SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 127
Unleashing Data:
The Key to Driving Massive
Improvements
Tom Burton, MBA
Co-Founder & Chief Improvement
Officer, Health Catalyst
© 2017 Health Catalyst
2
Learning Objectives
• Illustrate the importance of investing in analytics
training and infrastructure to prepare for massive
improvement in healthcare outcomes.
• Demonstrate how to unleash data at your organization
with efforts across the improvement spectrum.
• Recognize how to sustain and spread improvements
across your entire organization.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
3
To unleash the full potential of data,
organizations should adopt a
balanced approach to improvement
across the spectrums of both
effort and value.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential4
Our Mission: Be the Catalyst for Massive Improvement in Healthcare Outcomes
510+
Team Members
113+
Improvement
Case Studies
22
Best Places to
Work Awards
90+ Million
Patients
400+
Hospitals
4,000+
Clinics
Our CustomersOur Company
Academic Medical CentersCommunity Hospitals
Children’s Hospitals
Managed Service Organizations
Integrated Delivery Systems
Accountable Care Organizations
• Stanford – Palo Alto, CA
• Albany Medical – Albany, NY
• Indiana University – Indianapolis, IN
• KUHA – Kansas City, KS
• UTMB – Galveston, TX
• Dartmouth-Hitchcock – Lebanon, NH
• Health Share of Oregon – Portland, OR
• CEPAmerica – Oakland, CA
• USMM – Troy, MI
• North Memorial – Minneapolis, MN
• Gulfport Memorial – Gulfport, MS
• Thibodaux – Thibodaux, LA
• NorthBay – Fairfield, CA
• John Muir – Walnut Creek, CA
• Gunnison Valley – Gunnison, UT
• Texas Children’s – Houston, TX
• Children’s Hospital Wisconsin – Milwaukee, WI
• MultiCare – Tacoma, WA
• Providence – Portland, OR
• Alberta Health Services – Edmonton, CA
• Memorial Care – Fountain Valley, CA
• Cedars-Sinai – Los Angeles, CA
• Kaiser – Denver, CO
• Unity Point – Des Moines, IA
• Queens Health – Honolulu, HI
• Community Health Network – Indianapolis, IN
• Health Quest – Poughkeepsie, NY
• Hawaii Pacific Health – Honolulu, HI
• UPMC – Pittsburg, PA
• King’s Daughters Medical Center – Ashland, KY
• Piedmont – Atlanta, GA
• Mission – Asheville, NC
• Orlando Health – Orlando, FL
• Cone Health – Greensboro, NC
• Christiana Care – Wilmington, DE
• Westchester – Valhalla, NY
• Allina – Minneapolis, MN
• Partners – Boston, MA
• OSF – Peoria, IL
• Springfield Clinic – Springfield, IL
• Crystal Run – Middletown, NY
• OneCare Vermont – Colchester, VT
• Adirondacks ACO – Pittsburg, NY
• Adirondacks Health Institute – Glens Falls, NY
Health Catalyst Clients:
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential5
Unleashing Data to Achieve Massive Improvements
Organic Improvement
Let innovation happen - Light Effort
Fast Track Improvement
Medium Effort
Comprehensive Outcomes
High Effort
Value Across the spectrum of improvement effort, the value may be light, medium, or high value.
Enablers Highly trained and engaged team members and a robust analytics infrastructure (both platform & applications)
Volume
1,000s of day-to-day, better, data-driven
decisions
100s of quick win improvements using data
10s of deep changes, eliminating unwarranted
clinical, operational and/or financial variation
Examples
• 2-hour ad-hoc analysis by senior analyst
reveals insight that expanding clinic hours,
versus building an observation wing, will save
$3M in capital expense.
• Automated dashboard saves 4 hours of
manual data collection/reporting per week.
• Data helps clinicians identify high maternal
hypertension rates; insights + interventions
results in 15% improvement in hypertension
rates.
• Dashboard helps identify missing
documentation on high dollar accounts,
improving AR days by 10%.
• Deep process redesign, leveraging
predictive models, reduces sepsis mortality
rate by 15%, saves 125 lives per year, and
reduces costs by $1.6 M.
• Redesigning care management workflow
using mobile technology increases care plan
effectiveness by 28% and saves $3.4 M.
Sample Results
Measures
Technology utilization, number of lives impacted/saved, intervention rates, number/percent improvement, additional revenue, cost savings, cost
avoidance…
Sample
Communications
Vignettes, improvement snapshots, case study briefs, case studies, webinars, publications…
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential6
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
X
Effort
High
Light High
Value
Improvement Type
The Improvement Spectrum Matrix – Value and Effort
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential7
Effort
High
Light High
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
Improvement Type
Overemphasis on Deep Improvement Projects
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential8
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
Effort
High
Light High
Value
Improvement Type
Overemphasis on Light Effort Projects
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential9
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
Effort
High
Light High
Value
Improvement Type
Overemphasis on One Value Type
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential10
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
Effort
High
Light High
Value
Improvement Type
Overemphasis on One Value Type
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential11
Effort
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
High
Light High
Value
Improvement Type
IDEAL: Even Spread Across the Improvement Spectrum Matrix
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which type of improvements does your organization focus on? 147
respondents
1. Clinical – 20%
2. Financial – 13%
3. Patient Experience – 10%
4. Balanced mix – 58%
Poll Question #1
12
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which quadrant does your organization tend to gravitate toward? 137
respondents
1. High Effort and High Value – 24%
2. High Effort and Light Value – 9%
3. Light Effort and High Value – 24%
4. Light Effort and Light Value – 6%
5. Balanced approach across both spectrums avoiding high effort,
light value – 37%
Poll Question #2
13
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential14
Analogy Is the Key to Understanding
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential15
Introducing the Game: SPECTRUM
• Adapted by Health Catalyst from
the popular strategy game,
7 Wonders.
• Objective of the game:
Gain the most improvement
points.
• There are multiple ways to earn
improvement points .
• 3 years, 7 cards per year.
• Play a card and pass the rest to
your neighbor.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential16
Each Table Represents a Care Delivery System
Each Player Represents a Department in that
System
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential17
• Competition/conflict Between Departments
(+ or - Points Calculated at the End of Each Year)
• Budget for Improvement Efforts
(1 point / 3 coins)
• Data-Driven Culture (on game board)
• Light Effort Improvements
• Collaboration Between Departments
• System-Wide Adoption
• High Effort Clinical, Financial, and
Patient Experience Improvements
Scoring: Improvement Point Categories
Improvement
point symbol
At the end of Year III, once the budget disputes have been resolved, the players total
their improvement points on the scoring sheet in each of the following categories:
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential18
Game
Board
Layout
Key
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential19
Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success
• Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards)
– Acquire Data
– Grant Access to Data
– Build Actionable Metrics
– Find Insights in Data
• Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards)
– Analytics Engineer
– Change Agent
– Key Stakeholder
• Progress on your journey toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board)
– From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics
– Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential20
Only 8% of data required
for the population health
and precision medicine
strategy resides in
today’s EMR/EHR.
Source: Alberta Innovates Health Solutions, Secondary
Data Use Project, March 2016
http://www.aihealthsolutions.ca/initiatives-
partnerships/secondary-use-data-project/presentations/
Acquire Data . . .
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential21
Just Beginning: Digitization of Health
The Growing Ecosystem of Human Health Data
Healthcare
Encounter
Data
7x24
Biometric
Data
Consumer
Data
Genomic
&
Familial
Data
Social
Data
Outcomes
Data
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential22
Imagine the Richness of the Picture
22
The Growing Ecosystem of Human Health Data
Healthcare
Encounter
Data
7x24
Biometric
Data
Consumer
Data
Genomic
&
Familial
Data
Social
Data
Outcomes
Data
What is your 1, 3, and 5 year strategic data acquisition plan?
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential23
Acquire Data
Gartner: Health Data Convergence Hub
“Definition: The health data convergence hub is the
orchestration platform that brings together data from across the
consumer/citizen/patient health and wellness continuum and
prepares the data for delivery to downstream consumption
platforms, applications, analytics and "things." It automates the
ingestion of data — both structured and unstructured — from all
identified and permissioned sources; provides tracking and
traceability; and manages identity, compliance and security. It
may process algorithms and deliver the output to the correct
modality.”
- Laura Craft, Vi Shaffer, “Gartner: Hype Cycle for Healthcare Providers, 2017”
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential24
From Data Warehouse to Data Operating System
Traditional Data Warehouse
Health Data Convergence Hub
HC: Data Operating System
1. Collects data from EHR & Claims
2. Enables creating static reports
3. Enables SQL queries
4. Data is updated nightly
5. Not available in the EHR workflow
6. Requires replacing your existing DW
7. Proprietary schemas
8. Deals with tables and columns
1. Collects data from many sources
2. Enables creating static reports and web/mobile apps
3. Enables SQL, R, Python, Deep Learning queries
4. Data is always up-to-date
5. Insights are easily available in the EHR workflow
6. Works with your existing DW (or use our DW)
7. Industry standard schemas e.g., FHIR
8. Deals with tables, columns and clinical entities like
registries, measures
9. Provides centralized security at app and data levels
10. Machine Learning is as easy to use as SQL
11. Content Marketplace to share executable content with
other health systems
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential25
Acquire Data
Key Concepts To Accelerate Data Acquisition
Late-binding – don’t early bind complex data and waste valuable time during
data acquisitions by binding raw data into strict definitions, unless there is
persistent and global agreement, rather co-locate data into Source Data Marts or
Data Lakes with minimal transformation, allowing for flexibility in multiple future
use-cases.
Automation Tools – Use tools which automate the tedious and predictable
steps of building data marts. (e.g. Source Connectors, SMD, SAMD)
Leverage Big Data Capabilities – Make sure your data platform can leverage
silicon valley technologies like Hadoop/Spark, Machine Learning, Natural
Language Processing etc.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential26
Grant Access
One of the most challenging
polarities for organizations to
balance is how to grant
access to data.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential27
Data Access Polarity:
Data Protection AND Data Sharing
Symptoms of Extreme:
• Legitimate data request denied.
• IT controls all final signoff for
data access.
• 6 month process to get access.
Symptoms of Extreme:
• Data breach.
• Inappropriate data use.
Evidence of Balance:
• Streamlined access
approval process.
• Consistent regular
auditing.
• Appropriate use of
data.
• Data stewards
grant access.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential28
Grant Access
#1 Polarity: Data Sharing AND Data Protection
Key Concepts in Granting Access effectively
Data Steward Ownership - Shift access decision away from IT into
clinical/business owners hands – IT usually overemphasizes data protection.
Trust but Verify – Assume good intent and grant access to data more liberally
but increase your frequency and depth of your auditing capability.
Create Team- or Role-based data access policies – Streamline granting
access to entire teams or role groups to access data for improvement purposes.
When a new individual joins a group or gets a new role, access is automatically
granted.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential29
Build Actionable Metrics
The most sophisticated and accurate
predictive model is worthless
unless it promotes an action
that would otherwise
not have happened.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential30
The 5 Rights of Information Delivery
The How:
We believe if you get the
• Right Information, to the
• Right Audience, at the
• Right Granularity, at the
• Right Time, in the
• Right Visualization/Modality
… you produce the Right Action,
to Improve Outcomes
The Why:
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential31
Discover Insight
Data becomes valuable
when an insight is discovered,
such as a trend, pattern, correlation, or
causation.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential32
Average Before=8 hours delay
Average After=3 hours delay
Is This Result Good?
Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 16-17
Poor sample size,
looks like
improvement but no
improvement
occurred in reality
Trend occurred
naturally,
Intervention didn’t
cause improvement
Change wasn’t
permanent,
numbers are
slipping
Improvement
happened before
intervention, not
because of
intervention
Outlier caused
process to look like
it needed
improvement
Real
improvement
caused by
intervention
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential33
Why Traditional Scorecards Lack Insight
Metric Region 1 Region 2 Overall Score
Financial Metric XX.X XX.X XX.X
Quality Metric YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y
Experience Metric ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z
Scorecard Shows:
Current Measurement vs.
Target.
Does not show:
Trend, Variation, Noise vs.
Signal, Drill-down detail.
Static Report Shows:
Current Measurement
compared with Historic.
Does not show:
Variation, Noise vs. Signal,
Trend (very well), drill-down
detail.
Metric Last Year Current Year
LY Current Month LY Year To Date Current Month Year to Date
Financial Metric XX.X XX.X XX.X XX.X
Quality Metric YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y
Experience Metric ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z
Scorecard
Static Report
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential34
Insight Trap:
Rush to Judgment and Punish the Outliers
Current Condition
• Significant Volume.
• Significant Variation.
Option 1: “Punish the Outliers” or
“Cut Off the Tail”
Strategy
• Set a minimum standard of quality.
• Focus improvement effort on those people not meeting the
minimum standard.
# of
Cases
Mean
Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes
# of
Cases
Focus on
Minimum
Standard
Metric
Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential35
Leveraging Insight
Learning Approach: Focus on Better Process
Option 2: Identify Best Practice
“Narrow the curve and shift it to the right”
Strategy
• Identify evidenced based “Shared Baseline.”
• Focus improvement effort on reducing process variation by
following the “Shared Baseline.”
• Often those performing the best make the greatest improvements.
Excellent Outcomes
# of
Cases
Focus on Best
Practice Care
Process Model
Poor Outcomes
Current Condition
• Significant Volume.
• Significant Variation.
# of
Cases
Mean
Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential36
Variation Over Time
Mean
Upper Control Limit
Lower Control Limit
Adapted from R.C. Lloyd & Associates
Current Condition
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential37
Mean
Upper Control Limit
Lower Control Limit
Adapted from R.C. Lloyd & Associates
Variation Over Time
Variation Reduction
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential38
New Mean
Reduce Variation and Improve Outcomes
Intervention
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential39
Using Control Charts to Discover Insights
Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 116
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential40
Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success
• Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards)
– Acquire Data
– Grant Access to data
– Build Actionable Metrics
– Find Insights in data
• Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards)
– Analytics Engineer
– Change Agent
– Key Stakeholder
• Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board)
– From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics
– Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential41
“I told you I wasn’t a hunter gather. I’m an analyst!”
28
Train Analytics Engineer
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential42
Once Better Infrastructure Is in Place Analytics
Engineers Have More Time to Interpret Data
Non value-add work Value-add work
Understanding the question
Hunting for data
Interpreting data
Distributing data
Gathering, compiling or running
Weak Analytic System Strong Analytic System
Understanding the question
Hunting for data
Interpreting data
Distributing data
Gather, compiling or running
*poll of Analyst customer pre Catalyst Analytics Platform install
75%* of analyst time is spent in hunting & gathering in a weak analytics system
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential43
Core
Create insights
Present insights in a
compelling way
Understanding of
healthcare data
Core Technical
PL/SQL
Data modeling
Visualization &
reporting tools
Needed for the Future
• Stats, predictive, machine learning, AI, etc. • Visualization principles (e.g. Tufte, Few)
• Quality improvement (e.g. Lean, 6 Sigma) • Project management
The Skills Needed in the Analytics Space
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential44
You must have both the technical skill AND the clinical or
operational context (this is usually best achieved by partnering
with a change agent who has deep domain knowledge).
Otherwise, you might jump to the wrong conclusions …
Insights Require Technical Skill AND Context
Higher ice
cream sales
We taste
better
More shark
attacks
- -
Stop selling ice cream!
Warmer weather
Higher ice
cream sales
More shark
attacks
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential45
Recruit Change Agent
"In times of change, learners inherit the
future, while the learned find
themselves beautifully equipped to deal
with a world that no longer exists."
- Eric Hoffer
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential46
Diffusion of Innovation
Change Agents Are Typically Early Adopter SMEs
Innovators
early
adopters
early
majority
laggards
(never adopters)
* Adapted from Rogers, E. Diffusion of Innovations. New York, NY: 1995.
late
majority
Innovators. Recruit
innovators to re-design
care delivery
processes
TheChasm
N = number of individuals in group
N
N = number needed to influence group
(but they must be the right individuals)
Early adopters. Recruit early adopters to
chair improvement and to lead
implementation at each site.
(key individuals who can rally support)
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential47
Select Early Adopters Leaders
• You need both willing and able leaders.
• Identify those wanting to lead permanent improvement efforts –
throw their hat in the ring (willingness).
• Allow those not wishing to lead to participate in the selection
process (recommend top 3 picks – those with natural leadership =
ability ).
• Executive leadership can select from top recommendations the
most open minded leaders and give them decision rights.
• Involvement in the selection process leads to much, much better
adoption later (“Onboard for the take-off not just the crash-landing.”
– Dr. David Burton).
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential48
Change Agent Role: Preparing People for Change
Awareness
Desire
Knowledge
& Ability
Actively
Sustaining
Time
Productivity&Performance
High
Low
Keep the chaos period as
short as possible
Minimize the loss of
Productivity & Engagement
Change!
 Ensure managers/leaders are informed and prepared
to lead their teams through the change – available and
active.
 Warn people that the process may be uncomfortable,
but that they will survive.
 Identify champions to represent key player groups in the
design and implementation process.
 Leadership defines the why the change is needed, sets
the vision, then defines the sandbox for those impacted
to participate in designing the future.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential49
Engage Key Stakeholders
“Things get done only if the data we
gather can inform and inspire those in
a position to make a difference.”
–Mike Schmoker
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential50
Four Levels of Stakeholder Information Needs
Stakeholder
Group
Key Data Need Group Role
Executive Prioritization & Visibility Controls resources and funding allocations.
Domain
Leadership
Prioritization & Visibility Understands domain interactions and
tradeoffs (clinical, operational or financial).
Adoption Best Practice Tracking &
Actionable Metrics
Influences others and encourages change
(adoption of new processes).
Innovation Process Design &
Outcomes Prediction
Identifies root cause of poor outcomes and
designs better processes to produce better
outcomes.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential51
Example Stakeholder Analysis
STAKEHOLDER IMPACT IMPORTANCE MATRIX AREA
(see Stakeholder Matrix)
Current HEAT
Projected
HEAT
Projected HEAT
Name of functional role/group
affected by the change
Degree of impact on
this stakeholder
Level of
stakeholder's
influence on the
success of the
change
Where do they land on
the stakeholder matrix?
Today
After CEO Email
goes out
After the details
of the role changes
are shared
SVPs (SEL) significant medium a. KEY PLAYER productive zone productive zone productive zone
SVPs (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER overwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed
EL significant medium a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone
STDs significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed
TDs significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone
SDAs / DAs
(Tech Ops Pool)
significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed
Domain Experts (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed
Analytic Dirs (IL) significant a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed
SDAs / DAs (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed
Analysts (Prod Dev) significant a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed
Leadership Team moderate high a. KEY PLAYER overwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed
HR minor or none medium c. keep informed productive zone productive zone productive zone
Finance - FPA moderate medium a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone
Accounting moderate Low c. keep informed underwhelmed productive zone productive zone
Marketing minor or none Low c. keep informed underwhelmed productive zone productive zone
Customers moderate Low d. Keep satisfied productive zone underwhelmed productive zone
Identify Champions
to represent large
groups.
Keep Satisfied
Meet Their Needs
Key Player
Manage Closely
Monitor
Minimum Effort
Keep Informed
Show Consideration
Low High
High
Low
Interest of Stakeholders
Power/Influence
ofStakeholders
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential52
Provide Visibility to All Stakeholders
Shared Accountability Date: 10/1/2015 Overall Status
Risks and Uncertainties
Recruit /Train Kickoff AIM Intervention Rollout plan Results
Aug 2015 Aug 2015 Sep 2015 -- Sep 2015 Oct 2015
Guidance team
Mission, charter,
roles confirmed
Review draft
cohort and data
Finalize cohort
Define rollout
plan
Review initial
results
Content and
Analytics Lead
Review AIM
options
Data quality
issues identified
Identify
intervention(s)
Guidance team
validation
Implementation
plan adjusted
Implementation
team
Best practice
gathering
Direct
observation
Direct
observation
Solicit front-line
plan input
Review lessons
learned
Workgroup
team
Profile prelim.
data and cohort
Prioritize, select
AIM
Solicit front line
input
Finalize rollout
plan
Create AIM
statement #2
Workgroup
training
Guidance team
validation
Refine cohort and
metrics
Analytics dev &
test
Guidance team
validation
Repeat process
Guidance team
validation
Improvement Initiative Progress
Key
not
started
In
process
done
well
some
concerns
strong
concerns
Accomplishments Next Steps Issues / Help needed
• Feedback sessions with SMEs • Consolidate app versions
• Define rollout plan
• QV access
Long-term
AIM Goal
To realize X% in shared savings in the JCL ACO by the end of 2015. Going forward, achieve and sustain a
X% reduction in the PMPM, a X% reduction in patient leakage, and a X% decrease in out-of-network referrals
by February 2016.
AIM Performance
Goal #1:
Source CMS Claims data into the EDW by September 15th, 2015. Wire up the Shared Accountability application to
claims data, and show incremental value via the ability to determine JCL ACO network leakage as well as PMPM costs,
by October 1st, 2015.
Launch/Rolloutdate:10/1/2015
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential53
Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success
• Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards)
– Acquire Data
– Grant Access to data
– Build Actionable Metrics
– Find Insights in data
• Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards)
– Analytics Engineer
– Change Agent
– Key Stakeholder
• Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board)
– From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics
– Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential54
Developing a Data Driven Culture
“We’ve got to use every piece of data and
piece of information, and hopefully that will
help us be accurate with our player
evaluation. For us, that’s our life blood.”
- Billy Beane, General Manager Oakland A’s
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential55
The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture
Spreadsheet
Silos
• Silos or pockets of analysis.
• Conflicting spreadsheet reports and
interpretations of data.
• Battles over data ownership.
• Most time spent on hunting for and
gathering data.
• Focus is on is the data “right.”
Centralized
Reporting
Diabetes
Sepsis
Readmissions
Common, linkable
vocabulary
Financial
Source Marts
Administrative
Source Marts
Departmental
Source Marts
EMR
Source Marts
Patient
Satisfaction
Source Mart
FINANCIAL SOURCES
(e.g. EPSi, Peoplesoft, Lawson)
ADMINISTRATIVE SOURCES
(e.g. API Time Tracking)
EMR SOURCEs
(e.g. Cerner, Allscripts, NextGen)
DEPARTMENTAL SOURCES
(e.g. Apollo)
Pt. SATISFACTION
SOURCES
(e.g. NRC Picker, Press Ganey)
• Centralized single source of truth
established in EDW.
• Significant time spent on
standardizing definitions.
• Data begins to be trusted.
• Report queue begins to build.
• Focus is on requirements for
dashboard applications and
reports.
Data-Driven
Improvement Culture
• Improvement teams use analytics to
accelerate best practice adoption.
• Data drives decisions and actions.
• Focus is on growing and sustaining
outcomes improvement through
elimination of waste and variation
leveraging analytics.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential56
Analytics Embedded in Workflow
Imagine: Facebook as an EHR
From a blog Dale Sanders wrote in 2010
• Patient’s evolving health story at the
center of the record, not the encounter.
• Embedded video and images.
• Text and discrete data.
• Secure messaging.
• Social support from family & friends
• Flexible security, defined by the patient.
They expand our sense of
connectedness.
Analytics is embedded…
it’s ambient to the
experience.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential57
Analytics Embedded in Workflow
Imagine: Amazon as a Clinical Order Entry System
• Drug and device availability
• Pricing
• Home delivery
• Automatic refills
• Patient reported outcomes
From a blog Dale Sanders wrote in 2010
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential58
Kawamoto et al, University of Utah, BMJ, 2005
Physicians are 15x more likely to change their ordering and
treatment protocols if presented with substantiating data at the
point of care vs. presented with the same data in a clinical
process improvement meeting.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential59
The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture
InformationCost
Information Benefit
High
Low High
Bubble Size = Count of Information Type
Lower the cost of
building reports through
more automated data
acquisition tools.
Analytics Embedded in
Workflow Software
Predictive Models/
Machine Learning
Dynamic Visualizations
(e.g. Qlik Tableau)
Parameter Based
Reports
Static Reports &
Score Cards
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential60
The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture
Analytics Embedded in
Workflow Software
Predictive Models/
Machine Learning
Dynamic Visualizations
(e.g. Qlik Tableau)
Parameter Based
Reports
Static Reports &
Score Cards
InformationCost
Information Benefit
High
Low High
Bubble Size = Count of Information Type
Lower the cost of
building more advanced
analytics by leveraging
better design tools and
well trained Analytics
Engineers.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential61
The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture
InformationCost
Information Benefit
High
Low High
Bubble Size = Count of Information Type
Replace & consolidate static
reports and score cards with more
advanced analytics over time. Analytics Embedded in
Workflow Software
Predictive Models/
Machine Learning
Dynamic Visualizations
(e.g. Qlik Tableau)
Parameter Based
Reports
Static Reports &
Score Cards
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential62
The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture
InformationCost
Information Benefit
High
Low High
Bubble Size = Count of Information Type
Dramatically increase analytics
embedded in workflow as they are
15 X more likely to be adopted.
Analytics Embedded in
Workflow Software
Predictive Models/
Machine Learning
Dynamic Visualizations
(e.g. Qlik Tableau)
Parameter Based
Reports
Static Reports &
Score Cards
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential63
Capabilities to SCALE Outcomes Improvement
