SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 30
Download to read offline
Smarter Urban Planning Match Land Use with Citizen Needs and Financial Constraints ICCSA-CTP 2011_International Conference Santander, Spain, June 20th.-23rd. Maria-Lluïsa Marsal-Llacuna, Professor  Architecture and Building Engineering Department Universitat de Girona [email_address] Ying Tat Leung  Guang-Jie Ren Almaden Services Research IBM Research [email_address]   [email_address] Sponsors:  IBM ES, IBM US
OPENING
Cities are  complex ecosystems;  they rely on multiple stakeholders and core systems to meet the needs of citizens and local businesses  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Federal/National State/Province Citizens  and  Businesses Core Systems Transportation, Public Safety, Water, Utilities, Healthcare, Education, Social Services, Culture, Economic Dev, Urban Planning, Environment, etc. County City Government Manage and Support Business Areas: Vision,  Policy, Planning, Budgeting,  Revenue Collection, Finance, HR,  Legal, IT,  Admin, Procurement, Facilities, etc. Fund & Administrate via agencies & programs Create and deliver front-line services Private/Non-profit organizations Participate in, influence and evaluate the core systems Fund, elect, influence and evaluate the government at all levels Direct or Indirect influence through policies and funding Client Challenge: How can we represent the city ecosystem in ways that encourage collaboration and help resolve challenges?
IBM Response:  Actionable Business Architecture for Smarter Cities  as an integrated approach to manage city’s transformation journey Component Business Model Actionable Business Architecture Operating Models City Ecosystem Transportation Water Social Services … Local Government ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Business of IT Finance Human Capital Payment …  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Process Models IT Models Solutions and Projects ,[object Object],[object Object],IBM Approach Overall Design
Urban Planning  is one of the domains we have chosen for deep dive in 2011 Direct Control Execute City Vision and Strategy City Performance Management City Governance Operations Public Safety Strategy Crime, Fire and Emergency Management Public Safety Operations City Transportation Strategy Transportation Service Management Transportation Infrastructure Operations Citizen Health Strategy Health Service Management Health Service Operations City Utilities Strategy Utilities Service Management Utilities Infrastructure Operations Eco-City Strategy Sustainability Programs Management Sustainability Programs Delivery Urban Planning Strategy Development  Permit Management Land and Buildings Operations City Economic Policies Economic Programs Management Economic Development Operations Social Services Strategy Social Programs Management Social Services Delivery Education and Culture Policies Education and Culture Programs Management Education and Culture Operations Government-wide Administration Strategy Administration Services Management Administration Services Delivery City Strategy & Governance Public Safety Transportation Citizen Health Energy & Water Environmental Sustainability Urban Planning & Building Management Economic Development Social Services Education, Culture & Recreation Municipal Administration
PROBLEMS IN URBAN PLANNING
Our cities are having problems due to an unsuccessful planning Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs   Problem  # 2 Urban planning activity is lacking the objectivity that is needed to balance public and private interests.   Problem  # 3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger
Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizens’ needs   [Capsule/Parenthesis]:  Countries’ Administrative Style, Legal Tradition, Power System and Jurisdictional Structure
Problem #1   Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs   How is urban planning done today?  Main instrument is the law,  Urban Planning Acts .  Master plans  are normative graphical representation and  Cities  are the living result of master plans Today’s  cities complexity  asks for a  better informed and more documented planning activity
Problem #1   Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs   Administrative Model  of countries explains countries'  Legal Tradition  election as  Power System  explains countries'  Jurisdictional Structure .  Two  Styles of Law  exist,  Romans  or  Traditional  (mainly Unitarian C) and  Anglo-Saxon  (mainly Federations) Spain is an example of Romans Style in Unitarian Country while the US is an exception.  UK is the obvious exception of Anglo-Saxon Style of Law attachment in an Unitarian Country Styles of Law main’s difference :  Law’s consideration Romans Style , Law is equivalent to a contract Anglo-Saxon model , contract is a consequence of the Law therefore it is possible to generate as many contracts as required by different situations, using the Law only as a starting point.
Problem #1   Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs   Urbanism out of both  models  is opposed:  Continental   (based in Romans Style of Law)  leaves not much space for uncertainty,  all urban parameters are ruled Anglo-Saxon  promotes it  (model born in 1960),  only  zoning areas’  constructability and land uses are ruled >>opposed role and Administration’s behavior:  writ of tutelage in the first model vs discretional and active role in the second  (initiating urban planning activity) Continental Master Plans’  are not much flexible tools,  without uncertainties . based on property rights , Master plans consolidate existing Land Uses ones and project new ones.   Master Plans draw all future projects with  absolute detail, main root cause of speculation  in countries attached to this model .    “ Plan-Law”:  relationship between  Master Plan, Urban Project  and  Building  is established according to the Law Master Plans out of the New Model , in line of “action plans”, they do not constitute rights or obligations  Land Use is a right of the State .  State and Local Governments will  discretionally take Urban decisions  according to the  strategic lines drafted by Master Plans .  Master Plans are a model for the future  but  not capacitated to legally impose urban planning parameters
Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs   Urban planning normative, in any style of Law, rules what is strictly a planning competence  from  zoning  land uses (Anglo-Saxon Style) to constructability parameters and public/private lands distribution (Romans Style) Under this frame of responsibilities it is not possible to state that plans are concerned about population needs and, cities –overall- must be a comfortable place to live where needs are covered.  Population data is only taken into account when forecasting city’s growth for the next 20 years  [Masteplans standard forecasting timeline]  No information about  culture, wealth distribution, age structure, towns and cities geographical isolation,  etc…only in urban planners’  subjective thinking.
Not knowing about citizens’ needs it would be really a sort of chance that only by applying Urban Planning Acts’ mandatory principles, the city -as it’s product- fulfills residents’ expectations.  After this, it is possible to affirm that  urban planning’s social target is not accomplished Urban Planning tools and processes must be more documented and informed by considering social, economical and geographical profiles. Problem #2 Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests.   [Capsule/Parenthesis]:  how urban development’s plan deployment is paid
Problem #2  Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests A fair balance of public and private interests  goes in the direction of  social target’s  accomplishment  Urban Planners are a sort of moderators in this big deal between private actors (developers) and the public party (local administration).   Private actors will try to get the maximum profit of their private lands by squeezing the law  (there are some margins; urban parameters are not fixed values).   Administration, although it could seem the opposite, will not squeeze the law to get the maximum of public lands  (also values within a range)
Problem #2  Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests Proportions between public and private lands are ruled by law   (some margins for adjustments exist)   For instance, Catalan Urban Planning Act (DL 1/2005)  55% public  in regards of new settlement’s total area, distributed as the following  (some margins for combination exist) *for each 100m2 constructed, 20 m2. will be for  public space , between  10 and 20% of the total *similar  for facilities , between  5% and 20% of the total *the remaining, around  25% will be for roads   55% public  are “cessions” or “surrenders”: lands given free of cost to the Municipality from the investor  as a counterpart to the city for it’s private profit. Cessions are given in the following status:   *Public Space  urbanized.    *Empty plots  for facilities .    *Roads fully  finished  (with all technical infrastructure ready: water pipes, sewers, electricity and telecommunications nets)  Thus to have the public realm completed, municipality will have to pay for facilities’ construction. roads facilities green housing retail parking offices industry [Capsule/Parenthesis]:   how urban  development’s plan  deployment is paid public private
