SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
A Guide to Writing an Art Critique

*Within your critique, you must identify the artist and work, describe the elements and materials,
analyze relationships between elements, consider composition and content and then interpret the
work and its purpose.

*Below is a guide intended to help, though you do not need to follow it precisely.

Writing an Art Critique - the Feldman Method
Adapted from Edmund Feldman’s Aesthetic Criticism (as set out in Varieties of
Visual Experience,1972).

I. Give an introduction to the facts of the exhibit/screening. Who? What?
When? Where? If a group exhibition, choose one artwork to critique and identify
the artist(s), the title, the medium and year the work was created.

II. Critique the artwork using a four-step process.

A. Description
Make objective* or value-neutral* statements about the work in question.
Exclude interpretations and evaluations, and instead take an objective
inventory of the work. Point out single features such as objects, trees, and
people. Then point out abstract elements such as shapes and colors.
Finally point out materials or technologies used to compose this artwork.
*A test of objectivity would be that most people would agree with your
statement.

B. Formal analysis
Make statements about the relations among the things you named in the
descriptions (part A). You should note similarities and dissimilarities in
formal elements–such things as color, shape, or direction. Take note of
continuities (such as the color red repeated throughout the work) and of
connections (for example, the shape of a window repeated in the shape of
a table) between these formal elements and the subject matter. What kind
of spatial devices are used to create dimensionality? Do you see
examples of repetition or rhythm? Finally, note the overall qualities of the
work.

C. Interpretation
Make statements about the meaning(s) of the work. This is the most
creative part of your critique. Using a hypothesis, support it with
arguments, based on evidence given in the description and formal
analysis (parts A and B).

D. Judgment
This is the most complex part of the critique and requires an opinion
regarding the worth of an object, based on what was learned in the
previous stages of the critique. Evaluate the craftsmanship and technique.
Are parts of the work successfully interrelated? Does the work illicit a
response or communicate an idea? Are you moved by this work? What
do you think of it? What is your aesthetic judgment? And on what is
based?

III. Draw conclusions

More Related Content

What's hot

Basic Art Vocabulary
Basic Art VocabularyBasic Art Vocabulary
Basic Art VocabularyNatalie Hurd
 
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose Sculptures
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose SculpturesAbstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose Sculptures
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose SculpturesLindsay Lougheed
 
Cave paintings
Cave paintingsCave paintings
Cave paintingsCaramelBun
 
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable Irina Boone
 
Elements Of Design Powerpoint 2006
Elements Of Design Powerpoint  2006Elements Of Design Powerpoint  2006
Elements Of Design Powerpoint 2006tonye
 
Elements of Art and Principles of Design
Elements of Art and Principles of DesignElements of Art and Principles of Design
Elements of Art and Principles of Designdamaba78
 
Art Criticism student example (2)
Art Criticism student example (2)Art Criticism student example (2)
Art Criticism student example (2)Jacques de Beaufort
 
Elements of Art
Elements of ArtElements of Art
Elements of Artmcgehee
 
Sculpture: Types and Means of Production
Sculpture: Types and Means of ProductionSculpture: Types and Means of Production
Sculpture: Types and Means of Productionwalleriusz
 
Art critique worksheet
Art critique worksheetArt critique worksheet
Art critique worksheetNatalie Hurd
 
Introduction to Art History
Introduction to Art HistoryIntroduction to Art History
Introduction to Art HistoryJohn Ricard
 
A History Of Colour
A History Of ColourA History Of Colour
A History Of ColourTyler Tate
 
ELEMENTS OF ARTS
ELEMENTS OF ARTSELEMENTS OF ARTS
ELEMENTS OF ARTSEynah Pinon
 
Introduction to Contemporary Art
Introduction to Contemporary ArtIntroduction to Contemporary Art
Introduction to Contemporary ArtShin Chan
 

What's hot (20)

Basic Art Vocabulary
Basic Art VocabularyBasic Art Vocabulary
Basic Art Vocabulary
 
Abstract art
Abstract artAbstract art
Abstract art
 
Digital art
Digital artDigital art
Digital art
 
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose Sculptures
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose SculpturesAbstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose Sculptures
Abstract Sculpture - Wire and Panty Hose Sculptures
 
Cave paintings
Cave paintingsCave paintings
Cave paintings
 
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable
Art smart presentation; Landscape Artists: Albert Bierstadt and John Constable
 
Elements Of Design Powerpoint 2006
Elements Of Design Powerpoint  2006Elements Of Design Powerpoint  2006
Elements Of Design Powerpoint 2006
 