Leadership, Culture, and Governance
Financial Alignment
Where do we focus?
How are we compensated?
What should we
be doing?
How are we doing?
How do we change?
Clinical Outcomes
Cost Outcomes
Experience Outcomes
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential64
Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success
• Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards)
– Acquire Data
– Grant Access to data
– Build Actionable Metrics
– Find Insights in data
• Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards)
– Analytics Engineer
– Change Agent
– Key Stakeholder
• Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board)
– From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics
– Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which infrastructure component does your organization struggle with?
154 respondents
1. Acquiring data – 29%
2. Granting access to data – 10%
3. Building actionable metrics – 32%
4. Finding insights in data – 29%
Poll Question #3
65
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which role is the most scarce in your organization? 154 respondents
1. Analytics engineer – 51%
2. Change agent – 43%
3. Key stakeholder – 6%
Poll Question #4
66
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which capability/question does your organization struggle with most?
151 respondents
1. Analytics: How are we doing? – 14%
2. Best Practice: What should we be doing? – 7%
3. Adoption: How do we change? – 51%
4. Financial Alignment: How are we compensated? – 10%
5. Governance: Where do we focus? – 18%
Poll Question #5
67
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential68
Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum
• On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?)
– Return on Luck
– Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity)
– Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness)
• Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards)
– The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
– Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story
• Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards)
– Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
– Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams
• No Margin, No Mission (The Coins)
– Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations
– Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains
– Overhead Value Analysis
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential69
On-Going Opportunity Analysis
“Luck is not the key.
How you handle good or bad luck
is what matters.”
- Jim Collins
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential70
Return on Luck – Jim Collins
Return on Luck Keys
• Do both great and mediocre
companies encounter the same
amount of luck, good and bad? -
YES
• What can you do to capitalize on
your luck?
• Have you turned your bad-luck
events into a big part of what
makes your company great?
• Are you squandering your good
luck events?
Good Luck
• Governor with healthcare background is elected.
• Payer agrees to shared savings upside
opportunity.
• Local provider wants to join healthcare system
and open an institute.
Bad Luck
• Joint Commission visits at a bad time.
• New regulatory reporting required.
• Major philanthropy contributor stops giving.
• Competitor opens new facility.
• PCP refers out of network.
Common “Luck” Events in Healthcare
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential71
Build a Pipeline of Opportunities
One of the Analytics Engineer’s primary roles is to fill the pipeline of insights
and potential improvement opportunities.
Pipeline should exceed the execution capacity
of the organization.
• Motivates an increase in capacity.
• Teaches the organization to prioritize based on highest value.
• Allows for back-up opportunities to be advanced should a high priority
initiative stall indefinitely.
Do not limit pipeline to high-effort opportunities. Many organic improvements
can occur simply by exposing the opportunity.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential72
Value
Type
Financial
(Hard $)
Clinical /
Operational
Experience
Light
< 1 FTE or
$XXX
Process
Metric
Improved
Save
Clinician or
Patient Time
Medium > 1 < 3 FTE
Patient
Outcome
Improved
Overall
Satisfaction
score
improves
High > 3 FTE Life Saved
Evaluate Each Opportunity
Return on Investment
Effort to Achieve
• Light: < 1 FTE investment
• Medium: > 1 but < 3 FTE
• High: > 3 FTE investment
Value of Opportunity
Capability
• Do we have the skills required? What would it take
to gain skills?
• Do we have the equipment/tools required?
Capacity
• Do the stakeholders required to make the change
have the time to focus on this improvement? What
can we take off their plate?
Willingness
• Is there an acceptance of the need for change? Do
we have front-line buy-in?
• How much resistance will be encountered? From
whom? (mini stakeholder analysis)
Organizational Readiness
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential73
Readiness Assessment
• Quickly asses readiness with on-line surveys. (e.g. use something like survey monkey or
Health Catalyst provides a free on-line Outcomes Improvement Readiness Assessment
at https://oira.healthcatalyst.com .
• As you focus in on specific initiatives spend the time to interview key stakeholders of the
most important improvement initiatives and assess capability, capacity and willingness.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential74
Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum
• On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?)
– Return on Luck
– Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity)
– Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness)
• Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards)
– The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
– Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story
• Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards)
– Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
– Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams
• No Margin, No Mission (The Coins)
– Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations
– Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains
– Overhead Value Analysis
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential75
Light Effort Organic Improvements
To promote organic improvements organize Analytic Resources in a Hub and Spoke model
Centralized (Hub)
• Analytics Infrastructure.
• Analytic Engineer Training.
– Tool Training.
– Visualization standards.
– Statistical Analysis.
– Machine learning.
• Data Governance.
– Data Steward Training.
– Common Metric definitions.
– Data Quality Standards.
– Standardized Visualization Look & Feel to
promote ease of use.
De-centralized (Spoke)
• Responding to departmental
questions using Ad-hoc queries
or analysis.
• Custom dashboard
development.
• Interpretation of data, based on
local context and knowledge.
76
• Access to content
enabled through a
security model
endorsed by senior
leadership.
• Provisioning process
well defined and
operationalized.
Broadly Accessible
Data
• Analytic tool
capabilities support
what end users are
trying to do.
• Analytic community
has the ability to share
and distribute content.
Analytic Toolset
Alignment
• Teams are provided
education on the core
capabilities to support
their use of the data.
• Support function
available to answer
and direct questions.
Training & Support
• Continuants
understand what is
available, what is
changing, and what is
coming.
• Value being delivered
by the platform is
consistently and
broadly being
messaged.
Communication
• Individual or group is on point to grow analytics capabilities.
• Ensure evolving roadmap aligns with business/clinical priorities.
Analytics Leadership
The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential77
Organic Improvements – Be Opportunistic
Texas Children’s Example
Context
• Working on Asthma Action Plan Initiative.
Discovery
• While exploring the data MD Leader and Analytics
Engineer find anomalies in data around chest x-rays
unrelated to the asthma action plan initiative.
• Appears high percentage of chest x-rays from ED are
unwarranted.
• Analytics Engineer, performs deeper analysis within a
few hours and discovers highly utilized order set used
by Resident MDs in ED.
Intervention
• New default orders set using best practice
intervention criteria for x-ray designed to
replaces old order set.
• Resident MDs in ED instructed to use new
order set for children presenting with asthma.
Result
• Achieved and sustained a 49 % decrease in
unnecessary chest x-ray orders.
– Better Care for Patients
– Elimination of Unnecessary Cost
– No Extra X-ray Exposure to Kids
• Value = High
• Effort = Light
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential78
Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum
• On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?)
– Return on Luck
– Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity)
– Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness)
• Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards)
– The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
– Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story
• Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards)
– Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
– Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams
• No Margin, No Mission (The Coins)
– Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations
– Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains
– Overhead Value Analysis
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential79
Rosetta Stone: Translation between different
improvement methodologies.
Key Principle: Pick ONE Methodology and use it
consistently across your organization
Avoiding the Tower of Babel –
Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential80
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Analyze the
Opportunity
and Define the
Problem.
Scope the
Opportunity
and Set Goals.
Explore Root
Causes and
Set Process
Aims.
Design
Interventions
and Plan Initial
Implementation
Implement
Interventions
and Measure
Results.
Monitor,
Adjust, and
Continually
Learn.
Diffuse and
Sustain.
Is it an adoption
problem?
Are data valid?
Do we need to adjust
our interventions?
Do we need to
reevaluate
root cause?
Start with a directive from executive leadership based on high-level opportunity analysis and readiness assessment
The Seven Essential Elements of Improvement
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential81
Organization of Teams
Clinical and Technical
Prioritization
Adoption
Innovation
etc.
Outcomes Improvement
Executive Leadership Team
Content & Analytics Team(s)
Data Governance
Committee
Domain Guidance Team
Provides domain oversight
and drives priorities
Outcomes
Improvement Team(s)
Drives innovation & adoption
Workgroup(s)
as needed
Workgroup(s)
as needed
Innovates
Domain 1
Domain 2
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential82
Women & Newborn Guidance Team - Prioritization
Key
Key Stakeholder
Change Agent/SME
Analytics Engineer
Structure Typically Needed for Deep Effort Improvements
• Meet quarterly to prioritize allocation of
technical staff.
• Approves improvement AIMs
• Reviews progress and removes road
blocks.
OB NewbornGYN
Women & Newborn Guidance Leadership Dyad:
1) MD Clinical Program Director 2) Administrative Director
Domain Leadership Dyads:
1) MD Lead & 2) RN Lead.
SME
Data Steward
Analytics
Engineer
Analytics Team covers
entire guidance team.
Financial
Analyst
Small Teams - Innovation • Integrates Data from all relevant sources.
• Meet weekly in iteration planning meeting to identify improvement opportunity and insights.
• Build DRAFT processes, metrics, interventions & presents DRAFT work to Broader Teams.
• Grants access of analytic assets to broader team.
Domain Leadership Dyad
+ Analytics Team
OB Workgroup
Broad Teams – Adoption
• Broad RN and MD representation across system.
• Meet monthly to review, adjust and approve DRAFTs.
• Act as change agents to lead rollout of new process and measurement.
Guidance Leadership Dyad.
+ Domain Leadership Dyad.
+ Analytics Team.
+ Clinical representation from across system.
*All resources serve in these improvement roles part time ranging from
5% (MDs) to 50% (Analytics Engineer) of their time.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential83
Process Aim:
By X date increase the number of patients who have
follow-up completed within 7 days from X% to Y%.
Outcome Goal:
By X date decrease readmits from 22.1% to 17.7%.
Track follow-up compliance
(hospitalists, advanced practitioner,
cardiology nurse) discharge and
post results weekly.
Develop, educate, and implement
on a discharge scheduling protocol
to facilitate improved appointment
follow-up 7 days per week.
Intervention #1 Intervention #2
Heart Failure Example, Focus on Transitions
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential84
Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum
• On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?)
– Return on Luck
– Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity)
– Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness)
• Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards)
– The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
– Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story
• Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards)
– Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
– Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams
• No Margin, No Mission (The Coins)
– Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations
– Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains
– Overhead Value Analysis
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential85
Funding Improvement Work
“No Margin, No Mission”
»Sister Irene Kraus
Founding Chief Executive of the Daughters of Charity National Health System
American Hospital Association Chair
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential86
Funding Improvement Work
Involve the Finance Team Early in the Process
Working with CFO sanctioned financial analyst or other key stakeholders:
 Set baseline costs for current process
 Calculate improvement value:
- Hard Cost Savings = $ will be removed from the budget next year
- Soft Cost Efficiency Gain = Improvement efficiency will allow for employee to work on
higher priority tasks
- Cost Avoidance = Project the value of reversing a trend such as an upward cost trend
that becomes flat due to improvement efforts
 Negotiate with Payers on shared savings opportunities
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential87
The Right Granularity: Best Practice Compliance
Admits/1000 members
IP days/1000 members
OP visits/1000 members
Procedures/1000 members
ED visits/1000 members
Readmissions/1000 members
Utilization
Who should
get the care?
Cost/case
Cost/procedure
OR minutes
L&D minutes
Other LOS
Order Sets
Clinical
Support
Workflow
Cost per case
Nursing hours by unit
OR minutes
L&D minutes
Cycle times
Cost per ancillary test
Environmental services
What care
should be
included?
How can care
be delivered
efficiently ?
Indications for Intervention
Diagnostic algorithms
Indications for Referral
Triage Criteria
Treatment and Monitoring
Algorithms
Health Maintenance and
Preventive Guidelines
Standardized Follow-up Checklist
Post-acute care order sets
IP (SNF, IRF)
Home health, Hospice
Clinical Ops Procedure Guidelines
Granularity
Substance Selection Clinical Supply Chain
Management
Admission Order Sets Supplementary Order Sets
Pre-Procedure Order Sets
Post-procedure Order Sets
Bedside Care Practice Guidelines
Discharge Checklist
Patient Injury Prevention Protocol
Risk Assessment
Transfer Checklist
Question Examples of Best Practice Standard Possible Measures
Administrative
Support
Workflow
How can
administrative
operations be
performed
efficiently ?
AR Escalation Process
Network Design Process
Recruiting/Onboarding Process
AR Days
% out of network utilization
% Turnover
Team member
satisfaction/engagement
AR Escalation Process
Budgeting Process
Supply Chain Procurement
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential88
Involve Finance Early: Payment Model Considerations
= Negative Impact = Positive or Negative = Positive Impact
Improvement Type
Discounted
FFS
Per Diem
Per Case Bundled Per Case
Condition
Capitation
Full
Capitation
CMS Commercial CMS Commercial
Workflow
Diagnostic Variation
Standing Orders
MedicationSelection
Triage
Patient Safety
Ambulatory Treatment
and Monitoring
Indications for Referral
Indications for
Intervention
Operational Workflow
Diagnostic Variation
Standing Orders
Substance Selection
Triage Criteria
Patient Safety
Treatment and Monitoring
Algorithms
Indications for Referral
Indications for Intervention
25
Administrative Workflow
Depending on the
type of
improvement,
the financial impact
could be positive
or negative based
on the payment
model mix.
Therefore,
proactively involve
finance and
negotiate shared
savings with payers
up-front when
possible.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential89
Funding Improvement Work:
Balancing Value Mix Helps Fund Clinical & Experience Improvements
High
Light High
Value
IDEAL: Even spread across the Improvement Spectrum Matrix
Effort
Financial Value
Clinical Value
Experience Value
Improvement Type
As your governance team
prioritizes improvement initiative
make sure that the projected
hard $ cost savings can fund
the improvement efforts required
across all value types.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential90
Funding Improvement Work:
Overhead Value Analysis
• Frequently an organization has built up a large
inventory of regularly produced reports (with an
associated cost)
• In addition, many vended technical
point-solutions continue to be maintained over
decades (with an associated maintenance fee)
• Overhead Value Analysis is the “spring
cleaning process” of reviewing the cost to
maintain or produce these analytic assets
compared with the benefit each currently is
providing the organization.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential91
Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum
• On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?)
– Return on Luck
– Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity)
– Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness)
• Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards)
– The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
– Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story
• Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards)
– Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
– Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams
• No Margin, No Mission (The Coins)
– Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations
– Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains
– Overhead Value Analysis
© 2017 Health Catalyst
How does your organization prioritize opportunities for outcomes
improvement? 122 respondents
1. We can’t say no to anything. – 14%
2. We estimate the value to the organization. – 9%
3. We estimate both effort and value. – 20%
4. We estimate effort, value, and readiness. – 25%
5. It’s all about the politics. – 32%
Poll Question #6
92
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which of the prerequisites of organic improvement is weakest in your
organization? 121 respondents
1. Broadly accessible data. – 22%
2. Alignment around an analytic toolset. – 18%
3. Analytic training and support. – 25%
4. Communication of analytic value and roadmap. – 31%
5. All of these components are working well. – 4%
Poll Question #7
93
© 2017 Health Catalyst
True or False: My organization has stale analytic reports that are
never used but continue to be produced? 144 respondents
1. True – 73%
2. False – 27%
Poll Question #8
94
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential95
Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread
• Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow
Cards)
– Improve Data Quality.
– Train for Data Literacy.
– Promote Appropriate Data Access.
• System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards)
– Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group).
– Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette).
– Establish Improvement Governance.
• Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards)
– The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions.
– The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work.
– Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential96
Interdepartmental Collaboration
“Coming together is a beginning.
Keeping together is progress.
Working together is success.”
-Henry Ford
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential97
Definition of Data Governance
Data governance refers to the plans, processes, and
principles that are proactively applied to ensure that an
organization’s data is managed in such a way to
maximize the value of that data to the organization.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential98
The Triple Aim of Data Governance
1. Ensuring Data Quality
• Data Quality = Completeness x Accuracy x Timeliness.
2. Building Data Literacy
• Train on analytics basics (Data Awareness).
• Technical tools and analytic techniques (Analytics Team).
• Data content (Context provided by Data Stewards).
3. Maximizing Data Utilization
• Promote cross-department appropriate usage of data. Track # of users
per month by dashboard. Measure direct access.
https://www.healthcatalyst.com/demystifying-healthcare-data-governance
Utilization
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential99
Data Use Defines Data Quality Requirements
Balance the cost of achieving data quality with benefit.
Data Use Category Improvement Comparison or
Accountability
Research
Aim Outcomes Improvement Comparison, Choice,
Spur Change
Discover New
Knowledge
Test observability Test Observable No Test Test Blinded
Sample size Just Enough Obtain 100% Just in case
Flexibility of hypothesis Flexible, Changes as
Learning Takes Place
No Hypothesis Fixed
Is change an
improvement?
Run Charts and
Shewart Charts
No Change Focus T-Test, F-Test, p-value
Cost of data quality Low/Medium High Medium/High
Common challenges Tendency to Apply
More Rigor Than
Needed
Data Often Used for
Punishment
Access to Data
Sometimes
Problematic
Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 27
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential100
Data Literacy - Typical Current State
• Large backlogs of
analytic/report
requests.
• Knowledge workers = clinical
or operational knowledge
AND access to tools and
data.
Knowledge
Workers
Drillers
Viewers
User Distribution
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential101
Authors or
Knowledge
Workers
Viewers
Drillers
Knowledge
Workers
Data Literacy - Desired Future State
Increase number of knowledge workers by
doing the following:
• Expand data access.
• Simplify data structures.
• Continue use of naming standards.
• Provide better tools.
Promote shift in culture by rewarding process
knowledge discovery rather than punishing
outliers.
Desired User Distribution
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential102
Trust but Verify:
The Importance of Broad Access AND Auditing
Key Polarity: Grant Broad Access to Promote Utilization AND Rigorously Audit Appropriate Use of Data
https://www.idera.com/productssolutions/sqlserver/sqlcompliancemanager
Idera Compliance Manager
Audit tool example:
Idera Compliance Manager
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential103
Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread
• Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow
Cards)
– Improve Data Quality.
– Train for Data Literacy.
– Promote Appropriate Data Access.
• System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards)
– Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group).
– Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette).
– Establish Improvement Governance.
• Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards)
– The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions.
– The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work.
– Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential104
Analytical Services Working Group (ASWG) User Group
Purpose of ASWG:
Serve as a forum where analysts from the various
domains within the organization can collaborate to
define standards and share knowledge.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential105
Analytical Services Working Group (ASWG)
Responsibility Summary
Define information and analytical standards.
• Standardize calculations and definitions.
• Recommend tools and processes.
• Establish data quality standards.
Provide technical and domain cross-training.
Information consumers (analysts) provide feedback to technical staff on tools, information,
performance, processes, etc…
Technical staff (analytics engineer team) provides status updates and notices to analysts on
infrastructure and content.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential106
System-Wide Adoption
“Run your analytics department
like a small business.”
- Dale Sanders
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential107
Data-Driven Outcomes Improvement & Decision Making
Service
Oriented
Engaged,
High Contributing
Analytics Engineers Satisfied, Empowered
Analytics Customers
Scalable, Sustainable
Products
Employee
Focused
Technically
Sound
Analytic Asset Adoption
Running Your Analytics Department Like a Small
Business
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential108
System-wide Adoption: Effective Marketing
Effectively Marketing your Analytics Department requires
Two key elements:
• Educate
– Let the organization know what’s available.
– Help them become more sophisticated users of analytics.
• Share Results
– Success breeds success.
– Publish Improvement Vignettes.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential109
NO READMITS Bundle Successfully Lowers
COPD Readmissions
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (COPD) is responsible for
approximately 135,000 deaths
annually, making it the third
leading cause of death in the U.S.
Nationally, there are
approximately 700,000
hospitalizations with the principal
diagnosis of COPD each year,
with one in five patients being
readmitted within 30 days. The
national average cost for a COPD
readmission is between $9,000
and $12,000.
95% of COPD patients assessed for readmission risk.
17% reduction in readmission rate. Approximately 34 fewer
patients with COPD readmitted each year, saving an
estimated $360,000 annually based on national benchmarks.
9% improvement in PCP notification.
97% of patients with COPD get an order set.
Building from work done by the Heart Failure team, MultiCare's
Medicine Collaborative developed a NOREADMITS bundle
consisting of nine interventions for patients with COPD who are not
mechanically ventilated. The intent of the bundle was to decrease
the likelihood of readmission. After less than nine months, they
achieved the following results:
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential110
[Headline – the One Sentence Grabber]
The Setting:
What is the situation and
context?
The Challenge:
What was the complication?
What problem are we solving?
The Result:
What happened?
What was improved?
The Turning Point:
What interventions where used to make a difference?
How were analytics used in solving the problem?
What expertise was needed for the improvement?
Organization Logo
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential111
System-Wide Adoption: Improvement Governance
Stakeholders:
Starting at the
top, engage all
stakeholders
around a common
vision.
Shared
Understanding:
Have a common
understanding of
organizational needs,
capabilities, and
readiness.
Alignment:
Use a consistent
improvement
methodology, align
incentives, and
balance polarities.
Focus:
Practice disciplined
decision-making to
prioritize, fund,
organize, and
sustain initiatives.
Key Objective of Improvement Governance:
Move from a loose federation of hospitals and clinics
that share supply purchasing . . .
. . . to an integrated care delivery system that delivers
consistent high quality, coordinate care everywhere
across the continuum at the lowest appropriate cost.
Governance Quest
HAS 16 Game
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential112
Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread
• Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow
Cards)
– Improve Data Quality.
– Train for Data Literacy.
– Promote Appropriate Data Access.
• System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards)
– Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group).
– Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette).
– Establish Improvement Governance.
• Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards)
– The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions.
– The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work.
– Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential113
Avoiding Conflict & Contention: Creating a Pause
“Freedom is the ability to
pause between stimulus
and response and in the
pause to choose.”
- Viktor Frankl
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential114
The 10 Worst Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions
1. Use Data as a Weapon.
2. Misrepresent Data.
3. Prevent Appropriate Data Access.
4. Disengage from the Process.
5. Highlight Data Imperfections / Discredit.
6. Analysis Paralysis.
7. Political Favoritism.
8. Budget Cuts Across the Board.
9. Delay a Decision with Stall Tactics.
10. Stick to the Status Quo.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential115
Signs Someone Is Outside the Productive Zone
Blame others, distract attention, denial
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential116
Start With Compassion
When you don’t know what to try first,
lower the heat.
• Validate feelings, acknowledge loss.
• Simplify and clarify.
• Address the technical aspects.
• Break the problem into parts.
• Restore, add, or reallocate resources.
• Temporarily reclaim responsibility for tough issues.
• Give your attention.
• Take stock of what is available.
• A lot more time, enrich knowledge and skills.
Nobody misbehaves from a place of strength.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential117
Avoiding Contention: Understand Intent & Impact
“I know that you believe you
understood what you think I said, but I
am not sure you realize that what you
heard is not what I meant.”
- Robert McCloskey
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential118
Other’s impact on me
My intention Intention of other
My impact
Harvard Negotiation Project
Mine Other’s
Intention
Impact
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential119


