SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 33
Download to read offline
SOCIAL MEDIA
COMMITMENT ISSUES
          Saneel Radia
      Director of Innovation
         BBH/BBH Labs
  @bbhnewyork/@bbhlabs/@saneel
A guy in a suit
  somewhere decided
   media has 3 gears




PAID MEDIA        OWNED MEDIA

        EARNED MEDIA
typical facebook 
feed.
PAID MEDIA

this is paid 
media
EARNED MEDIA

this is living the social media 
dream. 
with such fla:ering 
comments….
OWNED MEDIA




it’s no wonder marketers are addicted to this 
bu:on. 
PAID MEDIA
                                                    Channels brands pay to use



                                                    EARNED MEDIA
                                                    People as channels



                                                    OWNED MEDIA
                                                    Channels brands control


This construct isn’t wrong. It’s how we approach 
it…
EARNED
                                                   PAID




                                                                                           OWNED
… which is as a FUNNEL. Why do marketers love funnels so damn much?
The goal is to get people through. 
Paid media doesn’t brand build– you’re buying likes. 
Earned media is sweet, sweet heaven. 
Owned media is *closing* the deal. 
Even when we don’t show this funnel to clients, the thinking is clearly there. 
EARNED
                                            PAID




                                                            OWNED
                                                    3 MAJOR ISSUES

But actually, thinking in a funnel kinda 
sucks. 
PAID


                                                                EARNED




                                                                                                OWNED
                                                       IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS



So few people make it to the end and they’re generally an echo chamber of hardcore fans. this isn’t bad– but it’s not broad enough to drive social media 
strategy. 
This type of thinking is exactly the mistake most marketers made with click‐thru‐rates years ago. 99.9% of what we were doing was considered value‐less– a  
means to an end.
PAID


                                                                EARNED




                                                                                               OWNED
                                                      IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS
                                                         BRAND = SOCIAL OBJECT


The second issue with the funnel is that when the end game is “OWNED MEDIA”, it’s like believing we’re the center of the universe. 
No one wanted to hear Galileo talk about‐ well the freakin’ SUN‐ so I hope I’m not found “vehemently suspect of heresy” as he was.
.
SOCIAL OBJECT
              “the reason two people are talking to each other, as
                     opposed to talking to somebody else.”
                                                                                                     HUGH MACLEOD

Social object = why 2 people are talking to each other. this can be a movie, a shared history, the fact that we’re plane neighbors (no but really don’t talk to 
me on planes)
It seems insane to think of a world where that Social Object would always be 1 of the 2 people (except maybe Kanye)
So why do brands do it? Why do they force people to talk only about the brand? It’s a bit Copernicus of us all, no?
PAID


                                                      EARNED




                                                               OWNED
                                                   IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS
                                                      BRAND = SOCIAL OBJECT
                                                 REQUIRES A BIG COMMITMENT

Even the word “owned” shows how we think about it. 
It’s OURS and you’re either IN or you’re OUT. 
TILL OPT-OUT DO US PART

You really have to love someone to marry them if they only talk about 
themselves.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN
                BRANDS ALLOW OTHER
                  SOCIAL OBJECTS?




What if a brand we’re to be willing to socialize around all those other things people connect 
about?
THEY
GET TO
HAVE
FLINGS
What’s a social media fling
                        look like?




What are some things people might say if we didn’t a) only talk about ourselves and b) demand such commitment from them?
What’s a social media fling
                          look like?
        LET’S HANG OUT...
        for right now




What if a person only had to “opt in” for a bit, naturally and without having to “opt 
out?”
What’s a social media fling
                        look like?
       LET’S HANG OUT...
       only when it’s relevant
       for right now




What if someone knew our only connecbon would be when it was relevant– and not because our data knew it was a “transacbon” moment?
What’s a social media fling
                           look like?
        LET’S HANG OUT...
        when you can credibly
        contribute
        only when it’s relevant
        for right now




