SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Interdisciplinary Performance Project DA6004<br />REVIEW – 20%  <br />Write a 1000 word essay in which you will review your own interdisciplinary performance project and one other project which has been presented as a result of this module. Both reviews should be written in a journalistic style as close to professional standard as possible. For the entire course of this module you are advised to follow professional performance reviews in current newspapers (e.g. The Guardian) in order to study and understand critical journalistic writing.<br />You can write your review in two parts – one review for your own project and one review for somebody else’s project. <br />OR<br />You can write your review in one part in which you compare both projects in one piece of writing.<br />Structure:<br />Structure your review like a normal essay with three sections:<br />1/ Introduction - Say who was performing, where, introduce to reader basic premise of piece, title, name of director/choreographer, collaborator, art forms used etc.<br />2/ Idea/Concept – Comment on the general idea of or behind the project and place it within a wider artistic landscape, have you seen something like this before, is it “en vogue” at the moment etc. How does “dance” fit with “the other” artform(s), do both art forms complement each other, if so how and why or if not, why has it been unsuccessful, did seeing the piece meet your expectations (according to its title or publicity visuals) etc.<br />3/ Performers & Performance - Comment on how the performers handle the production, are they confident, capable, are they suited for the piece, is it too hard or easy for the performers, i.e. do they look bad because the choreography or the concept isn't very good, etc. Comment on the design/composition/choreography of the project.<br />4/ The overall production - Comment on anything that is worthy of note, e.g. staging, venue, props, lighting, sound, music, costume, either because it is crucial to the concept or because it enhances the production, saves it, or lets it down. <br />5/ Conclusion - Comment on the overall look (your overall impressions), whether the production works despite faults or fails. Try and end on something punchy, like a play on the name of the production etc. Mention whether people should consider seeing the work.<br />Style:<br />Find one or two positive or interesting things to say about each work.<br />You can choose to focus on one or two elements of the production (e.g. costumes) that you feel confident to talk about because of your own expertise.<br />Acknowledge your own relevant experiences (as a maker or a recipient of art) in the review.<br />Avoid repetition of words or expressions; when you've already used 'work' and 'piece' 6 times each…<br />Objective: describe what was performed in accurate detail and render a judgment based on generally agreed upon standards.<br />Subjective: accurately describe what you see, but you are also expected to invest the review with your unique perspective.<br />You can be critical and even harsh when it is merited, but bear in mind it may be that you have simply missed the point through insufficient knowledge.<br />Keep in mind who you are writing for: How could your review help your audience or the producer of the reviewed piece become more capable?<br />Be your own sub-editor. Remember that, unless you arrange it, you won't have the benefit of another pair of eyes looking over your work. If time permits, put the piece to one side and reread it after a break.<br />Starter Kit:<br />Imagine that you are writing an email to a friend about the experience. It can be useful to jot down some key thoughts and then form them into an outline structure, before you write the piece in full.<br />Describe what you saw and give your reactions to the piece. This will usually involve talking about the style of the piece, your thoughts about the choreography, what the key performers bring to the work and the quality of the work. Most important is to convey why you enjoyed various aspects of the piece or visa-versa. Where appropriate, a discussion of the sets, lighting and costumes can help to give an impression of the look of the work. It can be useful to put the performance in context by writing about recent work by the choreographer or the director (the programme notes can be very useful for this sort of information) or why you decided that you would go to see the work.<br />Watch out for these dance critics and read/analyse/learn from their work:<br />Debra Craine of The Times<br />Jenny Gilbert of The Independent<br />Luke Jennings of The Observer<br />Judith Mackrell of The Guardian<br />
Review Guidelines

More Related Content

What's hot

Music vid part four rep
Music vid part four repMusic vid part four rep
Music vid part four rep
sssfcmedia
 
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
aquinasmedia
 
A2 evaluation
A2 evaluationA2 evaluation
A2 evaluation
sparkly
 
Planning an A2 Media Studies answer
Planning an A2 Media Studies answerPlanning an A2 Media Studies answer
Planning an A2 Media Studies answer
Andy Wallis
 