Elements of Art and Principles of Design
Elements of Art and Principles of DesignElements of Art and Principles of Design
Elements of Art and Principles of Design
 
Art Criticism student example (2)
Art Criticism student example (2)Art Criticism student example (2)
Art Criticism student example (2)
 
Elements of Art
Elements of ArtElements of Art
Elements of Art
 
Art History
Art HistoryArt History
Art History
 
The Visual Arts: Painting
The Visual Arts: PaintingThe Visual Arts: Painting
The Visual Arts: Painting
 
Sculpture: Types and Means of Production
Sculpture: Types and Means of ProductionSculpture: Types and Means of Production
Sculpture: Types and Means of Production
 
ELEMENTS OF ART
ELEMENTS OF ARTELEMENTS OF ART
ELEMENTS OF ART
 
Art critique worksheet
Art critique worksheetArt critique worksheet
Art critique worksheet
 
What is Art?
What is Art?What is Art?
What is Art?
 
Introduction to Art History
Introduction to Art HistoryIntroduction to Art History
Introduction to Art History
 
A History Of Colour
A History Of ColourA History Of Colour
A History Of Colour
 
ELEMENTS OF ARTS
ELEMENTS OF ARTSELEMENTS OF ARTS
ELEMENTS OF ARTS
 
Introduction to Contemporary Art
Introduction to Contemporary ArtIntroduction to Contemporary Art
Introduction to Contemporary Art
 

Viewers also liked

Edward%20 hopper%20prints
Edward%20 hopper%20printsEdward%20 hopper%20prints
Edward%20 hopper%20printsRobin Wuchina
 
Edward Hopper
Edward HopperEdward Hopper
Edward Hopperdavidjjhh
 
Cartoon analysis ppt
Cartoon analysis pptCartoon analysis ppt
Cartoon analysis pptMarniebell
 
Edward Hopper, a presentation
Edward Hopper, a presentationEdward Hopper, a presentation
Edward Hopper, a presentationMario Ricca
 
Bibliographie sur l'autoportrait
Bibliographie sur l'autoportraitBibliographie sur l'autoportrait
Bibliographie sur l'autoportraitjuliemds
 
American thirties
American thirtiesAmerican thirties
American thirtiesJDP
 
7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artworkcharlottefrost
 
How do you analyse an artwork
How do you analyse an artworkHow do you analyse an artwork
How do you analyse an artworkcharlottefrost
 
How do you describe an artwork
How do you describe an artworkHow do you describe an artwork
How do you describe an artworkcharlottefrost
 
Where does the idea of judging art come from
Where does the idea of judging art come fromWhere does the idea of judging art come from
Where does the idea of judging art come fromcharlottefrost
 
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...Enjielou
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Hopper exhibition
Hopper exhibitionHopper exhibition
Hopper exhibition
 
Edward%20 hopper%20prints
Edward%20 hopper%20printsEdward%20 hopper%20prints
Edward%20 hopper%20prints
 
Edward Hopper
Edward HopperEdward Hopper
Edward Hopper
 
Cartoon analysis ppt
Cartoon analysis pptCartoon analysis ppt
Cartoon analysis ppt
 
Edward Hopper, a presentation
Edward Hopper, a presentationEdward Hopper, a presentation
Edward Hopper, a presentation
 
Bibliographie sur l'autoportrait
Bibliographie sur l'autoportraitBibliographie sur l'autoportrait
Bibliographie sur l'autoportrait
 
American thirties
American thirtiesAmerican thirties
American thirties
 
7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork
 
How do you analyse an artwork
How do you analyse an artworkHow do you analyse an artwork
How do you analyse an artwork
 
How do you describe an artwork
How do you describe an artworkHow do you describe an artwork
How do you describe an artwork
 
Hopper interiors with woman
Hopper interiors with womanHopper interiors with woman
Hopper interiors with woman
 
Discussing Artwork
Discussing ArtworkDiscussing Artwork
Discussing Artwork
 
Where does the idea of judging art come from
Where does the idea of judging art come fromWhere does the idea of judging art come from
Where does the idea of judging art come from
 
How to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique ArtHow to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique Art
 
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
 

Similar to A guide to writing an art critique

Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docx
Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docxSave your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docx
Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docxtodd331
 
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docx
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docxArt AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docx
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docxwraythallchan
 
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docx
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docxMuseum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docx
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docxrosemarybdodson23141
 
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docx
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docxMuseum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docx
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docxgilpinleeanna
 
ARH2000 Art & Culture USF College of the Arts 1 .docx
ARH2000 Art & Culture  USF College of the Arts 1 .docxARH2000 Art & Culture  USF College of the Arts 1 .docx
ARH2000 Art & Culture USF College of the Arts 1 .docxtarifarmarie
 
