2. Overview of Presentation
♦ What is a RUBRIC?
♦ Advantages of a RUBRIC
♦ Types of RUBRICS
♦ Sample RUBRICS
♦ How to Create and Use a RUBRIC
♦ • Evaluating your Rubric
♦ Resources
3. Definition
♦A set of criteria and
performance indicators
arranged according to
expected levels of
performance
4. Purpose
♦To Communicate to teachers and
students what is expected in a
given performance or product
before it occurs.
♦Also used to assess the quality of
the performance or product once it
has been completed
♦ CTSIUToronto www.youtube.com/watch?v=IunWLH2FefO
5. Advantages of Rubrics: Instructor
*Objective and consistent among all students
*Leads to insight concerning the effectiveness of
instruction
*Clarifies criteria in specific terms
*Data analysis becomes easier
*Shows areas in need of improvement
*Establishes “ground rules” to resolve potential
academic disputes
6. Advantages of Rubrics: Students
“See the goal to ACHIEVE the goal”
♦ Helps define “quality”
♦ Instructors expectations are clear
♦ Manner in which to meet the expectations are
clear
♦ Students can better judge and revise their own
work and assist their peers
♦ Vehicle for student feedback – promote
student/faculty
8. Types of a Rubrics
Holistic
♦ Consist of a single scale
with all criteria to be
considered together
♦ A single score is assigned
♦ Instructor scores the
overall process or
assignment as a whole,
without judging
component part separately
Analytic
♦ Breaks the objective
into components parts
♦ Each portion is scored
independently using a
rating scale
♦ Final score is made up
of adding each
component parts
9. Holistic RUBRICS
Holistic rubrics-provide a single score
based on an overall impression of a
student’s performance on a task.
It used to score student work as a
whole yielding one holistic scored.
10. *Advantages: quick scoring provides an overview of
student achievement
*Disadvantages: does not provide detailed information, may
be difficult to provide one overall score
Use when:
you want a quick snapshot of achievement.
a single dimension is adequate to define quality.
11. Table 1: Template for Holistic Rubrics
Score Description
1
Demonstrates complete understanding
of the problem. All requirements of
task are included in response.
2
Demonstrates considerable understanding
of the problem. All requirements of task
are included.
3
Demonstrates partial understanding of the
problem. Most requirements of task are
included.
4
Demonstrates little understanding of the
problem. Many requirements of task are
missing.
5
Demonstrates no understanding of the
problem.
6 No response/task not attempted
12. Analytical Rubrics
Used to score student
work on multiple criteria or
dimensions, with each
dimension scored
separately.
14. Advantages of Analytical rubric
♦Provides useful feedback on areas of
strength and weaknesses
♦Criterion can be weighed to reflect
the relative importance of each
criteria.
24. Work Time
♦ You will be doing one of the following:
A. Evaluate your rubric- Are you using the
right type?
B. Modify existing Rubric
C. Create your own Rubric
25. RESOURCES
Creating and Using Rubrics.
(2011)University of Hawaii, Manoa.
Retrieved from
http://manoa.hawaii.edu/assessment/howto/rubr
ics.htm
Mandernach, B. J. (2003). Grading
Rubrics. Park University Faculty
Development Quick Tips.
Retrieved from
http://www.park.edu/cetl/quicktips/rubrics.html
#Tips%20for%20Rubric%20De
velopment
Marcotte, Madeleine. (2006). Building A
Better Mousetrap: The Rubric Debate.
Viewpoint: A Journal of
Developmental, and Collegiate Teaching,
Learning & Assessment. Retrieved from
26. Marcotte, Madeleine. (2006). Building A
Better Mousetrap: The Rubric Debate.
Viewpoint: A Journal of
Developmental, and Collegiate Teaching,
Learning & Assessment. Retrieved from
http://faculty.ccp.edu/dept/viewpoints/w06v7n
2/rubrics1.htm
Mertler, Craig A. (2001).
Designing scoring rubrics for your
classroom. Practical Assessment,
Research &
Evaluation, 7(25). Retrieved f rom
http://pareonline.net/getvn.asp?v=7&n=25
27. D.Cooper.Talk about Assesment : Strategies and tool for improve
Learning 2010
Roobrix.com-Rubric Converter
AAC&U Value rubrics,
http://www.carla.umn.edu/assessment/vac/evaluati
SDSU Encyclopedia of Educational Technology
http://coe.sdsu.educ/eet/articles/rubrics/index
www.taskstream.com