3 Things to Learn About:
 -How Kudu is able to fill the analytic gap between HDFS and Apache HBase -The trade-offs between real-time transactional access and fast analytic performance -How Kudu provides an option to achieve fast scans and random access from a single API

1. 1© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Apache Kudu Webinar Series
Technical Deep Dive
David Alves| Apache Kudu PMC | Cloudera

2. 2© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu Webinar Series
Part 1: Lambda Architectures – Simplified by Apache Kudu
A look into the potential trouble involved with a lambda architecture, and how Apache Kudu can
dramatically simplify real-time analytics.
Part 2: Extending the Capabilities of Operational and Analytical Databases
An examination of how Apache Kudu expands the set of use cases that Cloudera’s Operational and
Analytical databases can handle.
Part 3: Data-in-Motion: Unlock the Value of Real-Time Data
Forrester will discuss their research into real-time data pipelines and analytics, and Cloudera will
discuss how to make it a reality.
Part 4: Technical Deep-Dive into Apache Kudu
An in-depth examination of the technical architecture and design of Apache Kudu, straight from a Kudu
PMC Member.

3. 3© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Updateable Analytic Storage
Simple real-time analytics and updates with Apache Kudu
Kudu: Storage for fast analytics on fast data
• Simplified architecture for building real-time analytic
applications
• Designed for next-generation hardware for faster analytic
performance across frameworks
• Native Hadoop storage engine
Flexibility for the right tools for the right use
case in one platform
• Only analytic database for big data with Kudu + Impala
• Simple real-time applications with Kudu + Spark
Use cases
• Time series data
• Machine data analytics
• Online reporting
STRUCTURED
Sqoop
UNSTRUCTURED
Kafka, Flume
PROCESS, ANALYZE, SERVE
UNIFIED SERVICES
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
YARN
SECURITY
Sentry, RecordService
STORE
INTEGRATE
BATCH
Spark, Hive, Pig
MapReduce
STREAM
Spark
SQL
Impala
SEARCH
Solr
OTHER
Kite
NoSQL
HBase
OTHER
Object Store
FILESYSTEM
HDFS
RELATIONAL
Kudu

4. 4© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
HDFS
Fast Scans, Analytics
and Processing of
Stored Data
Fast On-Line
Updates &
Data Serving
Arbitrary Storage
(Active Archive)
Fast Analytics
(on fast-changing or
frequently-updated data)
Filling the Analytic Gap
Unchanging
Fast Changing
Frequent Updates
HBase
Append-Only
Real-Time
Kudu Kudu fills the Gap
Modern analytic
applications often
require complex data
flow & difficult
integration work to
move data between
HBase & HDFS
Analytic
Gap
Pace of Analysis
PaceofData

5. 5© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Better Together
Kudu Benefits from Integration with the Apache Ecosystem
Spark – Stream Processing for Kudu
• Open standard for real-time stream processing
• Effective for automating decision processes and machine
learning
• Use Cases include: Time Series Data & Machine Data
Analytics
Impala – High-Performance BI & SQL for Kudu
• Open standard for interactive SQL queries
• Powers analytic database workloads with flexibility, scale, and
open architecture
• Use Cases include: Time Series Data & Online Reporting

6. 6© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Apache Kudu Community

7. 7© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Kudu?
Use Cases and Motivation

8. 8© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Kudu?
A simultaneous combination of sequential and random reads and writes
Can you insert time series data in
real time? How long does it take to
prepare it for analysis? Can you get
results and act fast enough to
change outcomes?
Can you handle large volumes of
machine-generated data? Do you
have the tools to identify problems
or threats? Can your system do
machine learning?
How fast can you add data to your
data store? Are you trading off the
ability to do broad analytics for the
ability to make updates? Are you
retaining only part of your data?
Time Series Data Machine Data Analytics Online Reporting

