SlideShare a Scribd company logo

The definition and future of noncommercial

•Download as ODP, PDF•
•
Mike Linksvayer
Mike Linksvayer
TechnologyNews & Politics
1 of 32
The definition and future of noncommercial Mike Linksvayer Creative Commons 2011-09-17
 
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
 
 
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
NC problematic from commons license steward perspective: Built-in non-interoperability among licenses in CC suite Under-use of non-NC licenses, which realize far more value (projects rely on free licenses to exist; making available online doesn’t require a public license)
For (the commons) © would be far less problematic if noncommercial (any definition) sharing not restricted; push that norm
For (against commerce) Exclude commerce from society; prevent exploitation
For (commerce) Promise to not persecute fans, but protect some traditional proprietary licensing revenues
For (choice) CC doesn’t know what freedom means in various communities, which need to discover such for themselves; artists might think noncommercial is correct for them
re communities Free software didn’t immediately arrive at any use, any user – confusion about price and freedom, Linux first released under NC terms OA, OER, PSI, others converging on similar (excluding NC) definitions Possible any use, any user a sweet spot for intellectual commons, for all communities
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object]
 
[object Object]
(1) Don’t version NC licenses, eventually hide option from chooser, formally retire (2) Drop BY-NC-SA and BY-NC-ND to simplify suite (1) has been much requested, discussed, but never terribly actionable; should it become something discussed in serious company?
(3) Support NC licenses, but rebrand as something other than CC; move to non-creativecommons.org domain would be strongest (4) Clarify definition of NC (e.g., match conservative user wish; pointed out earlier more thorough definition in license could be useful for global license) (3) and (4) increase the range of suite (covering more restrictive ground), differentiation within suite (branding and legal), and clarity
Pros & cons Non-exhaustive Most have flipside
Commons Pro: address (and/or further leverage) incompatibility Con: dilute inclusiveness of brand
Licensors and licensees Pro: increase certainty Con: cost for/resistance from existing NC users
4.0 is a once-in-a-decade-or-more (we hope) opportunity; such an important part of the license suite must receive more scrutiny, range of options explored discuss

Recommended

Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and InfrastructureCreative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Mike Linksvayer
 
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing PolicyTowards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Mike Linksvayer
 
Free Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Free Software/Free Culture CollaborationFree Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Free Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Mike Linksvayer
 
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
Dobusch Leonhard
 
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative CommonsLugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Mike Linksvayer
 
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern CaliforniaCC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
Mike Linksvayer
 

Recommended

Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and InfrastructureCreative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Creative Commons Public Domain Legal Tools and Infrastructure
Mike Linksvayer
 
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing PolicyTowards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Towards License Interoperability: Patterns of Sustainable Sharing Policy
Mike Linksvayer
 
Free Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Free Software/Free Culture CollaborationFree Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Free Software/Free Culture Collaboration
Mike Linksvayer
 
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
How far behind Free Software is Free Culture?
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
CC's Role in the Global Commons Movement: Some Thoughts on Strategic Perspect...
Dobusch Leonhard
 
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative CommonsLugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Lugradio Live USA 2008 - Creative Commons
Mike Linksvayer
 
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Media Web Meet-up 1: CC "Rock'n'Rebirth"
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern CaliforniaCC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
CC @ American Society of Media Photographers Northern California
Mike Linksvayer
 
Semantic Copyright Expression Options
Semantic Copyright Expression OptionsSemantic Copyright Expression Options
Semantic Copyright Expression Options
Roland Alton
 
A guide to adding the CC BY license notice
A guide to adding the CC BY license noticeA guide to adding the CC BY license notice
A guide to adding the CC BY license notice
OPEN4Us
 
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association ConferenceGlobal Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Mike Linksvayer
 
Open siddur freedom
Open siddur freedomOpen siddur freedom
Open siddur freedom
efraimdf
 
Creative Commons
Creative CommonsCreative Commons
Creative Commons
Warren D. Allen Music Library at FSU
 
Creative Commons International
Creative Commons International Creative Commons International
Creative Commons International
Creative Commons International
 
Creative Commons: Design & Culture
Creative Commons: Design & CultureCreative Commons: Design & Culture
Creative Commons: Design & Culture
Jane Park
 
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
Mike Linksvayer
 
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
University of California, Berkeley
 