Mine Other’s
Intention
Impact
Harvard Negotiation Project
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential120


Our assumptions
about intentions
are often wrong.
Good intentions
do not make bad
impact unimportant
or irrelevant.
Harvard Negotiation Project
Mine Other’s
Intention
Impact
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential121
Other’s
This is what I
meant.
This is how it
felt/seemed to me.
Is that what you
meant?
How did it feel/land
with you?
Harvard Negotiation Project
Mine
Intention
Impact
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential122
Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread
• Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow
Cards)
– Improve Data Quality.
– Train for Data Literacy.
– Promote Appropriate Data Access.
• System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards)
– Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group).
– Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette).
– Establish Improvement Governance.
• Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards)
– The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions.
– The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work.
– Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Within the triple aim of data governance, our organization struggles
most with? 113 respondents
1. Data Quality. – 25%
2. Data Literacy. – 31%
3. Data Utilization. – 41%
4. We’re great at all three of these. – 3%
Poll Question #9
123
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Which of these 5 practices have you seen at your organization?
(select all that apply) 109 respondents
1. Use Data as a Weapon. – 32%
2. Misrepresent Data. – 41%
3. Prevent Appropriate Data Access. – 39%
4. Disengage from the Process. – 54%
5. Highlight Data Imperfections / Discredit. – 55%
Poll Question #10
124
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential125
Spectrum - Key Takeaways and Lessons Learned
Set your organization up for success
• Invest in Infrastructure (Acquire Data, Grant Access, Build Actionable Metrics and Discover Insights).
• Train Key Roles and Skills (Train Analytics Engineers, Recruit Change Agents and Engage Key Stakeholders).
• Create a Data-Driven Culture (Embed Analytics in Workflow, Invest in 5 Core Capabilities for improvement 1) Leadership,
Governance & Culture, 2) Analytics, 3) Best Practice, 4) Adoption and 5) Financial Alignment).
Unleash data across the Spectrum of Improvement
• Perform On-going Opportunity Analysis – Asses Value, Effort, Capabilities, Capacity and Willingness.
• Enable Light Effort Improvements – Prerequisites 1) Grant Broad Access, 2) Analytic Toolset Alignment, 3) Training and Support,
4) Communication and 5) Analytic Leadership; Be Opportunistic – improve your Return on Luck.
• Invest in Deep Effort, High-Value Improvement - Pick ONE Improvement Methodology, and Organize consistent on-going
interdisciplinary teams.
• Understand No Margin, No Mission – Involve the Finance time early, Fund clinical outcomes with financial results in other
domains, and use Overhead Value Analysis to eliminate less value reports and point solutions.
Sustaining and Spreading Improvement
• Collaborate with information & resources – Establish Data Governance – increase Data Quality, Data Literacy and Data Access.
• Promote system-wide adoption – Create an Analytic Services Working Group to promote standards & knowledge sharing, Market
you Analytics like a small business and establish improvement governance.
• Reduce wasteful contention – Avoid worst practices such as using data as a weapon, help everyone engage in the work by staying
in the ”Productive Zone, and improving communication by understanding intent and impact.
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential126
A
Questions &
Answers
© 2017 Health Catalyst
Proprietary and Confidential127
Thank You

