SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 63
Download to read offline
an introduc+on to 
                                  Nudge
                          Improving Decisions About 
                         Health, Wealth, and Happiness 
                    by Richard H. Thaler & Cass R. Sunstein




                               presented by Sarah G. Mitchell

What I am presenting is only an introduction to this rich and in-depth book. If you’re
interested in what I cover here, I encourage you to read the book.

Both of the authors are economists and professors, and Cass Sunstein now leads the White
House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. In the book they focus on public policy,
and situations like healthcare, the environment, and saving for retirement, but many of the
concepts they cover have relevance to the kinds of situations and choices we design.
What is a nudge?




A nudge is any aspect of the design of a choice (“choice architecture”) that alters people’s
behavior in a predictable way, without forbidding anything or actually changing the choice at
all. The example that went out in the event invitation was the clever internet cafe named their
wireless network “Have you tried the carrot cake.”
Why do we need nudges?
Freedom of choice 
                        is best, right?



Many economists (and some of the engineers I know) like to say that we don’t know better
than the user/chooser, that we should present all options to people, and let them choose.
The authors say this makes the false assumption that almost all people, almost all of the
time, make choices that are in their best interest, or at least are better than choices someone
else would make for them.
They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is
actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical
choice.

However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our
head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective
Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
vs.



            “Gut”                                          “Mind”
  (Automa+c Cogni+ve System)                      (Reflec+ve Cogni+ve System) 
They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is
actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical
choice.

However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our
head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective
Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
Here’s a classic example. Spock would look at this image and see clearly that the two
tabletops are exactly the same size. But most of us feel pretty sure that the one on the left is
longer and skinnier than the one on the right.
There is no such thing as 
                   a nudge‐less choice.




So the conclusion the authors draw from this is that SOMETHING is always influencing your
choices. People are influenced by small factors in the design of an experience, so even if you
don’t consciously design your choice architecture, it is still there, affecting the actions of the
choosers.
• CAFETERIA LINE IMAGE




Here’s another example. In this cafeteria, Spock would only put food on his tray that is good
for him, only taking as much as he needs and only what he can afford.

But our Homer is in there, reacting instinctively to many things, like which things are at the
beginning versus the end, and which things are up at eye level and which are below.

In fact, in one study mentioned in the book, the researchers were able to increase or decrease
selection of specific foods by 25%, just by rearranging them.
So say you are designing a cafeteria layout. What should you do? Ignore the fact that the
layout affects what people buy? Randomly rotate the placement of foods? Set it up to sell the
most of the expensive stuff? Or set it up so people choose more healthy foods? The book
encourages that last option with what they call “libertarian paternalism” - Nudging the
user (through placement, in this example) to make the best choice for his well being - WHAT
OUR SPOCK WOULD WANT, while not restricting choice at all. They are not banning junk food,
just making it less likely that someone will choose it on their own.
When do we especially 
   need nudges?
When is our Spock particularly weak and our Homer particularly strong. This happens
predictably in the following scenarios:
When we see the benefits 
   now, costs later.
I enjoy the benefit of this donut now, I pay the cost (to my health, waistline) later. I enjoy
coming home to a cool house because my AC was running all day, I pay the costs (both bills
and environmental) later.
When encountering decisions 
  we make infrequently.
We get better at everything through practice. If you had to optimize your investments as
frequently you have to drive your car, you’d probably be better at it.
When feedback is not 
   immediate.
Think of the impact digital cameras had on hobby photography, largely because you can see
right away what your picture looks like. Making investment decisions is kind of like the old
film photography model. You rearrange some stuff, and hope when you go back to see the
results you can remember what you did and extrapolate what worked and what didn’t.
When it is hard to imagine the 
    possible outcomes.
Imagine ordering at a restaurant from a menu in a language you do not understand. For
many people, this is what it is like to try to decide between investing in a “capital
appreciation fund” vs a “dynamic dividend fund.” The language of the choice selection makes
it very hard to imagine what the options really mean to you.
PredicDng Homer’s 
                      AcDons


So we know that our gut, our Homer, has more influence our decisions in those types of
situations. Fortunately, he’s pretty predictable, and therefore relatively easy to set up
safeguards agains.

I’ll cover 3 of the main ways to predict what people will do.
1.




