SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 45
Download to read offline
A Presentation on ‘Sophie’s World’
                   by
          Nayana RenuKumar
Sr. Knowledge Manager, Centre for Good Governance
Chapter Index

Chapter I--Garden of       Chapter XIII--The Postcards   Chapter XXV--Kant
Eden                       Chapter XIV--Two Cultures     Chapter XXVI--Romanticism
Chapter II--The Top Hat    Chapters XV--Middle Ages      Chapter XXVII--Hegel
Chapter III--The Myths     Chapter XVI-- Renaissance     Chapter XXVIII--Kierkegaard
Chapter IV--Natural        Chapter XVII--The Baroque     Chapter XXIX--Marx
Philosophers               Chapter XVIII--Descartes      Chapter XXX--SUMMARY/
Chapter V--Democritus      Chapter XIX--Spinoza          REVIEW & DARWIN
Chapter VI--Fate           Chapter XX--Locke             Chapter XXXI--Freud
Chapter VII--Socrates      Chapter XXI--Hume             Chapter XXXII--Our Own Time
Chapter VIII--Athens       Chapter XXII--Berkeley        Chapter XXXIII--Garden Party
Chapter IX--Plato          Chapter XXIII--Bjerkely       Chapter XXXIV--Counterpoint
Chapter X--Major's Cabin   Chapter XXIV--The             Chapter XXXV--The Big Bang
Chapter XI-Aristotle       Enlightenment
Chapter XII--Hellenism
The Garden of Eaden
    The Top Hat
     The Myths
The Garden of Eden



                        Who are you?
                     Where does the world
                         come from?
The Top Hat
            Dear Sophie,
The best way of approaching
philosophy is to ask a few                 A Greek philosopher who
philosophical questions:                       lived more than two
                                                thousand years ago
   How was the world created?
                                             believed that philosophy
   Is there any will or meaning behind        had its origin in man’s
   what happens?                                  sense of wonder
   Is there a life after death?
   How can        we    answer     these
   questions?
    And most important, how ought we
   to live?
The Myths
  ... a precarious balance between the forces of good and evil…

Philosophy -- the completely new way of thinking that evolved in
Greece about 600 years before Christ
Till then religions offered answers to people's questions
Religious explanations were handed down from generation to
generation as myths. Myth is a story about the gods which
sets out to explain why life is as it is
Around 700 B.C., Homer and Hesiod writes down much of the
Greek mythology. Once Myths existed in written form, it was
possible to discuss and criticize them.      Earliest Greek
philosophers criticized Homer’s mythology because the gods
resembled mortals too much
For the first time, it was said that the myths were nothing but
human notions
Natural Philosophers
THREE                              ELIATICS                          DEMOCRITUS
PHILOSOPHERS
FROM MILETUS                       Parmenides: Everything            Everything was made
                                   that exists had always            of was built up of
Thales: Source of all              existed. Nothing could            tiny invisible blocks,
things is water                    change                            each of which was
Anaximander: Our                                                     eternal and
                                   Heraclitus : Constant
world is only one of a                                               immutable.
                                   change, or flow, was the
myriad of worlds that              most basic characteristic of      Democritus    called
evolve and dissolve in             nature. Everything flows.         these smallest units
the boundless                                                        atoms
                                   Therefore we cannot step
Anaximenes : Source of             twice into the same river.
                                   Eerything could change
                                                                   Seekers of natural than
all things must be “air” or
                                                                        supernatural
“vapor                             Empedocles: World had          explanations for natural
All believed in the existence      to consist of more than one
                                                                          processes
of a single basic substance        single substance. Nature
                                                                  Decisive break with the
as the source of all things        could transform without
                                   anything actually changing.
                                                                     mythological world
                                                                           picture
Socrates
                                     Aristotle


   The Triumvirate
 3 great classical philosophers to
 influence European civilization




Plato
Socrates (470-399BC)
Most enigmatic figure in the entire history of philosophy
Life of Socrates mainly known through the writings of Plato has
inspired the Western world for nearly 2,500 years
Not a sophist, but a philosopher : Sophists and Socrates turned
their attention from questions of natural philosophy to
problems related to man and society.
He was neither certain nor indifferent: All he knew was that he
knew nothing—and it troubled him. "One thing only I know, and that is
that I know nothing" So he became a philosopher—someone who does not give up but
tirelessly pursues his quest for truth. He dared tell people how little we humans know.

The Art of Discourse : Never a believer of instruction. Like a midwife,
Socrates saw his task as helping people to “give birth” to correct
insight
By playing ignorant, Socrates forced people to use their common
sense
Socrates
All true insight comes from within: Real understanding must come from within;
only that can lead to true insight. Right insight leads to right action. He who
knows what good is will do good.
We all had the same chances because we all had the same common sense:
    There exists eternal and absolute rules for what is right or wrong.
    By using our common sense we can all arrive at these norms
    Ability to distinguish between right and wrong lies in people’s reason, not in society
    Unmistakable faith in human reason
Socrates managed to free himself from the prevailing views of his time by his own
intelligence. But he had to pay a heavy price for it
Socrates was killed because he disturbed the Athenian society's conventional
ideas and tried to light the way to true insight.
In Socrates, we therefore see how dangerous it could be to appeal to people’s
Reason.
Socrates must have had tremendous courage and sense of pedagogic responsibility
to go ahead regardless of the perils
Plato (428 -347 BC)
  Search for the eternal and immutable : Plato was concerned with the
  relationship between what is eternal and immutable, on the one hand, and what
  “flows,” on the other – middle ground between sophists and socrates
  Theory of Ideas: Reality is divided into two regions:
   ●   World of senses: About which we can only have approximate or
       incomplete knowledge by using our five senses. Here, “everything flows” and
       nothing is permanent.
   ●   World of ideas: About which we can have true knowledge by using our
       reason. This world of ideas cannot be perceived by the senses, but the ideas
       (or forms) are eternal and immutable. All natural forms are mere shadows
       or reflections of eternal forms or ideas – theory of ideas
Man is thus a dual creature: our body consists of earth and dust like
everything else in the sensory world (matter), but we also had an
immortal soul (spirit)
Plato
Pluto's political philosophy
 Body          Soul            Virtue        State
 Head          Reason          Wisdom        Rulers
 Chest         Will            Courage       Auxiliaries
 Abdomen       Appetite        Temperance    Laborers


Characterized by rationalism. Favored philosophers' rule of state. In
effect a totalitarian state with no family and political ties, not unlike
caste system. Later opined that a constitutional state is the next
best option
On women: Women could govern just as effectively as men for
the simple reason that the rulers govern by virtue of their reason.
Women have exactly the same powers of reasoning as men,
provided they get the same training and are exempt from child rearing
and housekeeping
Aristotle...not only the last of the great Greek philosophers, but also
                             Europe’s first great biologist (384-322 BC)


A meticulous organizer who set out to clarify our concepts.
Founded the science of Logic.
Criticized Plato's theory of ideas:

    Highest degree of reality is that which      Highest degree of reality is that which
    we think with our reason                     we perceive with our senses

    Things we see in natural world are purely    Things that are in the human soul were
    reflections of things that existed in the    purely reflections of natural objects. So
    higher reality of the world of ideas - and   nature is the real world
    thereby in the human soul

The distinction between “form” and “substance” plays an important part in
Aristotle’s explanation of the way we discern things in the world
Nature's scale: There is a gradual transition from simple growths to more
complicated plants, from simple animals to more complicated animals. With man at
the top of this “scale” who lives the whole life of nature.
Ethics: Three forms of happiness;
    Life of pleasure and enjoyment;
    Life as a free and responsible citizen;
    Life as thinker and philosopher.
All three criteria must be present at the same time for man to find happiness and
fulfillment. He rejected all forms of imbalance and advocated the golden mean
Women: Woman is incomplete, an unfinished man
Politics: Three good forms of constitution


