1. 1Source: Experiences in Visual Thinking by Robert McKim
Want to play around while you’re waiting for the webinar
to start? Use the whiteboard’s drawing tools to adapt the
circles into different objects (see example).
2. The Role of Play in Learning with
Technology
ELI Webinar
5/4/09
2
4. Objectives
• Discuss theories of “playful learning”
• Share examples of faculty-developed,
play-based learning experiences
• Provide advice and guiding questions
for the development of play-based learning
experiences on your campus
• Link to additional resources on play-
based learning
• Together, use technology to experience
play 4
6. What do the “Experts” Say?
6
Koster – Fun = Challenge at Edge of Ability
Osterweil – Four Freedoms of Play
Sutton-Smith – The Ambiguity of Play
Nat’l Institute of Play – Seven Patterns
Strong Museum – Six Elements of Play
Read more at http://playfullearning.pbworks.com/
Theoretical-Models-for-Play
7. What’s Going on While at Play?
7
Open-ended
Youth directed, Youth generated
Improvisation
Risk-taking
Emergent collaboration
and group process
Bricolage (Tinkering)
Deep engagement and personal investment
Experimentation
Multiple drafts/iterations
Imitation
Fantasy
“Convergent” process
for multimedia composition
9. PRACTICE AND LOW STAKES ASSESSMENT –
activities to review content and knowledge-based
information, as with computer games, students can
“level up” when ready
9
Dr. Carolyn Hopper, English (Study Skills)
“Play builds on a student’s intent to learn,
strengthens synaptic connections and allows
students to learn from their mistakes without the
stakes being too high”
MTSU Faculty Examples
10. DATA MANIPULATION – activities to provide
opportunities to apply content to situations
10
Dr. Don Roy, Marketing
Play “blends content learning with process
learning,” playing this simulation gives the students
the “chance to apply principles to give them a feel
for marketing.”
MTSU Faculty Examples
11. MTSU Faculty Examples
ROLE PLAY, SIMULATIONS, IMMERSIVE
ENVIRONMENTS – activities to provide
opportunities to apply content to “real-life” situations
and allow for higher order problem-solving and
analysis applications
11
Dr. Scott Seipel, Computer Information Systems
(Authored a multiplayer online decision making
game called The OPEC Game) When playing the
game “the students are engaged, involved and
really feel it;” “by the end of the semester, the
students will beg to play the game.”
12. Dr. Mary Jane Tracy
Honors Program
Simmons College
Author of the educational game
entitled "Greenwich Village,
1913, Suffrage, Labor, and the
New Woman"
Designing for play-based learning
12
NOTE: This clip is an excerpt from a longer interview.
Hear it all at http://playfullearning.pbworks.com/
Designing+for+Play-Based+Learning
13. What About You?
13
Use the chat to share examples of
playful learning at your own
institutions
14. Guiding Questions for successful
play-based learning experiences
• What learning objectives are you trying to
accomplish?
• What timing and resources constraints do you
face?
• What resources do you have available to “play
the game”?
• What support do you have available to help
you in the design and implementation?
14
Give you an overview of what the “experts” are saying about play
Example in higher education – and hear what faculty have to say about play and learning
Sometimes it’s more important to know the questions than to know the answers, so we provide questions designed to help you succeed in your design and use of play
This is a HUGE field that can take up a lifetime, not just an hour. So we’ve developed a wiki that provides additional resources should you want to pursue the topic in greater depth after today
FINALLY – heaven forbid! – we’ve built a bit of play into the webinar so that we “walk our talk.” For example, as you played around with the circles at the beginning of the webinar, you were “playing” at collaborative brainstorming in which the goal was to get lots of ideas on the table and to help you transition into a playful way of thinking.
When doing the poll – have them ham it up (imaging they are playing with their selection – what are they doing? If you wish, tell us about it in the chat)
Puzzle – this is an example that has a “right” answer, the enjoyment comes from wresting coherence and order from apparent chaos. When we talk of “play” the first thing that usually comes to mind are games that have a “solution.” This is really only a subset of a much larger set of “play” possibilities.