Problem #2  Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests Although urban planning has the described mechanisms  to compensate citizens for the private profit that developer will obtain out of the new developed area,  here,   urban planner has the additional role of watchman to  ensure that public and private purposes do not prioritize the private direction  and  public lands out of these compensation mechanisms are the maximum possible.  Sometimes urban planners are the only ones in this game of public and private lands distribution that defend the public portion.
Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger Although the existence of planning standards, margins are too wide to guarantee enough lands stock for public purposes.  An objective tool to measure citizens’ public needs would help in this –today subjective- deal of public and private lands distribution. [Capsule/Parenthesis]:   infrastructure as a “container” of services and  the problem of the unmeet planning and programming:  INTEGRATE TO INNOVATE
Problem #3  In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger When Administration sees reduced its public budget a 30% (case of Catalonia) means that “open segment” had bigger cuts to keep the overall budgeted reduction. Public realm, as a part of this “open segment” will suffer these bigger reductions.
Problem #3  In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger 2.technical infrastructure (or “networks”):  roads/ general transport network  Transport networks and supply networks are used to share the same area to provide population’s: water, electricity,  telecommunications and transport network.  Public realm  (roads/transport network, public space and facilities)  can be “packaged” as it follows:  1.social (or “nodal”) infrastructure :  all kind of facilities and public space 9 categories/kinds of facilities:  education,  sports,  health,  social assistance,  culture,  commercial,  cult,  transportation stations,  administration and protection.   Public space, beside to be considered social infrastructure, plays multiple roles: city lungs, city density reduction, etc.
Problem #3  In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger In the public realm, what is in real danger is the facility  (and its services)  thus Municipality will only get for free plots that later will need to be constructed  (facility building)  and urbanized  (outdoor/ complimentary facility’s area).   Technical networks are not really in danger although budget reductions thus are paid by private parties at the moment to develop the plan. A weak budget can lead to unconstructed facilities’ plots for a long time. Alternative solutions to new buildings’ construction must be found.
Problem #3  In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger Recent investigations have demonstrated that there is no match: while towns have an expecting surplus of plots for facilities (in regards of the services provided to inhabitants); cities experience the opposite: Municipalities have to spend budget buying plots to allocate the necessary services in the corresponding facility.  There is a strong need of an integrated planning and programming of facilities and services   [Capsule/Parenthesis]:   infrastructure as a “container” of services and  the problem of the unmeet planning and programming:  INTEGRATE TO INNOVATE Infrastructures must be understood as services’ “container” and these services their “content”  Focusing on the  facility (“container”) , we have schools buildings, hospitals buildings, swimming pools, etc.; their correspondence to  services (“content”)  would be, education, health care and sports.  Amounts and types of services are programmed by responsible Ministries, Education, Health, and Sports, etc. according to their targets of service’s coverage.  It is nearly impossible that plots for facilities, obtained by applying mandatory urban planning parameters, match with services to be provided according to specific data of coverage.
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS
Toward a citizen-centric, systematic and analytical approach to urban planning, enabled by software tools for data collection and decision support Problem #1:  Cities, as urban planning product, they are not covering citizens’ needs   Urban Planning is not accomplishing it’s main social target due to the non consideration of citizens needs.  Urban Planning tools and processes must be more documented and more informed by considering social, economical and geographical profiles.  Problem #2: Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests.   Although the existence of planning standards margins are too wide to guarantee enough lands stock for public purposes.  An objective tool to measure citizens’ public needs would help in this –today subjective- deal of public and private lands distribution.   Problem # 3: In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger.   A weak budget can lead to unconstructed plots for facilities for a long time. Alternative solutions to the construction of new buildings must be found.  Solution/Target  #  1:  To know  population needs  by taking into account  citizen’s opinion (surveys)  and comparing these results with the  existing offer.   Existing offer allows to obtain  values per capita  that, later, on can be used as  primary indicators  for gaps and critical points of coverage.   Solution/Target  #  2:  To  synchronize   facilities planning  (legal values for surrenders contained in urban planning acts)  with services programming  (official targets of service designed by competent administrations)  and,  introducing –the same-  geographical, economical and social correction and modeling factors  to legal standards and official targets Solution/target  #  3:  To find  alternative ways to new facilities’ construction  that –mainly- go trough  consolidation of existing facilities’ stock  by adding  compatible services (“multiservice facilities”).  Minor solutions are: “stationary facilities” and “mobile facilities”. Multiservice, stationary and mobile facilities are cost saving comparing to same services in single and/or permanent facilities.
Solution/Target # 1:  To know  population needs  by taking into account  citizen’s opinion (surveys)  and comparing these results with the  existing offer.   Existing offer allows to obtain  values per capita  that, later, on can be used as  primary indicators  for gaps and critical points of coverage. [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING] 1. Service & facilities demand  (base perception): 1.1. Definition of a public service and facilities  general catalog  for health and social assistance categories. Skeleton for all data systematization  ..pilotriteris planifiacació_health services and facilities.xls 1.2. Elaboration of a  complete inventory/census   of the existing facilities  and their general and detailed services. Obtaining square meters per capita ..pilotxcels i cadsalutot_defin_inventari complert.xls 1.3 Comparison between cataloged and systematized  surveys /(sensors) and  square meters per capita  of  existing service offer . Finding gaps and critical points of coverage form users’ point of view.  IBM Next 5 in 5 -- 2010.flv Methodology
Solution/Target # 2:  To  synchronize   facilities planning  (legal values for surrenders contained in urban planning acts)  with services programming  (official targets of service designed by competent administrations)  and,  introducing –the same-  geographical, economical and social correction and modeling factors  to legal standards and official targets [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING] 2. Service & facilities needs  (base requirement): 2.1 Amount’s  calculation of facilities and services needed  for the next years (2020 horizon) according to official targets designed by competent administration  (Ministry of Health, Ministry of Social Wealth and Family; Catalan Government) ..pilotriteris planifiacació_health services and facilities.xls   2.2 To  recalculate  previous resulting amounts (2.1 results)  by applying official ‘correction factors’  proclaimed by the same competent administrations.  ..pilotndicadors.2.1 AP (RE, US)P_increments i reduccions.xls 3. To summarize current gaps with future needs Methodology
Solution/Target # 3:  To find  alternative ways to new facilities’ construction  that –mainly- go trough  consolidation of existing facilities’ stock  by adding  compatible services (“multiservice facilities”).  Minor solutions are: “stationary facilities” and “mobile facilities”. Multiservice, stationary and mobile facilities are cost saving comparing to same services in single and/or permanent facilities. [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING to FACILITIES PLANNING] 4. Services’ pair rules and  Services pairs (existing pairing rules and potential new rules) 4.1  Pairing rules  based on existing combinations and logical requirements.  4.2  Relationship matrix  to identify potential positive and negative synergies between health and social assistance general services  ..pilotxcels i cadsalutot_SA.xls 5. Planning  Facilities’ consolidations  and  new facilities proposal’s  according to paired services (existing pairing and potential new pairs) Pending! Methodology
Support Tooling for Proposed Solutions:  A Solution Framework for Decision Support Provided by Commercial Partner or Existing Open-Source Software Proprietary Open Source to Universities Other Analysis Performance Reporting Services Database Facilities  Database Map Database Map Access Layer Data Access Layer Analytics Access  Layer User Interface Multi-Purpose  Facility Analysis Other Analysis
Support Tooling for Proposed Solutions:  Key Features of the Software Architecture ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Business Model ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
THANK YOU

