SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 129
The Digital Biome Re-engineering the Ecosystem to Survive and Thrive in the 21s Century Ramez Naam							        @ramez
Welcome to the Anthropocene
Global problems, global risks
Ocean Acidification
CATCH SOARING
Depleted Fisheries
Fish Tons Per Unit Effort
Annual Rice Yields in China.  Source: 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042809-112206
Species Loss
Peak Oil: Projections
Pathogens and Antibiotic Resistance?(At M. Vassar’s Request)
Biology as Info Tech
Goal:  100,000 Genomes by 2020
2020: $10 Human Genome
Knowing is Half the Battle
The Other Half is Doing
If the Genome is Digital
Can We Edit It?
Tools from biology
“When you think of all the things that are made from oil and the chemical industry and the fuel industries — if in the future we could find cells to replace most if not all of these processes, the ideal way would be to do it by direct design.”   -- Craig Venter
Algae Based Biofuels
Tobacco Mosaic Virus
GM Eucalyptus Trees
5 Days
The fundamental limits
Fresh Water
13%
Increasing Photosynthetic Efficiency for Greater Yield Xin-GuangZhu, Stephen P. Long, and Donald R. Ort, Annual Review of Plant Biology Timeline of boosting photosynthetic efficiency.  Source: 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042809-112206
Winning the Race
US Energy Spending: One Trillion Dollars You Are Here
Supply Price Demand Behavior
Garbage Data
Perceived Infinite Supply of:
Atmospheric CO2 Absorption
Ocean CO2 Absorption
Ocean Fish (at any given time)
Fresh Water Aquifers
Garbage Model:  Distortions
Clean Up Our Inputs
Clean Up Our Model
Price or Regulate Commons
Remove Distortions
Invest in R&D
Incentivize Conservation
Incentivize Efficiency
Incentivize Innovation
Maximize Odds of Success
Minimize Odds of Catastrophe
Ramez Naam      		            @ramez

More Related Content

Similar to The Digital Biome: Re-engineering Life on Earth to Survive and Thrive in the 21st Century

Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)
Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)
Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)Andreea Modrea
 
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015University of Florida
 
Agriculture Presentation For Ltu
Agriculture Presentation For LtuAgriculture Presentation For Ltu
Agriculture Presentation For Ltualan917
 
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable Agroecosystems
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable AgroecosystemsGeo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable Agroecosystems
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable AgroecosystemsICARDA
 
Xinobiotic Biodegradation
Xinobiotic BiodegradationXinobiotic Biodegradation
Xinobiotic BiodegradationAmit Pratush
 
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick Pendergrast
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick PendergrastThe Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick Pendergrast
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick PendergrastNickPendergrast
 
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018Hashem AL-ghaili
 
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should know
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should knowS O S Save The Planet - The facts you should know
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should knowthilight
 
Let our people grow presentation
Let our people grow presentationLet our people grow presentation
Let our people grow presentationSteve Yetay
 
Dr Morne Du Plessis Environmental Excellence
Dr Morne Du Plessis  Environmental ExcellenceDr Morne Du Plessis  Environmental Excellence
Dr Morne Du Plessis Environmental Excellenceaodesign
 
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwest
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwestAlgae biofuel production in the united states southwest
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwestMuay Kuldilok
 
Synbioabs2 gold
Synbioabs2 goldSynbioabs2 gold
Synbioabs2 goldjunvirola
 
Environmental biotechnology
Environmental biotechnologyEnvironmental biotechnology
Environmental biotechnologyBruno Mmassy
 
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills Tim Johnson
 
Get Green Challenge: Tim Johnson
Get Green Challenge: Tim JohnsonGet Green Challenge: Tim Johnson
Get Green Challenge: Tim Johnsonlbalthazor
 
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...ipc_conference
 

Similar to The Digital Biome: Re-engineering Life on Earth to Survive and Thrive in the 21st Century (20)

Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)
Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)
Health Effects on Letterhead with Links - AM July 25 (2)
 
The Limits Manifesto
The Limits ManifestoThe Limits Manifesto
The Limits Manifesto
 
Algae fuel
Algae fuelAlgae fuel
Algae fuel
 
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015
Kevin Folta's Biotalknowledgey Presentation at NC State 4/22/2015
 
Agriculture Presentation For Ltu
Agriculture Presentation For LtuAgriculture Presentation For Ltu
Agriculture Presentation For Ltu
 
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable Agroecosystems
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable AgroecosystemsGeo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable Agroecosystems
Geo-Big Data and Digital Augmentation for Sustainable Agroecosystems
 
Xinobiotic Biodegradation
Xinobiotic BiodegradationXinobiotic Biodegradation
Xinobiotic Biodegradation
 
Decentralized Waste Management Innovations
Decentralized Waste Management InnovationsDecentralized Waste Management Innovations
Decentralized Waste Management Innovations
 
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick Pendergrast
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick PendergrastThe Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick Pendergrast
The Food We Eat and its Impact on the Environment by Nick Pendergrast
 