People would be open to it if we were credible, no?. They might be socializing about something and welcome a brand with a credible / interesbng point‐of‐
view. 
For example, Red Bull feels like a brand that can credibly talk about Extreme Sports. I mean, they built Shaun White a half pipe, so they probably know a 
thing or 2—
or at least have cool stories.
What’s a social media fling
                          look like?
        LET’S HANG OUT...
        in specific company
        when you can credibly contribute
        only when it’s relevant
        for right now



The biggest shie in social media in the last year has been our ability to organize contacts be:er– Twi:er lists, understandable FB privacy sefng, etc. 
Clearly people don’t see their network as A network, but a digital collecbon of MANY networks. 
So why don’t brands try to figure out where they fit in? Because that’s NOT part of the funnel mentality. 
WHERE CAN BRANDS HAVE FLINGS?
WHERE CAN BRANDS HAVE FLINGS?




   IN THE RIPPLES AROUND
       SOCIAL OBJECTS
VIDEO RESPONSES


                       INTEREST-BASED
                         COMMUNITIES                                                                             BLOG COMMENTS




                                                                                                                 HASHTAG
                    PRODUCT                                                                                   CONVERSATIONS
                    REVIEWS




                                                                                                                GEO-MOBILE
                         CASUAL GAME                                                                           OPPORTUNITIES
                           LOBBIES
                                                         MULTIPLAYER GAMING
                                                            SCAFFOLDING
Flings can live in all of these places. They seem small at first, but just stop and think about how much you’re influenced about things you care about in these 
environments. 
I love technology & food. Much of my discovery/opinion/thinking about those subjects come from people I have no formal social media relabonship with. 
These are powerful ships passing in the night. 
POP-UP COMMUNITIES                                                                                       MOMENTS IN TIME




                                               CURRENTS OF DIALOGUE


This is by no means comprehensive, but flings fall in a few types of clear categories. 
Pop‐up communibes = dsicussion / engagement around any piece of content. think blog comments, reviews & response videos**
Currents of dialogue= any passion subject has a flow through. people just gefng into gardening, people preparing for a child, people becoming experts in 
biology.
Moments in bme = real‐world events that people “gather around.” think elecbons, Monday Night Football, holidays, fesbvals. 
WHY ARE
    FLINGS GREAT?

★   Way more people will have ‘em
★   They can be meaningful
★   Brands get to be more human
★   Digital media is headed there
A MORE SOCIAL
                MEDIA LANDSCAPE




                 COMMITMENTS                                                                                         FLINGS
Ditching the funnel opens up our eyes to how social the ENTIRE media landscape is. 
Think about all of those ripples inside content properbes – not “social media”. 
Now imagine we saw the value in this collecbvely as an industry? How much would brand push on sites to be *more* social in their offerings?
The good news is all sites and apps are trying to be more social at this point because traffic/usage depends on it. 
WHERE BEING
           COMMITTED…




Commitment isn’t bad… it just doesn’t feel like 
enough. 
DOESN’T RULE
          OUT HAVING A FLING




…when there are so many more opportunibes for brands. 
So let’s open up our relabonships from commitment only and start having FLINGS. 
THANKS
DISCUSSION:
      WHAT MUST
      BRANDS TO HAVE
      FLINGS?


The Social Media Week event then broke into discussion groups and we idenbfied what brands could do to have flings. 
An interesbng conclusion was that most people felt almost every brand (even those that are the opposite of lifestyle brands) could have flings in areas at 
bmes only tangenbally related to their product category. In fact, a brand like Starbucks was acknowledged to have flingy‐ness in everything from music to 
technology to local community to news events. That’s a huge opportunity for a brand to expand their social presence outside their cult of fans. 
If you want to know more about our discussion, ping me on twi:er: @saneel. 

