1. Information skills for a 21st Century Scotland
www.therightinformation.org/
The Scottish Information Literacy Community of Practice
Developing and running a National Information Literacy
Community of Practice on a shoestring
Christine Irving
Community of Practice Founding Member
Former SILP Project Officer
Freelance Information Professional
Research Fellow Edinburgh Napier University
LILAC 2014
Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield
Thursday 24thth April 2014

2. Developing and running a National Information
Literacy Community of Practice on a shoestring
1. What is a Community of Practice?
a. Definition & crucial characteristics
2. Building and developing a Community of Practice
a. Why create a Community of Practice?
b. Challenges
c. How we did it - online presence, content, launch, work in progress, request for help
3. Engagement and participation
a. Engagement and participation - not just a website
4. The practice
a. Achievements - shared practice, engagement
b. What has worked, what hasn’t
c. Lessons learned
d. Challenges

3. What is a Community of Practice?
Communities of practice have become a common term but:
– What is a 'community of practice' (CoP)
– How can we participate and engage in them
– How can we use them as an approach to knowing and learning?
Communities of Practice are
“groups of people who share a concern or a passion for something they do
and learn how to do it better as they interact regularly”. Etienne Wenger,
2006

4. What is a Community of Practice?
– crucial characteristics
Wenger identifies that there are three characteristic which are crucial to a community of
practice:
1. The domain. 'A community of practice is not merely a club of friends or a network of
connections between people. It has an identity defined by a shared domain of
interest. Membership therefore implies a commitment to the domain membership.‘
2. The community. 'In pursuing their interest in their domain, members engage in joint
activities and discussions, help each other, and share information. They build
relationships that enable them to learn from each other. A website in itself is not a
community of practice.'
3. The practice. 'A community of practice is not merely a community of interest.
Members of a community of practice are practitioners. They develop a shared
repertoire of resources: experiences, stories, tools, ways of addressing recurring
problems - in short a shared practice. This takes time and sustained interaction.‘
' It is the combination of these three elements that constitute a community of practice.
And it is by developing these three elements in parallel that one cultivates such a
community.' Wenger (2006)

5. Building a Community of Practice
Why create a Community of Practice?
Because:
• The Scottish Information Literacy Project and the funding ended March
2010
• It was important not to loose all the valuable work the Scottish
Information Literacy Project and it’s partners did, achieved and
• to continue the work …

6. Building a Community of Practice
Challenges :
• No funding
• Needed a new home / online presence for past and future activities
However there was already a community …
The SILP partners …
- we needed to harness the goodwill and willingness to continue with IL
work amongst them plus anyone else who was interested …

7. Building a Community of Practice
How?
After over a year of talking we had a new:
• Home / url www.therightinformation.org/ hosted by the Scottish Library and
Information Council (SLIC)
• Name – Information skills for a 21st Century Scotland
Next challenge was to create a new online presence for future and past activities:
• A Community of Practice and future activities
• Past activities – valuable archive of material built up over several years:
– Scottish Information Literacy Framework - a national overarching framework of
information literacy skills and competencies which all sectors of education can
recognize and develop or which can be applied to the world of work, equipping
learners with skills needed for the 21st century.
– information about the Scottish Information Literacy Project
– project blog.

8. Building a Community of Practice
Content: www.therightinformation.org/
Community of Practice
• Discussion Board
• Definition of what a Community of Practice was
Framework
What is information literacy?
• definitions, frameworks, information literacy and lifelong learning, information
literacy and education
• Literacies that are associated with or are required to be used in conjunction with
information literacy e.g. critical literacy, digital literacy, media literacy – definitions
given
Also …
• Members - sign up and log in
• Archive – Scottish Information Literacy project (SILIP)
• Blog roll
– Library and Information Literacy Websites
– Education, Learning and Development

9. Building a Community
of Practice
Information Skills for a 21st century
Scotland.
www.therightinformation.org/
Launched 11th June 2012
@ CILIPS Annual Conference in
Dundee
Hosted by Scottish Library and
Information Council (SLIC)
Work in progress / more to do …
Not just a website …