Creative Commons and the Culture of Openness
Creative Commons and the Culture of OpennessCreative Commons and the Culture of Openness
Creative Commons and the Culture of Openness
University of California, Berkeley
 
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
Jane Park
 
creative commons
creative commonscreative commons
creative commons
Marieke Guy
 
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfixOpen World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)ConferenceCC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
Mike Linksvayer
 
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons LicensingIntroduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Donna Gaudet
 
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
Mike Linksvayer
 
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons LicenseAnatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
Mandi Goodsett
 
What is the Creative Commons?
What is the Creative Commons?What is the Creative Commons?
What is the Creative Commons?
Mandi Goodsett
 
Basics of Copyright
Basics of CopyrightBasics of Copyright
Basics of Copyright
Mandi Goodsett
 
Creative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and youCreative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and you
horbal125
 
CCL and Database in Korea
CCL and Database in KoreaCCL and Database in Korea
CCL and Database in Korea
Jay Yoon
 
Open Credential and Radical Openness
Open Credential and Radical Openness Open Credential and Radical Openness
Open Credential and Radical Openness
Open Education Consortium
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association ConferenceGlobal Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Mike Linksvayer
 
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
Mike Linksvayer
 
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons LicensingIntroduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Donna Gaudet
 
Creative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and youCreative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and you
horbal125
 

What's hot (20)

Semantic Copyright Expression Options
Semantic Copyright Expression OptionsSemantic Copyright Expression Options
Semantic Copyright Expression Options
 
A guide to adding the CC BY license notice
A guide to adding the CC BY license noticeA guide to adding the CC BY license notice
A guide to adding the CC BY license notice
 
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association ConferenceGlobal Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
Global Copyright Challenges: 2011 Special Libraries Association Conference
 
Open siddur freedom
Open siddur freedomOpen siddur freedom
Open siddur freedom
 
Creative Commons
Creative CommonsCreative Commons
Creative Commons
 
Creative Commons International
Creative Commons International Creative Commons International
Creative Commons International
 
Creative Commons: Design & Culture
Creative Commons: Design & CultureCreative Commons: Design & Culture
Creative Commons: Design & Culture
 
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
"Opening" the Special Library: Open Source, Open Content, Open Data and More
 
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
OKF/CC open data licensing presentation at OKCon 2011
 
Creative Commons and the Culture of Openness
Creative Commons and the Culture of OpennessCreative Commons and the Culture of Openness
Creative Commons and the Culture of Openness
 
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
Adding the CC BY license to your materials (TAACCCT)
 
creative commons
creative commonscreative commons
creative commons
 
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfixOpen World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
Open World Forum [Followup]: 'require knowledgecommons' # bugfix
 
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)ConferenceCC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
CC @ Stanford Open Source Lab (un)Conference
 
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons LicensingIntroduction to Creative Commons Licensing
Introduction to Creative Commons Licensing
 
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
Open Source Hardware and Developments in Creative Commons Licenses, Compatibi...
 
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons LicenseAnatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
 
What is the Creative Commons?
What is the Creative Commons?What is the Creative Commons?
What is the Creative Commons?
 
Basics of Copyright
Basics of CopyrightBasics of Copyright
Basics of Copyright
 
Creative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and youCreative commons licenses and you
Creative commons licenses and you
 

Viewers also liked

Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovationProgram For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
Mike Linksvayer
 
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
Jane Park
 
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
claudioruiz
 
Search and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
Search and Discovery: OER's Open LoopSearch and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
Search and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
Nathan Yergler
 
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
SNOW.or.kr
 

Viewers also liked (20)

CCL and Database in Korea
CCL and Database in KoreaCCL and Database in Korea
CCL and Database in Korea
 
Open Credential and Radical Openness
Open Credential and Radical Openness Open Credential and Radical Openness
Open Credential and Radical Openness
 
Saudi Arabia’s National Open Education Strategy, Master Plan & Policy
Saudi Arabia’s National Open Education Strategy, Master Plan & PolicySaudi Arabia’s National Open Education Strategy, Master Plan & Policy
Saudi Arabia’s National Open Education Strategy, Master Plan & Policy
 
Creative Commons & Cultural Heritage
Creative Commons & Cultural HeritageCreative Commons & Cultural Heritage
Creative Commons & Cultural Heritage
 