     We have predictable 
       mental biases.
Anchoring Bias:
We are heavily biased by 
    where we start.
Say I told you, “the population of Chicago is 3 million. What is the population of Milwaukee?”
You might guess something like 1 million.
If I instead told you, “The population of Green Bay is 100,000. What is the population of
Milwaukee?” Most people guessed around 300,000. (The actual population is around
580,000.)
Availability Bias:
        We overes+mate the 
    likelihood of events we can 
          easily remember.



?
We are much more scared of vivid and easily imagined threats (like plane crashes or
tornadoes), than we are of mundane but much more common dangers (like asthma attacks).
We are 20x more likely to die of asthma attack than tornado, so if we were purely rational,
we’d be 20x more scared of asthma than tornadoes.
RepresentaDveness Bias:
We some+mes see paMerns 
  where there are none.
Based on the beauty pageant contestants you’ve seen in the media lately, you might think
that ALL of them are dumb as a post. (That’s not true.) Another example: If you wore your old
hat during two games which your team won, you might assume that it’s a lucky hat, and that
if you don’t wear it during the next game, your team will lose. (Sorry, there’s no connection.)
UnrealisDc OpDmism:
Almost all of us think we are 
    beMer than average.
90% predict
                                                                     they will
                                                                    score here.




    -                                                                                 +
In one study the authors conducted, 90% of their students predicted they would finish in the
top 2 percentiles in their class.
Loss Aversion:
We are happy when we gain 
  something, but twice as 
 unhappy when we lose it.
It does seem that someone who wears this shirt might only have been half as worked up
about getting the gun as he is about losing it.
Status Quo Bias:
We rarely overcome iner+a.
This XBox live offer from Microsoft is banking on people’s personal inertia. You get one
month of the gold service for $1, but then every month after that it bills you automatically at
the full price. Only 70% of all eligible people ever enroll in their 401ks. Have you adjusted
your 401k balance since you first set it up?
Framing Bias:
   “10 out of 100 die.”
            vs.
“90 out of 100 are cured.”
July ’08 NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll:

   Who would be the riskier choice for president?

    Barack Obama                                                              55%

    John McCain                                35%


   Who would be the safer choice for president?

    Barack Obama                                        41%

    John McCain                                                 46%



Both of these questions were asked in the same poll at the same time of the same people.
If the framing of the question had no effect on people, the responses here should just mirror
each other.
Priming Bias:
   What we see or hear 
immediately before a choice 
  affects how we behave.
When a national survey included this question, it increased purchase rates by 35%. Remember
the cafe example from earlier. Just by seeing the phrase “Have you tried the carrot cake”
when logging in to the wireless network increases the likelihood you’ll buy some.
2.




     We predictably succumb 
         to temptaDon.
I’m on a diet. 




                                         Planner 

The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate
how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
Mmmmmm, donut....




                                                                  One is ok.
                                                                  Or two.
                                                                  Or three.


                                        Doer  

The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate
how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
autopilot
You also have a third system...
Mindless choosing: your autopilot just continues doing what it’s used to - driving the same
route, or continuing to eat when there’s food in front of you. There was one study mentioned
in the book where participants were given very stale popcorn, either a large bag or a small
bag, and then watched a movie. Participants with the large bag ate 34% more, just because it
was there and they were on autopilot.
3.




      We predictably 
     follow the herd.
We like to conform. This is at the root of speculative bubbles, internet memes, and fads. One
phenomenon that drives us to conform is the “spotlight effect,” which makes us feel like
people are paying closer attention to us--especially when we’re not conforming--than they
really are. (I have a feeling this dude with the emover thinks everyone is paying attention to
him.)
One particularly interesting ramification of the herd behavior is its effect on popularity lists.
One experiment offered different groups of people the same set of downloadable mp3s with
visible popularity data. In the end, the most popular songs for each group were not
predictable and were not similar from group to group, except that they were lucky and picked
by the first users of the system.
So how can we help 
 our Spock defeat 
    our Homer?
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
This fly is etched on the urinal as an aiming incentive, and was proven to reduce spillage by
80%. Another example is a social program that gives teen moms a dollar a day every day that
they are not pregnant.
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
Mappings means how we translate data about an option into what it actually means for us,
like translating kilowatts of energy into dollars on the electricity bill, or translating
megapixels to maximum print size.
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
Not new to us - defaults are POWERFUL because of the Status Quo bias. You can default to
opt-in, opt-out, or mandatory choice (which is like having yes/no radio buttons with nothing
selected).
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
This device is designed to give you feedback about your energy usage AS you are using it. It
is also mapping your usage to money, targeting your loss aversion, and it plans to tap into
vast social pressures by broadcasting your usage statistics to Facebook and Twitter.
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
Also not new to interaction designers - plan for the errors. This is an example of planning for
a (somewhat gruesome) common error tourists make when visiting London.
iNcen+ves
Understand “mappings”
Defaults
Give Feedback
Expect Error
Structure Complex Choices
The paradox of choice is reduced if options are grouped. Or use strategies like “collaborative
filtering” to reduce options presented. The example above uses many different groupings and
filtering options to help you make the very complex choice, “Which of the thousands of songs
on this site should I listen to now?”
Lots of UX Examples




