2. What is Savant Syndrome?
“Persons with obvious mental [disability] who are
capable of performing remarkable feats in sharply
circumscribed areas at a remarkably high level”
Grossman 1983
intellectual deficit is marked and broad
remarkable behaviour is extraordinary in normal context
3. What is Savant Syndrome?
Rare
Severe mental disability
“Island of genius” involving increased memory skills
Link to autism:
10% people with autism have savant syndrome
50% people with savant syndrome have autistic spectrum disorder
Also present in other developmental disabilities or CNS injury/disease
4. What is Autism?
pervasive developmental disorder
presence of abnormal/impaired development before aged 3 years
abnormal functioning in the three areas of psychopathology:
reciprocal social interaction
communication
restricted, stereotyped, repetitive behaviour
phobias, sleep disorders, eating disorders, temper tantrums and self-directed
aggression are all also common
ICD-10 Classification
5. What is Autism?
ICD-10 uses secondary behaviours
Young et. al., developed the Flinders Observation Schedule of Pre-verbal
Autistic Characteristics (FOSPAC):
focussed on pre-verbal behaviour
not dependant on receptive language
objectively measurable
focussed on core deficit-linked behaviours
poor interaction
bizarre responses to external stimuli
repetitive movements
(Young 2001)
7. Why Savant Syndrome?
Relevant to psychiatry:
Responsible for increasing awareness of Autism
“Training the talent” as a “Conduit towards normalisation”
Brain function models must include this coexistence of mental disability and
exceptional mental ability
Ethical issues surrounding search for a cure
8. Savant Skills
Always related to incredible memory
very deep and narrow, associated with particular skill
Most commonly only one skill
Multiple skills more common in autistic savants
Classification of savant skills
Splinter Skills
most common
obsessions with/memorisation of music, trivia, maps etc.
Talented Savants
ability that is abnormally high in view of cognitive impairment
Prodigious Savants
very rare; <50 currently living
ability considered extraordinary even if viewed in a non-impaired person
9. Savant Skills
Typically found in the following areas:
musical ability
art
calendar calculating/mathematics
mechanical/spatial skills
Rarer skills:
polyglot
abnormal sensory discrimination
ability to know how much time has elapsed
outstanding knowledge in particular fields
Usually right hemisphere in type
10. Kim Peek
Macrocephaly, cerebellar damage, agenisis of corpus callosum
First steps aged 4 years
Motor difficulties
Photographic memory
Reading
10 seconds/page
recall 12,000 books
Calendar calculation skills
Learning piano
Sense of humour developing
11. Daniel Tammet
Autistic savant
Congenital childhood epilepsy
Mathematics, sequence memory, language skills
Synesthesia
π recalled to 22,514 digits
English, French, Spanish, German, Finnish, Lithuanian,
Estonian, Icelandic and Esperanto
Created Mänti language
12. Alonzo Clemons
Head injury as a toddler
Limited language
Clay sculpting talent
20 mins observation of TV
image
45 mins per sculpture
Highly accurate
Vocabulary increasing
Improving social competence
More independent
13. Derek Paravicini
Born 15 weeks premature
0.5 Kg
Oxygen therapy
bind
development affected
Self taught piano
Instantly recall thousands of pieces
Can play in any key
Jazz, Pop & Classical
Improvisation and performance
14. How does it work?
Numerous theories
None are complete
Eidetic imagery (photographic memory)
not present in all savants
may be simply a marker of brain damage
Inherited skills
not enough evidence for skills in relatives
Rote memory
memory cannot totally explain savant skills (Hermelin 2001)
15. How does it work?
savant skills tend to be right hemisphere in type
left brain dysfunction : right brain activity in autism
PET scans have shown ↓5-HT synthesis in left hemisphere in autism
(DeLong 1999)
Numerous case examples:
9 year old boy
gun shot wound to left hemisphere
mute, deaf and paralysed
subsequent savant mechanical skill (Brink 1980)
Right hemisphere compensation following left hemisphere injury
16. How does it work?
Two studies by Miller and Hou:
5 Frontotemporal Dementia patients acquired artistic skills: (Miller 1998)
dominant left hemisphere injury
“Loss of function in the left anterior temporal lobe may lead to the
‘paradoxical functional facilitation’ of artistic and musical skills”
SPECT imaging of 9 year old autistic savant: (Hou 2000)
bilateral ↑frontal lobe perfusion
bilateral ↓anterior temporal lobe perfusion
worse on the left
“The anatomic substrate for the savant syndrome may involve loss of function in
the left temporal lobe with enhanced function of the posterior cortex”
17. How does it work?
rTMS investigations: (Snyder & Mitchell 1999)
used to temporarily halt left hemisphere functioning
5/17 saw ↑in savant-type skills
savant-type skill possible for some, not all
savant processes in the brain occur in everyone but are drowned out by
higher functioning cognition
savant syndrome individuals have “privileged access to lower levels of
information not normally available through introspection”
18. How does it work?
However, some argue against this hypothesis:
prosodic features of speech (usually right hemisphere mediated) may be
absent in savants
melody recall is associated with left hemisphere
absolute pitch associated with larger planum temporale in left hemisphere
Multiple-site model of autism
autism shows several sites of pathology
one of these sites is the basis for savant skill
temporal and parietal polysensory areas
preservative attention and expanded primary pattern extraction
modality-specific information
predicts only some people with autism will develop savant skills
19. Savant Syndrome
rare
intellectual deficit
“island of genius”
link to autism
right hemisphere compensation following left hemisphere injury
multiple-site model of autism
possible future advances in our knowledge and understanding
“acquired” savant syndrome
hidden potential in us all?