More Related Content

What's hot

Physical planning in town planning
Physical planning in town planningPhysical planning in town planning
Physical planning in town planningAbhi Vallabhaneni
 
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...Desy Rosnita Sari
 
Planning Techniques
Planning TechniquesPlanning Techniques
Planning TechniquesAvik Mandal
 
Planning orientation through reference studies
Planning orientation through reference studiesPlanning orientation through reference studies
Planning orientation through reference studiesMohammad Shoeb Jafri
 
Compact city
Compact cityCompact city
Compact cityCoEP
 
Urban planning concept,principles and elementes
Urban planning  concept,principles and elementes Urban planning  concept,principles and elementes
Urban planning concept,principles and elementes TeshagerMengesha
 
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNING
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNINGALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNING
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNINGBlaise Nkubiyaho
 
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & Architecture
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & ArchitectureDefinitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & Architecture
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & ArchitectureIbtehal Ammar
 
Case Study (Stockholm City)
Case Study (Stockholm City)Case Study (Stockholm City)
Case Study (Stockholm City)suzilawatie
 
Settlement planning process
Settlement planning processSettlement planning process
Settlement planning processYoung Kibaka
 
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...drboon
 
Elements of urban design
Elements of urban designElements of urban design
Elements of urban designNeo Angala
 

What's hot (20)

Physical planning in town planning
Physical planning in town planningPhysical planning in town planning
Physical planning in town planning
 
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...
The city of theory, planning in the face of conflict, contested cities social...
 