      Form             Meaning                Must not degenerate into
      Monarchy         Only one head of       Tyranny
                       State                  One ruler captures power
      Aristocracy      Larger group of        Oligarchy
                       rulers                 Government run by a select few
      Polity           Democracy              Mob rule
Hellenism... a spark from the fire…

Athens loses its dominant role by 325 BC
Conquests of Alexander the Great      political upheavals   new
epoch in history of mankind
Hellenism refers to both the period of time and the Greek-
dominated culture that prevailed in the Hellenistic kingdoms of
Macedonia, Syria, and Egypt
Borders between countries and cultures became erased. In
place of “national religion, different cultures merged into a
fusion of creeds
New religious formations – fusion of many gods, many beliefs -
doubt and uncertainty about philosophy of life - religious
doubts, cultural dissolution, and pessimism - "The world had
grown old"
Hellenism
  Philosophic insight – not only for its own sake but also to
  free mankind from pessimism and the fear of death
  Eliminates boundaries between religion and philosophy
  Hellenistic philosophy
     Not startlingly original
     Continued to work with problems raised by Socrates,
     Plato, and Aristotle
     Common current: Desire to discover how mankind should
     best live and die – ethics - central philosophical project
     Emphasis on finding out what true happiness was and how
     it could be achieved.
Four major philosophical trends
The Cynics               &            Stoics
Antisthenes – Athens      -        Zeno -around 300 BC
around 400 B.C
                                   All natural processes follow
True happiness is not found        the unbreakable laws of
in external advantages or
                                   nature. Man must therefore
on being dependent on
random and fleeting things         learn to accept his destiny.

Therefore happiness       is       Nothing happens
within everyone’s reach            accidentally;
Having once been attained,         Everything happens through
it can never be lost               necessity;
                                   So it is of little use to
                                   complain when fate comes
                                   knocking at the door
Epicureans                      &         Neoplatonics
Epicurus around 300 BC                   Plato - distinction between
                                         world of ideas and sensory
The highest good is pleasure, the        world
greatest evil is pain
                                         Plotinus (270-205 BC) - world as
Pleasurable results of an action to      a span between two poles with
be weighed against possible side         divine light (God) at one end and
effects                                  absolute darkness at other end.
                                         All that exists is God. Soul is
Death does not concern us; as long       illuminated by the light from the
as we exist, death is not here. And      God, while matter is the
when it does come, we no longer exist    darkness that has no real
The gods are not to be feared. Death     existence.
is nothing to worry about.               Divine mystery in everything
                                         that exists. No barrier between
Good is easy to attain. The fearful is
                                         god and man
easy to endure.
Two Cultures, two philosophies
Indo-European: All nations and cultures              Semitic : Cultures using Semitic
using Indo-European languages (Most of               languages. Root of all three
Europe, India, Iran) Clear similarities in           Western religions - Judaism,
mode of thoughts                                     Christianity, Islam

Belief in many gods                               Belief in one god

Sought insight into world’s history - Sight       Relied on God’s words - Hearing
                                                  Distance between god and his creation –
Oneness with God
                                                  No pictures & sculptures -
Purpose of life is to be released from the        Purpose of life is to be redeemed from sin
cycle of rebirth                                  and blame
Religious life characterized by self-             Religious life characterized by prayer,
communion and meditation                          sermons, and study of scriptures
Cyclic view of history: History goes in           Linear view of history: In the beginning,
circles like seasons - no beginning and no        God created the world – history begun.
end - Civilizations rise and fall in an eternal   On Judgment day history will end, when
interplay between birth and death                 God judges the living and the dead
The Middle Ages...A 1000 year journey
   Rise of Christianity:
          145 AD                      300 AD               313 AD              380 AD
Paul’s missionary journeys   Christian Church banned   Accepted religion   Official religion

   Church puts the lid on Greek philosophy
        529 AD- Closed Plato’s Academy
        Monasteries wrested monopoly of education, reflection, and meditation

   By 600 AD, Islam wins over Middle East, Spain, and North African part
   of Roman empire; adopts Mecca, Medina, Jerusalem, and Bagdad
   Arabs inherited much of old Greek science; gains prominence in sciences
   Dark Ages, one interminable thousand-year-long night settled
   over Europe between antiquity and the Renaissance.
   Also seen as a period of germination and growth when schools and
   universities developed. Unifying force of Christian culture
Medieval philosophers
Took it almost for granted that Christianity was true. Only
questions:
  Whether to simply believe Christian revelations or approach
  them with help of reason
  No dramatic break with Greek philosophy; slow transition
  enabled by Fathers of the Church like St. Augustine
  St. Augustine:
     Located Platonic ideas in God and thus preserved the Platonic view
     of eternal ideas
        Biblical idea : God created the world out of the void.
        Greeks        : World had always existed.
        St. Augustine : Before God created the world, the ‘ideas’ were in the
        Divine mind
     Idea of City of God: Human history is a struggle between
     ‘Kingdom of God’ and ‘Kingdom of World for mastery over human
     beings
St. Thomas Aquinas
Christianized Aristotle just as St. Augustine Christianized Plato

Adopted Aristotle’s philosophy in all areas where it did not collide with
Church’s theology. (Logic, theory of knowledge, and natural philosophy)

No need for any conflict between philosophers like Aristotle and Christian
doctrine

God’s existence can be proved on the basis of Aristotle’s philosophy

Truths could be reached both through Christian faith and innate reason.
    Two paths to faith: Aristotle’s philosophy presumed the existence of a formal cause (God)
    which sets all natural processes going. Christianity knows this formal cause is god. God has
    thus revealed himself to mankind both through the Bible and through reason.

    Two paths to moral life: Bible teaches us how God wants us to live. But God has also given
    us a conscience to distinguish between right and wrong.

Aristotle goes only part of the way because he didn’t know of the Christian
revelation. But going only part of the way is not the same as going
the wrong way
Renaissance (Rebirth):
   Rich cultural development - began in late 14th century – N. Italy - spread rapidly
   northward in 200 years
   Rebirth of art and culture of antiquity
   After Dark Ages where life was seen through divine light, everything once again
   revolved around man - Renaissance humanism
Basis
   Changes on the cultural and economic front –
        From subsistence economy to a monetary economy.
        Developed cities – rise of middle class with better basic conditions of life.
        Rewarded people’s diligence, imagination, and ingenuity
        New demands on individual
   Three discoveries: - compass (easy navigation – great voyages), firearms,
   (military superiority) and printing press (dissemination of ideas – breaks free of
   Church monopoly) - essential preconditions
   Renaissance middle class - break away from feudal lords and church.
   Religion acquires a freer relationship to reasoning and science
   New scientific methods and a new religious fervor.
   Rediscovery of Greek culture through closer contact with the Arabs in
   Spain and Byzantine culture in East
New view of
   mankind                   Greater
                          individualism              Nothing to be
                                                      ashamed of                 Life in here and
• Resurgence of      •   Not mere beings, but                                           now
  humanism               unique individuals
                                                 •   Renewed interest in
• New belief in      •   Ideal of Renaissance        human anatomy          •   Man did not exist
  man and his            man, a man of                                          purely for God’s sake
  worth                                          •   After thousand
                         universal      genius
                                                     years of prudery, it   •   He felt at home in the
• Man was now            embracing all aspects
                                                     once again became          world
  considered             of life, art, and
                                                     usual for works of
  infinitely great       science                                            •   Life is not solely a
  and valuable                                       art to depict the
                                                                                preparation for afterlife
                         Emphasis          on        nude
                                                                                - whole new approach
                     •


