Partnering and building alliances is the preferred model of business growth for many CEO’s. In a recent survey, 70% of CEOs plan to partner extensively and indeed the top performers among those CEO’s do just that. Partnering leverages the expertise, resources, and talent beyond the walls of a single organization. Yet many companies lack the fundamental skills, capabilities and leadership to collaborate effectively. We have found in our practice that successful collaborative business relationships are built upon four crucial ingredients.
Business Model Canvas (BMC)- A new venture concept
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaborations
1. The Secret Sauce for
Successful Collaboration
Norma Watenpaugh
Principal, Phoenix Consulting Group
Global Board, ASAP
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
1
2. WINNERS COLLABORATE
70% CEO’s intend
to partner more
extensively Out performers out
partner by 28%
IBM Survey 2012
1700 CEO’s in 64 countries
Dutch Tulip Growers
who collaborated the
most – were the
most successful
The Secret Sauce to Siccessfi; Collaboration
3/6/2014
2
3. COLLABORATION IN THE SKILLS GAP
#1 trait CEOS look for
in employees; 70%
citing it as crucial
#2 fatal flaw in CEOS
Hbr.com2014
The Secret Sauce to Siccessfi; Collaboration
3/6/2014
3
4. Reasons to Partner
Innovation
Growth
New Product
Development
Expand into new
Markets
In-Source Innovation
Increase Customer
Satisfaction
Access to IP/Expertise
Transform Industries
Disruptive Business
Models
Competitive
Advantage
Efficiency
Logistic Efficiencies
Reduce Time to
Market
Leverage Shared
Resources
Cost Reduction
Geographic Expansion
Risk Mitigation
Co-Branding
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
5. What is a Partner?
A collaborative business relationship between two or more entities that share
assets, expertise, risks, rewards, and control to create greater value for their
customers and for their own organizations than could be efficiently
accomplished independently.
Transaction
Out-sourcing
OEM or
Licensing
Channel
Contract
Alliances
Virtual
Joint
Venture
Joint
Venture
M&A
Degree of Collaboration
The Secret Sauce to Siccessfi; Collaboration
3/6/2014
5
7. SUCCESS BEGINS AT THE TOP
STRONG EXECUTIVE
SPONSORSHIP IS CRUCIAL
• Sets the Strategic Vision
• Advocates the Value
• Fosters a Culture for Collaboration
• Last Stop in Escalation
• Organizational Navigator
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
7
8. Partner Lifecycle Framework
Builds Enabling Business Processes
Alliance-Specific
Strategy
Transform
Innovate
Exit
Launching &
Managing
Partner
Life Cycle
Alliance Structuring
& Governance
Analysis &
Selection
Building Trust &
Value
Operational
Planning
Source: ASAP Handbook of Alliance Management
The Secret Sauce to Siccessfi; Collaboration
3/6/2014
8
9. Alliance Value Prop
Operational Plan
Individual Roles, Responsibilities, Motivations,
Rewards
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
Stakeholder Mapping
Alliance Strategy
Alliance Team Charter
Corporate Strategy
Executive Sponsor
Strategies and Techniques for Alignment
3/6/2014
10. Innovative Business Model
Lilly Partnership for MDR - Tuberculosis
Defining the Challenge: Patient Compliance and Prevention
Creates a different ecosystem than just ‘cheap drugs”
Aspen Pharmacare, SIA
Int’l, Purdue University
Transfer of
Technology &
Drug Supply
Workplace
Awareness &
Prevention
Int’l Council of Nurses,
WHO, World Medical
Assoc. US Disease Control
and Prevention
Treatment,
Training &
Surveillance
Patient
Community
Support
Red Cross,
Red Crescent
Patient
Advocacy
TB Alert, TB Survival
Project
World Economic Forum,
Business Alliance to Stop TB
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
10
11. WIN/WIN/WIN Partnerships
Partner Math: 1 + 1 > 3
How do you benefit from the partnership?
How does your partner benefit?
How does the partnership create greater
customer value?
What is the likely result if one of the value
propositions is weak?