There are lots more examples out there (some of my colleagues will be presenting some
now), and now that you know what to look for I’m sure you’ll see them.

I’d just like to note that another tool we have as designers that this book doesn’t mention is
emotion. Emotion is certainly a strong nudging factor, and many great UX minds such as Don
Norman, Robert Fabricant, and Bill Buxton have written and spoken about using emotion in
design.
Recap




Nudges are about designing choices to try to help people make choices more with their
rational mind (their inner Spock) and less with their gut.
There are certain situations: Benefits now, cost later; decisions we have to make
infrequently, places where the feedback isn’t immediate or the outcome is hard to
imagine, where the Homer in us has the upper hand,
and we can use our knowledge of our predictable psychology in these ways mentioned:
incentives, understanding mappings, defaults, giving feedback, and structuring complex
choices to nudge our Spock to rebalance the power.
PLUG!
                                       Join us @ the 
                                       UX Book Club!

                 next mee+ng: July 22nd
                 Designing Gestural Interfaces

If you like what you saw here, join us! We read Nudge at our last meeting, and we plan to
read lots more great stuff in the future. (Come on, all your friends are doing it!)

More Related Content

What's hot

Applying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsApplying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsC.A.F.C.A.
 
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economics
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural EconomicsBehavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economics
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economicstutor2u
 
Behavioural economics alumni
Behavioural economics alumniBehavioural economics alumni
Behavioural economics alumniSquare Holes
 
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...beworks
 
Nudge theory
Nudge theoryNudge theory
Nudge theoryvikashita
 
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace Deloitte United States
 
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper Behavior
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper BehaviorWebinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper Behavior
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper BehaviorRevTrax
 
Behavioural Economics in Advertising Planning
Behavioural Economics in Advertising PlanningBehavioural Economics in Advertising Planning
Behavioural Economics in Advertising PlanningPhilip De Meulemeester
 
Behavioural Economics in B2B Marketing
Behavioural Economics in B2B MarketingBehavioural Economics in B2B Marketing
Behavioural Economics in B2B MarketingEarnest
 
Behavioural economics and digital marketing
Behavioural economics and digital marketingBehavioural economics and digital marketing
Behavioural economics and digital marketingVyshnavi Doss
 
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)Verhaert Masters in Innovation
 
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation Forum
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation ForumPredictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation Forum
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation ForumInnovation Excellence
 
Thinking Fast & Slow presentation
Thinking Fast & Slow presentationThinking Fast & Slow presentation
Thinking Fast & Slow presentationLaure Parsons
 
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and Slow
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and SlowDaniel kanheman Thinking Fast and Slow
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and SlowRashmi Parmar
 
You're not so smart - Cognitive Biases
You're not so smart - Cognitive BiasesYou're not so smart - Cognitive Biases
You're not so smart - Cognitive BiasesOdair Faléco
 
Exploiting Fast and Slow Thinking
Exploiting Fast and Slow ThinkingExploiting Fast and Slow Thinking
Exploiting Fast and Slow ThinkingRebecca Wirfs-Brock
 
Diversification Bias
Diversification BiasDiversification Bias
Diversification BiasRussell James
 
Williams thinking fast and slow
Williams thinking fast and slowWilliams thinking fast and slow
Williams thinking fast and slowactkm
 

What's hot (20)

Applying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsApplying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral Economics
 
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economics
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural EconomicsBehavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economics
Behavioural Nudges - Behavioural Economics
 
Behavioural economics alumni
Behavioural economics alumniBehavioural economics alumni
Behavioural economics alumni
 
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...
How to convince your boss to use insights and strategies from Behavioral Econ...
 