                         individual and    his
                                                 •   Man was bold               to physical world
                         personal relationship
                                                     enough to be
                         to God                                             •   Freedom to develop –
                                                     himself again
                                                                                limitless possibilities -
                                                                                aim was now to
                                                                                exceed all boundaries
    Unrivalled development in all spheres of life. Art and
    architecture, literature, music, philosophy, and science
    flourished as never before
    Pantheism: God was also present in his creation
Science...empiricism
New method of scientific investigation      - observation, experiment,
experience
Measure what can be measured, and make measurable what cannot be
measured : Galileo
Emphasize on practical value of knowledge
Starting to intervene in nature and beginning to control it
Nicolas Copernicus: Earth moved around the Sun and not vice versa
(1543) - Heliocentric world picture
Kepler - Planets move in elliptical orbits. Earth is a planet like any
other (1600s) . Same physical laws apply everywhere in the universe
Law of Inertia: A body remains in the state which it is in, at rest or in
motion, as long as no external force compels it to change its state.
Isaac Newton: Final description of the solar system and the planetary
orbits – Law of Universal Gravitation
Baroque...such stuff as dreams are made of (17th century)
   Irregularity and richness was typical of Baroque art than the plainer and more
   harmonious Renaissance art.
   Baroque favorite sayings : ‘Carpe diem’—‘seize the day',                   ‘memento mori' -
   ‘Remember that you must die.’
   Age of conflict, class differences, and irreconcilable contrasts - between
   Renaissance’s unremitting optimism and life of religious seclusion and self-
   denial; between rich and the poor; between magnificence and mendicancy;
   between Protestants and Catholics; wars between countries
   Birth of modern theater
   Philosophy of Baroque: Characterized by powerful struggles between diametrically
   opposed modes of thought
       Contours between Idealism and Materialism never so clearly present at the same time as in the
       Baroque.

       Great philosophers of this period – Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibiniz
Descartes
Father of modern philosophy: Assembled contemporary thought
into one coherent philosophical system
Socrates-Plato-St. Augustine-Descartes: Rationalists - reason as
the only path to knowledge                                     These
                                                                  questions -
Main concerns:                                                    substance of
                                                                  philosophical
What we can know, in other words, certain knowledge               argument for
                                                                  next 150 years
What was the relationship between body and mind.
Discourse on Philosophical Method: Philosophy should go from
the simple to the complex to construct a new insights. Ensure by
constant enumeration and control that nothing was left out. Then, a
philosophical conclusion would be within reach
Favorite line: Cogito, ergo sum: I think therefore I am
Dualist: Man is a dual creature-with a mind and body (matter –
extension of mind)
Baruch Spinoza
First to apply historic-critical interpretation of Bible: Critical
reading of Bible bearing in mind the period it was written in
Spinoza interpreted this as meaning both love of God and love of
humanity
Monist: Does not have dualistic view of reality as Descartes.
   Everything that exists can be reduced to one single reality
   Substance which may be God or nature.
   God speaking through the laws of nature is the inner cause of everything that happens

Everything in the material world happens through necessity. Spinoza
had a determinist view of the material, or natural, world
John Locke            David Hume




From Rationalists to Empiricists




                George Berkeley
John Locke (1632-1704)
Essay Concerning Human Understanding: Attempt to clarify two questions:
Where we get our ideas from: Mind at birth is an empty slate. Only source of
genuine knowledge is sensory experience. Knowledge that cannot be traced back to a
sensation is therefore false knowledge and must consequently be rejected. There’s
nothing in the intellect that wasn’t previously in the senses
Can we rely on our sense: Senses objectively reproduce primary qualities
(extension, weight, motion and number) world as it is. Senses only reproduce the
effect of the outer reality of secondary qualities (color, smell, taste, sound) on our
senses – subjective – world as it appears to us . Everyone agrees on primary
qualities, secondary qualities vary from person to person - relativism
"There is nothing in the mind except what was first in the senses" (Aristotle)
Inconsistent in empiricism: It is inherent in human reason to be able to know that
God exists
Forerunner of many liberal ideas: He spoke out for intellectual liberty and tolerance
and equality of the sexes, division of powers
David Hume (1711-1776)
A Treatise of Human Nature: We sometimes form complex ideas for which there
is no corresponding object in the physical world. Example – Batman or Superman.
Each element was once sensed, and entered the theater of the mind in the form
of a real ‘impression.’ Mind puts things together and constructs false ‘ideas
Hume sought to tidy up thoughts and notions: critical analysis of ideas
    Investigate every single idea to see whether it was compounded in a way that
    does not correspond to reality
    Opposed all thoughts and ideas that could not be traced back to
    corresponding sense perceptions
    "Dismiss all this meaningless nonsense which long has dominated
    metaphysical thought and brought it into disrepute"
With Hume’s philosophy, the final link between faith and knowledge was
broken
Hume also rebelled against rationalist thought in the area of ethics that the ability
to distinguish between right and wrong is inherent in human reason. “It is not
reason that determines what we say and do”
Berkeley (1685-1753)
Felt that current philosophies and science were a threat to
the Christian way of life
Material reality doesnot exist. We percieve only ideas. we
never have direct experience of things themselves.
Everything we see and feel is ‘an effect of God’s power.We
exist only in the mind of god
Our own perception of time and space can also be merely
figments of the mind Denied existence of a material world
beyond the human mind. Our sense perceptions proceed
from God.
Voltaire                                                Montesquieu
                       The Enlightenment
...from the way needles are made to the way cannons are founded




                                   Rousseau
Seven key words
Opposition to authority : Of French philosophers inspired by the English
philosophy and liberal political establishment
Rationalism: Unshakable faith in human reason- Age of Reason.
Enlightenment movement: Greatest monument- huge encyclopedia. All the
great philosophers and men of letters contributed to it. ‘Everything is to be found
here, 'from the way needles are made to the way cannons are founded
Cultural optimism: Once reason and knowledge became widespread, humanity
would make great progress. It could only be a question of time before irrationalism
and ignorance would give way to an ‘enlightened’ humanity
Return to nature: Emphasized intrinsic value of childhood
Natural religion: Religion also had to be brought into harmony with ‘natural’
reason. Deism - God only reveals himself to mankind through nature and natural
laws, never in any ‘supernatural’ way
Human rights: Not content themselves with theoretical views on man’s place in
society - fought actively for ‘natural rights’ (lights that everybody was entitled to
simply by being born) of the citizen. Campaign against censorship, for freedom of
expression in religion, morals, and politics, for abolition of slavery and for a more
humane treatment of criminals
Immanuel Kant
      Showed the way out of the philosophical impasse in the struggle
      between rationalism and empiricism
   Rationalists: Basis for all human knowledge Empiricists: Knowledge of the world
   lay in the mind                                 proceeded from senses
                            Kant: Both views are partly right and partly wrong