Made With Creative Commons
Made With Creative CommonsMade With Creative Commons
Made With Creative Commons
 
Creative Commons Certificates
Creative Commons CertificatesCreative Commons Certificates
Creative Commons Certificates
 
Third Mission of Universities, MOOCs and OERs
Third Mission of Universities, MOOCs and OERsThird Mission of Universities, MOOCs and OERs
Third Mission of Universities, MOOCs and OERs
 
Mainstreaming OER in Support of Achieving SDG4
Mainstreaming OER in Support of Achieving SDG4Mainstreaming OER in Support of Achieving SDG4
Mainstreaming OER in Support of Achieving SDG4
 
Building a more open, collaborative CC global movement
Building a more open, collaborative CC global movementBuilding a more open, collaborative CC global movement
Building a more open, collaborative CC global movement
 
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
 
Creative Commons Enforcement
Creative Commons EnforcementCreative Commons Enforcement
Creative Commons Enforcement
 
Using the CC BY license, Workshop for 2013 OPEN Kick-off
Using the CC BY license, Workshop for 2013 OPEN Kick-offUsing the CC BY license, Workshop for 2013 OPEN Kick-off
Using the CC BY license, Workshop for 2013 OPEN Kick-off
 
Phillips Remix Cycle Pixelodeon 2007
Phillips Remix Cycle Pixelodeon 2007Phillips Remix Cycle Pixelodeon 2007
Phillips Remix Cycle Pixelodeon 2007
 
CC로 이야기하는 오픈컬쳐
CC로 이야기하는 오픈컬쳐CC로 이야기하는 오픈컬쳐
CC로 이야기하는 오픈컬쳐
 
Let's CC (CCL contents search service)
Let's CC (CCL contents search service)Let's CC (CCL contents search service)
Let's CC (CCL contents search service)
 
Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovationProgram For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
Program For The Future: The Commons as a collective intelligence meta-innovation
 
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
CC and OER Presentation at Whipple Hill User Conference 09
 
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
2011 09 17 guia editores summit pp_tkey
 
Search and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
Search and Discovery: OER's Open LoopSearch and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
Search and Discovery: OER's Open Loop
 
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
SNOW CC conference OER briefing (eng. version)
 

Similar to The definition and future of noncommercial

Creative Commons Licensing
Creative Commons LicensingCreative Commons Licensing
Creative Commons Licensing
tracyl
 
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp OaklandTimothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
openoakland
 
Intro to Creative Commons Licenses
Intro to Creative Commons LicensesIntro to Creative Commons Licenses
Intro to Creative Commons Licenses
Lila Bailey
 

Similar to The definition and future of noncommercial (20)

FOSDEM 2012 Legal Devroom: ⊂ (FLOSS legal/policy ∩ CC [4.0])
FOSDEM 2012 Legal Devroom: ⊂ (FLOSS legal/policy ∩ CC [4.0])FOSDEM 2012 Legal Devroom: ⊂ (FLOSS legal/policy ∩ CC [4.0])
FOSDEM 2012 Legal Devroom: ⊂ (FLOSS legal/policy ∩ CC [4.0])
 
Anatomy of a Creative Commons (CC) Licence
Anatomy of a Creative Commons (CC) Licence Anatomy of a Creative Commons (CC) Licence
Anatomy of a Creative Commons (CC) Licence
 
Anatomy of a License (Creative Commons)
Anatomy of a License (Creative Commons)Anatomy of a License (Creative Commons)
Anatomy of a License (Creative Commons)
 
IOER Creative Commons Licenses
IOER Creative Commons LicensesIOER Creative Commons Licenses
IOER Creative Commons Licenses
 
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons LicenseAnatomy of a Creative Commons License
Anatomy of a Creative Commons License
 
Incompatibility
IncompatibilityIncompatibility
Incompatibility
 
Creative Commons Licensing
Creative Commons LicensingCreative Commons Licensing
Creative Commons Licensing
 
Creative commons, the 5 rs, and oer
Creative commons, the 5 rs, and oerCreative commons, the 5 rs, and oer
Creative commons, the 5 rs, and oer
 
Introduction To Open Source Licensing
Introduction To Open Source LicensingIntroduction To Open Source Licensing
Introduction To Open Source Licensing
 