Introduction to the evaluation
Introduction to the evaluationIntroduction to the evaluation
Introduction to the evaluation
jphibbert1979
 
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidance
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidanceYear 11 coursework evaluation guidance
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidance
Belinda Raji
 
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
nfgsmedia
 
Film poster analysis homework
Film poster analysis homeworkFilm poster analysis homework
Film poster analysis homework
ddoggart
 
1b Representation suggested essay plan
1b Representation suggested essay plan1b Representation suggested essay plan
1b Representation suggested essay plan
aquinasmedia
 
As Media Coursework 1
As Media Coursework 1As Media Coursework 1
As Media Coursework 1
Neill Ford
 
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATEDOCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
Mr Smith
 
Ocr advice nov 13 version2
Ocr advice nov 13 version2Ocr advice nov 13 version2
Ocr advice nov 13 version2
chrisianwelch
 

What's hot (19)

Music vid part four rep
Music vid part four repMusic vid part four rep
Music vid part four rep
 
G321 foundation media portfolio
G321 foundation media portfolioG321 foundation media portfolio
G321 foundation media portfolio
 
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
1b. Media Languages essay plan and theory
 
A2 evaluation
A2 evaluationA2 evaluation
A2 evaluation
 
Planning an A2 Media Studies answer
Planning an A2 Media Studies answerPlanning an A2 Media Studies answer
Planning an A2 Media Studies answer
 
Research and planning_self_evaluation
Research and planning_self_evaluationResearch and planning_self_evaluation
Research and planning_self_evaluation
 
Introduction to the evaluation
Introduction to the evaluationIntroduction to the evaluation
Introduction to the evaluation
 
Recipe for a good blog
Recipe for a good blogRecipe for a good blog
Recipe for a good blog
 
Music video production 1
Music video production 1Music video production 1
Music video production 1
 
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidance
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidanceYear 11 coursework evaluation guidance
Year 11 coursework evaluation guidance
 
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
Theoretical eval prod 1a essay writing 2013
 
Film poster analysis homework
Film poster analysis homeworkFilm poster analysis homework
Film poster analysis homework
 
1b Representation suggested essay plan
1b Representation suggested essay plan1b Representation suggested essay plan
1b Representation suggested essay plan
 
As Media Coursework 1
As Media Coursework 1As Media Coursework 1
As Media Coursework 1
 
A2 Media - Music Video Preproduction checklist
A2 Media - Music Video Preproduction checklistA2 Media - Music Video Preproduction checklist
A2 Media - Music Video Preproduction checklist
 
Presenting like a leader, by: Pierre El-Hnoud
Presenting like a leader, by: Pierre El-HnoudPresenting like a leader, by: Pierre El-Hnoud
Presenting like a leader, by: Pierre El-Hnoud
 
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATEDOCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
OCR A2 Media studies Exam Questions 1a and 1b tips UPDATED
 
Ocr advice nov 13 version2
Ocr advice nov 13 version2Ocr advice nov 13 version2
Ocr advice nov 13 version2
 
Fmp pre proposal
Fmp pre proposalFmp pre proposal
Fmp pre proposal
 

Similar to Review Guidelines

A2 evaluation
A2 evaluationA2 evaluation
A2 evaluation
sparkly
 
Essay #2 Visual Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
Essay #2 Visual  Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docxEssay #2 Visual  Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
Essay #2 Visual Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
jenkinsmandie
 
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docxResearch Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
audeleypearl
 
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshopArtist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
DeborahJ
 
Q1a guide db2011
Q1a guide db2011Q1a guide db2011
Q1a guide db2011
DB3igs
 
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docxBUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
RAHUL126667
 
Prezi and evaluation
Prezi and evaluationPrezi and evaluation
Prezi and evaluation
cigdemkalem
 

Similar to Review Guidelines (20)