      All our knowledge of the world comes from our sensations. But in our
      reason there are decisive factors that determine how we perceive the world
      around us
      We have no freedom if we lived only as creatures of the senses. But if we
      obey universal reason we are free and independent
      There are clear limits to what we can know. Mind’s ‘glasses’ set these limits
      It is not only mind which conforms to things. Things also conform to the
      mind.
Greatest contribution to philosophy : Dividing line between things in
themselves and things as they appear to us
Romanticism...Europe's last great cultural epoch
  ‘Feeling,” imagination,” experience,’ ‘yearning
  All of nature - human soul and physical reality - is the expression
  of one world spirit - Schelling
  Features:
      Yearning for something distant and unattainable like bygone
      eras; for nature and nature's mysteries
      Artists can provide something philosophers can’t express
      Urban phenomenon, youth
Romanticism helped strengthen the feeling of national identity
  Two forms of Romanticism
      Universal       Romanticism: Romantics             who    were
      preoccupied with nature, world soul, and artistic genius
      National Romanticism : Interested in the history, language
      and culture of ‘the people’
Hegel ... the reasonable is that which is viable…
First philosopher who tried to salvage philosophy when the 'Romantics had
dissolved everything into spirit'
Hegel’s philosophy – Historicism - A method to understand the progress
of history
Any human society and all human activities (science, art, or philosophy), are
defined by their history, so their essence can be sought only through
understanding that
There are no eternal truths. Only fixed point philosophy can hold onto is
history itself. The current of past traditions and present material conditions
determine what you think. No thought is true forever. (Aristotle - woman is
incomplete man)
Dialectic process -Three stages of knowledge:
    Thesis: A thought is proposed on the basis of other, previously proposed thoughts
    Antithesis: As soon as one thought is proposed, it will be contradicted by another
    Synthesis: Tension between these two opposite ways of thinking is resolved by the
    proposal of a third thought which accommodates the best of both points of view
"Philosophy is the history of philosophy"
Kierkegaard …Europe is on the road to bankruptcy…
   Critique of Romantic idealism and Hegelian historicism - "Both
   have obscured the individual’s responsibility for his own life"
   Sharp eye for the significance of the individual: We are more than ‘children
   of our time.’ Every single one of us is a unique individual who only lives
   once
Three concepts
                                               Three stages in the way of life:
Existentialism: Exist for the moment.
Instead of searching for 'The Truth', we       Aesthetic stage: Lives for the moment and
should focus on truths that are                grasps every opportunity of enjoyment. Slave
important to our individual life, our          to ones senses desires and moods.
existence.
                                               Ethical stage: Seriousness and consistency of
Subjective truth: Objective truths are
totally irrelevant to personal life. Really    moral choices. Living by the moral laws (Kant)
important truths are personal and              Religious stage: Jumping into the abyss’ of
subjective. Only these truths are ‘true
for me'                                        Faith’s in preference to aesthetic pleasure and
                                               reason’s call of duty. Although it can be ‘terrible
Faith: Fundamental questions in life can
                                               to jump into the open arms of the living God,
only be approached through faith; not
through knowledge or reason                    it is the only path to redemption
Marx
"Until now, ‘philosophers have only interpreted the world in various
ways; the point is to change it
Historical materialist
   Material changes are the ones that affect history
   It is the economic forces in society that create change and drive
   history forward
   Material, economic, and social relations are the basis of society
   This base determines the answers to questions of what was morally
   right (Peasant society - marriage)
   Society’s ruling class sets the norms for what is right or wrong
   History of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class
   struggles. Between those who own the means of production and
   those who do not. In other words, history is principally a matter of
   who is to own the means of production
Marx
Criticism of the capitalist method of production
  Worker alienation:
      Way you think is closely connected to the job you do
      Under capitalist system, worker labors for someone else
      Worker becomes alien to his work - but at the same time also alien to himself
  Revolution:
      Capitalist system is marching toward its own destruction; paving way to
      communism.
      Since ‘upper classes’ do not voluntarily relinquish power, change can only come
      through revolution
  Dictatorship of the proletariat : For a period, we get a new ‘class
  society’ in which the proletarians suppress the bourgeoisie by force
  Classless society: After the transition period, the dictatorship of the
  proletariat is replaced by a ‘classless society,’ - means of production are
  owned ‘by all’. From each according to his abilities, to each according to his
  needs.’
Darwin                                              Freud
Biologist and natural scientist          Developed psychoanalysis
Most openly challenged the Biblical      Constant tension between man and his
view of man’s place in Creation          surroundings - between his drives and
through 'The Origin of Species'.         needs and the demands of society
Darwin advanced two theories:
                                         Man is not really such a rational
   All existing vegetable and animal     creature
   forms were descended from earlier,
   more primitive forms through          Irrational impulses often determine
   biological evolution.                 what we think, what we dream, and
   Evolution was the result of natural   what we do
   selection
                                         Archaeology of soul: As we store the
In the struggle for life, those that     memory of all our experiences deep
were best adapted to their               inside us, psychoanalyst can dig deep
surroundings would survive and           into the patient’s mind and bring to
perpetuate the race                      light the experiences that have caused
                                         the patient’s psychological disorder
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905 to 1980)
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900)
                                               Leading light among existentialists
Reacted against Hegel’s ‘historicism.’
                                               Especially popular in the forties after the
Proposed    life    itself  as     a
                                               war
counterweight to the anemic interest
in history and Christian ‘slave                Existentialism is humanism
morality.’
                                               Man is the only living creature that is
Both Christianity and traditional              conscious of its own existence
philosophy had turned away from the
real world and pointed toward                  Man’s existence takes priority over
‘heaven’ or ‘the world of ideas.’              whatever he might otherwise be.
                                               ‘Existence takes priority over essence.’ “
Sought to effect a ‘revaluation of all
values,’ - life force of the strongest         Man has no such eternal ‘nature’ to fall
should not be hampered by the                  back on. We must decide for ourselves
weak.                                          how to live



Renaissance humanists had drawn attention, almost triumphantly, to man’s freedom
and independence
Sartre : Man’s freedom is a curse. ‘Man is condemned to be free. Because having once
been hurled into the world, he is responsible for everything he does"
Twentieth Century
Renewal of philosophical currents : Neo-Thomism, logical
empiricism, Neo-Marxism
Materialism: Search for the indivisible ‘elemental particle’ of
which all matter is composed
Ecophilosophy : Western civilization as a whole is on a
fundamentally wrong track, racing toward a head-on collision
with the limits of what our planet can tolerate. There is
something basically wrong with western thought. Our whole
mode of scientific thought is facing a ‘paradigm shift.’ Rise of
‘alternative movements’ advocating holism and a new lifestyle
In the Renaissance, the world began to explode. Beginning
with the great voyages of discovery, Europeans started to
travel all over the world.
Today it’s the opposite, an explosion in reverse.
World is becoming drawn together into one great
communications network.
The question is whether history is coming to an end
— or whether on the contrary we are on the threshold
of a completely new age
We are no longer simply citizens of a city—or of a
particular country.
We live in a planetary civilization

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Introduction to Philosophy
Introduction to PhilosophyIntroduction to Philosophy
Introduction to Philosophy
 
Philosophy 101 Intro
Philosophy 101 IntroPhilosophy 101 Intro
Philosophy 101 Intro
 
Medieval philosophy
Medieval philosophyMedieval philosophy
Medieval philosophy
 
Socrates
SocratesSocrates
Socrates
 
Plato and aristotle
Plato and aristotlePlato and aristotle
Plato and aristotle
 
Socrates
SocratesSocrates
Socrates
 
06 eastern philosophy
06 eastern philosophy06 eastern philosophy
06 eastern philosophy
 
A Powerpoint on Logic
A Powerpoint on LogicA Powerpoint on Logic
A Powerpoint on Logic
 
History of philosophy_and_philosophers
History of philosophy_and_philosophersHistory of philosophy_and_philosophers
History of philosophy_and_philosophers
 
History of Philosophy
History of Philosophy History of Philosophy
History of Philosophy
 
History of philosophy
History of philosophyHistory of philosophy
History of philosophy
 
What is philosophy presentation
What is philosophy presentationWhat is philosophy presentation
What is philosophy presentation
 
04 mind
04 mind04 mind
04 mind
 
The Sophists
The SophistsThe Sophists
The Sophists
 
Epistemology
EpistemologyEpistemology
Epistemology
 
THE PRE-SOCRATIC PHILOSOPHERS
THE PRE-SOCRATIC PHILOSOPHERSTHE PRE-SOCRATIC PHILOSOPHERS
THE PRE-SOCRATIC PHILOSOPHERS
 
Ch3ppt velasquez12
Ch3ppt velasquez12Ch3ppt velasquez12
Ch3ppt velasquez12
 
Socrates presentation
Socrates presentationSocrates presentation
Socrates presentation
 
Logic
LogicLogic
Logic
 
Hegel presentaciones ppt
Hegel  presentaciones pptHegel  presentaciones ppt
Hegel presentaciones ppt
 

Similar to Presentation on Sophy's world : 2000 years' philosophy in 45 slides

CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2
CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2
CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2ssuser3d3158
 