Best Practice Guidance:
Three-way value propositions are the foundation of sustainable partnerships
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
11
12. PARTNER BUSINESS MODEL DRIVES FINANCIAL VALUE
– SOLUTION PROVIDER EXAMPLE
Revenue Source
Basis
Product Resale Margin or
Referral Fee
10% of ASP* $50,000
$5,000
Cross Sell Opportunities
10% of ASP
$5,000
Customer Training
20% of ASP
$10,000
Implementation Services
100% of ASP
$50,000
Consulting Services
300% of ASP
$150,000
TOTAL
Revenue Recognized
$220,000
* Average Selling Price
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
12
13. Alliance Team Charter
When everyone is on the same page This is the page
Sets up the common vision for the
alliance/initiative
Joint team activity- People support
what they create
Sets expectations and builds trust
Sets standards for behavior through
operating principles
14. Alliance Core Values/Operating Principles
Govern How the Team Works Together and Shapes the Alliance Culture
Source: Rolls-Royce Starfish Alliance
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
15. Stakeholder Alignment
How does behavior change with commitment and accountability?
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
16. Competency for Collaboration
Soft Skills
- Conflict Resolution
- Cross Function
Team Management
- Influencing Others
Core Skills
- Strategic
Alignment
- Selection &
Qualification
- Leading without
Authority-
- Governance
- Problem Solving &
Critical Thinking
- Alliance
Negotiations
-Cultural Sensitivity
- Co-opetition
- Metrics
- Fostering
Collaboration
Business
Knowledge
Aptitudes
- Industry Trends
-Lead & Influence
- Business
Strategy
-Take Initiative
w/Little Supervision
-Marketing
Processes
-Strategic/Global
Thinkers
-Sales Processes
-Network across
Org Boundaries
-Change
Management
-Flexible
-Innovative/
Resourceful
People Oriented
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
16
18. WHAT IS A CULTURE FOR COLLABORATION
Win-Win Attitude
Empathy
Diversity is the source of
Innovation
Confrontation is the
starting point for
Collaboration
Flexibility
Commitment
Lead with Trust
18
19. “In the long history of
humankind (and animal
kind, too) those who learned
to collaborate and improvise
most effectively have
prevailed.”
Charles Darwin
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
3/6/2014
19
20. Go Forth and Partner
and Prosper!
The Secret Sauce for Successful Collaboration
1/14/2014
20
21. We specialize in best practice partner strategies, programs, and marketing. We
help companies transform their partnering practices to drive corporate growth,
innovation and build shareholder value.
Companies we have served:
www.phoenixcg.com ph:1 408 848 9514 email: normaw@phoenixcg.com
The Secret Sauce to Siccessfi; Collaboration
3/6/2014
21
Editor's Notes
Ask class why they partner?Does it vary from partner to partner?Why does your partner – partner with you?Some of the differences when the objectives are different. Different functions involved Different metrics Different governance
Lilly White PaperCuring Tuberculosis in the countries where it is endemic is a bigger problem that providing inexpensive drugs. Tuberculosis has become very resistant to most treatments and in order to control the disease, patients need to stay on the drug regime nearly two-years. This is difficult since people tend to stop taking the drug once symptoms abate and the net result is an even more drug-resistant strain. Lilly knew that if they wanted to make an impact on the toll this diseases takes, it needed to do more than partner with a low cost manufacturer. It had to surround the patients with an ecosystem that would support compliance for the full course of the treatment and further to address prevention. The partnership included many health organizations across the world as well as local support groups targeted to families and local health professionals. Over 27 organizations are involved. Lilly won the first Alliance Excellence Award for Social Responsibility awarded by ASAP in 2008
Most of the respondents acknowledged a culture and predisposition to outsourcing; but only half indicated a strong history or experience-base in outsourcing development functions to the countries of interest though all did actively outsource to U.S. and European based research organizations. The other half were in the early stages of this journey:doing the discovery, due diligence, and pilot projects leading up to a more extensive effort. Other countries mentioned, but not a focus of this study, were: Russia, Poland, and generally Eastern Europe and smaller Asian countries. Cost was not the primary driver.Building capacity or external capability, access to innovation, flexibility and adaptability in the business model, and time to market were all mentioned as more important than cost. Cost was maybe the 3rd priority…but intrinsic to the execution model.