Tim Brown – thinking with your hands (craft paper)
Gregory Bateson – child is playing at being a bishop not to become a bishop, but to explore what a bishop is – those who selected the costumes may learn though imagining the possibilities
Paper airplanes and Legos – the engineers and designers in the audience – tacking a challenge and prototyping possibilities
Kaleidoscope – exploring the world around from a range of perspectives – what would it look like if everyday views were reordered?
Etch-a-sketch – fun is in the making, the process. As with the Circles exercise, the goal is to get a lot of ideas on the table, not necessarily to retain them for posterity
Jump Rope – Perhaps the most kinesthetic example. Unfortunately, much of formal learning is disembodied, so kinesic learners are left to fend for themselves. With recent developments like the wii, perhaps more of technology-mediated play will be designed to include those of us who learn through movement.
For a one page synopsis, see the wiki!
Ralph Koster: A Theory of Fun for Game Design
Fun is the act of mastering a problem mentally. It is the feedback that our brains give us when we are absorbing patterns for learning purposes. If a problem is too easy or too hard, it's not perceived as "fun." As a person's mastery increases, things that used to be "fun" may become boring (e.g. Tic Tac Toe).
National Institute for Play: Types of Play
Attunement Play: e.g., the parent-child bonding that takes place during peek-a-boo with an infant
Body and Play Movement: fe.g., jumping, skipping, or twirling just for the sake of it
* Object Play: e.g., banging pans, skipping rocks, shooting marbles
Social Play: This type has three subsets (belonging, rough and tumble, celebratory)
Imaginative and Pretend Play: e.g., imaginary friends, dress-up, make-believe
* Storytelling / Narrative Play: e.g., puppet shows, shaggy dog stories
Transformative-Integrative Play: e.g., Einstein imaginatively riding pleasurably on a sunbeam at the speed of light, playing around with ideas for new products, play + science = transformation
Scot Osterweil: The Four Freedoms of Play
Freedom to :Experiment , Fail , Try on Different Identities Freedom of Effort (to stop at any time)
Brian Sutton-Smith: The Ambiguity of Play
Play is "liminal" in that it occupies a threshold between reality and unreality. Ambiguity of
Reference - Is that a pretend gun sound, or are you choking?.
* Referent - Is that an object or a toy? (stick transformed into a sabre)
Intent - Do you mean it, or is it pretend?
Sense - Is it serious, or is it nonsense?
Transition - You said you were only playing
* Contradiction - A man playing at being a woman
Meaning - Is it play or playfighting?
The Strong National Museum of Play: Elements of Play
Anticipation, Surprise, Pleasure, Understanding, Strength, Poise
* Each of these elements increases and grows stronger as you play
What are some of the common themes across all these theories?
Open-endedness, bricolage (for example, a phone used as the recording studio -- using technologies in unanticipated and inventive ways - cite "Tinkering as a Mode of Knowledge Production in a Digital Age" - Carnegie Foundation - Videos at http://vimeo.com/2183356),
Collaboration (group process in which each member contributes -- the strengths of one benefit the others)
Experimentation (ad lib is the "pre writing" for script development)
Composition process that spans several media (f2f improv, text, video),
(Youth) student-directed and student-generated content
Imitation and fantasy (learning through pretending a la Gregory Bateson)
Deep engagement and personal investment (flow).
How can we infuse more of these features into the learning experiences we offer to our students?
Brain based learning – plays / games builds on:
Intent to learn, interest and, memory
Builds on student knowledge
Strengthens synaptic connections
Provides immediate feedback
Assists with the amount and quality of college learning
Plugs into their creativity
Seeing the need and value of learning outside the classroom
Increases student responsibility
Example – “who wants to pass the final”
Using simulations in business – Introduction to MarketPlace
Encourage play in group allows them practice with decision making
Role of the faculty – coach – not telling them what to do but guiding them in the decision-making process”
Created a multiplayer online decision making game based on OPEC
Goal – put them in the situation – you are going to figure it out.
Roles that they can take given the cards they’ve been given
8 minute clip – want you to hear firsthand from a faculty member about her thoughts, perspectives, and experiences designing a game for her students