More Related Content

What's hot

The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss Out
The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss OutThe Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss Out
The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss OutHealth Catalyst
 
Health Reform and Meaningful Use
Health Reform and Meaningful UseHealth Reform and Meaningful Use
Health Reform and Meaningful UseHealth Catalyst
 
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next Normal
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next NormalThree Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next Normal
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next NormalHealth Catalyst
 
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare Leaders
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare LeadersFour Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare Leaders
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare LeadersHealth Catalyst
 
Value Based Reimbursement: The New Reality
Value Based Reimbursement: The New RealityValue Based Reimbursement: The New Reality
Value Based Reimbursement: The New RealityHealth Catalyst
 
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes MeasuresRealizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes MeasuresHealth Catalyst
 
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...Health Catalyst
 
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareAn ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareHealth Catalyst
 
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthCare Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthHealth Catalyst
 
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety
How to Use Data to Improve Patient SafetyHow to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety
How to Use Data to Improve Patient SafetyHealth Catalyst
 
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare Analytics
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare AnalyticsWhen the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare Analytics
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare AnalyticsHealth Catalyst
 
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative Analytics
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative AnalyticsHow to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative Analytics
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative AnalyticsHealth Catalyst
 
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement ProjectsHealth Catalyst
 
Quality Improvement in the Emergency Department
Quality Improvement in the Emergency DepartmentQuality Improvement in the Emergency Department
Quality Improvement in the Emergency DepartmentDavisKivairoChore
 
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just Pennies
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just PenniesGenomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just Pennies
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just PenniesHealth Catalyst
 
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part Discussion
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part DiscussionHow to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part Discussion
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part DiscussionHealth Catalyst
 
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...Health Catalyst
 
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...Health Catalyst
 
Predictive Analytics: Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...
Predictive Analytics:  Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...Predictive Analytics:  Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...
Predictive Analytics: Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...Health Catalyst
 

What's hot (20)

The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss Out
The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss OutThe Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss Out
The Real Opportunity of Precision Medicine and How to Not Miss Out
 
Health Reform and Meaningful Use
Health Reform and Meaningful UseHealth Reform and Meaningful Use
Health Reform and Meaningful Use
 
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next Normal
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next NormalThree Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next Normal
Three Strategies to Deliver Patient-Centered Care in the Next Normal
 
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare Leaders
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare LeadersFour Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare Leaders
Four Effective Opioid Interventions for Healthcare Leaders
 
Value Based Reimbursement: The New Reality
Value Based Reimbursement: The New RealityValue Based Reimbursement: The New Reality
Value Based Reimbursement: The New Reality
 
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes MeasuresRealizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures
Realizing the Promise of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures
 
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...
8 in 10 Hospitals Stand Pat on Population Health Strategy, Despite Uncertaint...
 
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareAn ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
 
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthCare Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
 
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety
How to Use Data to Improve Patient SafetyHow to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety
 
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare Analytics
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare AnalyticsWhen the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare Analytics
When the Promise of Prehabilitation Meets the Power of Healthcare Analytics
 
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative Analytics
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative AnalyticsHow to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative Analytics
How to Evaluate Emerging Healthcare Technology with Innovative Analytics
 
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects
7 Features of Highly Effective Outcomes Improvement Projects
 
Quality Improvement in the Emergency Department
Quality Improvement in the Emergency DepartmentQuality Improvement in the Emergency Department
Quality Improvement in the Emergency Department
 
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just Pennies
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just PenniesGenomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just Pennies
Genomic Medicine: Personalized Care for Just Pennies
 
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part Discussion
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part DiscussionHow to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part Discussion
How to Use Data to Improve Patient Safety: A Two-Part Discussion
 
Population Health Management
Population Health ManagementPopulation Health Management
Population Health Management
 
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
 
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...
Zero Sepsis Deaths: A Dialogue of Passion and Practical Wisdom on Sepsis Prev...
 
Predictive Analytics: Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...
Predictive Analytics:  Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...Predictive Analytics:  Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...
Predictive Analytics: Dale Sanders Presentation at Plante Moran Healthcare E...
 

Similar to Unleashing Massive Healthcare Improvements with Data

High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1
High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1
High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1Dennis P. Sweeney
 
The Foundations of Success in Population Health Management
The Foundations of Success in Population Health ManagementThe Foundations of Success in Population Health Management
The Foundations of Success in Population Health ManagementHealth Catalyst
 
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care Journey
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care JourneyeBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care Journey
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care JourneyNextGen Healthcare
 
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data Governance
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data GovernanceThe Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data Governance
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data GovernanceHealth Catalyst
 
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight: What We Can Do To C...
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight:  What We Can Do To C...Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight:  What We Can Do To C...
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight: What We Can Do To C...Health Catalyst
 
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptx
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptxESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptx
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptxMohamedAbbas208397
 
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21Health Catalyst
 
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based Care
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based CareHow Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based Care
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based CarePerficient, Inc.
 
Transforming Clinical Practice Initiative
Transforming Clinical Practice InitiativeTransforming Clinical Practice Initiative
Transforming Clinical Practice InitiativeCitiusTech
 
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptx
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptxV2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptx
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptxmeseprod
 
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are Demanding
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are DemandingDelivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are Demanding
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are DemandingHealth Catalyst
 
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdf
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdfA Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdf
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdfPatWilson13
 
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?Population Health Management: Where are YOU?
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?Phytel
 
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...Justin Campbell
 
eBook - How to Think Like an ACO
eBook - How to Think Like an ACOeBook - How to Think Like an ACO
eBook - How to Think Like an ACONextGen Healthcare
 
Health information technology networks presentation
Health information technology networks presentationHealth information technology networks presentation
Health information technology networks presentationlearfield
 
July 2015 accountable care webinar
July 2015 accountable care webinarJuly 2015 accountable care webinar
July 2015 accountable care webinarModern Healthcare
 

Similar to Unleashing Massive Healthcare Improvements with Data (20)

HM312 Week 3
HM312 Week 3HM312 Week 3
HM312 Week 3
 
High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1
High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1
High Risk patient Groups presentation 20150123.1
 
The Foundations of Success in Population Health Management
The Foundations of Success in Population Health ManagementThe Foundations of Success in Population Health Management
The Foundations of Success in Population Health Management
 
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care Journey
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care JourneyeBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care Journey
eBook - Tools, Resources, and Expertise for your ACO/Collaborative Care Journey
 
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data Governance
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data GovernanceThe Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data Governance
The Data Maze: Navigating the Complexities of Data Governance
 
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight: What We Can Do To C...
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight:  What We Can Do To C...Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight:  What We Can Do To C...
Patient-Centered Care Requires Patient-Centered Insight: What We Can Do To C...
 