More Related Content

Similar to Social Media Flings

Debunking social media myths
Debunking social media mythsDebunking social media myths
Debunking social media mythsVincent Teo
 
Planning for Transmedia
Planning for TransmediaPlanning for Transmedia
Planning for TransmediaGriffin Farley
 
Socail Media Rebranding
Socail Media Rebranding Socail Media Rebranding
Socail Media Rebranding Xie Qing
 
SOCMED FOR SME by Yuswohadi
SOCMED FOR SME by YuswohadiSOCMED FOR SME by Yuswohadi
SOCMED FOR SME by YuswohadiAkademi Berbagi
 
Social Media ProBook
Social Media ProBookSocial Media ProBook
Social Media ProBookeloquan
 
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.Thomas Marzano
 
Enterprise-Level Social Media
Enterprise-Level Social MediaEnterprise-Level Social Media
Enterprise-Level Social MediaMandy Poon
 
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, Tactic
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, TacticSocial Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, Tactic
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, TacticYuswohady
 
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into Content
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into ContentWorldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into Content
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into ContentKantar
 
Old Spice Market Strategies
Old Spice Market StrategiesOld Spice Market Strategies
Old Spice Market StrategiesMichael Buffa
 
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoon
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoonsocialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoon
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoonValtech Canada
 
Social Media Strategy in Hospitality
Social Media Strategy in HospitalitySocial Media Strategy in Hospitality
Social Media Strategy in HospitalityJeroen van der Schenk
 
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand SocializationFacebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization☀ Michel Demoor
 
New Brand Rules
New Brand RulesNew Brand Rules
New Brand RulesUwe Lucas
 
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy  Marketing: Life & The Like Economy
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy Hubert Grealish
 
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media Academy
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media AcademySocial Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media Academy
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media AcademyTCO
 
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)Eric Weaver
 
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012Paul Cash
 

Similar to Social Media Flings (20)

Debunking social media myths
Debunking social media mythsDebunking social media myths
Debunking social media myths
 
Planning for Transmedia
Planning for TransmediaPlanning for Transmedia
Planning for Transmedia
 
Socail Media Rebranding
Socail Media Rebranding Socail Media Rebranding
Socail Media Rebranding
 
SOCMED FOR SME by Yuswohadi
SOCMED FOR SME by YuswohadiSOCMED FOR SME by Yuswohadi
SOCMED FOR SME by Yuswohadi
 
Social Media ProBook
Social Media ProBookSocial Media ProBook
Social Media ProBook
 
Pro Book
Pro BookPro Book
Pro Book
 
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.
Followers, Fans and Fairytale Endings: How to Monetize Social Media.
 
Enterprise-Level Social Media
Enterprise-Level Social MediaEnterprise-Level Social Media
Enterprise-Level Social Media
 
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, Tactic
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, TacticSocial Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, Tactic
Social Media Marketing: Philosophy, Strategy, Tactic
 
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into Content
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into ContentWorldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into Content
Worldwide Mesh - Weaving the Context into Content
 
Old Spice Market Strategies
Old Spice Market StrategiesOld Spice Market Strategies
Old Spice Market Strategies
 
The Social Media Puzzle
The Social Media PuzzleThe Social Media Puzzle
The Social Media Puzzle
 
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoon
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoonsocialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoon
socialmedias_entrepriselevel_bymandypoon
 
Social Media Strategy in Hospitality
Social Media Strategy in HospitalitySocial Media Strategy in Hospitality
Social Media Strategy in Hospitality
 
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand SocializationFacebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization
Facebook Marketing Model: Brand Socialization
 
New Brand Rules
New Brand RulesNew Brand Rules
New Brand Rules
 
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy  Marketing: Life & The Like Economy
Marketing: Life & The Like Economy
 
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media Academy
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media AcademySocial Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media Academy
Social Ideas: mUmBRELLA and TCO Social Media Academy
 
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)
You Don't Need a Social Media Strategy (Washington DC Edition)
 
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012
B2B Marketing Conference Keynote 2012
 

More from Saneel Radia

5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}
5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}
5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}Saneel Radia
 
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation Partners
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation PartnersHow Ad Agencies Become Innovation Partners
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation PartnersSaneel Radia
 
Innovation vs. Creativity
Innovation vs. CreativityInnovation vs. Creativity
Innovation vs. CreativitySaneel Radia
 
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive Models
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive ModelsIntroduction to Innovation & Disruptive Models
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive ModelsSaneel Radia
 
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning Value
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning ValueScrew Earning Media, Start Earning Value
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning ValueSaneel Radia
 
Innovation & Collaboration
Innovation & CollaborationInnovation & Collaboration
Innovation & CollaborationSaneel Radia
 