Unit 2 drama in the making
Unit 2 drama in the makingUnit 2 drama in the making
Unit 2 drama in the making
 
A2 evaluation
A2 evaluationA2 evaluation
A2 evaluation
 
Final cs2 m3 13.3.13
Final cs2 m3 13.3.13Final cs2 m3 13.3.13
Final cs2 m3 13.3.13
 
Proposal (Improved)
Proposal (Improved)Proposal (Improved)
Proposal (Improved)
 
Design statement
Design statementDesign statement
Design statement
 
Essay #2 Visual Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
Essay #2 Visual  Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docxEssay #2 Visual  Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
Essay #2 Visual Textual Analysis For this essay, you will ana.docx
 
Portfolio Reviews Overview Students
Portfolio Reviews Overview StudentsPortfolio Reviews Overview Students
Portfolio Reviews Overview Students
 
Final Major Project
Final Major ProjectFinal Major Project
Final Major Project
 
How to write a theater report
How to write a theater reportHow to write a theater report
How to write a theater report
 
OCR Revision 1a &amp; 1 b
OCR Revision  1a &amp; 1 bOCR Revision  1a &amp; 1 b
OCR Revision 1a &amp; 1 b
 
Advanced media portfolio guidance task sheets and criteria
Advanced media portfolio   guidance task sheets and criteria Advanced media portfolio   guidance task sheets and criteria
Advanced media portfolio guidance task sheets and criteria
 
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docxResearch Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
Research Proposal Assignment Research Proposals exist for tw.docx
 
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshopArtist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
Artist' Statement: writing about your work workshop
 
AS UK cwk checklist
AS UK cwk checklistAS UK cwk checklist
AS UK cwk checklist
 
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guideAs coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
 
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guideAs coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
As coursework assessment criteria a plain english guide
 
Q1a guide db2011
Q1a guide db2011Q1a guide db2011
Q1a guide db2011
 
Webquest Template0[1]
Webquest Template0[1]Webquest Template0[1]
Webquest Template0[1]
 
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docxBUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
BUS 103 – Sample Web Site Instructor Sita Motipara .docx
 
Prezi and evaluation
Prezi and evaluationPrezi and evaluation
Prezi and evaluation
 

More from Davy and Kristin McGuire (20)

Narrative vs. Formal
Narrative vs. FormalNarrative vs. Formal
Narrative vs. Formal
 
Narrative vs. Formal
Narrative vs. FormalNarrative vs. Formal
Narrative vs. Formal
 
The Essentials of my Discipline
The Essentials of my DisciplineThe Essentials of my Discipline
The Essentials of my Discipline
 
Essay guidelines
Essay guidelinesEssay guidelines
Essay guidelines
 
Relationships
RelationshipsRelationships
Relationships
 
Stand & Stare Presentation
Stand & Stare PresentationStand & Stare Presentation
Stand & Stare Presentation
 
3rd sequence questionnaire
3rd sequence questionnaire3rd sequence questionnaire
3rd sequence questionnaire
 
Nick Kaye Performing the City
Nick Kaye   Performing the CityNick Kaye   Performing the City
Nick Kaye Performing the City
 
2nd sequence
2nd sequence 2nd sequence
2nd sequence
 
Music Video Art
Music Video ArtMusic Video Art
Music Video Art
 
Architecture
ArchitectureArchitecture
Architecture
 
Parkour
Parkour Parkour
Parkour
 
The gesamtkunstwerk
The gesamtkunstwerkThe gesamtkunstwerk
The gesamtkunstwerk
 
Production schedule for your music video..docx
Production schedule for your music video..docxProduction schedule for your music video..docx
Production schedule for your music video..docx
 
Beat-sheet
Beat-sheetBeat-sheet
Beat-sheet
 
Personality
PersonalityPersonality
Personality
 
Guidelines for the Creation of Stories in Performance
Guidelines for the Creation of Stories in PerformanceGuidelines for the Creation of Stories in Performance
Guidelines for the Creation of Stories in Performance
 