Planning Techniques
Planning TechniquesPlanning Techniques
Planning Techniques
 
Urban vocabulary 2011 (En)
Urban vocabulary 2011 (En)Urban vocabulary 2011 (En)
Urban vocabulary 2011 (En)
 
Planning orientation through reference studies
Planning orientation through reference studiesPlanning orientation through reference studies
Planning orientation through reference studies
 
Town planning
Town planningTown planning
Town planning
 
Planning Theory and Ideas
Planning Theory and IdeasPlanning Theory and Ideas
Planning Theory and Ideas
 
Compact city
Compact cityCompact city
Compact city
 
Urban planning concept,principles and elementes
Urban planning  concept,principles and elementes Urban planning  concept,principles and elementes
Urban planning concept,principles and elementes
 
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNING
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNINGALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNING
ALL YOU DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT URBAN PLANNING
 
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & Architecture
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & ArchitectureDefinitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & Architecture
Definitions of Urban Planning, Urban Design & Architecture
 
Cosmic, Machine And Organic Cities
Cosmic, Machine And Organic CitiesCosmic, Machine And Organic Cities
Cosmic, Machine And Organic Cities
 
Case Study (Stockholm City)
Case Study (Stockholm City)Case Study (Stockholm City)
Case Study (Stockholm City)
 
Urban Design Definition
Urban Design DefinitionUrban Design Definition
Urban Design Definition
 
Urban Policy
Urban PolicyUrban Policy
Urban Policy
 
Settlement planning process
Settlement planning processSettlement planning process
Settlement planning process
 
City forms
City formsCity forms
City forms
 
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...
An Urban Design Approach to a Sustainable Compact City in New Growth Potentia...
 
Theories of Urban Growth; Urban Forms
Theories of Urban Growth; Urban FormsTheories of Urban Growth; Urban Forms
Theories of Urban Growth; Urban Forms
 
Elements of urban design
Elements of urban designElements of urban design
Elements of urban design
 

Viewers also liked

Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...
Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...
Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...Global Airport Cities
 
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.emiliama
 
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)PublicFinanceTV
 
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIO
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIOסטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIO
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIOEfrat Holzer
 
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015Steve Richards
 
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)Loruel
 
Urban planning departments in Hyderabad
Urban planning departments in HyderabadUrban planning departments in Hyderabad
Urban planning departments in HyderabadInformage
 
The study of administration
The study of administrationThe study of administration
The study of administrationtaratoot
 
AICP Prep Course - Transportation Planning
AICP Prep Course - Transportation PlanningAICP Prep Course - Transportation Planning
AICP Prep Course - Transportation Planningguestd509af
 
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and History
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and HistoryIntroduction to Urban Transportation Planning and History
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and HistorySitesh Kumar Singh
 
Administration Vs. Management
Administration Vs. ManagementAdministration Vs. Management
Administration Vs. ManagementIrene Deona
 
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business Design
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business DesignWhat Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business Design
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business DesignThomas Vander Wal
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Urban planning
Urban planningUrban planning
Urban planning
 
Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...
Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...
Rafael Echevarne - Session 2 The Role of Airport Cities in Urban Renewal and ...
 
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.
From Lake to Airport Corridor. P2 Presentation.
 
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)
Bridging the Gap between Politics & Administration (John Nalbandian)
 
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIO
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIOסטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIO
סטודיו אורבני- URBAN STUDIO
 
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015
Aurecon_Aerotropolis - are airport cities the wave of the future_April 2015
 
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)
Comparative Local Politics and Administration (The Barangay)
 
Urban planning departments in Hyderabad
Urban planning departments in HyderabadUrban planning departments in Hyderabad
Urban planning departments in Hyderabad
 
EFRAT-HOLZER-BSV
EFRAT-HOLZER-BSVEFRAT-HOLZER-BSV
EFRAT-HOLZER-BSV
 
Power And Politics
Power And PoliticsPower And Politics
Power And Politics
 
Policy cycle
Policy cyclePolicy cycle
Policy cycle
 
"Professional Input in Enhancing Administrative Urban Planning Activities" by...
"Professional Input in Enhancing Administrative Urban Planning Activities" by..."Professional Input in Enhancing Administrative Urban Planning Activities" by...
"Professional Input in Enhancing Administrative Urban Planning Activities" by...
 
The study of administration
The study of administrationThe study of administration
The study of administration
 
AICP Prep Course - Transportation Planning
AICP Prep Course - Transportation PlanningAICP Prep Course - Transportation Planning
AICP Prep Course - Transportation Planning
 
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and History
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and HistoryIntroduction to Urban Transportation Planning and History
Introduction to Urban Transportation Planning and History
 
Administration Vs. Management
Administration Vs. ManagementAdministration Vs. Management
Administration Vs. Management
 
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business Design
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business DesignWhat Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business Design
What Urban Planning Can Teach Us About Social Business Design
 

Similar to Smarter Urban Planning: Match Land Use with Citizen Needs and Financial Constraints

Smart cities - Comparison among EU models
Smart cities - Comparison among EU modelsSmart cities - Comparison among EU models
Smart cities - Comparison among EU modelsMirko Podda
 
2 urban and spatial plannning and design
2 urban and spatial plannning and design2 urban and spatial plannning and design
2 urban and spatial plannning and designTatang Kurniawan
 
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdf
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdfcity_definition_what_is_a_city.pdf
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdfrhakimberly2021
 
The Governance of the Smart City
The Governance of the Smart CityThe Governance of the Smart City
The Governance of the Smart CitySmartCityExhibition
 
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel Aoun
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel AounThe Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel Aoun
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel AounSchneider Electric India
 
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate Change
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate ChangeMexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate Change
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate ChangeFagner Glinski
 