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 Presentation
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 PresentationRethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 Presentation
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 PresentationSaneel Radia
 
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)Saneel Radia
 
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad Agencies
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad AgenciesImpact of Digital Revolution on Ad Agencies
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad AgenciesSaneel Radia
 

More from Saneel Radia (9)

5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}
5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}
5 Things Startups Get Wrong {A Marketer's Perspective}
 
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation Partners
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation PartnersHow Ad Agencies Become Innovation Partners
How Ad Agencies Become Innovation Partners
 
Innovation vs. Creativity
Innovation vs. CreativityInnovation vs. Creativity
Innovation vs. Creativity
 
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive Models
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive ModelsIntroduction to Innovation & Disruptive Models
Introduction to Innovation & Disruptive Models
 
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning Value
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning ValueScrew Earning Media, Start Earning Value
Screw Earning Media, Start Earning Value
 
Innovation & Collaboration
Innovation & CollaborationInnovation & Collaboration
Innovation & Collaboration
 
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 Presentation
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 PresentationRethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 Presentation
Rethinking Media: A Planningness 2010 Presentation
 
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)
"Yes. But..." (a presentation by Emma Cookson)
 
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad Agencies
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad AgenciesImpact of Digital Revolution on Ad Agencies
Impact of Digital Revolution on Ad Agencies
 