9. 9© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Next generation hardware
Cheaper and faster every year.
Persistent memory (3D XPoint™)
Kudu can take advantage of SSD
and NVM using Intel’s NVM Library.
RAM is cheaper and bigger every
day.
Kudu runs smoothly with huge
RAM. Written in C++ to avoid GC
issues.
Modern CPUs are adding cores and
SIMD width, not GHz.
Kudu takes advantage of SIMD
instructions and concurrent data
structures.
Solid-state Storage Cheaper, Bigger Memory Efficiency on Modern CPUs

10. 10© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Apache Kudu: Scalable and fast tabular storage
Scalable
• Tested up to 275 nodes (~3PB cluster)
• Designed to scale to 1000s of nodes and tens of PBs
Fast
• Millions of read/write operations per second across cluster
• Multiple GB/second read throughput per node
Tabular
• Represents data in structured tables like a relational database
• Individual record-level access to 100+ billion row tables

11. 11© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Deep Dive:
Replication And Fault Tolerance

12. 12© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Metadata
• Replicated master
• Acts as a tablet directory
• Acts as a catalog (which tables exist, etc)
• Acts as a load balancer (tracks TS liveness, re-replicates under-replicated
tablets)
• Caches all metadata in RAM for high performance
• Client configured with master addresses
• Asks master for tablet locations as needed and caches them

13. 13© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Client
Hey Master! Where is the row for
‘tlipcon’ in table “T”?
It’s part of tablet 2, which is on servers {Z,Y,X}.
BTW, here’s info on other tablets you might
care about: T1, T2, T3, …
UPDATE tlipcon
SET col=foo
Meta Cache
T1: …
T2: …
T3: …

14. 14© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Raft consensus
TS A
Tablet 1
(LEADER)
Client
TS B
Tablet 1
(FOLLOWER)
TS C
Tablet 1
(FOLLOWER)
WAL
WALWAL
2b. Leader writes local WAL
1a. Client->Leader: Write() RPC
2a. Leader->Followers:
UpdateConsensus() RPC
3. Follower: write WAL
4. Follower->Leader: success
3. Follower: write WAL
5. Leader has achieved majority
6. Leader->Client: Success!

15. 15© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Fault tolerance
• Transient FOLLOWER failure:
• Leader can still achieve majority
• Restart follower TS within 5 min and it will rejoin transparently
• Transient LEADER failure:
• Followers expect to hear a heartbeat from their leader every 1.5 seconds
• 3 missed heartbeats: leader election!
• New LEADER is elected from remaining nodes within a few seconds
• Restart within 5 min and it rejoins as a FOLLOWER
• N replicas handle (N-1)/2 failures

16. 16© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Fault tolerance (2)
• Permanent failure (Tablet Copy):
• Leader notices that a follower has been dead for 5 minutes
• Evicts that follower
• Master selects a new replica(in PRE_VOTER state)
• Leader copies the data over to the new one, which joins as a new FOLLOWER
• New replica is assigned VOTER state
• Cluster change_config lets you add/remove tablet servers to a tablet’s
configuration(only supported from CLI tool)

17. 17© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Deep Dive:
Columnar Storage

18. 18© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Columnar Storage
• Improved Scan performance
• Predicates (e.g. WHERE time >= 2016-05-08T00:00:00) can be evaluated without reading
unnecessary data from other columns
• Efficient encodings can dramatically improve compression ratios, which reduces effective IO load
• Typed, homogenous data plays well to modern processor strengths (vectorization, pipelining)
• At the cost of random access performance
• single row access requires a number of seeks proportional to the number of columns
• BUT, random access is becoming cheaper (Cheap RAM, SSDs, NVRAM)

19. 19© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Row Storage
{23059873, newsycbot, 1442865158, Visual exp…}
{22309487, RideImpala, 1442828307, Introducing …}
…
Tweet_id, user_name, created_at, text
Scans have to read all the data, no encodings

20. 20© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Columnar storage
{25059873,
22309487,
23059861,
23010982}
Tweet_id
{newsycbot,
RideImpala,
fastly,
llvmorg}
User_name
{1442865158,
1442828307,
1442865156,
1442865155}
Created_at
{Visual exp…,
Introducing ..,
Missing July…,
LLVM 3.7….}
text