Smart City Mission
Smart City MissionSmart City Mission
Smart City MissionNaman Markan
 
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jcea
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jceaA dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jcea
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jceaFernanda Nascimento Corghi
 
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"KRITYANAND UNESCO CLUB Jamshedpur
 
Presentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptxPresentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptxMohdHaque7
 
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2Schneider Electric India
 
The role of ICT in the new urban agenda
The role of ICT in the new urban agendaThe role of ICT in the new urban agenda
The role of ICT in the new urban agendaEricsson
 
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...Lisa Thompson
 

Similar to Smarter Urban Planning: Match Land Use with Citizen Needs and Financial Constraints (20)

Smart cities - Comparison among EU models
Smart cities - Comparison among EU modelsSmart cities - Comparison among EU models
Smart cities - Comparison among EU models
 
2 urban and spatial plannning and design
2 urban and spatial plannning and design2 urban and spatial plannning and design
2 urban and spatial plannning and design
 
#SCE2014 Draft Programme_ENG
#SCE2014 Draft Programme_ENG#SCE2014 Draft Programme_ENG
#SCE2014 Draft Programme_ENG
 
Smart city report
Smart city reportSmart city report
Smart city report
 
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdf
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdfcity_definition_what_is_a_city.pdf
city_definition_what_is_a_city.pdf
 
The Governance of the Smart City
The Governance of the Smart CityThe Governance of the Smart City
The Governance of the Smart City
 
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel Aoun
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel AounThe Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel Aoun
The Smart City Cornerstone: Urban Efficiency by Charbel Aoun
 
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate Change
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate ChangeMexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate Change
Mexican Sustainable Urban and Mobility Strategy and Climate Change
 
Smart City Mission
Smart City MissionSmart City Mission
Smart City Mission
 
Input soliciting v2
Input soliciting v2Input soliciting v2
Input soliciting v2
 
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jcea
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jceaA dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jcea
A dynamic planner as a sustainable planning way _ jcea
 
TOWN PLANNING
TOWN PLANNINGTOWN PLANNING
TOWN PLANNING
 
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"
Role of technology in SMART governance “Smart City, Safe City"
 
Presentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptxPresentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptx
 
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency
Smart City - Cornerstone of EfficiencySmart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency
 
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2
Smart City - Cornerstone of Efficiency - V2
 
The role of ICT in the new urban agenda
The role of ICT in the new urban agendaThe role of ICT in the new urban agenda
The role of ICT in the new urban agenda
 
Smart city1
Smart city1Smart city1
Smart city1
 
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...
An Eco Friendly Architecture, H E C. E B At Muller And The...
 
smart city .pdf
smart city .pdfsmart city .pdf
smart city .pdf
 

More from Beniamino Murgante

Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable cities
Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable citiesAnalyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable cities
Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable citiesBeniamino Murgante
 
Smart Cities: New Science for the Cities
Smart Cities: New Science for the CitiesSmart Cities: New Science for the Cities
Smart Cities: New Science for the CitiesBeniamino Murgante
 
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processes
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processesThe evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processes
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processesBeniamino Murgante
 
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...Beniamino Murgante
 
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...Beniamino Murgante
 
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing Walkability
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing WalkabilityInvolving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing Walkability
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing WalkabilityBeniamino Murgante
 
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg Beniamino Murgante
 
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...Beniamino Murgante
 
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of trieste
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of triestePresentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of trieste
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of triesteBeniamino Murgante
 
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...Beniamino Murgante
 
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...Beniamino Murgante
 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector Beniamino Murgante
 
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...Beniamino Murgante
 
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...Beniamino Murgante
 
Planning and Smartness: the true challenge
Planning and Smartness: the true challengePlanning and Smartness: the true challenge
Planning and Smartness: the true challengeBeniamino Murgante
 
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...Beniamino Murgante
 
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness Beniamino Murgante
 
Tecnologie, Territorio, Smartness
Tecnologie, Territorio, SmartnessTecnologie, Territorio, Smartness
Tecnologie, Territorio, SmartnessBeniamino Murgante
 

More from Beniamino Murgante (20)

Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable cities
Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable citiesAnalyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable cities
Analyzing and assessing ecological transition in building sustainable cities
 
Smart Cities: New Science for the Cities
Smart Cities: New Science for the CitiesSmart Cities: New Science for the Cities
Smart Cities: New Science for the Cities
 
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processes
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processesThe evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processes
The evolution of spatial analysis and modeling in decision processes
 
Smart City or Urban Science?
Smart City or Urban Science?Smart City or Urban Science?
Smart City or Urban Science?
 
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...
Involving citizens in smart energy approaches: the experience of an energy pa...
 
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...
Programmazione per la governance territoriale in tema di tutela della biodive...
 
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing Walkability
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing WalkabilityInvolving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing Walkability
Involving Citizens in a Participation Process for Increasing Walkability
 
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg
Presentation of ICCSA 2019 at the University of Saint petersburg
 
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...
RISCHIO TERRITORIALE NEL GOVERNO DEL TERRITORIO: Ricerca e formazione nelle s...
 
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of trieste
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of triestePresentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of trieste
Presentation of ICCSA 2017 at the University of trieste
 
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
 
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...
Focussing Energy Consumers’ Behaviour Change towards Energy Efficiency and Lo...
 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector 
Socio-Economic Planning profiles: Sciences VS Daily activities in public sector 
 
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION – NEED TO KNOW (GI-N2K) Towards a more demand-driven g...
 
