SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
When facts are fluid
Emerging best practices to verify
information on social media

Alfred Hermida
University of British Columbia
@hermida
Photo: Robert Croma
http://www.flickr.com/photos/croma/

JEAA, December 3, 2013
Verification:
The essence
of journalism
Kovach and
Rosenstiel, 2001

Photo: Flood G http://www.flickr.com/photos/_flood_/
Accuracy:
A persistent issue

Photo: Ines Njers http://www.flickr.com/photos/inesnjers/
Systemic verification
๏‚กMessage-based analysis
๏‚กUser-based analysis

๏‚กTopic-based analysis
๏‚กPropagation-based analysis
Systemic verification
๏‚กMessage-based analysis
๏‚กUser-based analysis

๏‚กTopic-based analysis
๏‚กPropagation-based analysis
Fake!
Systemic verification
๏‚กMessage-based analysis
๏‚กUser-based analysis

๏‚กTopic-based analysis
๏‚กPropagation-based analysis
BBC golden rule
Contact the source
Surge of new
Twitter accounts

Photo: Rebecca Hildreth http://www.flickr.com/photos/rebeccahildreth/
Systemic verification
๏‚กMessage-based analysis
๏‚กUser-based analysis

๏‚กTopic-based analysis
๏‚กPropagation-based analysis
London riots:
Social media
blamed

Photo: Mack Male http://www.flickr.com/photos/mastermaq/
Questioning messages

Photo: Claudio Jofrรฉ Larenas http://www.flickr.com/photos/nazgulhead/
Systemic verification
๏‚กMessage-based analysis
๏‚กUser-based analysis

๏‚กTopic-based analysis
๏‚กPropagation-based analysis
Speed of
diffusion

Photo: Rebecca Hildreth http://www.flickr.com/photos/rebeccahildreth/
Spotting dirty tricks

Photo: Martha Coakley
Sorting fact from fiction

Photo: Patrick Hoesly http://www.flickr.com/photos/zooboing/
Thank
you

More Related Content

What's hot

E0 d4nuim
E0 d4nuimE0 d4nuim
E0 d4nuim
Eoin O'Dell
ย 
BIOL 303 Spring 2013
BIOL 303 Spring 2013BIOL 303 Spring 2013
BIOL 303 Spring 2013
Laksamee Putnam
ย 
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonDMedia and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
Dm Gibson
ย 
Civil rights project outline
Civil rights project outlineCivil rights project outline
Civil rights project outline
Jonah Howard
ย 
twitter_golden_globes
twitter_golden_globestwitter_golden_globes
twitter_golden_globes
Tomofumi Ogawa
ย 

What's hot (20)