Nudge theory
Nudge theoryNudge theory
Nudge theory
 
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace
Six behavioral economics lessons for the workplace
 
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper Behavior
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper BehaviorWebinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper Behavior
Webinar: Using Behavioral Economics to Identify What Motivates Shopper Behavior
 
Behavioural Economics in Advertising Planning
Behavioural Economics in Advertising PlanningBehavioural Economics in Advertising Planning
Behavioural Economics in Advertising Planning
 
Behavioural Economics in B2B Marketing
Behavioural Economics in B2B MarketingBehavioural Economics in B2B Marketing
Behavioural Economics in B2B Marketing
 
Behavioural economics and digital marketing
Behavioural economics and digital marketingBehavioural economics and digital marketing
Behavioural economics and digital marketing
 
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)
Nudging: design concepts to change our behavior (by Louise Haazen & David Pas)
 
Paradox Of Choice
Paradox Of ChoiceParadox Of Choice
Paradox Of Choice
 
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation Forum
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation ForumPredictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation Forum
Predictably Irrational - Dan Ariely - World Innovation Forum
 
Thinking Fast & Slow presentation
Thinking Fast & Slow presentationThinking Fast & Slow presentation
Thinking Fast & Slow presentation
 
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and Slow
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and SlowDaniel kanheman Thinking Fast and Slow
Daniel kanheman Thinking Fast and Slow
 
You're not so smart - Cognitive Biases
You're not so smart - Cognitive BiasesYou're not so smart - Cognitive Biases
You're not so smart - Cognitive Biases
 
Exploiting Fast and Slow Thinking
Exploiting Fast and Slow ThinkingExploiting Fast and Slow Thinking
Exploiting Fast and Slow Thinking
 
Diversification Bias
Diversification BiasDiversification Bias
Diversification Bias
 
Williams thinking fast and slow
Williams thinking fast and slowWilliams thinking fast and slow
Williams thinking fast and slow
 
Status Quo Bias
Status Quo BiasStatus Quo Bias
Status Quo Bias
 

Viewers also liked

Nudge Presentation
Nudge PresentationNudge Presentation
Nudge Presentationjkru123
 
Nudge presentation
Nudge presentationNudge presentation
Nudge presentationJShep79
 
Fa 102a Motion Graphic Exploration
Fa 102a Motion Graphic ExplorationFa 102a Motion Graphic Exploration
Fa 102a Motion Graphic ExplorationJShep79
 
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheHow to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheLeslie Samuel
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Nudge Presentation
Nudge PresentationNudge Presentation
Nudge Presentation
 
Nudge theory
Nudge theory Nudge theory
Nudge theory
 
Nudge
NudgeNudge
Nudge
 
Nudge presentation
Nudge presentationNudge presentation
Nudge presentation
 
Nudge Theory
Nudge TheoryNudge Theory
Nudge Theory
 
Fa 102a Motion Graphic Exploration
Fa 102a Motion Graphic ExplorationFa 102a Motion Graphic Exploration
Fa 102a Motion Graphic Exploration
 
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheHow to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
 

Similar to An Introduction to Nudge: Improving Decisions Through Choice Architecture

Management of Organizations-Part I
Management of Organizations-Part IManagement of Organizations-Part I
Management of Organizations-Part IRamnath Srinivasan
 
Principles of behavioural economics
Principles of behavioural economics  Principles of behavioural economics
Principles of behavioural economics Terry Corby
 
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)tutor2u
 
You Are Not As Rational As You Think
You Are Not As Rational As You ThinkYou Are Not As Rational As You Think
You Are Not As Rational As You ThinkYang Ao Wei 楊翱維
 
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job better
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job betterBehavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job better
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job betterDigitasLBi Paris
 
Behavioral Economics for the Web
Behavioral Economics for the WebBehavioral Economics for the Web
Behavioral Economics for the WebKam Star
 
Criticalthinking
CriticalthinkingCriticalthinking
Criticalthinkingholly_cin
 
Risk Management Ebook
Risk Management Ebook Risk Management Ebook
Risk Management Ebook Daniel Crosby
 