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...
Garden in motion. An experience of citizens involvement in public space regen...
 
Planning and Smartness: the true challenge
Planning and Smartness: the true challengePlanning and Smartness: the true challenge
Planning and Smartness: the true challenge
 
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...
GeoSDI: una piattaforma social di dati geografici basata sui principi di INSP...
 
Murgante smart energy
Murgante smart energyMurgante smart energy
Murgante smart energy
 
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness
Informazione Geografica, Città, Smartness
 
Tecnologie, Territorio, Smartness
Tecnologie, Territorio, SmartnessTecnologie, Territorio, Smartness
Tecnologie, Territorio, Smartness
 

Recently uploaded

COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a WebsiteCOMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Websitedgelyza
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfAijun Zhang
 
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAAnypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAshyamraj55
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarPrecisely
 
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...UbiTrack UK
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IES VE
 
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxCybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxGDSC PJATK
 
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptx
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptxIntroduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptx
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptxMatsuo Lab
 
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptx
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptxBuilding AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptx
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptxUdaiappa Ramachandran
 
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024D Cloud Solutions
 
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...DianaGray10
 
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCost
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCostKubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCost
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCostMatt Ray
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDELiveplex
 
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Brian Pichman
 
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.YounusS2
 
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfUiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfDianaGray10
 
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLDesigning A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLRuncy Oommen
 
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemBird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemAsko Soukka
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6DianaGray10
 

Recently uploaded (20)

COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a WebsiteCOMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
 
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAAnypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
 
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...
UWB Technology for Enhanced Indoor and Outdoor Positioning in Physiological M...
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
 
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxCybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
 
20230104 - machine vision
20230104 - machine vision20230104 - machine vision
20230104 - machine vision
 
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptx
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptxIntroduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptx
Introduction to Matsuo Laboratory (ENG).pptx
 
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptx
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptxBuilding AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptx
Building AI-Driven Apps Using Semantic Kernel.pptx
 
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
 
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
 
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCost
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCostKubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCost
KubeConEU24-Monitoring Kubernetes and Cloud Spend with OpenCost
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
 
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
 
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.
Basic Building Blocks of Internet of Things.
 
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfUiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
 
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLDesigning A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
 
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemBird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
 

Smarter Urban Planning: Match Land Use with Citizen Needs and Financial Constraints