21. References
Treffert, D.A. Savant Syndrome: An Extraordinary Condition – A Synopsis: Past, Present, Future.
Hermelin, B. (2001). Bright Splinters of the Mind. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Young, R. (2001). Current research in the area of Autism and Savant Syndrome. International Education
Journal, 2(4):329-333.
Hou, C., Miller, B.L., Cummings, J. (2000). Artistic savants. Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol. Behav. Neurol.,
13:29-38.
DeLong, R. (1999). Autism: new data suggests a new hypothesis. Neurology, 52:911-916.
Miller, L.K. (1999) The Savant Syndrome: Intellectual Impairment and Exceptional Skill. Psychological
Bulletin, 125(1): 31-46.
Snyder, A., Mitchell, D. (1999). Is integer arithmetic fundamental to mental processing? Proc. Royal Soc.
London Biol. Sci., 266:587-592.
Miller, B.L., Cummings, J., Mishkin, F. (1998). Emergence of artistic talent in fronto-temporal dementia.
Neurology, 51:978-982.
Rimland, B., Fein, D.A. (1988) Special Talents of autistic savants. In: The Exceptional Brain:
Neurophysiology of Talent and Special Abilities. Obler, L.K., Fein, D.A., eds. New York: Guilford Press.
Grossman, H. (1983) Classification in mental retardation. Washington, DC: American Association on Mental
Deficiency: 179.
Brink, T. (1980). Idiot savant with unusual mechanical ability. Am. J. Psychiatry, 137:250-251.
Giray, E.F., Barclay, A.G. (1977). Eidetic imagery: longitudinal results in brain-damaged children. Am. J.
Ment. Defic., 82:311-314.
Secondary behaviours such as relating to language are not seen before 4 years of age and therefore autism is often diagnosed late
Poor interaction: gaze (engagement), social referencing, joint attention, reciprocity of smile
Repetitive movements:
Bizarre responses: response to name, response to sounds, response to verbal commands, anticipatory posture for being picked up
This graph shows the number of children diagnosed with autism in the US from 1992 to 2003. It is also said that more progress has been made in our knowledge of Savant Syndrome in the last 15 years than the previous 100.
Autism awareness: talk about Kim Peek and Rain Man; the incidence of diagnosed autism has increased since the 1990s
Ethical issues: some autistic children and adults are opposed to attempts to cure autism. These people see autism as part of who they are and in some cases they perceive treatments and attempts of a cure to be unethical
Classification: there is a spectrum of savant ability
Musical ability: most common is piano, with perfect pitch; although composing without performing has been reported; multiple instruments (up to 20)
Art: drawing, painting, sculpting
Mathematics: rapid calculating skills; compute prime numbers; IN THE ABSENCE OF SIMPLE ARITHMETIC ABILITY
Polyglot = someone with a high degree of proficiency in several languages
Ability to know how much time has elapsed WITHOUT THE USE OF CLOCKS
Mechanical/spatial skills: measure distances accurately without use of instruments; construct highly accurate complex models
Right hemisphere skills are non-symbolic and artistic; Left hemisphere skills are more sequential, logical and symbolic
Born with all conditions of first bulletpoint
Motor difficulties such as walking in a ‘sidelong’ manner and cannot button his shirt
Can recall 12,000 books from memory
Remembers music he heard decades ago and plays it on piano, but his dexterity is limited
Sense of humour has been developing since 2004 according to Kim’s father and since ‘Rain Man’ was made his social skills have improved – CONDUIT TOWARDS NORMALISATION!
Synesthesia: in his mind each number up to 10,000 has its own unique shape and feel. “289 is particularly ugly, 333 is particularly attractive and pi is beautiful”
Pi recollection european record
Learnt Icelandic in a week for a documentary and went on Icelandic TV for an interview
Manti is based on Finnish and Estonian
“None are complete”: none have been able to explain all savants
Inherited skills: for example one study of 23 relatives found only 1 family member to have special skills
Rote memory: several studies have shown….
Rote memory definition = remembering the information without fully understanding it or being able to comprehend the complexities of the information
As previously mentioned, there has been more progress in our knowledge of Savant Syndrome in the last 15 years than in the previous 100. Now I am going to talk about some of the more recent discoveries.
Bulletpoint 2: ….has been shown in numerous studies
“Loss of function in…..”: this is what the authors of the report concluded
“Paradoxical funct….”: a hypothesised process whereby selective degeneration of the anterior temporal and orbitofrontal cortices decreases inhibition of visual systems involved with perception, thereby enhancing artistic interests and abilities”
SPECT = single positron emission computed tomography (uses gamma rays and can provide true 3D information)
rTMS = repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation
used to temporarily halt aspects of left hemisphere functioning
Savant-type skill is possible for some, not all – just as in the disabled population
Bulletpoint 5: conclusion of the authors
Bulletpoint 6: hypotheses if the authors
…primary pattern extraction in processing auditory and visual input.
Modality specific information, thus explaining some savants inability to apply their knowledge
This model also predicts that only a subset of ppl with autism will develop savant skills and also allows non-autistic ppl to develop savant skills.