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptx
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptxESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptx
ESM Software - Healthcare Strategy Map Examples.pptx
 
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21
Key Principles and Approaches to Populaiton Health mManagement - HAS Session 21
 
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based Care
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based CareHow Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based Care
How Northwestern Medicine is Leveraging Epic to Enable Value-Based Care
 
Transforming Clinical Practice Initiative
Transforming Clinical Practice InitiativeTransforming Clinical Practice Initiative
Transforming Clinical Practice Initiative
 
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptx
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptxV2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptx
V2 hospitals-care-systems-of-future.pptx
 
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are Demanding
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are DemandingDelivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are Demanding
Delivering the Healthcare Pricing Transparency That Consumers Are Demanding
 
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdf
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdfA Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdf
A Seven Step Approach to a Clinically Integrated Network.pdf
 
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?Population Health Management: Where are YOU?
Population Health Management: Where are YOU?
 
10th Annual Utah's Health Services Research Conference - Data: What's availab...
10th Annual Utah's Health Services Research Conference - Data: What's availab...10th Annual Utah's Health Services Research Conference - Data: What's availab...
10th Annual Utah's Health Services Research Conference - Data: What's availab...
 
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...
Best Practices for Enabling HIE and Incorporating Capabilities into EHR Workf...
 
eBook - How to Think Like an ACO
eBook - How to Think Like an ACOeBook - How to Think Like an ACO
eBook - How to Think Like an ACO
 
Health information technology networks presentation
Health information technology networks presentationHealth information technology networks presentation
Health information technology networks presentation
 
July 2015 accountable care webinar
July 2015 accountable care webinarJuly 2015 accountable care webinar
July 2015 accountable care webinar
 
Making Sense of MACRA
Making Sense of MACRAMaking Sense of MACRA
Making Sense of MACRA
 

More from Health Catalyst

2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights
2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights
2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology InsightsHealth Catalyst
 
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and Labor
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and LaborThree Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and Labor
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and LaborHealth Catalyst
 
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 32024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3Health Catalyst
 
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 22024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2Health Catalyst
 
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 12024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1Health Catalyst
 
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and Beyond
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and BeyondWhat’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and Beyond
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and BeyondHealth Catalyst
 
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee Replacement
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee ReplacementAutomated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee Replacement
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee ReplacementHealth Catalyst
 
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule UpdatesHealth Catalyst
 
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final Rule
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final RuleWhat's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final Rule
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final RuleHealth Catalyst
 
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2Health Catalyst
 
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdf
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdfVitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdf
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdfHealth Catalyst
 
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS Solutions
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS SolutionsDriving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS Solutions
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS SolutionsHealth Catalyst
 
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average Outsourcing
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average OutsourcingTech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average Outsourcing
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average OutsourcingHealth Catalyst
 
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set UpdatesHealth Catalyst
 
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital Technology
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital TechnologyHow Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital Technology
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital TechnologyHealth Catalyst
 
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency Ends
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency EndsCOVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency Ends
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency EndsHealth Catalyst
 
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and Patient
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and PatientAutomated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and Patient
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and PatientHealth Catalyst
 
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptx
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptxA Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptx
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptxHealth Catalyst
 
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business Intelligence
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business IntelligenceSelf-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business Intelligence
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business IntelligenceHealth Catalyst
 
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™Health Catalyst
 

More from Health Catalyst (20)

2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights
2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights
2024 HCAT Healthcare Technology Insights
 
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and Labor
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and LaborThree Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and Labor
Three Keys to a Successful Margin: Charges, Costs, and Labor
 
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 32024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3
2024 CPT® Updates (Professional Services Focused) - Part 3
 
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 22024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2
2024 CPT® Code Updates (HIM Focused) - Part 2
 
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 12024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1
2024 CPT® Code Updates (CDM Focused) - Part 1
 
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and Beyond
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and BeyondWhat’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and Beyond
What’s Next for Hospital Price Transparency in 2024 and Beyond
 
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee Replacement
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee ReplacementAutomated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee Replacement
Automated Patient Reported Outcomes (PROs) for Hip & Knee Replacement
 
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates
2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) Final Rule Updates
 
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final Rule
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final RuleWhat's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final Rule
What's Next for OPPS: A Look at the 2024 Final Rule
 
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2
Insight into the 2024 ICD-10 PCS Updates - Part 2
 
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdf
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdfVitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdf
Vitalware Insight Into the 2024 ICD10 CM Updates.pdf
 
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS Solutions
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS SolutionsDriving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS Solutions
Driving Value: Boosting Clinical Registry Value Using ARMUS Solutions
 
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average Outsourcing
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average OutsourcingTech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average Outsourcing
Tech-Enabled Managed Services: Not Your Average Outsourcing
 
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates
2023 Mid-Year CPT/HCPCS Code Set Updates
 
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital Technology
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital TechnologyHow Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital Technology
How Managing Chronic Conditions Is Streamlined with Digital Technology
 
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency Ends
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency EndsCOVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency Ends
COVID-19: After the Public Health Emergency Ends
 
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and Patient
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and PatientAutomated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and Patient
Automated Medication Compliance Tools for the Provider and Patient
 
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptx
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptxA Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptx
A Facility-Focused Guide to Applying Modifiers Corectly.pptx
 
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business Intelligence
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business IntelligenceSelf-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business Intelligence
Self-Service Analytics: How to Use Healthcare Business Intelligence
 
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™
Optimize Your Labor Management with Health Catalyst PowerLabor™
 

Recently uploaded

Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Me
Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near MeBook Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Me
Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Menarwatsonia7
 
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photosparshadkalavatidevi7
 
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady Presentation
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady PresentationMVP Health Care City of Schenectady Presentation
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady PresentationMVP Health Care
 
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...satishsharma69855
 
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...ddev2574
 
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photoskartikkumark7k7
 
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photosparshadkalavatidevi7
 
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalore
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service BangaloreCall Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalore
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalorenarwatsonia7
 
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdf
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdfSARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdf
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdfDolisha Warbi
 
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...narwatsonia7
 
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOW
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOWRussian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOW
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOWsangeevkumar5478
 
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...narwatsonia7
 
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...sandeepkumar69420
 
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So Far
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So FarSingle Assessment Framework - What We Know So Far
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So FarCareLineLive
 
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...ddev2574
 
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Service
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts ServiceCall Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Service
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Servicenarwatsonia7
 
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbai
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service MumbaiCollege Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbai
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbaisonalikaur4
 
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptx
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptxFAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptx
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptxMumux Mirani
 
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...sandeepkumar69420
 
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...vrvipin164
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Me
Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near MeBook Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Me
Book Call Girls in Hosur - 7001305949 | 24x7 Service Available Near Me
 
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Laxmi Nagar 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
 
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady Presentation
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady PresentationMVP Health Care City of Schenectady Presentation
MVP Health Care City of Schenectady Presentation
 
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls South Delhi | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
 
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...
Rohini Sector 30 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few C...
 
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Sawda 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
 
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original PhotosCall Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
Call Girls Ghaziabad 9999965857 Cheap and Best with original Photos
 
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalore
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service BangaloreCall Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalore
Call Girl Bangalore Aashi 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Bangalore
 
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdf
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdfSARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdf
SARS (SEVERE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME).pdf
 
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...
Housewife Call Girls Nandini Layout - Phone No 7001305949 For Ultimate Sexual...
 
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOW
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOWRussian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOW
Russian Escorts Service Delhi 9711199171 SONI VIP & HOT BOOK NOW
 
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...
Russian Call Girl Chandapura Dommasandra Road - 7001305949 Escorts Service 50...
 
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Mohan Nagar | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
 
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So Far
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So FarSingle Assessment Framework - What We Know So Far
Single Assessment Framework - What We Know So Far
 
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Rohini Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
 
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Service
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts ServiceCall Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Service
Call Girl Service ITPL - [ Cash on Delivery ] Contact 7001305949 Escorts Service
 
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbai
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service MumbaiCollege Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbai
College Call Girls Mumbai Alia 9910780858 Independent Escort Service Mumbai
 
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptx
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptxFAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptx
FAMILY in sociology for physiotherapists.pptx
 
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
Russian Call Girls Ajmeri Gate | 9711199171 | High Profile -New Model -Availa...
 
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...
Gurgaon Sector 45 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few ...
 