  • 1. Smarter Urban Planning Match Land Use with Citizen Needs and Financial Constraints ICCSA-CTP 2011_International Conference Santander, Spain, June 20th.-23rd. Maria-Lluïsa Marsal-Llacuna, Professor Architecture and Building Engineering Department Universitat de Girona [email_address] Ying Tat Leung Guang-Jie Ren Almaden Services Research IBM Research [email_address] [email_address] Sponsors: IBM ES, IBM US
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. Urban Planning is one of the domains we have chosen for deep dive in 2011 Direct Control Execute City Vision and Strategy City Performance Management City Governance Operations Public Safety Strategy Crime, Fire and Emergency Management Public Safety Operations City Transportation Strategy Transportation Service Management Transportation Infrastructure Operations Citizen Health Strategy Health Service Management Health Service Operations City Utilities Strategy Utilities Service Management Utilities Infrastructure Operations Eco-City Strategy Sustainability Programs Management Sustainability Programs Delivery Urban Planning Strategy Development Permit Management Land and Buildings Operations City Economic Policies Economic Programs Management Economic Development Operations Social Services Strategy Social Programs Management Social Services Delivery Education and Culture Policies Education and Culture Programs Management Education and Culture Operations Government-wide Administration Strategy Administration Services Management Administration Services Delivery City Strategy & Governance Public Safety Transportation Citizen Health Energy & Water Environmental Sustainability Urban Planning & Building Management Economic Development Social Services Education, Culture & Recreation Municipal Administration
  • 6. PROBLEMS IN URBAN PLANNING
  • 7. Our cities are having problems due to an unsuccessful planning Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs Problem # 2 Urban planning activity is lacking the objectivity that is needed to balance public and private interests. Problem # 3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger
  • 8. Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizens’ needs [Capsule/Parenthesis]: Countries’ Administrative Style, Legal Tradition, Power System and Jurisdictional Structure
  • 9. Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs How is urban planning done today? Main instrument is the law, Urban Planning Acts . Master plans are normative graphical representation and Cities are the living result of master plans Today’s cities complexity asks for a better informed and more documented planning activity
  • 10. Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs Administrative Model of countries explains countries' Legal Tradition election as Power System explains countries' Jurisdictional Structure . Two Styles of Law exist, Romans or Traditional (mainly Unitarian C) and Anglo-Saxon (mainly Federations) Spain is an example of Romans Style in Unitarian Country while the US is an exception. UK is the obvious exception of Anglo-Saxon Style of Law attachment in an Unitarian Country Styles of Law main’s difference : Law’s consideration Romans Style , Law is equivalent to a contract Anglo-Saxon model , contract is a consequence of the Law therefore it is possible to generate as many contracts as required by different situations, using the Law only as a starting point.
  • 11. Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs Urbanism out of both models is opposed: Continental (based in Romans Style of Law) leaves not much space for uncertainty, all urban parameters are ruled Anglo-Saxon promotes it (model born in 1960), only zoning areas’ constructability and land uses are ruled >>opposed role and Administration’s behavior: writ of tutelage in the first model vs discretional and active role in the second (initiating urban planning activity) Continental Master Plans’ are not much flexible tools, without uncertainties . based on property rights , Master plans consolidate existing Land Uses ones and project new ones. Master Plans draw all future projects with absolute detail, main root cause of speculation in countries attached to this model . “ Plan-Law”: relationship between Master Plan, Urban Project and Building is established according to the Law Master Plans out of the New Model , in line of “action plans”, they do not constitute rights or obligations Land Use is a right of the State . State and Local Governments will discretionally take Urban decisions according to the strategic lines drafted by Master Plans . Master Plans are a model for the future but not capacitated to legally impose urban planning parameters
  • 12. Problem #1 Cities -as urban planning product- are not covering citizen needs Urban planning normative, in any style of Law, rules what is strictly a planning competence from zoning land uses (Anglo-Saxon Style) to constructability parameters and public/private lands distribution (Romans Style) Under this frame of responsibilities it is not possible to state that plans are concerned about population needs and, cities –overall- must be a comfortable place to live where needs are covered. Population data is only taken into account when forecasting city’s growth for the next 20 years [Masteplans standard forecasting timeline] No information about culture, wealth distribution, age structure, towns and cities geographical isolation, etc…only in urban planners’ subjective thinking.
  • 13. Not knowing about citizens’ needs it would be really a sort of chance that only by applying Urban Planning Acts’ mandatory principles, the city -as it’s product- fulfills residents’ expectations. After this, it is possible to affirm that urban planning’s social target is not accomplished Urban Planning tools and processes must be more documented and informed by considering social, economical and geographical profiles. Problem #2 Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests. [Capsule/Parenthesis]: how urban development’s plan deployment is paid
  • 14. Problem #2 Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests A fair balance of public and private interests goes in the direction of social target’s accomplishment Urban Planners are a sort of moderators in this big deal between private actors (developers) and the public party (local administration). Private actors will try to get the maximum profit of their private lands by squeezing the law (there are some margins; urban parameters are not fixed values). Administration, although it could seem the opposite, will not squeeze the law to get the maximum of public lands (also values within a range)
  • 15. Problem #2 Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests Proportions between public and private lands are ruled by law (some margins for adjustments exist) For instance, Catalan Urban Planning Act (DL 1/2005) 55% public in regards of new settlement’s total area, distributed as the following (some margins for combination exist) *for each 100m2 constructed, 20 m2. will be for public space , between 10 and 20% of the total *similar for facilities , between 5% and 20% of the total *the remaining, around 25% will be for roads 55% public are “cessions” or “surrenders”: lands given free of cost to the Municipality from the investor as a counterpart to the city for it’s private profit. Cessions are given in the following status: *Public Space urbanized. *Empty plots for facilities . *Roads fully finished (with all technical infrastructure ready: water pipes, sewers, electricity and telecommunications nets) Thus to have the public realm completed, municipality will have to pay for facilities’ construction. roads facilities green housing retail parking offices industry [Capsule/Parenthesis]: how urban development’s plan deployment is paid public private
  • 16. Problem #2 Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests Although urban planning has the described mechanisms to compensate citizens for the private profit that developer will obtain out of the new developed area, here, urban planner has the additional role of watchman to ensure that public and private purposes do not prioritize the private direction and public lands out of these compensation mechanisms are the maximum possible. Sometimes urban planners are the only ones in this game of public and private lands distribution that defend the public portion.
  • 17. Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger Although the existence of planning standards, margins are too wide to guarantee enough lands stock for public purposes. An objective tool to measure citizens’ public needs would help in this –today subjective- deal of public and private lands distribution. [Capsule/Parenthesis]: infrastructure as a “container” of services and the problem of the unmeet planning and programming: INTEGRATE TO INNOVATE
  • 18. Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger When Administration sees reduced its public budget a 30% (case of Catalonia) means that “open segment” had bigger cuts to keep the overall budgeted reduction. Public realm, as a part of this “open segment” will suffer these bigger reductions.
