SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Does Stem Cell Research Have A
Retraction Problem?
World Stem Cell Summit
San Antonio, TX
December 4, 2014
Ivan Oransky
Co-founder, Retraction Watch
http://retractionwatch.com
@ivanoransky
Nature, November 27, 2014
Retractions on the Rise
http://pmretract.heroku.com/byyear
Most Retractions Due to Misconduct
PNAS online October 1, 2012
The Rise of Post-Publication Peer Review
The Rise of Post-Publication Peer Review
-Cell 2013; 153: 1228-1238
hESCs in Cell
โ€œIt does however have several examples of image
reuse which might be of interest to PubPeer
members and readers.โ€
hESCs in Cell
hESCs in Cell
hESCs in Cell
Journals Are Listening
Journals Are Listening
Doing The Right Thing Pays
Contact Info
ivan-oransky@erols.com
http://retractionwatch.com
@ivanoransky
Thanks to Nancy Lapid, Reuters Health

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
Visit Lillehammer AS
ย 
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power pointElizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
bmarkey
ย 
What makes research news?
What makes research news?What makes research news?
What makes research news?
Ivan Oransky
ย 
October 2011 newsletter
October 2011 newsletterOctober 2011 newsletter
October 2011 newsletter
Sharon Dennany
ย 
January 2012 newsletter
January 2012 newsletterJanuary 2012 newsletter
January 2012 newsletter
Sharon Dennany
ย 
Why Verbal Communication Fails?
Why Verbal Communication Fails?Why Verbal Communication Fails?
Why Verbal Communication Fails?
Babu Rao
ย 
April 12, 2011
April 12, 2011 April 12, 2011
April 12, 2011
Sharon Dennany
ย 

Viewers also liked (15)

Vestul Anatoliei - Ephes, autor Nick Sava
 Vestul Anatoliei - Ephes, autor Nick Sava  Vestul Anatoliei - Ephes, autor Nick Sava
Vestul Anatoliei - Ephes, autor Nick Sava
ย 
Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
Lillehammer turist strategi mot 2013
ย 
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power pointElizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
Elizabeth markey~ edu 643 ineractive power point
ย 
What makes research news?
What makes research news?What makes research news?
What makes research news?
ย 
โ€žPร‚Nฤ‚ LA EMINESCU ศ˜I DE LA EL SPRE NOIโ€
โ€žPร‚Nฤ‚ LA EMINESCU ศ˜I DE LA EL SPRE NOIโ€โ€žPร‚Nฤ‚ LA EMINESCU ศ˜I DE LA EL SPRE NOIโ€
โ€žPร‚Nฤ‚ LA EMINESCU ศ˜I DE LA EL SPRE NOIโ€
ย 
Falezedepiatra net, nr28-36, 2012
Falezedepiatra net, nr28-36, 2012Falezedepiatra net, nr28-36, 2012
Falezedepiatra net, nr28-36, 2012
ย 
October 2011 newsletter
October 2011 newsletterOctober 2011 newsletter
October 2011 newsletter
ย 
IT Governance
IT GovernanceIT Governance
IT Governance
ย 
DEZBATERILE GRUPULUI DE REFLECศšIE PRIVIND DEMOCRATIA REALฤ‚
DEZBATERILE GRUPULUI DE REFLECศšIE PRIVIND DEMOCRATIA REALฤ‚DEZBATERILE GRUPULUI DE REFLECศšIE PRIVIND DEMOCRATIA REALฤ‚
DEZBATERILE GRUPULUI DE REFLECศšIE PRIVIND DEMOCRATIA REALฤ‚
ย 
January 2012 newsletter
January 2012 newsletterJanuary 2012 newsletter
January 2012 newsletter
ย 
Why Verbal Communication Fails?
Why Verbal Communication Fails?Why Verbal Communication Fails?
Why Verbal Communication Fails?
ย 
DigiLit Leicester: TEAN Conference
DigiLit Leicester: TEAN ConferenceDigiLit Leicester: TEAN Conference
DigiLit Leicester: TEAN Conference
ย 
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment PlanCoverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
ย 
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
ย 
April 12, 2011
April 12, 2011 April 12, 2011
April 12, 2011
ย 

Similar to Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?