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018
Science-Based Decision-Making – TEDxRoma 2018
 
RSDResearchPaperFinal
RSDResearchPaperFinalRSDResearchPaperFinal
RSDResearchPaperFinal
 
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should know
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should knowS O S Save The Planet - The facts you should know
S O S Save The Planet - The facts you should know
 
Let our people grow presentation
Let our people grow presentationLet our people grow presentation
Let our people grow presentation
 
Dr Morne Du Plessis Environmental Excellence
Dr Morne Du Plessis  Environmental ExcellenceDr Morne Du Plessis  Environmental Excellence
Dr Morne Du Plessis Environmental Excellence
 
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwest
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwestAlgae biofuel production in the united states southwest
Algae biofuel production in the united states southwest
 
Synbioabs2 gold
Synbioabs2 goldSynbioabs2 gold
Synbioabs2 gold
 
Environmental biotechnology
Environmental biotechnologyEnvironmental biotechnology
Environmental biotechnology
 
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills
Waste To Energy Opportunities in the Ocean's Giant Floating Landfills
 
Get Green Challenge: Tim Johnson
Get Green Challenge: Tim JohnsonGet Green Challenge: Tim Johnson
Get Green Challenge: Tim Johnson
 
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
 

Recently uploaded

Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck Presentation
Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck PresentationConnect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck Presentation
Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck PresentationSlibray Presentation
 
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationMy Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationRidwan Fadjar
 
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr BaganFwdays
 
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024Lorenzo Miniero
 
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii SoldatenkoFwdays
 
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)Wonjun Hwang
 
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL Certs
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL CertsScanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL Certs
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL CertsRizwan Syed
 
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage Cost
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage CostLeverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage Cost
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage CostZilliz
 
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr LapshynFwdays
 
Story boards and shot lists for my a level piece
Story boards and shot lists for my a level pieceStory boards and shot lists for my a level piece
Story boards and shot lists for my a level piececharlottematthew16
 
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):comworks
 
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024Stephanie Beckett
 
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks..."LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...Fwdays
 
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdf
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdfUnraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdf
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdfAlex Barbosa Coqueiro
 
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector Databases
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector DatabasesVector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector Databases
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector DatabasesZilliz
 
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024BookNet Canada
 
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easy
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easyCommit 2024 - Secret Management made easy
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easyAlfredo García Lavilla
 
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project SetupStreamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project SetupFlorian Wilhelm
 
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdf
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdfSearch Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdf
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdfRankYa
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck Presentation
Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck PresentationConnect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck Presentation
Connect Wave/ connectwave Pitch Deck Presentation
 
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationMy Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
 
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
 
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024
SIP trunking in Janus @ Kamailio World 2024
 
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
 
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)
Bun (KitWorks Team Study 노별마루 발표 2024.4.22)
 
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL Certs
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL CertsScanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL Certs
Scanning the Internet for External Cloud Exposures via SSL Certs
 
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage Cost
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage CostLeverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage Cost
Leverage Zilliz Serverless - Up to 50X Saving for Your Vector Storage Cost
 
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
 
Story boards and shot lists for my a level piece
Story boards and shot lists for my a level pieceStory boards and shot lists for my a level piece
Story boards and shot lists for my a level piece
 
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
 
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024
What's New in Teams Calling, Meetings and Devices March 2024
 
DMCC Future of Trade Web3 - Special Edition
DMCC Future of Trade Web3 - Special EditionDMCC Future of Trade Web3 - Special Edition
DMCC Future of Trade Web3 - Special Edition
 
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks..."LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
 
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdf
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdfUnraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdf
Unraveling Multimodality with Large Language Models.pdf
 
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector Databases
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector DatabasesVector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector Databases
Vector Databases 101 - An introduction to the world of Vector Databases
 
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC CataList - Tech Forum 2024
 
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easy
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easyCommit 2024 - Secret Management made easy
Commit 2024 - Secret Management made easy
 
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project SetupStreamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
 
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdf
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdfSearch Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdf
Search Engine Optimization SEO PDF for 2024.pdf
 

The Digital Biome: Re-engineering Life on Earth to Survive and Thrive in the 21st Century