  • 19. Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger 2.technical infrastructure (or “networks”): roads/ general transport network Transport networks and supply networks are used to share the same area to provide population’s: water, electricity, telecommunications and transport network. Public realm (roads/transport network, public space and facilities) can be “packaged” as it follows: 1.social (or “nodal”) infrastructure : all kind of facilities and public space 9 categories/kinds of facilities: education, sports, health, social assistance, culture, commercial, cult, transportation stations, administration and protection. Public space, beside to be considered social infrastructure, plays multiple roles: city lungs, city density reduction, etc.
  • 20. Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger In the public realm, what is in real danger is the facility (and its services) thus Municipality will only get for free plots that later will need to be constructed (facility building) and urbanized (outdoor/ complimentary facility’s area). Technical networks are not really in danger although budget reductions thus are paid by private parties at the moment to develop the plan. A weak budget can lead to unconstructed facilities’ plots for a long time. Alternative solutions to new buildings’ construction must be found.
  • 21. Problem #3 In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger Recent investigations have demonstrated that there is no match: while towns have an expecting surplus of plots for facilities (in regards of the services provided to inhabitants); cities experience the opposite: Municipalities have to spend budget buying plots to allocate the necessary services in the corresponding facility. There is a strong need of an integrated planning and programming of facilities and services [Capsule/Parenthesis]: infrastructure as a “container” of services and the problem of the unmeet planning and programming: INTEGRATE TO INNOVATE Infrastructures must be understood as services’ “container” and these services their “content” Focusing on the facility (“container”) , we have schools buildings, hospitals buildings, swimming pools, etc.; their correspondence to services (“content”) would be, education, health care and sports. Amounts and types of services are programmed by responsible Ministries, Education, Health, and Sports, etc. according to their targets of service’s coverage. It is nearly impossible that plots for facilities, obtained by applying mandatory urban planning parameters, match with services to be provided according to specific data of coverage.
  • 23. Toward a citizen-centric, systematic and analytical approach to urban planning, enabled by software tools for data collection and decision support Problem #1: Cities, as urban planning product, they are not covering citizens’ needs Urban Planning is not accomplishing it’s main social target due to the non consideration of citizens needs. Urban Planning tools and processes must be more documented and more informed by considering social, economical and geographical profiles. Problem #2: Urban planning activity is lacking objectivity when balancing public and private interests. Although the existence of planning standards margins are too wide to guarantee enough lands stock for public purposes. An objective tool to measure citizens’ public needs would help in this –today subjective- deal of public and private lands distribution. Problem # 3: In moments of economic crisis, cities’ public realm is in danger. A weak budget can lead to unconstructed plots for facilities for a long time. Alternative solutions to the construction of new buildings must be found. Solution/Target # 1: To know population needs by taking into account citizen’s opinion (surveys) and comparing these results with the existing offer. Existing offer allows to obtain values per capita that, later, on can be used as primary indicators for gaps and critical points of coverage. Solution/Target # 2: To synchronize facilities planning (legal values for surrenders contained in urban planning acts) with services programming (official targets of service designed by competent administrations) and, introducing –the same- geographical, economical and social correction and modeling factors to legal standards and official targets Solution/target # 3: To find alternative ways to new facilities’ construction that –mainly- go trough consolidation of existing facilities’ stock by adding compatible services (“multiservice facilities”). Minor solutions are: “stationary facilities” and “mobile facilities”. Multiservice, stationary and mobile facilities are cost saving comparing to same services in single and/or permanent facilities.
  • 24. Solution/Target # 1: To know population needs by taking into account citizen’s opinion (surveys) and comparing these results with the existing offer. Existing offer allows to obtain values per capita that, later, on can be used as primary indicators for gaps and critical points of coverage. [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING] 1. Service & facilities demand (base perception): 1.1. Definition of a public service and facilities general catalog for health and social assistance categories. Skeleton for all data systematization ..pilotriteris planifiacació_health services and facilities.xls 1.2. Elaboration of a complete inventory/census of the existing facilities and their general and detailed services. Obtaining square meters per capita ..pilotxcels i cadsalutot_defin_inventari complert.xls 1.3 Comparison between cataloged and systematized surveys /(sensors) and square meters per capita of existing service offer . Finding gaps and critical points of coverage form users’ point of view. IBM Next 5 in 5 -- 2010.flv Methodology
  • 25. Solution/Target # 2: To synchronize facilities planning (legal values for surrenders contained in urban planning acts) with services programming (official targets of service designed by competent administrations) and, introducing –the same- geographical, economical and social correction and modeling factors to legal standards and official targets [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING] 2. Service & facilities needs (base requirement): 2.1 Amount’s calculation of facilities and services needed for the next years (2020 horizon) according to official targets designed by competent administration (Ministry of Health, Ministry of Social Wealth and Family; Catalan Government) ..pilotriteris planifiacació_health services and facilities.xls 2.2 To recalculate previous resulting amounts (2.1 results) by applying official ‘correction factors’ proclaimed by the same competent administrations. ..pilotndicadors.2.1 AP (RE, US)P_increments i reduccions.xls 3. To summarize current gaps with future needs Methodology
  • 26. Solution/Target # 3: To find alternative ways to new facilities’ construction that –mainly- go trough consolidation of existing facilities’ stock by adding compatible services (“multiservice facilities”). Minor solutions are: “stationary facilities” and “mobile facilities”. Multiservice, stationary and mobile facilities are cost saving comparing to same services in single and/or permanent facilities. [from SERVICES PROGRAMMING to FACILITIES PLANNING] 4. Services’ pair rules and Services pairs (existing pairing rules and potential new rules) 4.1 Pairing rules based on existing combinations and logical requirements. 4.2 Relationship matrix to identify potential positive and negative synergies between health and social assistance general services ..pilotxcels i cadsalutot_SA.xls 5. Planning Facilities’ consolidations and new facilities proposal’s according to paired services (existing pairing and potential new pairs) Pending! Methodology
  • 27. Support Tooling for Proposed Solutions: A Solution Framework for Decision Support Provided by Commercial Partner or Existing Open-Source Software Proprietary Open Source to Universities Other Analysis Performance Reporting Services Database Facilities Database Map Database Map Access Layer Data Access Layer Analytics Access Layer User Interface Multi-Purpose Facility Analysis Other Analysis
  • 28.
  • 29.

Editor's Notes

  1. Urban planning tools we are using today are the same as 30 years before (law and masterplan) and wiht the same srtucutre and contnent but ciites’ are –by far- more complex
  2. How is the law is both styles
  3. How are the masterplans
  4. In romans style Law is more detailed and precise, and consequently masterplans out of this style of law. We could think that romans style planning is more informed and documented due To it’s detailed nature. It is not like this, in both cases it is only ruled planning competences. The complexity of the city is not represented.
  5. Danger is that public and private stratgey can go in the private’s direction.
  6. To have public realm completed municipality will have to pay for faciliities’ construction
  7. Because public lands mean costs to administration (maintenance for public space and roads+ facilities construction) administration can be not really intrested in recieving big amounts of public lands
  8. Public realm as a part of open segment will really suffer this cuts
  9. A large number of kinds of facilities are in daner
  10. To integrate faciliites and services it is more effcient and also a cost saving measure