Life Against Life: Final Project
Life Against Life: Final ProjectLife Against Life: Final Project
Life Against Life: Final Project
Hans Mundahl
ย 
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correctingIoannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
Marilyn Mann
ย 
Trial and Error Discover Neimark
Trial and Error Discover NeimarkTrial and Error Discover Neimark
Trial and Error Discover Neimark
Jill Neimark
ย 
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online
ย 
H organ donation
H organ donationH organ donation
H organ donation
snovitski
ย 

Similar to Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem? (20)

Reproducibility Initiative Strata RX - Ignite
Reproducibility Initiative Strata RX - IgniteReproducibility Initiative Strata RX - Ignite
Reproducibility Initiative Strata RX - Ignite
ย 
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving BadlyReviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
ย 
Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
Scrutiny of Science Goes PublicScrutiny of Science Goes Public
Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
ย 
Ideals and Norms in Scholarship
Ideals and Norms in ScholarshipIdeals and Norms in Scholarship
Ideals and Norms in Scholarship
ย 
Rutgers
RutgersRutgers
Rutgers
ย 
How Do We Know What We Know?
How Do We Know What We Know?How Do We Know What We Know?
How Do We Know What We Know?
ย 
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Retractions, Peer Review, and TransparencyRetractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
ย 
January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...
January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...
January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...
ย 
Life Against Life: Final Project
Life Against Life: Final ProjectLife Against Life: Final Project
Life Against Life: Final Project
ย 
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correctingIoannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
Ioannidis why science is not necessarily self correcting
ย 
Trial and Error Discover Neimark
Trial and Error Discover NeimarkTrial and Error Discover Neimark
Trial and Error Discover Neimark
ย 
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
Jessica Polka - Preprints in the life sciences: Cultural change, funder polic...
ย 
Technical Writing Project - Scientific Articles
Technical Writing Project - Scientific ArticlesTechnical Writing Project - Scientific Articles
Technical Writing Project - Scientific Articles
ย 
Helth law
Helth lawHelth law
Helth law
ย 
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosisCan a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
ย 
Covering Screening Tests: Do No Harm (As A Reporter)
Covering Screening Tests: Do No Harm (As A Reporter)Covering Screening Tests: Do No Harm (As A Reporter)
Covering Screening Tests: Do No Harm (As A Reporter)
ย 
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
ย 
H organ donation
H organ donationH organ donation
H organ donation
ย 
Animal Research A Personal Lesson
Animal Research  A Personal LessonAnimal Research  A Personal Lesson
Animal Research A Personal Lesson
ย 
Can We Still Trust Science?
Can We Still Trust Science?Can We Still Trust Science?
Can We Still Trust Science?
ย 

More from Ivan Oransky

Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 finalFnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Ivan Oransky
ย 

More from Ivan Oransky (20)

The relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retraction
The relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retractionThe relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retraction
The relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retraction
ย 
During COVID-19, Are Preprints The Problem?
During COVID-19, Are Preprints The Problem?During COVID-19, Are Preprints The Problem?
During COVID-19, Are Preprints The Problem?
ย 
Does Science Self-Correct?
Does Science Self-Correct?Does Science Self-Correct?
Does Science Self-Correct?
ย 
Why We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About Fraud
Why We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About FraudWhy We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About Fraud
Why We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About Fraud
ย 
WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?
WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?
WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?
ย 
The Retraction Watch Database
The Retraction Watch DatabaseThe Retraction Watch Database
The Retraction Watch Database
ย 
Fake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction Watch
Fake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction WatchFake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction Watch
Fake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction Watch
ย 
APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018
APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018
APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018
ย 
FNLM Carlisle talk
FNLM Carlisle talkFNLM Carlisle talk
FNLM Carlisle talk
ย 
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
ย 
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific PublishingScientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
ย 
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
How Often Are Studies Wrong?How Often Are Studies Wrong?
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
ย 
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific FraudHow Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
ย 
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
How to pitch reporters without being annoyingHow to pitch reporters without being annoying
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
ย 
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical JournalismShoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
ย 
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
ย 
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todayโ€™s eco...
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todayโ€™s eco...New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todayโ€™s eco...
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todayโ€™s eco...
ย 
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
ย 
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 finalFnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
ย 
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
ย 