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)La Laland
 
Greek Philosophers
Greek PhilosophersGreek Philosophers
Greek PhilosophersDiana Turner
 
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptx
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptxLecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptx
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptxAidanaSharipova1
 
Greek philosophy and culture
Greek philosophy and cultureGreek philosophy and culture
Greek philosophy and cultureKristin Bowling
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)inventionjournals
 
Ancient Greek Philosophy
Ancient Greek PhilosophyAncient Greek Philosophy
Ancient Greek PhilosophyMr. Finnie
 
Human nature: Ancient Philosophy
Human nature: Ancient PhilosophyHuman nature: Ancient Philosophy
Human nature: Ancient PhilosophyRachelle Rona
 
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptx
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptxphilo 2023 2024 1st.pptx
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptxlove812543
 
western Philosophy
western Philosophy western Philosophy
western Philosophy moonjee
 
Brief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionBrief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionNoel Jopson
 
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docx
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docxI am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docx
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docxsusanschei
 
03 Before Darwin
03   Before Darwin03   Before Darwin
03 Before DarwinJohn Lynch
 
Report philosophers
Report  philosophersReport  philosophers
Report philosophersNeli Garsula
 
Brief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionBrief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionNoel Jopson
 

Similar to Presentation on Sophy's world : 2000 years' philosophy in 45 slides (18)

CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2
CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2
CH2 - Archetypes of Wisdom Douglas J. Soccio Chapter 2
 
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)
Philosophers (pythagoras, democritus, nietzche, jaspers)
 
Greek Philosophers
Greek PhilosophersGreek Philosophers
Greek Philosophers
 
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptx
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptxLecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptx
Lecture 3_FrommGreeks to modern science.pptx
 
Plato
PlatoPlato
Plato
 
Greek philosophy and culture
Greek philosophy and cultureGreek philosophy and culture
Greek philosophy and culture
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
 
Ancient Greek Philosophy
Ancient Greek PhilosophyAncient Greek Philosophy
Ancient Greek Philosophy
 
Human nature: Ancient Philosophy
Human nature: Ancient PhilosophyHuman nature: Ancient Philosophy
Human nature: Ancient Philosophy
 
Refuting Atheism
Refuting AtheismRefuting Atheism
Refuting Atheism
 
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptx
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptxphilo 2023 2024 1st.pptx
philo 2023 2024 1st.pptx
 
Original Essay Topics
Original Essay TopicsOriginal Essay Topics
Original Essay Topics
 
western Philosophy
western Philosophy western Philosophy
western Philosophy
 
Brief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionBrief historical introduction
Brief historical introduction
 
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docx
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docxI am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docx
I am Dr. John Fruncillo and I will be your professor for this on-.docx
 
03 Before Darwin
03   Before Darwin03   Before Darwin
03 Before Darwin
 
Report philosophers
Report  philosophersReport  philosophers
Report philosophers
 
Brief historical introduction
Brief historical introductionBrief historical introduction
Brief historical introduction
 

More from Nayana Renukumar

Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)
Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)
Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)Nayana Renukumar
 
State of civil services survey 2010
State of civil services survey 2010State of civil services survey 2010
State of civil services survey 2010Nayana Renukumar
 
Development strategies public exp - india
Development strategies   public exp - indiaDevelopment strategies   public exp - india
Development strategies public exp - indiaNayana Renukumar
 
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and components
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and componentsGood Governance : Origin, concepts and components
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and componentsNayana Renukumar
 

More from Nayana Renukumar (8)

Civil service reforms
Civil service reformsCivil service reforms
Civil service reforms
 
Citizen charter
Citizen charterCitizen charter
Citizen charter
 
Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)
Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)
Sevottam (excellence in public service delivery)
 
State of civil services survey 2010
State of civil services survey 2010State of civil services survey 2010
State of civil services survey 2010
 
Administrative reforms
Administrative reformsAdministrative reforms
Administrative reforms
 
Development strategies public exp - india
Development strategies   public exp - indiaDevelopment strategies   public exp - india
Development strategies public exp - india
 
Benchmarking open data
Benchmarking open dataBenchmarking open data
Benchmarking open data
 
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and components
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and componentsGood Governance : Origin, concepts and components
Good Governance : Origin, concepts and components
 

Recently uploaded

Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxMusic 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxleah joy valeriano
 
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4MiaBumagat1
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxVanesaIglesias10
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...Postal Advocate Inc.
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatYousafMalik24
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptxmary850239
 
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptxmary850239
 
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptIntegumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptshraddhaparab530
 
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)cama23
 
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPWhat is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
 
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designKeynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designMIPLM
 
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...JojoEDelaCruz
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfTechSoup
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17Celine George
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxMusic 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
 
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
 
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
 
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17
Field Attribute Index Feature in Odoo 17
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
 
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptIntegumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
 
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)
Global Lehigh Strategic Initiatives (without descriptions)
 
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPWhat is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
 
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designKeynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
 
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
 
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxLEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxFINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
 

