIVE AND AND TIME CONSUMING TIME CONSUMING KEY QUESTION: KEY QUESTION: MOLECULAR MARKERS MOLECULAR MARKERS OR OR IN VITRO ANALYSIS IN VITRO ANALYSIS GOOD SURROGATES GOOD SURROGATES TO PREDICT TO PREDICT CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE? CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE?
  • 36. MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS MOLECULAR MARKERS CAN ASSESS PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE PARASITE DRUG RESISTANCE DHFR DHFR TRIPLE MUTANT dhfr DOUBLE MUTANT dhps AND AND DHPS DHPS ALLELES ALLELES TANZANIA TANZANIA 2002-2004 2002-2004 CLINICAL FAILURE Mugittu et al 2004
  • 37. MOLECULAR MARKERS OF SP RESISTANCE MOLECULAR MARKERS OF SP RESISTANCE CORRLEATE WITH CLINICAL FAILURE CORRLEATE WITH CLINICAL FAILURE 1.0 Observed-14 Observed-28 Observed-42 0.8 Fit-14 CLINICAL FAILURE Fit-28 Fit-42 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 PREVALENCE OF "TRIPLE/DOUBLE"
  • 38. HOW CAN WE FIT THIS TOGETHER? HOW CAN WE FIT THIS TOGETHER? EARLY WARNINGS OF CLINICAL FAILURE 100% DATA FROM PREVALENCE OF RESISTANT P[ARASITES (%) 90% ALEXIS NZILA TRIPLE MUTANTS DHFR EDWARD MBERU KAMAU CAROL SIBLEY X ro 70% vit S NT in CE A 60% UT AN EM o ST 50% iv 50% 50% IPL v SI in RE TR E C PM % N A 30% 30% X ST SI E R 20% 20% X /S D 10% PM 10% 10% 90-93 93-95 95-97 97-99 00-02 UNTIL LATE 80s PM/SD INTRODUCED KILIFI, KENYA
  • 39. WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED? WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED? •• RESISTANCE ARISES RARELY, BUT RESISTANCE ARISES RARELY, BUT SPREADS RELATIVELY QUICKLY SPREADS RELATIVELY QUICKLY •• CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE IS THE LAST CLINICAL TREATMENT FAILURE IS THE LAST STEP IN A LONG SERIES OF CHANGES STEP IN A LONG SERIES OF CHANGES •• EARLY WARNING OF RESISTANCE EARLY WARNING OF RESISTANCE •• SLOWER TIME TO CLEAR PARASITES SLOWER TIME TO CLEAR PARASITES •• IN VITRO INCREASES IN IC50 VALUE IN VITRO INCREASES IN IC50 VALUE •• INCREASING PREVALENCE OF INCREASING PREVALENCE OF “RESISTANT” ALLELES “RESISTANT” ALLELES
  • 40. WHAT DATA ARE MISSING? WHAT DATA ARE MISSING? •• SURVEILLANCE SPOTTY SURVEILLANCE SPOTTY •• REPORTS LONG AFTER FACT REPORTS LONG AFTER FACT BUT THIS IS IMPROVING RAPIDLY
  • 41. 1986 VERY LONG VERY LONG LAG LAG BETWEEN BETWEEN SEEING SEEING 4-5 years RESISTANCE RESISTANCE 6-7 years AND AND 8 years CHANGING CHANGING DRUG DRUG POLICY POLICY Charmot et al 1991 NEED FAR BETTER COORDINATION AMONG GROUPS NEED FAR BETTER COORDINATION AMONG GROUPS INVOLVED IN RESISTANCE DETERMINATION INVOLVED IN RESISTANCE DETERMINATION
  • 42. WE HAVE ALWAYS PLAYED CATCH UP WE HAVE ALWAYS PLAYED CATCH UP FROM WHITE, 1999 AS DRUGS FAIL, WE CHRONICLE THE FAILURES
  • 43. WE NEED COORDINATED, OPEN ACCESS WE NEED COORDINATED, OPEN ACCESS DATABASE FROM ALL ENDEMIC AREAS DATABASE FROM ALL ENDEMIC AREAS NEEDS TO CONNECT WITH ROUTINE SURVEILLANCE
  • 44. WHAT MUST WE DO NOW? WHAT MUST WE DO NOW? •• CONSOLIDATE RECENT DATA ON “OLD” CONSOLIDATE RECENT DATA ON “OLD” DRUGS DRUGS •• CREATE AND MAINTAIN AN OPEN ACCESS CREATE AND MAINTAIN AN OPEN ACCESS DATABASE OF RESISTANCE DATA DATABASE OF RESISTANCE DATA WORLDWIDE WORLDWIDE •• WHERE DID RESISTANCE ARISE? WHERE DID RESISTANCE ARISE? •• OVER WHAT ROUTES DID SPREAD OCCUR? OVER WHAT ROUTES DID SPREAD OCCUR? •• HOW DO SURROGATE MARKERS RELATE TO HOW DO SURROGATE MARKERS RELATE TO CLINICAL OUTCOMES? CLINICAL OUTCOMES?