Recently uploaded

Bacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and ClassificationsBacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
Areesha Ahmad
ย 
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptxSeismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
AlMamun560346
ย 
module for grade 9 for distance learning
module for grade 9 for distance learningmodule for grade 9 for distance learning
module for grade 9 for distance learning
levieagacer
ย 
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Sรฉrgio Sacani
ย 
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptxIntroduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
Bhagirath Gogikar
ย 
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
PirithiRaju
ย 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
ย 
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
ย 
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and ClassificationsBacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
ย 
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptxSeismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
ย 
module for grade 9 for distance learning
module for grade 9 for distance learningmodule for grade 9 for distance learning
module for grade 9 for distance learning
ย 
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
ย 
STS-UNIT 4 CLIMATE CHANGE POWERPOINT PRESENTATION
STS-UNIT 4 CLIMATE CHANGE POWERPOINT PRESENTATIONSTS-UNIT 4 CLIMATE CHANGE POWERPOINT PRESENTATION
STS-UNIT 4 CLIMATE CHANGE POWERPOINT PRESENTATION
ย 
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx .
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx                 .Clean In Place(CIP).pptx                 .
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx .
ย 
Connaught Place, Delhi Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
Connaught Place, Delhi Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verifiedConnaught Place, Delhi Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
Connaught Place, Delhi Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
ย 
Kochi โคCALL GIRL 84099*07087 โคCALL GIRLS IN Kochi ESCORT SERVICEโคCALL GIRL
Kochi โคCALL GIRL 84099*07087 โคCALL GIRLS IN Kochi ESCORT SERVICEโคCALL GIRLKochi โคCALL GIRL 84099*07087 โคCALL GIRLS IN Kochi ESCORT SERVICEโคCALL GIRL
Kochi โคCALL GIRL 84099*07087 โคCALL GIRLS IN Kochi ESCORT SERVICEโคCALL GIRL
ย 
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)
ย 
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfZoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
ย 
โคJammu Kashmir Call Girls 8617697112 Personal Whatsapp Number ๐Ÿ’ฆโœ….
โคJammu Kashmir Call Girls 8617697112 Personal Whatsapp Number ๐Ÿ’ฆโœ….โคJammu Kashmir Call Girls 8617697112 Personal Whatsapp Number ๐Ÿ’ฆโœ….
โคJammu Kashmir Call Girls 8617697112 Personal Whatsapp Number ๐Ÿ’ฆโœ….
ย 
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptxIntroduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
Introduction,importance and scope of horticulture.pptx
ย 
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
ย 
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts ServiceJustdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
ย 
High Profile ๐Ÿ” 8250077686 ๐Ÿ“ž Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar๐Ÿ‘
High Profile ๐Ÿ” 8250077686 ๐Ÿ“ž Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar๐Ÿ‘High Profile ๐Ÿ” 8250077686 ๐Ÿ“ž Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar๐Ÿ‘
High Profile ๐Ÿ” 8250077686 ๐Ÿ“ž Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar๐Ÿ‘
ย 
High Class Escorts in Hyderabad โ‚น7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 969456...
High Class Escorts in Hyderabad โ‚น7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 969456...High Class Escorts in Hyderabad โ‚น7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 969456...
High Class Escorts in Hyderabad โ‚น7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 969456...
ย 
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
ย 
Unit5-Cloud.pptx for lpu course cse121 o
Unit5-Cloud.pptx for lpu course cse121 oUnit5-Cloud.pptx for lpu course cse121 o
Unit5-Cloud.pptx for lpu course cse121 o
ย 

Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?