E0 d4nuim
E0 d4nuimE0 d4nuim
E0 d4nuim
ย 
Sj may-15-uw-deohs
Sj may-15-uw-deohsSj may-15-uw-deohs
Sj may-15-uw-deohs
ย 
Media literacy panel
Media literacy panel Media literacy panel
Media literacy panel
ย 
Photographic Composition Rules
 Photographic Composition Rules Photographic Composition Rules
Photographic Composition Rules
ย 
Evolution,Eugenics Nazis and Racism
Evolution,Eugenics Nazis and RacismEvolution,Eugenics Nazis and Racism
Evolution,Eugenics Nazis and Racism
ย 
The Biggest Lies on the Internet. Using Real Life Examples to Help Students M...
The Biggest Lies on the Internet. Using Real Life Examples to Help Students M...The Biggest Lies on the Internet. Using Real Life Examples to Help Students M...
The Biggest Lies on the Internet. Using Real Life Examples to Help Students M...
ย 
Examining toxic interactions and political engagement on Twitter
Examining toxic interactions and political engagement on TwitterExamining toxic interactions and political engagement on Twitter
Examining toxic interactions and political engagement on Twitter
ย 
Lhs preso
Lhs presoLhs preso
Lhs preso
ย 
Hallam healthresearch tweetchats
Hallam healthresearch tweetchatsHallam healthresearch tweetchats
Hallam healthresearch tweetchats
ย 
BIOL 303 Spring 2013
BIOL 303 Spring 2013BIOL 303 Spring 2013
BIOL 303 Spring 2013
ย 
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonDMedia and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
Media and the Criminal Justice SystemIP2 GibsonD
ย 
Communication 200 (covid version)
Communication 200 (covid version)Communication 200 (covid version)
Communication 200 (covid version)
ย 
The Fan Fiction Reading Guide
The Fan Fiction Reading GuideThe Fan Fiction Reading Guide
The Fan Fiction Reading Guide
ย 
Civil rights project outline
Civil rights project outlineCivil rights project outline
Civil rights project outline
ย 
Hyperpolitics (American Style)
Hyperpolitics (American Style)Hyperpolitics (American Style)
Hyperpolitics (American Style)
ย 
Searching socialmedia
Searching socialmediaSearching socialmedia
Searching socialmedia
ย 
ACM Web-Science 2014: Assisting Crisis Coordination Using Social Media
ACM Web-Science 2014: Assisting Crisis Coordination Using Social MediaACM Web-Science 2014: Assisting Crisis Coordination Using Social Media
ACM Web-Science 2014: Assisting Crisis Coordination Using Social Media
ย 
Open Culture: Fractals of Freedom
Open Culture: Fractals of FreedomOpen Culture: Fractals of Freedom
Open Culture: Fractals of Freedom
ย 
TSEM Fall 2015 Warner Class1
TSEM Fall 2015 Warner Class1TSEM Fall 2015 Warner Class1
TSEM Fall 2015 Warner Class1
ย 
twitter_golden_globes
twitter_golden_globestwitter_golden_globes
twitter_golden_globes
ย 

Viewers also liked

HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
Janeen Alliston
ย 
It's Christmas
It's ChristmasIt's Christmas
It's Christmas
anabraga
ย 
Campeonato
CampeonatoCampeonato
Campeonato
ield
ย 
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
josito1
ย 
Social Networking
Social NetworkingSocial Networking
Social Networking
Robert Gibson
ย 

Viewers also liked (17)

HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
HEW2014: The Content is the Experience: Lessons in Creating a Student-Centere...
ย 
All the news that's fit to share
All the news that's fit to shareAll the news that's fit to share
All the news that's fit to share
ย 
AEJMC: Planning a student website
AEJMC: Planning a student websiteAEJMC: Planning a student website
AEJMC: Planning a student website
ย 
Emotions and the art of sharing
Emotions and the art of sharingEmotions and the art of sharing
Emotions and the art of sharing
ย 
Rewiring journalism: The new literacies of networked communication architectu...
Rewiring journalism: The new literacies of networked communication architectu...Rewiring journalism: The new literacies of networked communication architectu...
Rewiring journalism: The new literacies of networked communication architectu...
ย 
It's Christmas
It's ChristmasIt's Christmas
It's Christmas
ย 
Campeonato
CampeonatoCampeonato
Campeonato
ย 
Paralisis Cerebral
Paralisis CerebralParalisis Cerebral
Paralisis Cerebral
ย 
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
Quieres Una Pepsi 9946
ย 
Collaborative story-telling
Collaborative story-tellingCollaborative story-telling
Collaborative story-telling
ย 
Thought leadership on social media
Thought leadership on social mediaThought leadership on social media
Thought leadership on social media
ย 
Equinoterapia en Paralisis Cerebral
 Equinoterapia en Paralisis Cerebral Equinoterapia en Paralisis Cerebral
Equinoterapia en Paralisis Cerebral
ย 
Oqueesperar2
Oqueesperar2Oqueesperar2
Oqueesperar2
ย 
B.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital ContentB.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital Content
ย 
Puesta en marcha del Plan de Ictus de la Comunidad de Murcia
Puesta en marcha del Plan de Ictus de la Comunidad de MurciaPuesta en marcha del Plan de Ictus de la Comunidad de Murcia
Puesta en marcha del Plan de Ictus de la Comunidad de Murcia
ย 
Verification 101 with Storyful
Verification 101 with StoryfulVerification 101 with Storyful
Verification 101 with Storyful
ย 
Social Networking
Social NetworkingSocial Networking
Social Networking
ย 