10. Engagement and participation
Not just a website …
at the launch invitation given to everyone interested in information literacy and
associated skills and competencies (individuals and groups across the LIS
sectors/community) to come and join the community, engage and participate …
To:
• Act as facilitators for their sector
• Share practice
• Contribute to the communities’ knowledge of information literacy:
– Activities
– case studies
– News
– conferences and events
– new research
• Become involved / engage in information literacy:
– Advocacy
– Strategies
– Projects, proposals

11. Engagement and participation
First meeting with recruited community sector members /
facilitators / activists.
Main areas of interest identified:
• Developing core IL skills in FE;
• Assessing the impact of IL training;
• Advocacy for IL;
• Instructing teachers in IL,
• IL as an employability skill;
• IL toolkits for young people;
• Teaching IL skills in public libraries;
• Links between schools and public libraries,
• Use of electronic IL resources in public libraries;
• Online training packages in HE (short demo of SMILE);
• Workplace IL skills social media; training materials for
teachers.
• NLS the Toolkit being developed - looking for partners to
work with in the different sectors on the toolkit.
• Identify training and CPD needs
We now have bi
annual face to face
meetings with
community sector
members /
facilitators / activists.
Meeting minutes are
posted on the blog.

12. The practice -
Achievements:
Membership grown – 106 members (includes 4 editors
and 9 bloggers) at 2nd April 2014
Additional features added - community blog, events
list, RSS feed, search box, new banner & colours
Sharing practice:
• Dundee College's Literacy Information Skills
Project
• SMILE - a free information literacy resource
Co-ordination and synergy of activities, strategies,
developments, advocacy, engagement , promotions
etc. examples include
• National Library's new information literacy
resource ‘Project Blaster’ toolkit for producing
projects aimed at Primary 6/7 children and their
children – community members involved in
development of toolkit
• Royal Society of Edinburgh digital participation
enquiry individual members and CoP responded,
call to arms re interim report Response to the RSE
Enquiry into Digital Participation

13. Information skills for a 21st Century Scotland
www.therightinformation.org/
What has worked
• Face to face meetings
• Co-ordination and synergy of
activities, strategies,
developments, advocacy,
engagement, promotions etc.
• Blog postings – regular postings
followed by Tweets (Twitter
followers increased)
What hasn’t
• Wider member engagement
• Members reluctant to blog or
comment on blog postings
• Framework update – plan was to
– continue to develop the current
version
– updating it to incorporate new
research, adding case studies, and so
on …
– use and promote the framework

14. The practice - lessons learned:
The lessons learned from the Scottish Information Literacy Project are applicable to the Community of
Practice:
 Partnerships and networking is crucial using both personal and professional contacts
 Work cross sector and not just with librarians and information specialists
 Identify organisations to work with that have an interest in information literacy / shared outcomes.
 Offer support to practitioners. Support at policy levels informs the development of good practice at
institutional level which can be fed back to further policy development, thus creating a virtuous
circle. This is particularly helpful to small organisations or solo operators like school librarians
 Have meetings and involve people. Encourage reporting on activities by activists. Thus gives activists
an opportunity to present their ideas and receive comments and constructive criticism. Outcomes
can them be fed into policy making
 Encourage writing and reporting so that others both within the country and abroad can be aware of
your work and learn from it and comment on it
 The development of learning material content should be an outcome of policy thinking but must be
cross sectoral and should not simply be higher education material ‘bolted’ on to another context
such as workplace information literacy skills development. The role of project partners is essential in
developing materials and exemplars of good practice

15. The practice - lessons learned:
A Community of Practice should not be seen as a cheap option, it is funded not with money but
with members, freely giving their time and commitment.
Wenger’s three characteristic are crucial to a community of practice:
Domain
 Membership therefore implies a commitment to the domain membership
The Community of Practice needs commitment from its membership for anything to happen. Some members
more committed than others.
The community
 Members engage in joint activities and discussions, help each other, and share information. They build
relationships that enable them to learn from each other.
The above is happening through the bi-annual face to face meetings where relationships are made. No evidence
of it happening between the rest of the membership.
The practice
 Takes time and sustained interaction
A Community of Practice runs on relationships, commitment, the generosity
of peoples time and sustained interaction.

16. Information skills for a 21st Century Scotland
www.therightinformation.org
Thank you
Christine Irving
christine.irving8@gmail.com
C.Irving@napier.ac.uk