Unleashing Massive Healthcare Improvements with Data

  • 1. Unleashing Data: The Key to Driving Massive Improvements Tom Burton, MBA Co-Founder & Chief Improvement Officer, Health Catalyst
  • 2. © 2017 Health Catalyst 2 Learning Objectives • Illustrate the importance of investing in analytics training and infrastructure to prepare for massive improvement in healthcare outcomes. • Demonstrate how to unleash data at your organization with efforts across the improvement spectrum. • Recognize how to sustain and spread improvements across your entire organization.
  • 3. © 2017 Health Catalyst 3 To unleash the full potential of data, organizations should adopt a balanced approach to improvement across the spectrums of both effort and value.
  • 4. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential4 Our Mission: Be the Catalyst for Massive Improvement in Healthcare Outcomes 510+ Team Members 113+ Improvement Case Studies 22 Best Places to Work Awards 90+ Million Patients 400+ Hospitals 4,000+ Clinics Our CustomersOur Company Academic Medical CentersCommunity Hospitals Children’s Hospitals Managed Service Organizations Integrated Delivery Systems Accountable Care Organizations • Stanford – Palo Alto, CA • Albany Medical – Albany, NY • Indiana University – Indianapolis, IN • KUHA – Kansas City, KS • UTMB – Galveston, TX • Dartmouth-Hitchcock – Lebanon, NH • Health Share of Oregon – Portland, OR • CEPAmerica – Oakland, CA • USMM – Troy, MI • North Memorial – Minneapolis, MN • Gulfport Memorial – Gulfport, MS • Thibodaux – Thibodaux, LA • NorthBay – Fairfield, CA • John Muir – Walnut Creek, CA • Gunnison Valley – Gunnison, UT • Texas Children’s – Houston, TX • Children’s Hospital Wisconsin – Milwaukee, WI • MultiCare – Tacoma, WA • Providence – Portland, OR • Alberta Health Services – Edmonton, CA • Memorial Care – Fountain Valley, CA • Cedars-Sinai – Los Angeles, CA • Kaiser – Denver, CO • Unity Point – Des Moines, IA • Queens Health – Honolulu, HI • Community Health Network – Indianapolis, IN • Health Quest – Poughkeepsie, NY • Hawaii Pacific Health – Honolulu, HI • UPMC – Pittsburg, PA • King’s Daughters Medical Center – Ashland, KY • Piedmont – Atlanta, GA • Mission – Asheville, NC • Orlando Health – Orlando, FL • Cone Health – Greensboro, NC • Christiana Care – Wilmington, DE • Westchester – Valhalla, NY • Allina – Minneapolis, MN • Partners – Boston, MA • OSF – Peoria, IL • Springfield Clinic – Springfield, IL • Crystal Run – Middletown, NY • OneCare Vermont – Colchester, VT • Adirondacks ACO – Pittsburg, NY • Adirondacks Health Institute – Glens Falls, NY Health Catalyst Clients:
  • 5. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential5 Unleashing Data to Achieve Massive Improvements Organic Improvement Let innovation happen - Light Effort Fast Track Improvement Medium Effort Comprehensive Outcomes High Effort Value Across the spectrum of improvement effort, the value may be light, medium, or high value. Enablers Highly trained and engaged team members and a robust analytics infrastructure (both platform & applications) Volume 1,000s of day-to-day, better, data-driven decisions 100s of quick win improvements using data 10s of deep changes, eliminating unwarranted clinical, operational and/or financial variation Examples • 2-hour ad-hoc analysis by senior analyst reveals insight that expanding clinic hours, versus building an observation wing, will save $3M in capital expense. • Automated dashboard saves 4 hours of manual data collection/reporting per week. • Data helps clinicians identify high maternal hypertension rates; insights + interventions results in 15% improvement in hypertension rates. • Dashboard helps identify missing documentation on high dollar accounts, improving AR days by 10%. • Deep process redesign, leveraging predictive models, reduces sepsis mortality rate by 15%, saves 125 lives per year, and reduces costs by $1.6 M. • Redesigning care management workflow using mobile technology increases care plan effectiveness by 28% and saves $3.4 M. Sample Results Measures Technology utilization, number of lives impacted/saved, intervention rates, number/percent improvement, additional revenue, cost savings, cost avoidance… Sample Communications Vignettes, improvement snapshots, case study briefs, case studies, webinars, publications…
  • 6. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential6 Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value X Effort High Light High Value Improvement Type The Improvement Spectrum Matrix – Value and Effort
  • 7. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential7 Effort High Light High Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value Improvement Type Overemphasis on Deep Improvement Projects
  • 8. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential8 Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value Effort High Light High Value Improvement Type Overemphasis on Light Effort Projects
  • 9. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential9 Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value Effort High Light High Value Improvement Type Overemphasis on One Value Type
  • 10. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential10 Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value Effort High Light High Value Improvement Type Overemphasis on One Value Type
  • 11. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential11 Effort Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value High Light High Value Improvement Type IDEAL: Even Spread Across the Improvement Spectrum Matrix
  • 12. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which type of improvements does your organization focus on? 147 respondents 1. Clinical – 20% 2. Financial – 13% 3. Patient Experience – 10% 4. Balanced mix – 58% Poll Question #1 12
  • 13. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which quadrant does your organization tend to gravitate toward? 137 respondents 1. High Effort and High Value – 24% 2. High Effort and Light Value – 9% 3. Light Effort and High Value – 24% 4. Light Effort and Light Value – 6% 5. Balanced approach across both spectrums avoiding high effort, light value – 37% Poll Question #2 13
  • 14. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential14 Analogy Is the Key to Understanding
  • 15. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential15 Introducing the Game: SPECTRUM • Adapted by Health Catalyst from the popular strategy game, 7 Wonders. • Objective of the game: Gain the most improvement points. • There are multiple ways to earn improvement points . • 3 years, 7 cards per year. • Play a card and pass the rest to your neighbor.
  • 16. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential16 Each Table Represents a Care Delivery System Each Player Represents a Department in that System
  • 17. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential17 • Competition/conflict Between Departments (+ or - Points Calculated at the End of Each Year) • Budget for Improvement Efforts (1 point / 3 coins) • Data-Driven Culture (on game board) • Light Effort Improvements • Collaboration Between Departments • System-Wide Adoption • High Effort Clinical, Financial, and Patient Experience Improvements Scoring: Improvement Point Categories Improvement point symbol At the end of Year III, once the budget disputes have been resolved, the players total their improvement points on the scoring sheet in each of the following categories:
  • 18. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential18 Game Board Layout Key
  • 19. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential19 Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success • Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards) – Acquire Data – Grant Access to Data – Build Actionable Metrics – Find Insights in Data • Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards) – Analytics Engineer – Change Agent – Key Stakeholder • Progress on your journey toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board) – From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics – Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
  • 20. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential20 Only 8% of data required for the population health and precision medicine strategy resides in today’s EMR/EHR. Source: Alberta Innovates Health Solutions, Secondary Data Use Project, March 2016 http://www.aihealthsolutions.ca/initiatives- partnerships/secondary-use-data-project/presentations/ Acquire Data . . .
  • 21. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential21 Just Beginning: Digitization of Health The Growing Ecosystem of Human Health Data Healthcare Encounter Data 7x24 Biometric Data Consumer Data Genomic & Familial Data Social Data Outcomes Data
  • 22. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential22 Imagine the Richness of the Picture 22 The Growing Ecosystem of Human Health Data Healthcare Encounter Data 7x24 Biometric Data Consumer Data Genomic & Familial Data Social Data Outcomes Data What is your 1, 3, and 5 year strategic data acquisition plan?
  • 23. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential23 Acquire Data Gartner: Health Data Convergence Hub “Definition: The health data convergence hub is the orchestration platform that brings together data from across the consumer/citizen/patient health and wellness continuum and prepares the data for delivery to downstream consumption platforms, applications, analytics and "things." It automates the ingestion of data — both structured and unstructured — from all identified and permissioned sources; provides tracking and traceability; and manages identity, compliance and security. It may process algorithms and deliver the output to the correct modality.” - Laura Craft, Vi Shaffer, “Gartner: Hype Cycle for Healthcare Providers, 2017”
  • 24. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential24 From Data Warehouse to Data Operating System Traditional Data Warehouse Health Data Convergence Hub HC: Data Operating System 1. Collects data from EHR & Claims 2. Enables creating static reports 3. Enables SQL queries 4. Data is updated nightly 5. Not available in the EHR workflow 6. Requires replacing your existing DW 7. Proprietary schemas 8. Deals with tables and columns 1. Collects data from many sources 2. Enables creating static reports and web/mobile apps 3. Enables SQL, R, Python, Deep Learning queries 4. Data is always up-to-date 5. Insights are easily available in the EHR workflow 6. Works with your existing DW (or use our DW) 7. Industry standard schemas e.g., FHIR 8. Deals with tables, columns and clinical entities like registries, measures 9. Provides centralized security at app and data levels 10. Machine Learning is as easy to use as SQL 11. Content Marketplace to share executable content with other health systems
  • 25. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential25 Acquire Data Key Concepts To Accelerate Data Acquisition Late-binding – don’t early bind complex data and waste valuable time during data acquisitions by binding raw data into strict definitions, unless there is persistent and global agreement, rather co-locate data into Source Data Marts or Data Lakes with minimal transformation, allowing for flexibility in multiple future use-cases. Automation Tools – Use tools which automate the tedious and predictable steps of building data marts. (e.g. Source Connectors, SMD, SAMD) Leverage Big Data Capabilities – Make sure your data platform can leverage silicon valley technologies like Hadoop/Spark, Machine Learning, Natural Language Processing etc.
  • 26. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential26 Grant Access One of the most challenging polarities for organizations to balance is how to grant access to data.
  • 27. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential27 Data Access Polarity: Data Protection AND Data Sharing Symptoms of Extreme: • Legitimate data request denied. • IT controls all final signoff for data access. • 6 month process to get access. Symptoms of Extreme: • Data breach. • Inappropriate data use. Evidence of Balance: • Streamlined access approval process. • Consistent regular auditing. • Appropriate use of data. • Data stewards grant access.
  • 28. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential28 Grant Access #1 Polarity: Data Sharing AND Data Protection Key Concepts in Granting Access effectively Data Steward Ownership - Shift access decision away from IT into clinical/business owners hands – IT usually overemphasizes data protection. Trust but Verify – Assume good intent and grant access to data more liberally but increase your frequency and depth of your auditing capability. Create Team- or Role-based data access policies – Streamline granting access to entire teams or role groups to access data for improvement purposes. When a new individual joins a group or gets a new role, access is automatically granted.
  • 29. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential29 Build Actionable Metrics The most sophisticated and accurate predictive model is worthless unless it promotes an action that would otherwise not have happened.
  • 30. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential30 The 5 Rights of Information Delivery The How: We believe if you get the • Right Information, to the • Right Audience, at the • Right Granularity, at the • Right Time, in the • Right Visualization/Modality … you produce the Right Action, to Improve Outcomes The Why:
  • 31. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential31 Discover Insight Data becomes valuable when an insight is discovered, such as a trend, pattern, correlation, or causation.
  • 32. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential32 Average Before=8 hours delay Average After=3 hours delay Is This Result Good? Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 16-17 Poor sample size, looks like improvement but no improvement occurred in reality Trend occurred naturally, Intervention didn’t cause improvement Change wasn’t permanent, numbers are slipping Improvement happened before intervention, not because of intervention Outlier caused process to look like it needed improvement Real improvement caused by intervention
  • 33. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential33 Why Traditional Scorecards Lack Insight Metric Region 1 Region 2 Overall Score Financial Metric XX.X XX.X XX.X Quality Metric YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y Experience Metric ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z Scorecard Shows: Current Measurement vs. Target. Does not show: Trend, Variation, Noise vs. Signal, Drill-down detail. Static Report Shows: Current Measurement compared with Historic. Does not show: Variation, Noise vs. Signal, Trend (very well), drill-down detail. Metric Last Year Current Year LY Current Month LY Year To Date Current Month Year to Date Financial Metric XX.X XX.X XX.X XX.X Quality Metric YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y YY.Y Experience Metric ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z ZZ.Z Scorecard Static Report
  • 34. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential34 Insight Trap: Rush to Judgment and Punish the Outliers Current Condition • Significant Volume. • Significant Variation. Option 1: “Punish the Outliers” or “Cut Off the Tail” Strategy • Set a minimum standard of quality. • Focus improvement effort on those people not meeting the minimum standard. # of Cases Mean Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes # of Cases Focus on Minimum Standard Metric Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes
  • 35. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential35 Leveraging Insight Learning Approach: Focus on Better Process Option 2: Identify Best Practice “Narrow the curve and shift it to the right” Strategy • Identify evidenced based “Shared Baseline.” • Focus improvement effort on reducing process variation by following the “Shared Baseline.” • Often those performing the best make the greatest improvements. Excellent Outcomes # of Cases Focus on Best Practice Care Process Model Poor Outcomes Current Condition • Significant Volume. • Significant Variation. # of Cases Mean Excellent OutcomesPoor Outcomes
  • 36. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential36 Variation Over Time Mean Upper Control Limit Lower Control Limit Adapted from R.C. Lloyd & Associates Current Condition
  • 37. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential37 Mean Upper Control Limit Lower Control Limit Adapted from R.C. Lloyd & Associates Variation Over Time Variation Reduction
  • 38. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential38 New Mean Reduce Variation and Improve Outcomes Intervention
  • 39. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential39 Using Control Charts to Discover Insights Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 116
  • 40. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential40 Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success • Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards) – Acquire Data – Grant Access to data – Build Actionable Metrics – Find Insights in data • Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards) – Analytics Engineer – Change Agent – Key Stakeholder • Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board) – From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics – Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
  • 41. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential41 “I told you I wasn’t a hunter gather. I’m an analyst!” 28 Train Analytics Engineer
  • 42. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential42 Once Better Infrastructure Is in Place Analytics Engineers Have More Time to Interpret Data Non value-add work Value-add work Understanding the question Hunting for data Interpreting data Distributing data Gathering, compiling or running Weak Analytic System Strong Analytic System Understanding the question Hunting for data Interpreting data Distributing data Gather, compiling or running *poll of Analyst customer pre Catalyst Analytics Platform install 75%* of analyst time is spent in hunting & gathering in a weak analytics system
  • 43. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential43 Core Create insights Present insights in a compelling way Understanding of healthcare data Core Technical PL/SQL Data modeling Visualization & reporting tools Needed for the Future • Stats, predictive, machine learning, AI, etc. • Visualization principles (e.g. Tufte, Few) • Quality improvement (e.g. Lean, 6 Sigma) • Project management The Skills Needed in the Analytics Space
  • 44. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential44 You must have both the technical skill AND the clinical or operational context (this is usually best achieved by partnering with a change agent who has deep domain knowledge). Otherwise, you might jump to the wrong conclusions … Insights Require Technical Skill AND Context Higher ice cream sales We taste better More shark attacks - - Stop selling ice cream! Warmer weather Higher ice cream sales More shark attacks
  • 45. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential45 Recruit Change Agent "In times of change, learners inherit the future, while the learned find themselves beautifully equipped to deal with a world that no longer exists." - Eric Hoffer
  • 46. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential46 Diffusion of Innovation Change Agents Are Typically Early Adopter SMEs Innovators early adopters early majority laggards (never adopters) * Adapted from Rogers, E. Diffusion of Innovations. New York, NY: 1995. late majority Innovators. Recruit innovators to re-design care delivery processes TheChasm N = number of individuals in group N N = number needed to influence group (but they must be the right individuals) Early adopters. Recruit early adopters to chair improvement and to lead implementation at each site. (key individuals who can rally support)
  • 47. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential47 Select Early Adopters Leaders • You need both willing and able leaders. • Identify those wanting to lead permanent improvement efforts – throw their hat in the ring (willingness). • Allow those not wishing to lead to participate in the selection process (recommend top 3 picks – those with natural leadership = ability ). • Executive leadership can select from top recommendations the most open minded leaders and give them decision rights. • Involvement in the selection process leads to much, much better adoption later (“Onboard for the take-off not just the crash-landing.” – Dr. David Burton).
  • 48. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential48 Change Agent Role: Preparing People for Change Awareness Desire Knowledge & Ability Actively Sustaining Time Productivity&Performance High Low Keep the chaos period as short as possible Minimize the loss of Productivity & Engagement Change!  Ensure managers/leaders are informed and prepared to lead their teams through the change – available and active.  Warn people that the process may be uncomfortable, but that they will survive.  Identify champions to represent key player groups in the design and implementation process.  Leadership defines the why the change is needed, sets the vision, then defines the sandbox for those impacted to participate in designing the future.
  • 49. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential49 Engage Key Stakeholders “Things get done only if the data we gather can inform and inspire those in a position to make a difference.” –Mike Schmoker
  • 50. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential50 Four Levels of Stakeholder Information Needs Stakeholder Group Key Data Need Group Role Executive Prioritization & Visibility Controls resources and funding allocations. Domain Leadership Prioritization & Visibility Understands domain interactions and tradeoffs (clinical, operational or financial). Adoption Best Practice Tracking & Actionable Metrics Influences others and encourages change (adoption of new processes). Innovation Process Design & Outcomes Prediction Identifies root cause of poor outcomes and designs better processes to produce better outcomes.