Puneet Kishor - The new Creative Commons 4.0 Licence – what’s new and why it’...
Puneet Kishor - The new Creative Commons 4.0 Licence – what’s new and why it’...Puneet Kishor - The new Creative Commons 4.0 Licence – what’s new and why it’...
Puneet Kishor - The new Creative Commons 4.0 Licence – what’s new and why it’...
 
commons
commonscommons
commons
 
About Open Licenses
About Open LicensesAbout Open Licenses
About Open Licenses
 
SFO15-TR7: OSS License Compliance
SFO15-TR7: OSS License Compliance SFO15-TR7: OSS License Compliance
SFO15-TR7: OSS License Compliance
 
SFO15-TR1: The Philosophy of Open Source Development
SFO15-TR1: The Philosophy of Open Source DevelopmentSFO15-TR1: The Philosophy of Open Source Development
SFO15-TR1: The Philosophy of Open Source Development
 
Platform terms and CC licenses
Platform terms and CC licensesPlatform terms and CC licenses
Platform terms and CC licenses
 
Creative commons
Creative commonsCreative commons
Creative commons
 
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp OaklandTimothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
Timothy Vollmer's keynote at CityCamp Oakland
 
Legal considerations for platforms
Legal considerations for platformsLegal considerations for platforms
Legal considerations for platforms
 
2009 10-08 soa-og_itil_does service in it service rhyme with service as in so...
2009 10-08 soa-og_itil_does service in it service rhyme with service as in so...2009 10-08 soa-og_itil_does service in it service rhyme with service as in so...
2009 10-08 soa-og_itil_does service in it service rhyme with service as in so...
 
Intro to Creative Commons Licenses
Intro to Creative Commons LicensesIntro to Creative Commons Licenses
Intro to Creative Commons Licenses
 

More from Mike Linksvayer

Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
Mike Linksvayer
 
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!) Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
Mike Linksvayer
 
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen scienceOpen data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
Mike Linksvayer
 
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and ChoicesMass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
Mike Linksvayer
 
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently failsOpen World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
Mike Linksvayer
 
Webmission.be visits Creative Commons
Webmission.be visits Creative CommonsWebmission.be visits Creative Commons
Webmission.be visits Creative Commons
Mike Linksvayer
 
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
Mike Linksvayer
 
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative CommonsHOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
Mike Linksvayer
 
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
Mike Linksvayer
 
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
Mike Linksvayer
 
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
Mike Linksvayer
 
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology SeminarThe Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
Mike Linksvayer
 
The Future of Digital Freedom
The Future of Digital FreedomThe Future of Digital Freedom
The Future of Digital Freedom
Mike Linksvayer
 
Five myths about the future of culture and the commons
Five myths about the future of culture and the commonsFive myths about the future of culture and the commons
Five myths about the future of culture and the commons
Mike Linksvayer
 
Certifying public domain works
Certifying public domain worksCertifying public domain works
Certifying public domain works
Mike Linksvayer
 

More from Mike Linksvayer (20)

Citizen Science and Collaborative Data Crosswalks
Citizen Science and Collaborative Data CrosswalksCitizen Science and Collaborative Data Crosswalks
Citizen Science and Collaborative Data Crosswalks
 
Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
Leave it to the Experts: Leveraging Archive.org and Creative Commons for PEG ...
 
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!) Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
Software Eats the (Commons/Public Licensing) World (It Should!)
 
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen scienceOpen data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
Open data policy for scientists as citizens and for citizen science
 
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and ChoicesMass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
Mass Collaboration [Policy]: What, Why, and Choices
 
Digital Commons Meetup at Wikimania 2012
Digital Commons Meetup at Wikimania 2012Digital Commons Meetup at Wikimania 2012
Digital Commons Meetup at Wikimania 2012
 
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently failsOpen World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
Open World Forum: 'require knowledgecommons' # This currently fails
 
Learning Resource Metadata Initiative: Vocabulary Development Best Practices
Learning Resource Metadata Initiative: Vocabulary Development Best PracticesLearning Resource Metadata Initiative: Vocabulary Development Best Practices
Learning Resource Metadata Initiative: Vocabulary Development Best Practices
 
Webmission.be visits Creative Commons
Webmission.be visits Creative CommonsWebmission.be visits Creative Commons
Webmission.be visits Creative Commons
 
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
New and Emerging Legal Infrastructures Conference (NELIC): Creative Commons ...
 