21. 21© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Columnar storage
{25059873,
22309487,
23059861,
23010982}
Tweet_id
{newsycbot,
RideImpala,
fastly,
llvmorg}
User_name
{1442865158,
1442828307,
1442865156,
1442865155}
Created_at
{Visual exp…,
Introducing ..,
Missing July…,
LLVM 3.7….}
text
SELECT COUNT(*) FROM tweets WHERE user_name = ‘newsycbot’;
Only read 1 column
1GB 2GB 1GB 200GB
…AND door open to big IO gains with compression and encoding

22. 22© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Available Encodings:
• Dictionary (Strings, Binary)
• Bitshuffle (Numeric)
• RLE (Numeric, Bool)
Available Compression:
• Snappy
• LZ4
• ZLib
Columnar Storage – Other Encodings/Compression
Kudu 1.3 ships with “good” defaults for most cases

23. 23© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Deep Dive:
Write and Read Paths

24. 24© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
LSM vs Kudu
• LSM – Log Structured Merge (Cassandra, HBase, etc)
• Inserts and updates all go to an in-memory map (MemStore) and later flush to
on-disk files (HFile/SSTable)
• Reads perform an on-the-fly merge of all on-disk HFiles
• Kudu
• Shares some traits (memstores, compactions)
• More complex.
• Slower writes in exchange for faster reads (especially scans)

25. 25© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
LSM Insert Path
MemStore
INSERT
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“1”
HFile 1
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“1”
flush

26. 26© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
LSM Insert Path
MemStore
INSERT
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah2”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“2”
HFile 2
Row=r2 col=c1 val=“blah2”
Row=r2 col=c2 val=“2”
flush
HFile 1
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“1”

27. 27© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
LSM Update path
MemStore
UPDATE
HFile 1
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“2”
HFile 2
Row=r2 col=c1 val=“v2”
Row=r2 col=c2 val=“5”
Row=r2 col=c1 val=“newval”
Note: all updates are “fully
decoupled” from reads. Random-
write workload is transformed to
fully sequential!

28. 28© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
LSM Read path
MemStore
HFile 1
Row=r1 col=c1 val=“blah”
Row=r1 col=c2 val=“2”
HFile 2
Row=r2 col=c1 val=“v2”
Row=r2 col=c2 val=“5”
Row=r2 col=c1 val=“newval”
Merge based on string row
keys
R1: c1=blah c2=2
R2: c1=newval c2=5
….
CPU intensive!
Must always read
rowkeys
Any given row may exist across
multiple HFiles: must always
merge!
The more HFiles to merge, the
slower it reads

29. 29© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – Inserts and Flushes
MemRowSet
INSERT(“todd”, “$1000”,”engineer”)
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
flush

30. 30© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – Inserts and Flushes
MemRowSet
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
name pay role
DiskRowSet 2
INSERT(“doug”, “$1B”, “Hadoop man”)
flush

31. 31© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage - Updates
MemRowSet
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
name pay role
DiskRowSet 2
Delta MS
Delta MS
Each DiskRowSet has its own
DeltaMemStore to
accumulate updates
base data
base data

32. 32© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage - Updates
MemRowSet
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
name pay role
DiskRowSet 2
Delta MS
Delta MS
UPDATE set pay=“$1M”
WHERE name=“todd”
Is the row in DiskRowSet 2?
(check bloom filters)
Is the row in DiskRowSet 1?
(check bloom filters)
Bloom says: no!
Bloom says: maybe!
Search key column to find
offset: rowid = 150
150: col 1=$1M
base data

33. 33© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – Read path
MemRowSet
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
name pay role
DiskRowSet 2
Delta MS
Delta MS
150: pay=$1M
Read rows in DiskRowSet 2
Then, read rows in
DiskRowSet 1
Any row is only in exactly one
DiskRowSet– no need to merge cross-
DRS!
Updates are merged based on ordinal
offset within DRS: array indexing, no
string compares
base data
base data