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you from
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you fromThe 12 cognitive biases that prevent you from
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you fromCol Mukteshwar Prasad
 
Doomscrolling Breakthrough
Doomscrolling Breakthrough Doomscrolling Breakthrough
Doomscrolling Breakthrough jacobschroers
 
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docx
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docxI’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docx
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docxssuser47f0be
 
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong things
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong thingsRailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong things
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong thingsHilary Stohs-Krause
 
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.Amanda Anderson
 

Similar to An Introduction to Nudge: Improving Decisions Through Choice Architecture (20)

Management of Organizations-Part I
Management of Organizations-Part IManagement of Organizations-Part I
Management of Organizations-Part I
 
Principles of behavioural economics
Principles of behavioural economics  Principles of behavioural economics
Principles of behavioural economics
 
St PeterS Prep Essay
St PeterS Prep EssaySt PeterS Prep Essay
St PeterS Prep Essay
 
Introduction to nudge 2
Introduction to nudge 2Introduction to nudge 2
Introduction to nudge 2
 
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)
Mo Tanweer on Behavioural economics (2010)
 
You Are Not As Rational As You Think
You Are Not As Rational As You ThinkYou Are Not As Rational As You Think
You Are Not As Rational As You Think
 
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job better
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job betterBehavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job better
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job better
 
Behavioral Economics for the Web
Behavioral Economics for the WebBehavioral Economics for the Web
Behavioral Economics for the Web
 
Inscriptions 41 April 2023.pdf
Inscriptions 41 April 2023.pdfInscriptions 41 April 2023.pdf
Inscriptions 41 April 2023.pdf
 
Looking inside the Cheese - Engaging people in workplace health and safety
Looking inside the Cheese - Engaging people in workplace health and safetyLooking inside the Cheese - Engaging people in workplace health and safety
Looking inside the Cheese - Engaging people in workplace health and safety
 
2013 12 25 social media and the (uk) insurance sector
2013 12 25 social media and the (uk) insurance sector2013 12 25 social media and the (uk) insurance sector
2013 12 25 social media and the (uk) insurance sector
 
Criticalthinking
CriticalthinkingCriticalthinking
Criticalthinking
 
Risk Management Ebook
Risk Management Ebook Risk Management Ebook
Risk Management Ebook
 
Feb8 notes
Feb8 notesFeb8 notes
Feb8 notes
 
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you from
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you fromThe 12 cognitive biases that prevent you from
The 12 cognitive biases that prevent you from
 
Doomscrolling Breakthrough
Doomscrolling Breakthrough Doomscrolling Breakthrough
Doomscrolling Breakthrough
 
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docx
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docxI’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docx
I’m Not Guilty, Because I Had No ChoiceWe were talking last week.docx
 
Future of coaching Kim Stephenson
Future of coaching Kim StephensonFuture of coaching Kim Stephenson
Future of coaching Kim Stephenson
 
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong things
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong thingsRailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong things
RailsConf 2020: Why we worry about all the wrong things
 
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.
Essayer Wow Mist Of Pandaria. Online assignment writing service.
 

Recently uploaded

Expanded definition: technical and operational
Expanded definition: technical and operationalExpanded definition: technical and operational
Expanded definition: technical and operationalssuser3e220a
 
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptx
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptxMillenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptx
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptxJanEmmanBrigoli
 
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemConcurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemChristalin Nelson
 
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfGrade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfJemuel Francisco
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17Celine George
 
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptxmary850239
 
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped data
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped dataMeasures of Position DECILES for ungrouped data
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped dataBabyAnnMotar
 
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for ParentsChoosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parentsnavabharathschool99
 
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
ClimART Action    |    eTwinning ProjectClimART Action    |    eTwinning Project
ClimART Action | eTwinning Projectjordimapav
 
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...JojoEDelaCruz
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSJoshuaGantuangco2
 
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designKeynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designMIPLM
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptxmary850239
 
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docx
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docxEMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docx
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docxElton John Embodo
 
Transaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemTransaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemChristalin Nelson
 
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptx
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptxPresentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptx
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptxRosabel UA
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Expanded definition: technical and operational
Expanded definition: technical and operationalExpanded definition: technical and operational
Expanded definition: technical and operational
 
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptx
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptxMillenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptx
Millenials and Fillennials (Ethical Challenge and Responses).pptx
 
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemConcurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
 
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfGrade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
 
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
 
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...
HỌC TỐT TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO CHƯƠNG TRÌNH GLOBAL SUCCESS ĐÁP ÁN CHI TIẾT - CẢ NĂ...
 