  • 51. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential51 Example Stakeholder Analysis STAKEHOLDER IMPACT IMPORTANCE MATRIX AREA (see Stakeholder Matrix) Current HEAT Projected HEAT Projected HEAT Name of functional role/group affected by the change Degree of impact on this stakeholder Level of stakeholder's influence on the success of the change Where do they land on the stakeholder matrix? Today After CEO Email goes out After the details of the role changes are shared SVPs (SEL) significant medium a. KEY PLAYER productive zone productive zone productive zone SVPs (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER overwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed EL significant medium a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone STDs significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed TDs significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone SDAs / DAs (Tech Ops Pool) significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed Domain Experts (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed Analytic Dirs (IL) significant a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed SDAs / DAs (IL) significant high a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed Analysts (Prod Dev) significant a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed underwhelmed overwhelmed Leadership Team moderate high a. KEY PLAYER overwhelmed overwhelmed overwhelmed HR minor or none medium c. keep informed productive zone productive zone productive zone Finance - FPA moderate medium a. KEY PLAYER underwhelmed productive zone productive zone Accounting moderate Low c. keep informed underwhelmed productive zone productive zone Marketing minor or none Low c. keep informed underwhelmed productive zone productive zone Customers moderate Low d. Keep satisfied productive zone underwhelmed productive zone Identify Champions to represent large groups. Keep Satisfied Meet Their Needs Key Player Manage Closely Monitor Minimum Effort Keep Informed Show Consideration Low High High Low Interest of Stakeholders Power/Influence ofStakeholders
  • 52. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential52 Provide Visibility to All Stakeholders Shared Accountability Date: 10/1/2015 Overall Status Risks and Uncertainties Recruit /Train Kickoff AIM Intervention Rollout plan Results Aug 2015 Aug 2015 Sep 2015 -- Sep 2015 Oct 2015 Guidance team Mission, charter, roles confirmed Review draft cohort and data Finalize cohort Define rollout plan Review initial results Content and Analytics Lead Review AIM options Data quality issues identified Identify intervention(s) Guidance team validation Implementation plan adjusted Implementation team Best practice gathering Direct observation Direct observation Solicit front-line plan input Review lessons learned Workgroup team Profile prelim. data and cohort Prioritize, select AIM Solicit front line input Finalize rollout plan Create AIM statement #2 Workgroup training Guidance team validation Refine cohort and metrics Analytics dev & test Guidance team validation Repeat process Guidance team validation Improvement Initiative Progress Key not started In process done well some concerns strong concerns Accomplishments Next Steps Issues / Help needed • Feedback sessions with SMEs • Consolidate app versions • Define rollout plan • QV access Long-term AIM Goal To realize X% in shared savings in the JCL ACO by the end of 2015. Going forward, achieve and sustain a X% reduction in the PMPM, a X% reduction in patient leakage, and a X% decrease in out-of-network referrals by February 2016. AIM Performance Goal #1: Source CMS Claims data into the EDW by September 15th, 2015. Wire up the Shared Accountability application to claims data, and show incremental value via the ability to determine JCL ACO network leakage as well as PMPM costs, by October 1st, 2015. Launch/Rolloutdate:10/1/2015
  • 53. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential53 Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success • Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards) – Acquire Data – Grant Access to data – Build Actionable Metrics – Find Insights in data • Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards) – Analytics Engineer – Change Agent – Key Stakeholder • Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board) – From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics – Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
  • 54. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential54 Developing a Data Driven Culture “We’ve got to use every piece of data and piece of information, and hopefully that will help us be accurate with our player evaluation. For us, that’s our life blood.” - Billy Beane, General Manager Oakland A’s
  • 55. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential55 The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture Spreadsheet Silos • Silos or pockets of analysis. • Conflicting spreadsheet reports and interpretations of data. • Battles over data ownership. • Most time spent on hunting for and gathering data. • Focus is on is the data “right.” Centralized Reporting Diabetes Sepsis Readmissions Common, linkable vocabulary Financial Source Marts Administrative Source Marts Departmental Source Marts EMR Source Marts Patient Satisfaction Source Mart FINANCIAL SOURCES (e.g. EPSi, Peoplesoft, Lawson) ADMINISTRATIVE SOURCES (e.g. API Time Tracking) EMR SOURCEs (e.g. Cerner, Allscripts, NextGen) DEPARTMENTAL SOURCES (e.g. Apollo) Pt. SATISFACTION SOURCES (e.g. NRC Picker, Press Ganey) • Centralized single source of truth established in EDW. • Significant time spent on standardizing definitions. • Data begins to be trusted. • Report queue begins to build. • Focus is on requirements for dashboard applications and reports. Data-Driven Improvement Culture • Improvement teams use analytics to accelerate best practice adoption. • Data drives decisions and actions. • Focus is on growing and sustaining outcomes improvement through elimination of waste and variation leveraging analytics.
  • 56. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential56 Analytics Embedded in Workflow Imagine: Facebook as an EHR From a blog Dale Sanders wrote in 2010 • Patient’s evolving health story at the center of the record, not the encounter. • Embedded video and images. • Text and discrete data. • Secure messaging. • Social support from family & friends • Flexible security, defined by the patient. They expand our sense of connectedness. Analytics is embedded… it’s ambient to the experience.
  • 57. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential57 Analytics Embedded in Workflow Imagine: Amazon as a Clinical Order Entry System • Drug and device availability • Pricing • Home delivery • Automatic refills • Patient reported outcomes From a blog Dale Sanders wrote in 2010
  • 58. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential58 Kawamoto et al, University of Utah, BMJ, 2005 Physicians are 15x more likely to change their ordering and treatment protocols if presented with substantiating data at the point of care vs. presented with the same data in a clinical process improvement meeting.
  • 59. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential59 The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture InformationCost Information Benefit High Low High Bubble Size = Count of Information Type Lower the cost of building reports through more automated data acquisition tools. Analytics Embedded in Workflow Software Predictive Models/ Machine Learning Dynamic Visualizations (e.g. Qlik Tableau) Parameter Based Reports Static Reports & Score Cards
  • 60. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential60 The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture Analytics Embedded in Workflow Software Predictive Models/ Machine Learning Dynamic Visualizations (e.g. Qlik Tableau) Parameter Based Reports Static Reports & Score Cards InformationCost Information Benefit High Low High Bubble Size = Count of Information Type Lower the cost of building more advanced analytics by leveraging better design tools and well trained Analytics Engineers.
  • 61. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential61 The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture InformationCost Information Benefit High Low High Bubble Size = Count of Information Type Replace & consolidate static reports and score cards with more advanced analytics over time. Analytics Embedded in Workflow Software Predictive Models/ Machine Learning Dynamic Visualizations (e.g. Qlik Tableau) Parameter Based Reports Static Reports & Score Cards
  • 62. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential62 The Journey Towards a Data-Driven Culture InformationCost Information Benefit High Low High Bubble Size = Count of Information Type Dramatically increase analytics embedded in workflow as they are 15 X more likely to be adopted. Analytics Embedded in Workflow Software Predictive Models/ Machine Learning Dynamic Visualizations (e.g. Qlik Tableau) Parameter Based Reports Static Reports & Score Cards
  • 63. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential63 Capabilities to SCALE Outcomes Improvement Leadership, Culture, and Governance Financial Alignment Where do we focus? How are we compensated? What should we be doing? How are we doing? How do we change? Clinical Outcomes Cost Outcomes Experience Outcomes
  • 64. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential64 Principles – Spectrum Year 1 – Invest for Success • Invest in Data Infrastructure (The Brown Cards) – Acquire Data – Grant Access to data – Build Actionable Metrics – Find Insights in data • Invest in People - Train Key Roles and Skills (The Gray Cards) – Analytics Engineer – Change Agent – Key Stakeholder • Progress on your Journey Toward a Data-Driven Culture (Game Board) – From Scorecards to Embedded Analytics – Data-driven Culture Core Capabilities
  • 65. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which infrastructure component does your organization struggle with? 154 respondents 1. Acquiring data – 29% 2. Granting access to data – 10% 3. Building actionable metrics – 32% 4. Finding insights in data – 29% Poll Question #3 65
  • 66. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which role is the most scarce in your organization? 154 respondents 1. Analytics engineer – 51% 2. Change agent – 43% 3. Key stakeholder – 6% Poll Question #4 66
  • 67. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which capability/question does your organization struggle with most? 151 respondents 1. Analytics: How are we doing? – 14% 2. Best Practice: What should we be doing? – 7% 3. Adoption: How do we change? – 51% 4. Financial Alignment: How are we compensated? – 10% 5. Governance: Where do we focus? – 18% Poll Question #5 67
  • 68. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential68 Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum • On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?) – Return on Luck – Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity) – Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness) • Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards) – The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement – Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story • Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards) – Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology – Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams • No Margin, No Mission (The Coins) – Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations – Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains – Overhead Value Analysis
  • 69. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential69 On-Going Opportunity Analysis “Luck is not the key. How you handle good or bad luck is what matters.” - Jim Collins
  • 70. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential70 Return on Luck – Jim Collins Return on Luck Keys • Do both great and mediocre companies encounter the same amount of luck, good and bad? - YES • What can you do to capitalize on your luck? • Have you turned your bad-luck events into a big part of what makes your company great? • Are you squandering your good luck events? Good Luck • Governor with healthcare background is elected. • Payer agrees to shared savings upside opportunity. • Local provider wants to join healthcare system and open an institute. Bad Luck • Joint Commission visits at a bad time. • New regulatory reporting required. • Major philanthropy contributor stops giving. • Competitor opens new facility. • PCP refers out of network. Common “Luck” Events in Healthcare
  • 71. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential71 Build a Pipeline of Opportunities One of the Analytics Engineer’s primary roles is to fill the pipeline of insights and potential improvement opportunities. Pipeline should exceed the execution capacity of the organization. • Motivates an increase in capacity. • Teaches the organization to prioritize based on highest value. • Allows for back-up opportunities to be advanced should a high priority initiative stall indefinitely. Do not limit pipeline to high-effort opportunities. Many organic improvements can occur simply by exposing the opportunity.
  • 72. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential72 Value Type Financial (Hard $) Clinical / Operational Experience Light < 1 FTE or $XXX Process Metric Improved Save Clinician or Patient Time Medium > 1 < 3 FTE Patient Outcome Improved Overall Satisfaction score improves High > 3 FTE Life Saved Evaluate Each Opportunity Return on Investment Effort to Achieve • Light: < 1 FTE investment • Medium: > 1 but < 3 FTE • High: > 3 FTE investment Value of Opportunity Capability • Do we have the skills required? What would it take to gain skills? • Do we have the equipment/tools required? Capacity • Do the stakeholders required to make the change have the time to focus on this improvement? What can we take off their plate? Willingness • Is there an acceptance of the need for change? Do we have front-line buy-in? • How much resistance will be encountered? From whom? (mini stakeholder analysis) Organizational Readiness
  • 73. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential73 Readiness Assessment • Quickly asses readiness with on-line surveys. (e.g. use something like survey monkey or Health Catalyst provides a free on-line Outcomes Improvement Readiness Assessment at https://oira.healthcatalyst.com . • As you focus in on specific initiatives spend the time to interview key stakeholders of the most important improvement initiatives and assess capability, capacity and willingness.
  • 74. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential74 Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum • On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?) – Return on Luck – Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity) – Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness) • Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards) – The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement – Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story • Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards) – Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology – Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams • No Margin, No Mission (The Coins) – Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations – Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains – Overhead Value Analysis
  • 75. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential75 Light Effort Organic Improvements To promote organic improvements organize Analytic Resources in a Hub and Spoke model Centralized (Hub) • Analytics Infrastructure. • Analytic Engineer Training. – Tool Training. – Visualization standards. – Statistical Analysis. – Machine learning. • Data Governance. – Data Steward Training. – Common Metric definitions. – Data Quality Standards. – Standardized Visualization Look & Feel to promote ease of use. De-centralized (Spoke) • Responding to departmental questions using Ad-hoc queries or analysis. • Custom dashboard development. • Interpretation of data, based on local context and knowledge.
  • 76. 76 • Access to content enabled through a security model endorsed by senior leadership. • Provisioning process well defined and operationalized. Broadly Accessible Data • Analytic tool capabilities support what end users are trying to do. • Analytic community has the ability to share and distribute content. Analytic Toolset Alignment • Teams are provided education on the core capabilities to support their use of the data. • Support function available to answer and direct questions. Training & Support • Continuants understand what is available, what is changing, and what is coming. • Value being delivered by the platform is consistently and broadly being messaged. Communication • Individual or group is on point to grow analytics capabilities. • Ensure evolving roadmap aligns with business/clinical priorities. Analytics Leadership The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement
  • 77. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential77 Organic Improvements – Be Opportunistic Texas Children’s Example Context • Working on Asthma Action Plan Initiative. Discovery • While exploring the data MD Leader and Analytics Engineer find anomalies in data around chest x-rays unrelated to the asthma action plan initiative. • Appears high percentage of chest x-rays from ED are unwarranted. • Analytics Engineer, performs deeper analysis within a few hours and discovers highly utilized order set used by Resident MDs in ED. Intervention • New default orders set using best practice intervention criteria for x-ray designed to replaces old order set. • Resident MDs in ED instructed to use new order set for children presenting with asthma. Result • Achieved and sustained a 49 % decrease in unnecessary chest x-ray orders. – Better Care for Patients – Elimination of Unnecessary Cost – No Extra X-ray Exposure to Kids • Value = High • Effort = Light
  • 78. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential78 Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum • On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?) – Return on Luck – Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity) – Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness) • Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards) – The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement – Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story • Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards) – Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology – Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams • No Margin, No Mission (The Coins) – Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations – Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains – Overhead Value Analysis
  • 79. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential79 Rosetta Stone: Translation between different improvement methodologies. Key Principle: Pick ONE Methodology and use it consistently across your organization Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology
  • 80. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential80 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Analyze the Opportunity and Define the Problem. Scope the Opportunity and Set Goals. Explore Root Causes and Set Process Aims. Design Interventions and Plan Initial Implementation Implement Interventions and Measure Results. Monitor, Adjust, and Continually Learn. Diffuse and Sustain. Is it an adoption problem? Are data valid? Do we need to adjust our interventions? Do we need to reevaluate root cause? Start with a directive from executive leadership based on high-level opportunity analysis and readiness assessment The Seven Essential Elements of Improvement
  • 81. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential81 Organization of Teams Clinical and Technical Prioritization Adoption Innovation etc. Outcomes Improvement Executive Leadership Team Content & Analytics Team(s) Data Governance Committee Domain Guidance Team Provides domain oversight and drives priorities Outcomes Improvement Team(s) Drives innovation & adoption Workgroup(s) as needed Workgroup(s) as needed Innovates Domain 1 Domain 2
  • 82. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential82 Women & Newborn Guidance Team - Prioritization Key Key Stakeholder Change Agent/SME Analytics Engineer Structure Typically Needed for Deep Effort Improvements • Meet quarterly to prioritize allocation of technical staff. • Approves improvement AIMs • Reviews progress and removes road blocks. OB NewbornGYN Women & Newborn Guidance Leadership Dyad: 1) MD Clinical Program Director 2) Administrative Director Domain Leadership Dyads: 1) MD Lead & 2) RN Lead. SME Data Steward Analytics Engineer Analytics Team covers entire guidance team. Financial Analyst Small Teams - Innovation • Integrates Data from all relevant sources. • Meet weekly in iteration planning meeting to identify improvement opportunity and insights. • Build DRAFT processes, metrics, interventions & presents DRAFT work to Broader Teams. • Grants access of analytic assets to broader team. Domain Leadership Dyad + Analytics Team OB Workgroup Broad Teams – Adoption • Broad RN and MD representation across system. • Meet monthly to review, adjust and approve DRAFTs. • Act as change agents to lead rollout of new process and measurement. Guidance Leadership Dyad. + Domain Leadership Dyad. + Analytics Team. + Clinical representation from across system. *All resources serve in these improvement roles part time ranging from 5% (MDs) to 50% (Analytics Engineer) of their time.
  • 83. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential83 Process Aim: By X date increase the number of patients who have follow-up completed within 7 days from X% to Y%. Outcome Goal: By X date decrease readmits from 22.1% to 17.7%. Track follow-up compliance (hospitalists, advanced practitioner, cardiology nurse) discharge and post results weekly. Develop, educate, and implement on a discharge scheduling protocol to facilitate improved appointment follow-up 7 days per week. Intervention #1 Intervention #2 Heart Failure Example, Focus on Transitions