34. 34© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – Delta flushes
MemRowSet
name pay role
DiskRowSet 1
name pay role
DiskRowSet 2
Delta MS
Delta MS
0: pay=fooREDO DeltaFile
Flush
A REDO delta indicates how to
transform between the ‘base data’
(columnar) and a later version
base data
base data

35. 35© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – Major delta compaction
name pay role
DiskRowSet(pre-compaction)
Delta MS
REDO DeltaFile REDO DeltaFile REDO DeltaFile
Many deltas accumulate: lots of delta
application work on reads
name pay role
DiskRowSet(post-compaction)
Delta MS
Unmerged REDO
deltasUNDO deltas
If a column has few updates, doesn’t need to be
re-written: those deltas maintained in new
DeltaFile
Merge updates for columns with high update
percentage
base data

36. 36© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu storage – RowSet Compactions
DRS 1 (32MB)
[PK=alice], [PK=joe], [PK=linda], [PK=zach]
DRS 2 (32MB)
[PK=bob], [PK=jon], [PK=mary] [PK=zeke]
DRS 3 (32MB)
[PK=carl], [PK=julie], [PK=omar] [PK=zoe]
DRS 4 (32MB) DRS 5 (32MB) DRS 6 (32MB)
[alice, bob, carl, joe] [jon, julie, linda,
mary]
[omar, zach, zeke, zoe]
Reorganize rows to avoid rowsets
with overlapping key ranges
Writes for “chris” have to perform
bloom lookups on all 3 RS

37. 37© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Kudu Storage - Compactions
• Main Idea: Always be compacting!
• Compactions run continuously to prevent IO storms
• ”Budgeted” RS compactions: What is the best way to spend X MBs IO?
• Physical/Logical decoupling: different replicas run compactions at different times

38. 38© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Deep Dive
Partitioning

39. 39© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning
• Kudu has flexible policies for distributing data among partitions
• Hash partitioning is built in, and can be combined with range partitioning
• Keys are ordered within a partition
• Key order matters
• Partitioning key order dictates distribution
• Primary key order affects how much data is read for scans

40. 40© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Primary Key selection
• Example - Time series data:
• ”time” - timestamp
• ”series” - {region, server, metric}
(us-east.appserver01.loadavg, 2016-05-
09T15:14:00Z)
(us-east.appserver01.loadavg, 2016-05-
09T15:15:00Z)
(us-west.dbserver03.rss, 2016-05-
09T15:14:30Z)
(us-west.dbserver03.rss, 2016-05-
09T15:14:30Z)
(2016-05-09T15:14:00Z, us-
east.appserver01.loadavg)
(2016-05-09T15:14:30Z, us-west.dbserver03.rss)
(2016-05-09T15:15:00Z, us-
east.appserver01.loadavg)
(2016-05-09T15:14:30Z, us-west.dbserver03.rss)
(series, time) (time, series)
SELECT * WHERE series = ‘us-east.appserver01.loadavg’;

41. 41© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Time Range (inserts)
All Inserts go to Latest PartitionBig scans (across large time intervals)
can be parallelized across many partitions

42. 42© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Series Range
Inserts are spread among all partitionsScans are over a single partition

43. 43© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Series Range
Partitions can become unbalanced,
resulting in hot spotting

44. 44© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Series Hash (inserts)
Inserts are spread among all partitionsScans are over a single partition

45. 45© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Series Hash
Partitions grow overtime, eventually
becoming too big for a single server

46. 46© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Partitioning — By Series Hash + Time Range
Inserts are spread among all partitions
in the latest time range
Big scans (across large time intervals)
can be parallelized across partitions

47. 47© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Next Steps
Get Started with
Kudu & Cloudera
Start Contributing
to Kudu
• www.cloudera.com/downloads
• https://blog.cloudera.com/?s=kudu
http://kudu.apache.org/

48. 48© Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved.
Thank you
David Alves – Apache Kudu PMC
@dribeiroalves