  • 45. THINGS USED TO BE SIMPLE… THINGS USED TO BE SIMPLE… CHLOROQUINE CHLOROQUINE SULFADOXINE/PYRIMETHAMINE SULFADOXINE/PYRIMETHAMINE QUININE QUININE MEFLOQUINE MEFLOQUINE MEFLOQUINE/ARTESUNATE MEFLOQUINE/ARTESUNATE
  • 46. RESISTANCE TO OLD DRUGS…. RESISTANCE TO OLD DRUGS…. CHANGE TO COMBINATION THERAPY CHANGE TO COMBINATION THERAPY 2003 2006
  • 47. 2006 ACT ADOPTIONS 2006 ACT ADOPTIONS Countries which need ACT policy Countries which adopted ACT
  • 48. MANY ACTs ARE IN USE OR IN TRIAL MANY ACTs ARE IN USE OR IN TRIAL •• ARTESUNATE-MEFLOQUINE ARTESUNATE-MEFLOQUINE •• ARTEMETHER-LUMEFANTRINE ARTEMETHER-LUMEFANTRINE •• ARTESUNATE-AMODIAQUINE ARTESUNATE-AMODIAQUINE •• DIHYDROARTEMISININ-PIPERAQUINE DIHYDROARTEMISININ-PIPERAQUINE •• CHLORPROGUANIL-DAPSONE-ARTESUNATE CHLORPROGUANIL-DAPSONE-ARTESUNATE •• ARTESUNATE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE ARTESUNATE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE AND….. AND….. •• CHLOROQUINE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE CHLOROQUINE- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE •• AMODIAQUINE -- SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE AMODIAQUINE SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE
  • 49. ACTs CURRENTLY EFFECTIVE, ACTs CURRENTLY EFFECTIVE, BUT…….. BUT…….. HOW CAN WE SUSTAIN HOW CAN WE SUSTAIN MAXIMUM MAXIMUM USEFUL THERAPEUTIC LIFE USEFUL THERAPEUTIC LIFE OF ACTs? OF ACTs? HOW CAN WE HOW CAN WE STAY AHEAD OF THE STAY AHEAD OF THE EVOLUTIONARY CURVE? EVOLUTIONARY CURVE?
  • 50. NETWORK MUST BE PROSPECTIVE NETWORK MUST BE PROSPECTIVE •• CURRENT TOOLS ARE ADEQUATE CURRENT TOOLS ARE ADEQUATE •• MANY WELL PLACED SENTINAL SITES MANY WELL PLACED SENTINAL SITES •• REAL TIME REPORTING MORE COMMON REAL TIME REPORTING MORE COMMON •• NEW INITIATIVES WITH COMPLEMENTARY NEW INITIATIVES WITH COMPLEMENTARY OBJECTIVES OBJECTIVES •• GLOBAL FUND REQUIREMENTS GLOBAL FUND REQUIREMENTS •• ACT CONSORTIUM ACT CONSORTIUM •• IPTp IPTp •• IPTi IPTi
  • 51. WORLD ANTIMALARIAL WORLD ANTIMALARIAL RESISTANCE NETWORK RESISTANCE NETWORK CLINICAL DRUG EFFICACY MOLECULAR PHARMACO- MARKERS LOGICAL OF ASSESSMENT RESISTANCE IN VITRO DRUG ASSESSMENT
  • 52. PHARMACOLOGICAL PHARMACOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF DRUGS ASSESSMENT OF DRUGS CLINICAL CLINICAL DRUG DRUG EFFICACY EFFICACY PHARMACO- LOGICAL WHY DID THE PATIENT WHY DID THE PATIENT ASSESSMENT FAIL TREATMENT? FAIL TREATMENT? WAS THE DRUG LEVEL WAS THE DRUG LEVEL ADEQUATE? ADEQUATE?
  • 53. CLINICAL FAILURE CLINICAL FAILURE WITH ADEQUATE DRUG WITH ADEQUATE DRUG PRESUMPTIVE PRESUMPTIVE RESISTANT PARASITES RESISTANT PARASITES IN VITRO ANALYSIS IN VITRO ANALYSIS
  • 54. PATIENT ISOLATES WITH INCREASED PATIENT ISOLATES WITH INCREASED DRUG RESISTANCE IN VITRO DRUG RESISTANCE IN VITRO CANDIDATES FOR INTENSIVE GENETIC CANDIDATES FOR INTENSIVE GENETIC ANALYSIS ANALYSIS IDENTIFICATION OF LOCI ASSOCIATED IDENTIFICATION OF LOCI ASSOCIATED WITH RESISTANCE TO EACH WITH RESISTANCE TO EACH PARTNER IN ACT PARTNER IN ACT
  • 55. HOW TO MOVE TO HOW TO MOVE TO EVIDENCE BASED DRUG USE EVIDENCE BASED DRUG USE WE’RE HERE WE NEED TO MOVE TO HERE Don deSavigny and Fred Binka Don deSavigny and Fred Binka
  • 56. DRUG RESISTANCE IN VIVO DRUG RESISTANCE IN VIVO