Social Media Flings

  • 1. SOCIAL MEDIA COMMITMENT ISSUES Saneel Radia Director of Innovation BBH/BBH Labs @bbhnewyork/@bbhlabs/@saneel
  • 2. A guy in a suit somewhere decided media has 3 gears PAID MEDIA OWNED MEDIA EARNED MEDIA
  • 5.
  • 9. PAID MEDIA Channels brands pay to use EARNED MEDIA People as channels OWNED MEDIA Channels brands control This construct isn’t wrong. It’s how we approach  it…
  • 10. EARNED PAID OWNED … which is as a FUNNEL. Why do marketers love funnels so damn much? The goal is to get people through.  Paid media doesn’t brand build– you’re buying likes.  Earned media is sweet, sweet heaven.  Owned media is *closing* the deal.  Even when we don’t show this funnel to clients, the thinking is clearly there. 
  • 11. EARNED PAID OWNED 3 MAJOR ISSUES But actually, thinking in a funnel kinda  sucks. 
  • 12. PAID EARNED OWNED IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS So few people make it to the end and they’re generally an echo chamber of hardcore fans. this isn’t bad– but it’s not broad enough to drive social media  strategy.  This type of thinking is exactly the mistake most marketers made with click‐thru‐rates years ago. 99.9% of what we were doing was considered value‐less– a   means to an end.
  • 13. PAID EARNED OWNED IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS BRAND = SOCIAL OBJECT The second issue with the funnel is that when the end game is “OWNED MEDIA”, it’s like believing we’re the center of the universe.  No one wanted to hear Galileo talk about‐ well the freakin’ SUN‐ so I hope I’m not found “vehemently suspect of heresy” as he was. .
  • 14. SOCIAL OBJECT “the reason two people are talking to each other, as opposed to talking to somebody else.” HUGH MACLEOD Social object = why 2 people are talking to each other. this can be a movie, a shared history, the fact that we’re plane neighbors (no but really don’t talk to  me on planes) It seems insane to think of a world where that Social Object would always be 1 of the 2 people (except maybe Kanye) So why do brands do it? Why do they force people to talk only about the brand? It’s a bit Copernicus of us all, no?
  • 15. PAID EARNED OWNED IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THIS BRAND = SOCIAL OBJECT REQUIRES A BIG COMMITMENT Even the word “owned” shows how we think about it.  It’s OURS and you’re either IN or you’re OUT. 
  • 16. TILL OPT-OUT DO US PART You really have to love someone to marry them if they only talk about  themselves.
  • 17. WHAT HAPPENS WHEN BRANDS ALLOW OTHER SOCIAL OBJECTS? What if a brand we’re to be willing to socialize around all those other things people connect  about?
  • 19. What’s a social media fling look like? What are some things people might say if we didn’t a) only talk about ourselves and b) demand such commitment from them?
  • 20. What’s a social media fling look like? LET’S HANG OUT... for right now What if a person only had to “opt in” for a bit, naturally and without having to “opt  out?”
  • 21. What’s a social media fling look like? LET’S HANG OUT... only when it’s relevant for right now What if someone knew our only connecbon would be when it was relevant– and not because our data knew it was a “transacbon” moment?
  • 22. What’s a social media fling look like? LET’S HANG OUT... when you can credibly contribute only when it’s relevant for right now People would be open to it if we were credible, no?. They might be socializing about something and welcome a brand with a credible / interesbng point‐of‐ view.  For example, Red Bull feels like a brand that can credibly talk about Extreme Sports. I mean, they built Shaun White a half pipe, so they probably know a  thing or 2— or at least have cool stories.
  • 23. What’s a social media fling look like? LET’S HANG OUT... in specific company when you can credibly contribute only when it’s relevant for right now The biggest shie in social media in the last year has been our ability to organize contacts be:er– Twi:er lists, understandable FB privacy sefng, etc.  Clearly people don’t see their network as A network, but a digital collecbon of MANY networks.  So why don’t brands try to figure out where they fit in? Because that’s NOT part of the funnel mentality. 
  • 24. WHERE CAN BRANDS HAVE FLINGS?
  • 25. WHERE CAN BRANDS HAVE FLINGS? IN THE RIPPLES AROUND SOCIAL OBJECTS
  • 26. VIDEO RESPONSES INTEREST-BASED COMMUNITIES BLOG COMMENTS HASHTAG PRODUCT CONVERSATIONS REVIEWS GEO-MOBILE CASUAL GAME OPPORTUNITIES LOBBIES MULTIPLAYER GAMING SCAFFOLDING Flings can live in all of these places. They seem small at first, but just stop and think about how much you’re influenced about things you care about in these  environments.  I love technology & food. Much of my discovery/opinion/thinking about those subjects come from people I have no formal social media relabonship with.  These are powerful ships passing in the night. 
  • 27. POP-UP COMMUNITIES MOMENTS IN TIME CURRENTS OF DIALOGUE This is by no means comprehensive, but flings fall in a few types of clear categories.  Pop‐up communibes = dsicussion / engagement around any piece of content. think blog comments, reviews & response videos** Currents of dialogue= any passion subject has a flow through. people just gefng into gardening, people preparing for a child, people becoming experts in  biology. Moments in bme = real‐world events that people “gather around.” think elecbons, Monday Night Football, holidays, fesbvals. 
  • 28. WHY ARE FLINGS GREAT? ★ Way more people will have ‘em ★ They can be meaningful ★ Brands get to be more human ★ Digital media is headed there
  • 29. A MORE SOCIAL MEDIA LANDSCAPE COMMITMENTS FLINGS Ditching the funnel opens up our eyes to how social the ENTIRE media landscape is.  Think about all of those ripples inside content properbes – not “social media”.  Now imagine we saw the value in this collecbvely as an industry? How much would brand push on sites to be *more* social in their offerings? The good news is all sites and apps are trying to be more social at this point because traffic/usage depends on it. 
  • 30. WHERE BEING COMMITTED… Commitment isn’t bad… it just doesn’t feel like  enough. 
  • 31. DOESN’T RULE OUT HAVING A FLING …when there are so many more opportunibes for brands.  So let’s open up our relabonships from commitment only and start having FLINGS. 
  • 33. DISCUSSION: WHAT MUST BRANDS TO HAVE FLINGS? The Social Media Week event then broke into discussion groups and we idenbfied what brands could do to have flings.  An interesbng conclusion was that most people felt almost every brand (even those that are the opposite of lifestyle brands) could have flings in areas at  bmes only tangenbally related to their product category. In fact, a brand like Starbucks was acknowledged to have flingy‐ness in everything from music to  technology to local community to news events. That’s a huge opportunity for a brand to expand their social presence outside their cult of fans.  If you want to know more about our discussion, ping me on twi:er: @saneel.