Editor's Notes

  1. Plankton are near the bottom of the food chain.Corals are responsible for 50% of ocean biodiversity.
  2. Reefs are responsible for about half of ocean biodiversity.
  3. Plenty of fish in the sea.
  4. Average American uses 1600 cubic meters of water per year.A cube 40’ on a side.
  5. Aral Sea spans Uzbekistan and Kazakstan: 1989-2003
  6. Aral Sea, 2009. Source: National Geographic
  7. Olagalla Aquifer
  8. Endangered species. As a computer scientist I see this as a loss of information with no backup.
  9. Extinction rate – log scale.
  10. SARS virus was sequenced in 5 days.At 1AM on April 7, 2003, an isolate of the SARS virus arrived at the Michael Smith Genome Sciences Centre. Five days later, the lab published the virus sequence for the first time.
  11. Dawkins: Biology in One Word: Digital
  12. Venter: Most Important Research Tool: The Computer
  13. George Church
  14. Just an example. Relatively few genes took us from wolves to this variety of dogs.In the wild we’ll sequence all sorts of organisms and learn what genes allow some to work in extreme heat, others in extreme cold, others in extreme radiation, and so on.
  15. Venter, artificial life = Gene Printing, 1.1 million bases
  16. Let’s start with energy.One of the proposed replacements for fossil fuels is biofuels, using photosynthesis to capture the sun’s energy and then refining it into fuel. After all, all fossil fuels are basically congealed solar energy.Unfortunately, current biofuels haven’t panned out. They’re expensive to refine, they compete with food crops.
  17. EnterCraig Venter. Why is he talking about fuels? Because Exxon paid his company Synthetic Genomics $600 million to work with them on genetically engineered organisms for biofuels.
  18. Cyanobacteria (blue green algae) for fuels. 3.5 B years old. Genetic modification to produce variants that produce ethanol, oil, or even hydrogen gas.Source:http://www.ecofriendlymag.com/sustainable-transporation-and-alternative-fuel/the-big-boys-of-industry-move-into-next-generation-algae-fuels/
  19. Proposed Algae Biofuel facility in Arizona. Doesn’t compete with food crops. Can use very brackish water not suitable for irrigation. Sucks CO2 out of the atmosphere.
  20. DARPA: Beginning production of biofuel from algae in 2013. Projected price of under $5 / gallon. Part of the goal is to be able to grow fuel in forward areas.
  21. Now, all of those biofuel pathways go through photosynthesis, which itself has a theoretical peak efficiency of 13%. A more efficient way would be to actually produce electricity.
  22. Can be harvested by chopping up the plants, and sprayed onto a conductive surface to create a very cheap photovoltaic surface.
  23. ArborGen GM Eucalyptus – grow twice as fast, less of a protein called lingin.
  24. What percent change is necessary to offset all industrial CO2 output
  25. GM Salmon from a company called Aquabounty, have genes inserted from a “pout fish”, grow about 50% faster than normal Salmon, fewer calories consumed vs. calories delivered. Could be our first genetically modified food animal.
  26. Not an alien probe, not a nanomachine – at least not how you may think of it. This is a Coccolithophore. They’re a family of species that account for about 30% of the calcification – the creation of new shells – that happens in the ocean. And unlike other calcifiers, they actually calcify *more* in high CO2 oceans. Can we borrow their genes?
  27. Not an alien probe, not a nanomachine – at least not how you may think of it. This is a Coccolithophore. They’re a family of species that account for about 30% of the calcification – the creation of new shells – that happens in the ocean. And unlike other calcifiers, they actually calcify *more* in high CO2 oceans. Can we borrow their genes?
  28. Most coral damage actually from fishing, sport, and other activities. We’ve been practicing ways to regenerate corals.
  29. Maldives. Corals were dying. But what we’ve discovered is that there are new growth, growing at 5x the rate of typical coral growth. The same thing happens in waters that are too hot. But not all corals do this. Only a subset. Some of the difference is probably environmental, but some genetic.
  30. So can we figure out the genes that make some corals regenerate, and transplant those into others?
  31. Spanish Ibex. Extinct. For 7 minutes were no longer extinct.
  32. Fresh water is an energy problem. We use a tiny tiny fraction of all water on the planet. Saltwater + energy, can be fresh water.Desalination = 0.77 kwh per cubic meter.Americans use 1600 cubic meters per capita per year.For 9 B people, would be 11 Trillion Kw Hours3 KilaMega9 Giga12 Tera15 Peta= 1.1 * 10^16 watt hoursSun delivers 350,000,000 * 10^12 = 3.5 * 10^20Current Energy Usage = 150,000 Twhours / year = 1.5 x 10^17
  33. What about food?
  34. So what about food? Can we further increase food production? C3 Crops: Wheat, rice, potatoes, barley.C4 Crops:  maize, sugar cane, millet, and sorghumCurrent photosynthetic efficiency of C3 and C4 plants. Source: 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042809-112206
  35. Theoretical max efficiency is 13%. Per James Bolton and David Hall. Must stress that we don’t know how to biologically design a system that reaches this efficiency. But that is what a perfect biotech could achieve with photosynthesis.Current photosynthetic efficiency of C3 and C4 plants. Source: 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042809-112206THE MAXIMUM EFFICIENCY OF PHOTOSYNTHESIS, JAMES R. BOLTON’? and DAVID O. HALL, Photochemistry und Photobiology Vol. 53, No. 4. pp. 545-548, 1991
  36. In addition to whatever tax funded dollars we have, we should also be looking to the free market to fund some of this R&D.
  37. Assumed that behind Supply and Demand are rational actors who make decisions. Someone with a shrinking supply starts charging more.