Presentation on Sophy's world : 2000 years' philosophy in 45 slides

  • 1. A Presentation on ‘Sophie’s World’ by Nayana RenuKumar Sr. Knowledge Manager, Centre for Good Governance
  • 2. Chapter Index Chapter I--Garden of Chapter XIII--The Postcards Chapter XXV--Kant Eden Chapter XIV--Two Cultures Chapter XXVI--Romanticism Chapter II--The Top Hat Chapters XV--Middle Ages Chapter XXVII--Hegel Chapter III--The Myths Chapter XVI-- Renaissance Chapter XXVIII--Kierkegaard Chapter IV--Natural Chapter XVII--The Baroque Chapter XXIX--Marx Philosophers Chapter XVIII--Descartes Chapter XXX--SUMMARY/ Chapter V--Democritus Chapter XIX--Spinoza REVIEW & DARWIN Chapter VI--Fate Chapter XX--Locke Chapter XXXI--Freud Chapter VII--Socrates Chapter XXI--Hume Chapter XXXII--Our Own Time Chapter VIII--Athens Chapter XXII--Berkeley Chapter XXXIII--Garden Party Chapter IX--Plato Chapter XXIII--Bjerkely Chapter XXXIV--Counterpoint Chapter X--Major's Cabin Chapter XXIV--The Chapter XXXV--The Big Bang Chapter XI-Aristotle Enlightenment Chapter XII--Hellenism
  • 3. The Garden of Eaden The Top Hat The Myths
  • 4. The Garden of Eden Who are you? Where does the world come from?
  • 5. The Top Hat Dear Sophie, The best way of approaching philosophy is to ask a few A Greek philosopher who philosophical questions: lived more than two thousand years ago How was the world created? believed that philosophy Is there any will or meaning behind had its origin in man’s what happens? sense of wonder Is there a life after death? How can we answer these questions? And most important, how ought we to live?
  • 6. The Myths ... a precarious balance between the forces of good and evil… Philosophy -- the completely new way of thinking that evolved in Greece about 600 years before Christ Till then religions offered answers to people's questions Religious explanations were handed down from generation to generation as myths. Myth is a story about the gods which sets out to explain why life is as it is Around 700 B.C., Homer and Hesiod writes down much of the Greek mythology. Once Myths existed in written form, it was possible to discuss and criticize them. Earliest Greek philosophers criticized Homer’s mythology because the gods resembled mortals too much For the first time, it was said that the myths were nothing but human notions
  • 7. Natural Philosophers THREE ELIATICS DEMOCRITUS PHILOSOPHERS FROM MILETUS Parmenides: Everything Everything was made that exists had always of was built up of Thales: Source of all existed. Nothing could tiny invisible blocks, things is water change each of which was Anaximander: Our eternal and Heraclitus : Constant world is only one of a immutable. change, or flow, was the myriad of worlds that most basic characteristic of Democritus called evolve and dissolve in nature. Everything flows. these smallest units the boundless atoms Therefore we cannot step Anaximenes : Source of twice into the same river. Eerything could change Seekers of natural than all things must be “air” or supernatural “vapor Empedocles: World had explanations for natural All believed in the existence to consist of more than one processes of a single basic substance single substance. Nature Decisive break with the as the source of all things could transform without anything actually changing. mythological world picture
  • 8. Socrates Aristotle The Triumvirate 3 great classical philosophers to influence European civilization Plato
  • 9. Socrates (470-399BC) Most enigmatic figure in the entire history of philosophy Life of Socrates mainly known through the writings of Plato has inspired the Western world for nearly 2,500 years Not a sophist, but a philosopher : Sophists and Socrates turned their attention from questions of natural philosophy to problems related to man and society. He was neither certain nor indifferent: All he knew was that he knew nothing—and it troubled him. "One thing only I know, and that is that I know nothing" So he became a philosopher—someone who does not give up but tirelessly pursues his quest for truth. He dared tell people how little we humans know. The Art of Discourse : Never a believer of instruction. Like a midwife, Socrates saw his task as helping people to “give birth” to correct insight By playing ignorant, Socrates forced people to use their common sense
  • 10. Socrates All true insight comes from within: Real understanding must come from within; only that can lead to true insight. Right insight leads to right action. He who knows what good is will do good. We all had the same chances because we all had the same common sense: There exists eternal and absolute rules for what is right or wrong. By using our common sense we can all arrive at these norms Ability to distinguish between right and wrong lies in people’s reason, not in society Unmistakable faith in human reason Socrates managed to free himself from the prevailing views of his time by his own intelligence. But he had to pay a heavy price for it Socrates was killed because he disturbed the Athenian society's conventional ideas and tried to light the way to true insight. In Socrates, we therefore see how dangerous it could be to appeal to people’s Reason. Socrates must have had tremendous courage and sense of pedagogic responsibility to go ahead regardless of the perils
  • 11. Plato (428 -347 BC) Search for the eternal and immutable : Plato was concerned with the relationship between what is eternal and immutable, on the one hand, and what “flows,” on the other – middle ground between sophists and socrates Theory of Ideas: Reality is divided into two regions: ● World of senses: About which we can only have approximate or incomplete knowledge by using our five senses. Here, “everything flows” and nothing is permanent. ● World of ideas: About which we can have true knowledge by using our reason. This world of ideas cannot be perceived by the senses, but the ideas (or forms) are eternal and immutable. All natural forms are mere shadows or reflections of eternal forms or ideas – theory of ideas Man is thus a dual creature: our body consists of earth and dust like everything else in the sensory world (matter), but we also had an immortal soul (spirit)
  • 12. Plato Pluto's political philosophy Body Soul Virtue State Head Reason Wisdom Rulers Chest Will Courage Auxiliaries Abdomen Appetite Temperance Laborers Characterized by rationalism. Favored philosophers' rule of state. In effect a totalitarian state with no family and political ties, not unlike caste system. Later opined that a constitutional state is the next best option On women: Women could govern just as effectively as men for the simple reason that the rulers govern by virtue of their reason. Women have exactly the same powers of reasoning as men, provided they get the same training and are exempt from child rearing and housekeeping
  • 13. Aristotle...not only the last of the great Greek philosophers, but also Europe’s first great biologist (384-322 BC) A meticulous organizer who set out to clarify our concepts. Founded the science of Logic. Criticized Plato's theory of ideas: Highest degree of reality is that which Highest degree of reality is that which we think with our reason we perceive with our senses Things we see in natural world are purely Things that are in the human soul were reflections of things that existed in the purely reflections of natural objects. So higher reality of the world of ideas - and nature is the real world thereby in the human soul The distinction between “form” and “substance” plays an important part in Aristotle’s explanation of the way we discern things in the world
  • 14. Nature's scale: There is a gradual transition from simple growths to more complicated plants, from simple animals to more complicated animals. With man at the top of this “scale” who lives the whole life of nature. Ethics: Three forms of happiness; Life of pleasure and enjoyment; Life as a free and responsible citizen; Life as thinker and philosopher. All three criteria must be present at the same time for man to find happiness and fulfillment. He rejected all forms of imbalance and advocated the golden mean Women: Woman is incomplete, an unfinished man Politics: Three good forms of constitution Form Meaning Must not degenerate into Monarchy Only one head of Tyranny State One ruler captures power Aristocracy Larger group of Oligarchy rulers Government run by a select few Polity Democracy Mob rule
  • 15. Hellenism... a spark from the fire… Athens loses its dominant role by 325 BC Conquests of Alexander the Great political upheavals new epoch in history of mankind Hellenism refers to both the period of time and the Greek- dominated culture that prevailed in the Hellenistic kingdoms of Macedonia, Syria, and Egypt Borders between countries and cultures became erased. In place of “national religion, different cultures merged into a fusion of creeds New religious formations – fusion of many gods, many beliefs - doubt and uncertainty about philosophy of life - religious doubts, cultural dissolution, and pessimism - "The world had grown old"
  • 16. Hellenism Philosophic insight – not only for its own sake but also to free mankind from pessimism and the fear of death Eliminates boundaries between religion and philosophy Hellenistic philosophy Not startlingly original Continued to work with problems raised by Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle Common current: Desire to discover how mankind should best live and die – ethics - central philosophical project Emphasis on finding out what true happiness was and how it could be achieved. Four major philosophical trends
  • 17. The Cynics & Stoics Antisthenes – Athens - Zeno -around 300 BC around 400 B.C All natural processes follow True happiness is not found the unbreakable laws of in external advantages or nature. Man must therefore on being dependent on random and fleeting things learn to accept his destiny. Therefore happiness is Nothing happens within everyone’s reach accidentally; Having once been attained, Everything happens through it can never be lost necessity; So it is of little use to complain when fate comes knocking at the door
  • 18. Epicureans & Neoplatonics Epicurus around 300 BC Plato - distinction between world of ideas and sensory The highest good is pleasure, the world greatest evil is pain Plotinus (270-205 BC) - world as Pleasurable results of an action to a span between two poles with be weighed against possible side divine light (God) at one end and effects absolute darkness at other end. All that exists is God. Soul is Death does not concern us; as long illuminated by the light from the as we exist, death is not here. And God, while matter is the when it does come, we no longer exist darkness that has no real The gods are not to be feared. Death existence. is nothing to worry about. Divine mystery in everything that exists. No barrier between Good is easy to attain. The fearful is god and man easy to endure.