Similar to When facts are fluid: Emerging best practices to verify information on social media

Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Jerimie
ย 
Research Project 9th Honors Lit
Research Project 9th Honors LitResearch Project 9th Honors Lit
Research Project 9th Honors Lit
joshjeon
ย 

Similar to When facts are fluid: Emerging best practices to verify information on social media (10)

Your Friend as Editor
Your Friend as EditorYour Friend as Editor
Your Friend as Editor
ย 
Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)
ย 
Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)Things you should consider when using social media (1)
Things you should consider when using social media (1)
ย 
Tweets and Truth
Tweets and TruthTweets and Truth
Tweets and Truth
ย 
The Death of Print Journalism and Rise of Digital Media
The Death of Print Journalism and Rise of Digital MediaThe Death of Print Journalism and Rise of Digital Media
The Death of Print Journalism and Rise of Digital Media
ย 
Research Project 9th Honors Lit
Research Project 9th Honors LitResearch Project 9th Honors Lit
Research Project 9th Honors Lit
ย 
#journalism: Reconfiguring journalism, one tweet at a time
#journalism: Reconfiguring journalism, one tweet at a time#journalism: Reconfiguring journalism, one tweet at a time
#journalism: Reconfiguring journalism, one tweet at a time
ย 
Connected But Lonely: How Constant Connectivity Is Affecting Us
Connected But Lonely: How Constant Connectivity Is Affecting UsConnected But Lonely: How Constant Connectivity Is Affecting Us
Connected But Lonely: How Constant Connectivity Is Affecting Us
ย 
The Power of the Selfie
The Power of the SelfieThe Power of the Selfie
The Power of the Selfie
ย 
Flipbook.pdf
Flipbook.pdf Flipbook.pdf
Flipbook.pdf
ย 

More from Alfred Hermida Ph.D.

More from Alfred Hermida Ph.D. (12)

Sourcing the Arab Spring: A Case Study of Andy Carvinโ€™s Sources During the Tu...
Sourcing the Arab Spring: A Case Study of Andy Carvinโ€™s Sources During the Tu...Sourcing the Arab Spring: A Case Study of Andy Carvinโ€™s Sources During the Tu...
Sourcing the Arab Spring: A Case Study of Andy Carvinโ€™s Sources During the Tu...
ย 
Share, like, recommend: Decoding the social media news consumer
Share, like, recommend: Decoding the social media news consumerShare, like, recommend: Decoding the social media news consumer
Share, like, recommend: Decoding the social media news consumer
ย 
Tweets and Truth
Tweets and TruthTweets and Truth
Tweets and Truth
ย 
The promise and practice of participatory journalism
The promise and practice of participatory journalismThe promise and practice of participatory journalism
The promise and practice of participatory journalism
ย 
The Networked Scholar
The Networked ScholarThe Networked Scholar
The Networked Scholar
ย 
Lessons from integrated approach to journalism education
Lessons from integrated approach to journalism educationLessons from integrated approach to journalism education
Lessons from integrated approach to journalism education
ย 
Wikifying the CBC
Wikifying the CBCWikifying the CBC
Wikifying the CBC
ย 
Blogging 101 for researchers
Blogging 101 for researchersBlogging 101 for researchers
Blogging 101 for researchers
ย 
Social media principles and practice
Social media principles and practiceSocial media principles and practice
Social media principles and practice
ย 
Twittering the News
Twittering the NewsTwittering the News
Twittering the News
ย 
From one to many to one of many
From one to many to one of manyFrom one to many to one of many
From one to many to one of many
ย 
When journalists go backstage: Reassessing privacy for social media
When journalists go backstage: Reassessing privacy for social mediaWhen journalists go backstage: Reassessing privacy for social media
When journalists go backstage: Reassessing privacy for social media
ย 