Dance-Music-Relationships
Dance-Music-RelationshipsDance-Music-Relationships
Dance-Music-Relationships
 
Your character’s autobiography
Your character’s autobiographyYour character’s autobiography
Your character’s autobiography
 
Instructions for Video-walk
Instructions for Video-walkInstructions for Video-walk
Instructions for Video-walk
 

Review Guidelines

  • 1. Interdisciplinary Performance Project DA6004<br />REVIEW – 20% <br />Write a 1000 word essay in which you will review your own interdisciplinary performance project and one other project which has been presented as a result of this module. Both reviews should be written in a journalistic style as close to professional standard as possible. For the entire course of this module you are advised to follow professional performance reviews in current newspapers (e.g. The Guardian) in order to study and understand critical journalistic writing.<br />You can write your review in two parts – one review for your own project and one review for somebody else’s project. <br />OR<br />You can write your review in one part in which you compare both projects in one piece of writing.<br />Structure:<br />Structure your review like a normal essay with three sections:<br />1/ Introduction - Say who was performing, where, introduce to reader basic premise of piece, title, name of director/choreographer, collaborator, art forms used etc.<br />2/ Idea/Concept – Comment on the general idea of or behind the project and place it within a wider artistic landscape, have you seen something like this before, is it “en vogue” at the moment etc. How does “dance” fit with “the other” artform(s), do both art forms complement each other, if so how and why or if not, why has it been unsuccessful, did seeing the piece meet your expectations (according to its title or publicity visuals) etc.<br />3/ Performers & Performance - Comment on how the performers handle the production, are they confident, capable, are they suited for the piece, is it too hard or easy for the performers, i.e. do they look bad because the choreography or the concept isn't very good, etc. Comment on the design/composition/choreography of the project.<br />4/ The overall production - Comment on anything that is worthy of note, e.g. staging, venue, props, lighting, sound, music, costume, either because it is crucial to the concept or because it enhances the production, saves it, or lets it down. <br />5/ Conclusion - Comment on the overall look (your overall impressions), whether the production works despite faults or fails. Try and end on something punchy, like a play on the name of the production etc. Mention whether people should consider seeing the work.<br />Style:<br />Find one or two positive or interesting things to say about each work.<br />You can choose to focus on one or two elements of the production (e.g. costumes) that you feel confident to talk about because of your own expertise.<br />Acknowledge your own relevant experiences (as a maker or a recipient of art) in the review.<br />Avoid repetition of words or expressions; when you've already used 'work' and 'piece' 6 times each…<br />Objective: describe what was performed in accurate detail and render a judgment based on generally agreed upon standards.<br />Subjective: accurately describe what you see, but you are also expected to invest the review with your unique perspective.<br />You can be critical and even harsh when it is merited, but bear in mind it may be that you have simply missed the point through insufficient knowledge.<br />Keep in mind who you are writing for: How could your review help your audience or the producer of the reviewed piece become more capable?<br />Be your own sub-editor. Remember that, unless you arrange it, you won't have the benefit of another pair of eyes looking over your work. If time permits, put the piece to one side and reread it after a break.<br />Starter Kit:<br />Imagine that you are writing an email to a friend about the experience. It can be useful to jot down some key thoughts and then form them into an outline structure, before you write the piece in full.<br />Describe what you saw and give your reactions to the piece. This will usually involve talking about the style of the piece, your thoughts about the choreography, what the key performers bring to the work and the quality of the work. Most important is to convey why you enjoyed various aspects of the piece or visa-versa. Where appropriate, a discussion of the sets, lighting and costumes can help to give an impression of the look of the work. It can be useful to put the performance in context by writing about recent work by the choreographer or the director (the programme notes can be very useful for this sort of information) or why you decided that you would go to see the work.<br />Watch out for these dance critics and read/analyse/learn from their work:<br />Debra Craine of The Times<br />Jenny Gilbert of The Independent<br />Luke Jennings of The Observer<br />Judith Mackrell of The Guardian<br />