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative CommonsHOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
HOLLAND=OPEN trade mission visits Creative Commons
 
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
eval("freedom_stack.push(culture)"); // The Creative Commons Solution?
 
Collaboration for Good Futures
Collaboration for Good FuturesCollaboration for Good Futures
Collaboration for Good Futures
 
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
Emerging Issues 2010: Whose Big Idea?
 
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
OER content interoperability for Wikimedia platforms (panel)
 
Singularity University Open Source Panel
Singularity University Open Source PanelSingularity University Open Source Panel
Singularity University Open Source Panel
 
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology SeminarThe Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
The Commons - Networked Politics & Technology Seminar
 
The Future of Digital Freedom
The Future of Digital FreedomThe Future of Digital Freedom
The Future of Digital Freedom
 
Five myths about the future of culture and the commons
Five myths about the future of culture and the commonsFive myths about the future of culture and the commons
Five myths about the future of culture and the commons
 
Certifying public domain works
Certifying public domain worksCertifying public domain works
Certifying public domain works
 

Recently uploaded

Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Principled Technologies
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Drew Madelung
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Joaquim Jorge
 
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
vu2urc
 
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot TakeoffStrategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
sammart93
 
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Miguel Araújo
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Partners Life - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Partners Life - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Partners Life - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Partners Life - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
presentation ICT roal in 21st century education
presentation ICT roal in 21st century educationpresentation ICT roal in 21st century education
presentation ICT roal in 21st century education
 
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone ProcessorsExploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
 
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdfGenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
 
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organizationScaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
 
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Developing An App To Navigate The Roads of Brazil
Developing An App To Navigate The Roads of BrazilDeveloping An App To Navigate The Roads of Brazil
Developing An App To Navigate The Roads of Brazil
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
 
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps ScriptAutomating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
 
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
 
HTML Injection Attacks: Impact and Mitigation Strategies
HTML Injection Attacks: Impact and Mitigation StrategiesHTML Injection Attacks: Impact and Mitigation Strategies
HTML Injection Attacks: Impact and Mitigation Strategies
 
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot TakeoffStrategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
 
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
 
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
 
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 

The definition and future of noncommercial

  • 1. The definition and future of noncommercial Mike Linksvayer Creative Commons 2011-09-17
  • 2.  
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.  
  • 8.  
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. NC problematic from commons license steward perspective: Built-in non-interoperability among licenses in CC suite Under-use of non-NC licenses, which realize far more value (projects rely on free licenses to exist; making available online doesn’t require a public license)
  • 16. For (the commons) © would be far less problematic if noncommercial (any definition) sharing not restricted; push that norm
  • 17. For (against commerce) Exclude commerce from society; prevent exploitation
  • 18. For (commerce) Promise to not persecute fans, but protect some traditional proprietary licensing revenues
  • 19. For (choice) CC doesn’t know what freedom means in various communities, which need to discover such for themselves; artists might think noncommercial is correct for them
  • 20. re communities Free software didn’t immediately arrive at any use, any user – confusion about price and freedom, Linux first released under NC terms OA, OER, PSI, others converging on similar (excluding NC) definitions Possible any use, any user a sweet spot for intellectual commons, for all communities
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.  
  • 26.
  • 27. (1) Don’t version NC licenses, eventually hide option from chooser, formally retire (2) Drop BY-NC-SA and BY-NC-ND to simplify suite (1) has been much requested, discussed, but never terribly actionable; should it become something discussed in serious company?
  • 28. (3) Support NC licenses, but rebrand as something other than CC; move to non-creativecommons.org domain would be strongest (4) Clarify definition of NC (e.g., match conservative user wish; pointed out earlier more thorough definition in license could be useful for global license) (3) and (4) increase the range of suite (covering more restrictive ground), differentiation within suite (branding and legal), and clarity
  • 29. Pros & cons Non-exhaustive Most have flipside
  • 30. Commons Pro: address (and/or further leverage) incompatibility Con: dilute inclusiveness of brand
  • 31. Licensors and licensees Pro: increase certainty Con: cost for/resistance from existing NC users
  • 32. 4.0 is a once-in-a-decade-or-more (we hope) opportunity; such an important part of the license suite must receive more scrutiny, range of options explored discuss