Recently uploaded

Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in MasudpurDelhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
ย 
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
AshtonCains
ย 
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service ๐Ÿ‘–
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service  ๐Ÿ‘–CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service  ๐Ÿ‘–
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service ๐Ÿ‘–
anilsa9823
ย 
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
anilsa9823
ย 
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ” Cash Payment
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow  ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ”  Cash PaymentTop Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow  ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ”  Cash Payment
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ” Cash Payment
anilsa9823
ย 
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Call Girls In Delhi Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pleasure
ย 
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptxFactors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
vemusae
ย 

Recently uploaded (20)

Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in MasudpurDelhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
ย 
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
ย 
Film show evaluation powerpoint for site
Film show evaluation powerpoint for siteFilm show evaluation powerpoint for site
Film show evaluation powerpoint for site
ย 
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
Film the city investagation powerpoint :)
ย 
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service ๐Ÿ‘–
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service  ๐Ÿ‘–CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service  ๐Ÿ‘–
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Takrohi Lucknow best Female service ๐Ÿ‘–
ย 
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON โžฅ8923113531 ๐Ÿ”Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
ย 
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageYour LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
ย 
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ” Cash Payment
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow  ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ”  Cash PaymentTop Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow  ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ”  Cash Payment
Top Call Girls In Charbagh ( Lucknow ) ๐Ÿ” 8923113531 ๐Ÿ” Cash Payment
ย 
BDSMโšกCall Girls in Sector 76 Noida Escorts >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
BDSMโšกCall Girls in Sector 76 Noida Escorts >เผ’8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSMโšกCall Girls in Sector 76 Noida Escorts >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
BDSMโšกCall Girls in Sector 76 Noida Escorts >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
ย 
Elite Class โžฅ8448380779โ–ป Call Girls In Nizammuddin Delhi NCR
Elite Class โžฅ8448380779โ–ป Call Girls In Nizammuddin Delhi NCRElite Class โžฅ8448380779โ–ป Call Girls In Nizammuddin Delhi NCR
Elite Class โžฅ8448380779โ–ป Call Girls In Nizammuddin Delhi NCR
ย 
Call Girls In South Ex. Delhi O9654467111 Women Seeking Men
Call Girls In South Ex. Delhi O9654467111 Women Seeking MenCall Girls In South Ex. Delhi O9654467111 Women Seeking Men
Call Girls In South Ex. Delhi O9654467111 Women Seeking Men
ย 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
ย 
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketingSocial media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
ย 
Production diary Film the city powerpoint
Production diary Film the city powerpointProduction diary Film the city powerpoint
Production diary Film the city powerpoint
ย 
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 37 ๐Ÿ’“ Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
ย 
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptxFactors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
ย 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
ย 
O9654467111 Call Girls In Dwarka Women Seeking Men
O9654467111 Call Girls In Dwarka Women Seeking MenO9654467111 Call Girls In Dwarka Women Seeking Men
O9654467111 Call Girls In Dwarka Women Seeking Men
ย 
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazineWebsite research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
ย 
Enjoy NightโšกCall Girls Palam Vihar Gurgaon >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy NightโšกCall Girls Palam Vihar Gurgaon >เผ’8448380779 Escort ServiceEnjoy NightโšกCall Girls Palam Vihar Gurgaon >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy NightโšกCall Girls Palam Vihar Gurgaon >เผ’8448380779 Escort Service
ย 

When facts are fluid: Emerging best practices to verify information on social media

Editor's Notes

  1. Coakley concedes defeats
  2. Coakley concedes defeats
  3. Coakley concedes defeats
  4. 7 Fake Hurricane Sandy photos you are sharing on social mediaโ€http://mashable.com/2012/10/29/fake-hurricane-sandy-photos/