  • 19. Two Cultures, two philosophies Indo-European: All nations and cultures Semitic : Cultures using Semitic using Indo-European languages (Most of languages. Root of all three Europe, India, Iran) Clear similarities in Western religions - Judaism, mode of thoughts Christianity, Islam Belief in many gods Belief in one god Sought insight into world’s history - Sight Relied on God’s words - Hearing Distance between god and his creation – Oneness with God No pictures & sculptures - Purpose of life is to be released from the Purpose of life is to be redeemed from sin cycle of rebirth and blame Religious life characterized by self- Religious life characterized by prayer, communion and meditation sermons, and study of scriptures Cyclic view of history: History goes in Linear view of history: In the beginning, circles like seasons - no beginning and no God created the world – history begun. end - Civilizations rise and fall in an eternal On Judgment day history will end, when interplay between birth and death God judges the living and the dead
  • 20. The Middle Ages...A 1000 year journey Rise of Christianity: 145 AD 300 AD 313 AD 380 AD Paul’s missionary journeys Christian Church banned Accepted religion Official religion Church puts the lid on Greek philosophy 529 AD- Closed Plato’s Academy Monasteries wrested monopoly of education, reflection, and meditation By 600 AD, Islam wins over Middle East, Spain, and North African part of Roman empire; adopts Mecca, Medina, Jerusalem, and Bagdad Arabs inherited much of old Greek science; gains prominence in sciences Dark Ages, one interminable thousand-year-long night settled over Europe between antiquity and the Renaissance. Also seen as a period of germination and growth when schools and universities developed. Unifying force of Christian culture
  • 21. Medieval philosophers Took it almost for granted that Christianity was true. Only questions: Whether to simply believe Christian revelations or approach them with help of reason No dramatic break with Greek philosophy; slow transition enabled by Fathers of the Church like St. Augustine St. Augustine: Located Platonic ideas in God and thus preserved the Platonic view of eternal ideas Biblical idea : God created the world out of the void. Greeks : World had always existed. St. Augustine : Before God created the world, the ‘ideas’ were in the Divine mind Idea of City of God: Human history is a struggle between ‘Kingdom of God’ and ‘Kingdom of World for mastery over human beings
  • 22. St. Thomas Aquinas Christianized Aristotle just as St. Augustine Christianized Plato Adopted Aristotle’s philosophy in all areas where it did not collide with Church’s theology. (Logic, theory of knowledge, and natural philosophy) No need for any conflict between philosophers like Aristotle and Christian doctrine God’s existence can be proved on the basis of Aristotle’s philosophy Truths could be reached both through Christian faith and innate reason. Two paths to faith: Aristotle’s philosophy presumed the existence of a formal cause (God) which sets all natural processes going. Christianity knows this formal cause is god. God has thus revealed himself to mankind both through the Bible and through reason. Two paths to moral life: Bible teaches us how God wants us to live. But God has also given us a conscience to distinguish between right and wrong. Aristotle goes only part of the way because he didn’t know of the Christian revelation. But going only part of the way is not the same as going the wrong way
  • 23.
  • 24. Renaissance (Rebirth): Rich cultural development - began in late 14th century – N. Italy - spread rapidly northward in 200 years Rebirth of art and culture of antiquity After Dark Ages where life was seen through divine light, everything once again revolved around man - Renaissance humanism Basis Changes on the cultural and economic front – From subsistence economy to a monetary economy. Developed cities – rise of middle class with better basic conditions of life. Rewarded people’s diligence, imagination, and ingenuity New demands on individual Three discoveries: - compass (easy navigation – great voyages), firearms, (military superiority) and printing press (dissemination of ideas – breaks free of Church monopoly) - essential preconditions Renaissance middle class - break away from feudal lords and church. Religion acquires a freer relationship to reasoning and science New scientific methods and a new religious fervor. Rediscovery of Greek culture through closer contact with the Arabs in Spain and Byzantine culture in East
  • 25. New view of mankind Greater individualism Nothing to be ashamed of Life in here and • Resurgence of • Not mere beings, but now humanism unique individuals • Renewed interest in • New belief in • Ideal of Renaissance human anatomy • Man did not exist man and his man, a man of purely for God’s sake worth • After thousand universal genius years of prudery, it • He felt at home in the • Man was now embracing all aspects once again became world considered of life, art, and usual for works of infinitely great science • Life is not solely a and valuable art to depict the preparation for afterlife Emphasis on nude - whole new approach • individual and his • Man was bold to physical world personal relationship enough to be to God • Freedom to develop – himself again limitless possibilities - aim was now to exceed all boundaries Unrivalled development in all spheres of life. Art and architecture, literature, music, philosophy, and science flourished as never before Pantheism: God was also present in his creation
  • 26. Science...empiricism New method of scientific investigation - observation, experiment, experience Measure what can be measured, and make measurable what cannot be measured : Galileo Emphasize on practical value of knowledge Starting to intervene in nature and beginning to control it Nicolas Copernicus: Earth moved around the Sun and not vice versa (1543) - Heliocentric world picture Kepler - Planets move in elliptical orbits. Earth is a planet like any other (1600s) . Same physical laws apply everywhere in the universe Law of Inertia: A body remains in the state which it is in, at rest or in motion, as long as no external force compels it to change its state. Isaac Newton: Final description of the solar system and the planetary orbits – Law of Universal Gravitation
  • 27. Baroque...such stuff as dreams are made of (17th century) Irregularity and richness was typical of Baroque art than the plainer and more harmonious Renaissance art. Baroque favorite sayings : ‘Carpe diem’—‘seize the day', ‘memento mori' - ‘Remember that you must die.’ Age of conflict, class differences, and irreconcilable contrasts - between Renaissance’s unremitting optimism and life of religious seclusion and self- denial; between rich and the poor; between magnificence and mendicancy; between Protestants and Catholics; wars between countries Birth of modern theater Philosophy of Baroque: Characterized by powerful struggles between diametrically opposed modes of thought Contours between Idealism and Materialism never so clearly present at the same time as in the Baroque. Great philosophers of this period – Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibiniz
  • 28. Descartes Father of modern philosophy: Assembled contemporary thought into one coherent philosophical system Socrates-Plato-St. Augustine-Descartes: Rationalists - reason as the only path to knowledge These questions - Main concerns: substance of philosophical What we can know, in other words, certain knowledge argument for next 150 years What was the relationship between body and mind. Discourse on Philosophical Method: Philosophy should go from the simple to the complex to construct a new insights. Ensure by constant enumeration and control that nothing was left out. Then, a philosophical conclusion would be within reach Favorite line: Cogito, ergo sum: I think therefore I am Dualist: Man is a dual creature-with a mind and body (matter – extension of mind)
  • 29. Baruch Spinoza First to apply historic-critical interpretation of Bible: Critical reading of Bible bearing in mind the period it was written in Spinoza interpreted this as meaning both love of God and love of humanity Monist: Does not have dualistic view of reality as Descartes. Everything that exists can be reduced to one single reality Substance which may be God or nature. God speaking through the laws of nature is the inner cause of everything that happens Everything in the material world happens through necessity. Spinoza had a determinist view of the material, or natural, world
  • 30. John Locke David Hume From Rationalists to Empiricists George Berkeley
  • 31. John Locke (1632-1704) Essay Concerning Human Understanding: Attempt to clarify two questions: Where we get our ideas from: Mind at birth is an empty slate. Only source of genuine knowledge is sensory experience. Knowledge that cannot be traced back to a sensation is therefore false knowledge and must consequently be rejected. There’s nothing in the intellect that wasn’t previously in the senses Can we rely on our sense: Senses objectively reproduce primary qualities (extension, weight, motion and number) world as it is. Senses only reproduce the effect of the outer reality of secondary qualities (color, smell, taste, sound) on our senses – subjective – world as it appears to us . Everyone agrees on primary qualities, secondary qualities vary from person to person - relativism "There is nothing in the mind except what was first in the senses" (Aristotle) Inconsistent in empiricism: It is inherent in human reason to be able to know that God exists Forerunner of many liberal ideas: He spoke out for intellectual liberty and tolerance and equality of the sexes, division of powers
  • 32. David Hume (1711-1776) A Treatise of Human Nature: We sometimes form complex ideas for which there is no corresponding object in the physical world. Example – Batman or Superman. Each element was once sensed, and entered the theater of the mind in the form of a real ‘impression.’ Mind puts things together and constructs false ‘ideas Hume sought to tidy up thoughts and notions: critical analysis of ideas Investigate every single idea to see whether it was compounded in a way that does not correspond to reality Opposed all thoughts and ideas that could not be traced back to corresponding sense perceptions "Dismiss all this meaningless nonsense which long has dominated metaphysical thought and brought it into disrepute" With Hume’s philosophy, the final link between faith and knowledge was broken Hume also rebelled against rationalist thought in the area of ethics that the ability to distinguish between right and wrong is inherent in human reason. “It is not reason that determines what we say and do”