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxSelect a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxzenobiakeeney
 
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxSelect a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxnicolleszkyj
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdflimziahuei
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one briefLim Zia Huei
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdflimziahuei
 
Design Project 1 Brief
Design Project 1 BriefDesign Project 1 Brief
Design Project 1 BriefBolin Loong
 
DS Design project one brief
DS Design project one   briefDS Design project one   brief
DS Design project one briefJonathan Lim
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one briefLim Zia Huei
 
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 Brief
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 BriefITD (DESIGN) Project 1 Brief
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 BriefForestedTiger
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one briefdeantkc
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdflimziahuei
 
ITD - Project 1b brief
ITD - Project 1b briefITD - Project 1b brief
ITD - Project 1b briefrachaelcheong
 

Similar to A guide to writing an art critique (20)

Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docx
Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docxSave your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docx
Save your file as a .rtf file or .doc to ensure that it can be opene.docx
 
Webquestfinal2
Webquestfinal2Webquestfinal2
Webquestfinal2
 
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docx
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docxArt AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docx
Art AnalysisDirections Reserve a work by signing up f.docx
 
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docx
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docxMuseum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docx
Museum Paper FORMAL ANALYSISDue 122 1. Description = .docx
 
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docx
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docxMuseum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docx
Museum paper Rubric Formal Analysis of Artwork Points 401..docx
 
ARH2000 Art & Culture USF College of the Arts 1 .docx
ARH2000 Art & Culture  USF College of the Arts 1 .docxARH2000 Art & Culture  USF College of the Arts 1 .docx
ARH2000 Art & Culture USF College of the Arts 1 .docx
 
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxSelect a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
 
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docxSelect a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
Select a museumI have already went to the Museum the work selecte.docx
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one brief
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
 
DesDign project one brief
DesDign project one   briefDesDign project one   brief
DesDign project one brief
 
Design Project 1 Brief
Design Project 1 BriefDesign Project 1 Brief
Design Project 1 Brief
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one brief
 
DS Design project one brief
DS Design project one   briefDS Design project one   brief
DS Design project one brief
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one brief
 
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 Brief
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 BriefITD (DESIGN) Project 1 Brief
ITD (DESIGN) Project 1 Brief
 
Design project one brief
Design project one   briefDesign project one   brief
Design project one brief
 
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdfDesign Project One - Brief.pdf
Design Project One - Brief.pdf
 
ITD - Project 1b brief
ITD - Project 1b briefITD - Project 1b brief
ITD - Project 1b brief
 

A guide to writing an art critique

  • 1. A Guide to Writing an Art Critique *Within your critique, you must identify the artist and work, describe the elements and materials, analyze relationships between elements, consider composition and content and then interpret the work and its purpose. *Below is a guide intended to help, though you do not need to follow it precisely. Writing an Art Critique - the Feldman Method Adapted from Edmund Feldman’s Aesthetic Criticism (as set out in Varieties of Visual Experience,1972). I. Give an introduction to the facts of the exhibit/screening. Who? What? When? Where? If a group exhibition, choose one artwork to critique and identify the artist(s), the title, the medium and year the work was created. II. Critique the artwork using a four-step process. A. Description Make objective* or value-neutral* statements about the work in question. Exclude interpretations and evaluations, and instead take an objective inventory of the work. Point out single features such as objects, trees, and people. Then point out abstract elements such as shapes and colors. Finally point out materials or technologies used to compose this artwork. *A test of objectivity would be that most people would agree with your statement. B. Formal analysis Make statements about the relations among the things you named in the descriptions (part A). You should note similarities and dissimilarities in formal elements–such things as color, shape, or direction. Take note of continuities (such as the color red repeated throughout the work) and of connections (for example, the shape of a window repeated in the shape of a table) between these formal elements and the subject matter. What kind of spatial devices are used to create dimensionality? Do you see examples of repetition or rhythm? Finally, note the overall qualities of the work. C. Interpretation Make statements about the meaning(s) of the work. This is the most creative part of your critique. Using a hypothesis, support it with arguments, based on evidence given in the description and formal analysis (parts A and B). D. Judgment This is the most complex part of the critique and requires an opinion regarding the worth of an object, based on what was learned in the previous stages of the critique. Evaluate the craftsmanship and technique. Are parts of the work successfully interrelated? Does the work illicit a response or communicate an idea? Are you moved by this work? What do you think of it? What is your aesthetic judgment? And on what is based? III. Draw conclusions