  • 84. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential84 Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum • On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?) – Return on Luck – Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity) – Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness) • Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards) – The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement – Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story • Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards) – Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology – Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams • No Margin, No Mission (The Coins) – Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations – Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains – Overhead Value Analysis
  • 85. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential85 Funding Improvement Work “No Margin, No Mission” »Sister Irene Kraus Founding Chief Executive of the Daughters of Charity National Health System American Hospital Association Chair
  • 86. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential86 Funding Improvement Work Involve the Finance Team Early in the Process Working with CFO sanctioned financial analyst or other key stakeholders:  Set baseline costs for current process  Calculate improvement value: - Hard Cost Savings = $ will be removed from the budget next year - Soft Cost Efficiency Gain = Improvement efficiency will allow for employee to work on higher priority tasks - Cost Avoidance = Project the value of reversing a trend such as an upward cost trend that becomes flat due to improvement efforts  Negotiate with Payers on shared savings opportunities
  • 87. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential87 The Right Granularity: Best Practice Compliance Admits/1000 members IP days/1000 members OP visits/1000 members Procedures/1000 members ED visits/1000 members Readmissions/1000 members Utilization Who should get the care? Cost/case Cost/procedure OR minutes L&D minutes Other LOS Order Sets Clinical Support Workflow Cost per case Nursing hours by unit OR minutes L&D minutes Cycle times Cost per ancillary test Environmental services What care should be included? How can care be delivered efficiently ? Indications for Intervention Diagnostic algorithms Indications for Referral Triage Criteria Treatment and Monitoring Algorithms Health Maintenance and Preventive Guidelines Standardized Follow-up Checklist Post-acute care order sets IP (SNF, IRF) Home health, Hospice Clinical Ops Procedure Guidelines Granularity Substance Selection Clinical Supply Chain Management Admission Order Sets Supplementary Order Sets Pre-Procedure Order Sets Post-procedure Order Sets Bedside Care Practice Guidelines Discharge Checklist Patient Injury Prevention Protocol Risk Assessment Transfer Checklist Question Examples of Best Practice Standard Possible Measures Administrative Support Workflow How can administrative operations be performed efficiently ? AR Escalation Process Network Design Process Recruiting/Onboarding Process AR Days % out of network utilization % Turnover Team member satisfaction/engagement AR Escalation Process Budgeting Process Supply Chain Procurement
  • 88. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential88 Involve Finance Early: Payment Model Considerations = Negative Impact = Positive or Negative = Positive Impact Improvement Type Discounted FFS Per Diem Per Case Bundled Per Case Condition Capitation Full Capitation CMS Commercial CMS Commercial Workflow Diagnostic Variation Standing Orders MedicationSelection Triage Patient Safety Ambulatory Treatment and Monitoring Indications for Referral Indications for Intervention Operational Workflow Diagnostic Variation Standing Orders Substance Selection Triage Criteria Patient Safety Treatment and Monitoring Algorithms Indications for Referral Indications for Intervention 25 Administrative Workflow Depending on the type of improvement, the financial impact could be positive or negative based on the payment model mix. Therefore, proactively involve finance and negotiate shared savings with payers up-front when possible.
  • 89. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential89 Funding Improvement Work: Balancing Value Mix Helps Fund Clinical & Experience Improvements High Light High Value IDEAL: Even spread across the Improvement Spectrum Matrix Effort Financial Value Clinical Value Experience Value Improvement Type As your governance team prioritizes improvement initiative make sure that the projected hard $ cost savings can fund the improvement efforts required across all value types.
  • 90. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential90 Funding Improvement Work: Overhead Value Analysis • Frequently an organization has built up a large inventory of regularly produced reports (with an associated cost) • In addition, many vended technical point-solutions continue to be maintained over decades (with an associated maintenance fee) • Overhead Value Analysis is the “spring cleaning process” of reviewing the cost to maintain or produce these analytic assets compared with the benefit each currently is providing the organization.
  • 91. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential91 Principles – Spectrum Year 2 – Leverage the Entire Spectrum • On-Going Opportunity Analysis (What card should I play?) – Return on Luck – Build an Opportunity Pipeline (at least 3 X your capacity) – Evaluate Each Opportunity (Effort, Value, Capability, Capacity, and Willingness) • Light Effort Improvements (The Blue Cards) – The Prerequisites of Organic Improvement – Be Opportunistic – TCH – Chest X-ray Story • Deep Continuous Improvement (The Green Cards) – Avoiding the Tower of Babel – Pick ONE Improvement Methodology – Organize Consistent On-going Interdisciplinary Teams • No Margin, No Mission (The Coins) – Involve the Finance Team Early and Establish Baselines for ROI Calculations – Fund Clinical Outcomes with Financial Results in Other Domains – Overhead Value Analysis
  • 92. © 2017 Health Catalyst How does your organization prioritize opportunities for outcomes improvement? 122 respondents 1. We can’t say no to anything. – 14% 2. We estimate the value to the organization. – 9% 3. We estimate both effort and value. – 20% 4. We estimate effort, value, and readiness. – 25% 5. It’s all about the politics. – 32% Poll Question #6 92
  • 93. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which of the prerequisites of organic improvement is weakest in your organization? 121 respondents 1. Broadly accessible data. – 22% 2. Alignment around an analytic toolset. – 18% 3. Analytic training and support. – 25% 4. Communication of analytic value and roadmap. – 31% 5. All of these components are working well. – 4% Poll Question #7 93
  • 94. © 2017 Health Catalyst True or False: My organization has stale analytic reports that are never used but continue to be produced? 144 respondents 1. True – 73% 2. False – 27% Poll Question #8 94
  • 95. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential95 Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread • Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow Cards) – Improve Data Quality. – Train for Data Literacy. – Promote Appropriate Data Access. • System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards) – Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group). – Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette). – Establish Improvement Governance. • Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards) – The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions. – The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work. – Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
  • 96. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential96 Interdepartmental Collaboration “Coming together is a beginning. Keeping together is progress. Working together is success.” -Henry Ford
  • 97. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential97 Definition of Data Governance Data governance refers to the plans, processes, and principles that are proactively applied to ensure that an organization’s data is managed in such a way to maximize the value of that data to the organization.
  • 98. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential98 The Triple Aim of Data Governance 1. Ensuring Data Quality • Data Quality = Completeness x Accuracy x Timeliness. 2. Building Data Literacy • Train on analytics basics (Data Awareness). • Technical tools and analytic techniques (Analytics Team). • Data content (Context provided by Data Stewards). 3. Maximizing Data Utilization • Promote cross-department appropriate usage of data. Track # of users per month by dashboard. Measure direct access. https://www.healthcatalyst.com/demystifying-healthcare-data-governance Utilization
  • 99. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential99 Data Use Defines Data Quality Requirements Balance the cost of achieving data quality with benefit. Data Use Category Improvement Comparison or Accountability Research Aim Outcomes Improvement Comparison, Choice, Spur Change Discover New Knowledge Test observability Test Observable No Test Test Blinded Sample size Just Enough Obtain 100% Just in case Flexibility of hypothesis Flexible, Changes as Learning Takes Place No Hypothesis Fixed Is change an improvement? Run Charts and Shewart Charts No Change Focus T-Test, F-Test, p-value Cost of data quality Low/Medium High Medium/High Common challenges Tendency to Apply More Rigor Than Needed Data Often Used for Punishment Access to Data Sometimes Problematic Adapted from The Health Care Data Guide, p. 27
  • 100. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential100 Data Literacy - Typical Current State • Large backlogs of analytic/report requests. • Knowledge workers = clinical or operational knowledge AND access to tools and data. Knowledge Workers Drillers Viewers User Distribution
  • 101. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential101 Authors or Knowledge Workers Viewers Drillers Knowledge Workers Data Literacy - Desired Future State Increase number of knowledge workers by doing the following: • Expand data access. • Simplify data structures. • Continue use of naming standards. • Provide better tools. Promote shift in culture by rewarding process knowledge discovery rather than punishing outliers. Desired User Distribution
  • 102. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential102 Trust but Verify: The Importance of Broad Access AND Auditing Key Polarity: Grant Broad Access to Promote Utilization AND Rigorously Audit Appropriate Use of Data https://www.idera.com/productssolutions/sqlserver/sqlcompliancemanager Idera Compliance Manager Audit tool example: Idera Compliance Manager
  • 103. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential103 Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread • Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow Cards) – Improve Data Quality. – Train for Data Literacy. – Promote Appropriate Data Access. • System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards) – Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group). – Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette). – Establish Improvement Governance. • Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards) – The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions. – The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work. – Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
  • 104. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential104 Analytical Services Working Group (ASWG) User Group Purpose of ASWG: Serve as a forum where analysts from the various domains within the organization can collaborate to define standards and share knowledge.
  • 105. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential105 Analytical Services Working Group (ASWG) Responsibility Summary Define information and analytical standards. • Standardize calculations and definitions. • Recommend tools and processes. • Establish data quality standards. Provide technical and domain cross-training. Information consumers (analysts) provide feedback to technical staff on tools, information, performance, processes, etc… Technical staff (analytics engineer team) provides status updates and notices to analysts on infrastructure and content.
  • 106. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential106 System-Wide Adoption “Run your analytics department like a small business.” - Dale Sanders
  • 107. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential107 Data-Driven Outcomes Improvement & Decision Making Service Oriented Engaged, High Contributing Analytics Engineers Satisfied, Empowered Analytics Customers Scalable, Sustainable Products Employee Focused Technically Sound Analytic Asset Adoption Running Your Analytics Department Like a Small Business
  • 108. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential108 System-wide Adoption: Effective Marketing Effectively Marketing your Analytics Department requires Two key elements: • Educate – Let the organization know what’s available. – Help them become more sophisticated users of analytics. • Share Results – Success breeds success. – Publish Improvement Vignettes.
  • 109. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential109 NO READMITS Bundle Successfully Lowers COPD Readmissions Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) is responsible for approximately 135,000 deaths annually, making it the third leading cause of death in the U.S. Nationally, there are approximately 700,000 hospitalizations with the principal diagnosis of COPD each year, with one in five patients being readmitted within 30 days. The national average cost for a COPD readmission is between $9,000 and $12,000. 95% of COPD patients assessed for readmission risk. 17% reduction in readmission rate. Approximately 34 fewer patients with COPD readmitted each year, saving an estimated $360,000 annually based on national benchmarks. 9% improvement in PCP notification. 97% of patients with COPD get an order set. Building from work done by the Heart Failure team, MultiCare's Medicine Collaborative developed a NOREADMITS bundle consisting of nine interventions for patients with COPD who are not mechanically ventilated. The intent of the bundle was to decrease the likelihood of readmission. After less than nine months, they achieved the following results:
  • 110. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential110 [Headline – the One Sentence Grabber] The Setting: What is the situation and context? The Challenge: What was the complication? What problem are we solving? The Result: What happened? What was improved? The Turning Point: What interventions where used to make a difference? How were analytics used in solving the problem? What expertise was needed for the improvement? Organization Logo
  • 111. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential111 System-Wide Adoption: Improvement Governance Stakeholders: Starting at the top, engage all stakeholders around a common vision. Shared Understanding: Have a common understanding of organizational needs, capabilities, and readiness. Alignment: Use a consistent improvement methodology, align incentives, and balance polarities. Focus: Practice disciplined decision-making to prioritize, fund, organize, and sustain initiatives. Key Objective of Improvement Governance: Move from a loose federation of hospitals and clinics that share supply purchasing . . . . . . to an integrated care delivery system that delivers consistent high quality, coordinate care everywhere across the continuum at the lowest appropriate cost. Governance Quest HAS 16 Game
  • 112. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential112 Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread • Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow Cards) – Improve Data Quality. – Train for Data Literacy. – Promote Appropriate Data Access. • System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards) – Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group). – Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette). – Establish Improvement Governance. • Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards) – The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions. – The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work. – Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
  • 113. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential113 Avoiding Conflict & Contention: Creating a Pause “Freedom is the ability to pause between stimulus and response and in the pause to choose.” - Viktor Frankl
  • 114. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential114 The 10 Worst Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions 1. Use Data as a Weapon. 2. Misrepresent Data. 3. Prevent Appropriate Data Access. 4. Disengage from the Process. 5. Highlight Data Imperfections / Discredit. 6. Analysis Paralysis. 7. Political Favoritism. 8. Budget Cuts Across the Board. 9. Delay a Decision with Stall Tactics. 10. Stick to the Status Quo.
  • 115. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential115 Signs Someone Is Outside the Productive Zone Blame others, distract attention, denial
  • 116. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential116 Start With Compassion When you don’t know what to try first, lower the heat. • Validate feelings, acknowledge loss. • Simplify and clarify. • Address the technical aspects. • Break the problem into parts. • Restore, add, or reallocate resources. • Temporarily reclaim responsibility for tough issues. • Give your attention. • Take stock of what is available. • A lot more time, enrich knowledge and skills. Nobody misbehaves from a place of strength.
  • 117. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential117 Avoiding Contention: Understand Intent & Impact “I know that you believe you understood what you think I said, but I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.” - Robert McCloskey
  • 118. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential118 Other’s impact on me My intention Intention of other My impact Harvard Negotiation Project Mine Other’s Intention Impact
  • 119. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential119   Mine Other’s Intention Impact Harvard Negotiation Project
  • 120. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential120   Our assumptions about intentions are often wrong. Good intentions do not make bad impact unimportant or irrelevant. Harvard Negotiation Project Mine Other’s Intention Impact
  • 121. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential121 Other’s This is what I meant. This is how it felt/seemed to me. Is that what you meant? How did it feel/land with you? Harvard Negotiation Project Mine Intention Impact
  • 122. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential122 Principles – Spectrum Year 3 – Sustain and Spread • Interdepartmental Collaboration Requires Good Data Governance (The Yellow Cards) – Improve Data Quality. – Train for Data Literacy. – Promote Appropriate Data Access. • System-Wide Adoption (The Purple Cards) – Establishing an Analytic Services Working Group (User Group). – Marketing your Analytics Like a Small Business (The Improvement Vignette). – Establish Improvement Governance. • Avoiding Conflict and Contention (The Red Cards) – The Worst 10 Practices in Healthcare Analytic Interactions. – The Productive Zone – Helping Everyone Engage in the Work. – Improving Interdepartmental Communication (Intent and Impact).
  • 123. © 2017 Health Catalyst Within the triple aim of data governance, our organization struggles most with? 113 respondents 1. Data Quality. – 25% 2. Data Literacy. – 31% 3. Data Utilization. – 41% 4. We’re great at all three of these. – 3% Poll Question #9 123
  • 124. © 2017 Health Catalyst Which of these 5 practices have you seen at your organization? (select all that apply) 109 respondents 1. Use Data as a Weapon. – 32% 2. Misrepresent Data. – 41% 3. Prevent Appropriate Data Access. – 39% 4. Disengage from the Process. – 54% 5. Highlight Data Imperfections / Discredit. – 55% Poll Question #10 124
  • 125. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential125 Spectrum - Key Takeaways and Lessons Learned Set your organization up for success • Invest in Infrastructure (Acquire Data, Grant Access, Build Actionable Metrics and Discover Insights). • Train Key Roles and Skills (Train Analytics Engineers, Recruit Change Agents and Engage Key Stakeholders). • Create a Data-Driven Culture (Embed Analytics in Workflow, Invest in 5 Core Capabilities for improvement 1) Leadership, Governance & Culture, 2) Analytics, 3) Best Practice, 4) Adoption and 5) Financial Alignment). Unleash data across the Spectrum of Improvement • Perform On-going Opportunity Analysis – Asses Value, Effort, Capabilities, Capacity and Willingness. • Enable Light Effort Improvements – Prerequisites 1) Grant Broad Access, 2) Analytic Toolset Alignment, 3) Training and Support, 4) Communication and 5) Analytic Leadership; Be Opportunistic – improve your Return on Luck. • Invest in Deep Effort, High-Value Improvement - Pick ONE Improvement Methodology, and Organize consistent on-going interdisciplinary teams. • Understand No Margin, No Mission – Involve the Finance time early, Fund clinical outcomes with financial results in other domains, and use Overhead Value Analysis to eliminate less value reports and point solutions. Sustaining and Spreading Improvement • Collaborate with information & resources – Establish Data Governance – increase Data Quality, Data Literacy and Data Access. • Promote system-wide adoption – Create an Analytic Services Working Group to promote standards & knowledge sharing, Market you Analytics like a small business and establish improvement governance. • Reduce wasteful contention – Avoid worst practices such as using data as a weapon, help everyone engage in the work by staying in the ”Productive Zone, and improving communication by understanding intent and impact.
  • 126. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential126 A Questions & Answers
  • 127. © 2017 Health Catalyst Proprietary and Confidential127 Thank You