  • 33. Berkeley (1685-1753) Felt that current philosophies and science were a threat to the Christian way of life Material reality doesnot exist. We percieve only ideas. we never have direct experience of things themselves. Everything we see and feel is ‘an effect of God’s power.We exist only in the mind of god Our own perception of time and space can also be merely figments of the mind Denied existence of a material world beyond the human mind. Our sense perceptions proceed from God.
  • 34. Voltaire Montesquieu The Enlightenment ...from the way needles are made to the way cannons are founded Rousseau
  • 35. Seven key words Opposition to authority : Of French philosophers inspired by the English philosophy and liberal political establishment Rationalism: Unshakable faith in human reason- Age of Reason. Enlightenment movement: Greatest monument- huge encyclopedia. All the great philosophers and men of letters contributed to it. ‘Everything is to be found here, 'from the way needles are made to the way cannons are founded Cultural optimism: Once reason and knowledge became widespread, humanity would make great progress. It could only be a question of time before irrationalism and ignorance would give way to an ‘enlightened’ humanity Return to nature: Emphasized intrinsic value of childhood Natural religion: Religion also had to be brought into harmony with ‘natural’ reason. Deism - God only reveals himself to mankind through nature and natural laws, never in any ‘supernatural’ way Human rights: Not content themselves with theoretical views on man’s place in society - fought actively for ‘natural rights’ (lights that everybody was entitled to simply by being born) of the citizen. Campaign against censorship, for freedom of expression in religion, morals, and politics, for abolition of slavery and for a more humane treatment of criminals
  • 36. Immanuel Kant Showed the way out of the philosophical impasse in the struggle between rationalism and empiricism Rationalists: Basis for all human knowledge Empiricists: Knowledge of the world lay in the mind proceeded from senses Kant: Both views are partly right and partly wrong All our knowledge of the world comes from our sensations. But in our reason there are decisive factors that determine how we perceive the world around us We have no freedom if we lived only as creatures of the senses. But if we obey universal reason we are free and independent There are clear limits to what we can know. Mind’s ‘glasses’ set these limits It is not only mind which conforms to things. Things also conform to the mind. Greatest contribution to philosophy : Dividing line between things in themselves and things as they appear to us
  • 37. Romanticism...Europe's last great cultural epoch ‘Feeling,” imagination,” experience,’ ‘yearning All of nature - human soul and physical reality - is the expression of one world spirit - Schelling Features: Yearning for something distant and unattainable like bygone eras; for nature and nature's mysteries Artists can provide something philosophers can’t express Urban phenomenon, youth Romanticism helped strengthen the feeling of national identity Two forms of Romanticism Universal Romanticism: Romantics who were preoccupied with nature, world soul, and artistic genius National Romanticism : Interested in the history, language and culture of ‘the people’
  • 38. Hegel ... the reasonable is that which is viable… First philosopher who tried to salvage philosophy when the 'Romantics had dissolved everything into spirit' Hegel’s philosophy – Historicism - A method to understand the progress of history Any human society and all human activities (science, art, or philosophy), are defined by their history, so their essence can be sought only through understanding that There are no eternal truths. Only fixed point philosophy can hold onto is history itself. The current of past traditions and present material conditions determine what you think. No thought is true forever. (Aristotle - woman is incomplete man) Dialectic process -Three stages of knowledge: Thesis: A thought is proposed on the basis of other, previously proposed thoughts Antithesis: As soon as one thought is proposed, it will be contradicted by another Synthesis: Tension between these two opposite ways of thinking is resolved by the proposal of a third thought which accommodates the best of both points of view "Philosophy is the history of philosophy"
  • 39. Kierkegaard …Europe is on the road to bankruptcy… Critique of Romantic idealism and Hegelian historicism - "Both have obscured the individual’s responsibility for his own life" Sharp eye for the significance of the individual: We are more than ‘children of our time.’ Every single one of us is a unique individual who only lives once Three concepts Three stages in the way of life: Existentialism: Exist for the moment. Instead of searching for 'The Truth', we Aesthetic stage: Lives for the moment and should focus on truths that are grasps every opportunity of enjoyment. Slave important to our individual life, our to ones senses desires and moods. existence. Ethical stage: Seriousness and consistency of Subjective truth: Objective truths are totally irrelevant to personal life. Really moral choices. Living by the moral laws (Kant) important truths are personal and Religious stage: Jumping into the abyss’ of subjective. Only these truths are ‘true for me' Faith’s in preference to aesthetic pleasure and reason’s call of duty. Although it can be ‘terrible Faith: Fundamental questions in life can to jump into the open arms of the living God, only be approached through faith; not through knowledge or reason it is the only path to redemption
  • 40. Marx "Until now, ‘philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it Historical materialist Material changes are the ones that affect history It is the economic forces in society that create change and drive history forward Material, economic, and social relations are the basis of society This base determines the answers to questions of what was morally right (Peasant society - marriage) Society’s ruling class sets the norms for what is right or wrong History of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class struggles. Between those who own the means of production and those who do not. In other words, history is principally a matter of who is to own the means of production
  • 41. Marx Criticism of the capitalist method of production Worker alienation: Way you think is closely connected to the job you do Under capitalist system, worker labors for someone else Worker becomes alien to his work - but at the same time also alien to himself Revolution: Capitalist system is marching toward its own destruction; paving way to communism. Since ‘upper classes’ do not voluntarily relinquish power, change can only come through revolution Dictatorship of the proletariat : For a period, we get a new ‘class society’ in which the proletarians suppress the bourgeoisie by force Classless society: After the transition period, the dictatorship of the proletariat is replaced by a ‘classless society,’ - means of production are owned ‘by all’. From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs.’
  • 42. Darwin Freud Biologist and natural scientist Developed psychoanalysis Most openly challenged the Biblical Constant tension between man and his view of man’s place in Creation surroundings - between his drives and through 'The Origin of Species'. needs and the demands of society Darwin advanced two theories: Man is not really such a rational All existing vegetable and animal creature forms were descended from earlier, more primitive forms through Irrational impulses often determine biological evolution. what we think, what we dream, and Evolution was the result of natural what we do selection Archaeology of soul: As we store the In the struggle for life, those that memory of all our experiences deep were best adapted to their inside us, psychoanalyst can dig deep surroundings would survive and into the patient’s mind and bring to perpetuate the race light the experiences that have caused the patient’s psychological disorder
  • 43. Jean-Paul Sartre (1905 to 1980) Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) Leading light among existentialists Reacted against Hegel’s ‘historicism.’ Especially popular in the forties after the Proposed life itself as a war counterweight to the anemic interest in history and Christian ‘slave Existentialism is humanism morality.’ Man is the only living creature that is Both Christianity and traditional conscious of its own existence philosophy had turned away from the real world and pointed toward Man’s existence takes priority over ‘heaven’ or ‘the world of ideas.’ whatever he might otherwise be. ‘Existence takes priority over essence.’ “ Sought to effect a ‘revaluation of all values,’ - life force of the strongest Man has no such eternal ‘nature’ to fall should not be hampered by the back on. We must decide for ourselves weak. how to live Renaissance humanists had drawn attention, almost triumphantly, to man’s freedom and independence Sartre : Man’s freedom is a curse. ‘Man is condemned to be free. Because having once been hurled into the world, he is responsible for everything he does"
  • 44. Twentieth Century Renewal of philosophical currents : Neo-Thomism, logical empiricism, Neo-Marxism Materialism: Search for the indivisible ‘elemental particle’ of which all matter is composed Ecophilosophy : Western civilization as a whole is on a fundamentally wrong track, racing toward a head-on collision with the limits of what our planet can tolerate. There is something basically wrong with western thought. Our whole mode of scientific thought is facing a ‘paradigm shift.’ Rise of ‘alternative movements’ advocating holism and a new lifestyle
  • 45. In the Renaissance, the world began to explode. Beginning with the great voyages of discovery, Europeans started to travel all over the world. Today it’s the opposite, an explosion in reverse. World is becoming drawn together into one great communications network. The question is whether history is coming to an end — or whether on the contrary we are on the threshold of a completely new age We are no longer simply citizens of a city—or of a particular country. We live in a planetary civilization