Paradigm shift in nursing research by RS MEHTA
Paradigm shift in nursing research by RS MEHTAParadigm shift in nursing research by RS MEHTA
Paradigm shift in nursing research by RS MEHTA
 
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped data
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped dataMeasures of Position DECILES for ungrouped data
Measures of Position DECILES for ungrouped data
 
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for ParentsChoosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
 
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
ClimART Action    |    eTwinning ProjectClimART Action    |    eTwinning Project
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
 
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
ENG 5 Q4 WEEk 1 DAY 1 Restate sentences heard in one’s own words. Use appropr...
 
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
 
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-designKeynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
Keynote by Prof. Wurzer at Nordex about IP-design
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
 
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docx
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docxEMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docx
EMBODO Lesson Plan Grade 9 Law of Sines.docx
 
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxFINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
Transaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemTransaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management System
 
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptx
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptxPresentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptx
Presentation Activity 2. Unit 3 transv.pptx
 

An Introduction to Nudge: Improving Decisions Through Choice Architecture

  • 1. an introduc+on to  Nudge Improving Decisions About  Health, Wealth, and Happiness  by Richard H. Thaler & Cass R. Sunstein presented by Sarah G. Mitchell What I am presenting is only an introduction to this rich and in-depth book. If you’re interested in what I cover here, I encourage you to read the book. Both of the authors are economists and professors, and Cass Sunstein now leads the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. In the book they focus on public policy, and situations like healthcare, the environment, and saving for retirement, but many of the concepts they cover have relevance to the kinds of situations and choices we design.
  • 2. What is a nudge? A nudge is any aspect of the design of a choice (“choice architecture”) that alters people’s behavior in a predictable way, without forbidding anything or actually changing the choice at all. The example that went out in the event invitation was the clever internet cafe named their wireless network “Have you tried the carrot cake.”
  • 4. Freedom of choice  is best, right? Many economists (and some of the engineers I know) like to say that we don’t know better than the user/chooser, that we should present all options to people, and let them choose. The authors say this makes the false assumption that almost all people, almost all of the time, make choices that are in their best interest, or at least are better than choices someone else would make for them.
  • 5. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  • 6. vs. “Gut” “Mind” (Automa+c Cogni+ve System)  (Reflec+ve Cogni+ve System)  They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  • 7. Here’s a classic example. Spock would look at this image and see clearly that the two tabletops are exactly the same size. But most of us feel pretty sure that the one on the left is longer and skinnier than the one on the right.
  • 8. There is no such thing as  a nudge‐less choice. So the conclusion the authors draw from this is that SOMETHING is always influencing your choices. People are influenced by small factors in the design of an experience, so even if you don’t consciously design your choice architecture, it is still there, affecting the actions of the choosers.
  • 9. • CAFETERIA LINE IMAGE Here’s another example. In this cafeteria, Spock would only put food on his tray that is good for him, only taking as much as he needs and only what he can afford. But our Homer is in there, reacting instinctively to many things, like which things are at the beginning versus the end, and which things are up at eye level and which are below. In fact, in one study mentioned in the book, the researchers were able to increase or decrease selection of specific foods by 25%, just by rearranging them.
  • 10. So say you are designing a cafeteria layout. What should you do? Ignore the fact that the layout affects what people buy? Randomly rotate the placement of foods? Set it up to sell the most of the expensive stuff? Or set it up so people choose more healthy foods? The book encourages that last option with what they call “libertarian paternalism” - Nudging the user (through placement, in this example) to make the best choice for his well being - WHAT OUR SPOCK WOULD WANT, while not restricting choice at all. They are not banning junk food, just making it less likely that someone will choose it on their own.
  • 11. When do we especially  need nudges?
  • 12. When is our Spock particularly weak and our Homer particularly strong. This happens predictably in the following scenarios:
  • 13. When we see the benefits  now, costs later.
  • 14. I enjoy the benefit of this donut now, I pay the cost (to my health, waistline) later. I enjoy coming home to a cool house because my AC was running all day, I pay the costs (both bills and environmental) later.
  • 16. We get better at everything through practice. If you had to optimize your investments as frequently you have to drive your car, you’d probably be better at it.
  • 18. Think of the impact digital cameras had on hobby photography, largely because you can see right away what your picture looks like. Making investment decisions is kind of like the old film photography model. You rearrange some stuff, and hope when you go back to see the results you can remember what you did and extrapolate what worked and what didn’t.
  • 20. Imagine ordering at a restaurant from a menu in a language you do not understand. For many people, this is what it is like to try to decide between investing in a “capital appreciation fund” vs a “dynamic dividend fund.” The language of the choice selection makes it very hard to imagine what the options really mean to you.
  • 21. PredicDng Homer’s  AcDons So we know that our gut, our Homer, has more influence our decisions in those types of situations. Fortunately, he’s pretty predictable, and therefore relatively easy to set up safeguards agains. I’ll cover 3 of the main ways to predict what people will do.
  • 22. 1. We have predictable  mental biases.
  • 24. Say I told you, “the population of Chicago is 3 million. What is the population of Milwaukee?” You might guess something like 1 million.
  • 25. If I instead told you, “The population of Green Bay is 100,000. What is the population of Milwaukee?” Most people guessed around 300,000. (The actual population is around 580,000.)
  • 26. Availability Bias: We overes+mate the  likelihood of events we can  easily remember. ?
  • 27. We are much more scared of vivid and easily imagined threats (like plane crashes or tornadoes), than we are of mundane but much more common dangers (like asthma attacks). We are 20x more likely to die of asthma attack than tornado, so if we were purely rational, we’d be 20x more scared of asthma than tornadoes.
  • 29. Based on the beauty pageant contestants you’ve seen in the media lately, you might think that ALL of them are dumb as a post. (That’s not true.) Another example: If you wore your old hat during two games which your team won, you might assume that it’s a lucky hat, and that if you don’t wear it during the next game, your team will lose. (Sorry, there’s no connection.)
  • 31. 90% predict they will score here. - + In one study the authors conducted, 90% of their students predicted they would finish in the top 2 percentiles in their class.
  • 33. It does seem that someone who wears this shirt might only have been half as worked up about getting the gun as he is about losing it.
  • 35. This XBox live offer from Microsoft is banking on people’s personal inertia. You get one month of the gold service for $1, but then every month after that it bills you automatically at the full price. Only 70% of all eligible people ever enroll in their 401ks. Have you adjusted your 401k balance since you first set it up?
  • 36. Framing Bias: “10 out of 100 die.” vs. “90 out of 100 are cured.”
  • 37. July ’08 NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll: Who would be the riskier choice for president? Barack Obama 55% John McCain 35% Who would be the safer choice for president? Barack Obama 41% John McCain 46% Both of these questions were asked in the same poll at the same time of the same people. If the framing of the question had no effect on people, the responses here should just mirror each other.
  • 38. Priming Bias: What we see or hear  immediately before a choice  affects how we behave.
  • 39. When a national survey included this question, it increased purchase rates by 35%. Remember the cafe example from earlier. Just by seeing the phrase “Have you tried the carrot cake” when logging in to the wireless network increases the likelihood you’ll buy some.
  • 40. 2. We predictably succumb  to temptaDon.
  • 41. I’m on a diet.  Planner  The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  • 42. Mmmmmm, donut.... One is ok. Or two. Or three. Doer   The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  • 43. autopilot You also have a third system... Mindless choosing: your autopilot just continues doing what it’s used to - driving the same route, or continuing to eat when there’s food in front of you. There was one study mentioned in the book where participants were given very stale popcorn, either a large bag or a small bag, and then watched a movie. Participants with the large bag ate 34% more, just because it was there and they were on autopilot.
  • 44. 3. We predictably  follow the herd.
  • 45. We like to conform. This is at the root of speculative bubbles, internet memes, and fads. One phenomenon that drives us to conform is the “spotlight effect,” which makes us feel like people are paying closer attention to us--especially when we’re not conforming--than they really are. (I have a feeling this dude with the emover thinks everyone is paying attention to him.)
  • 46. One particularly interesting ramification of the herd behavior is its effect on popularity lists. One experiment offered different groups of people the same set of downloadable mp3s with visible popularity data. In the end, the most popular songs for each group were not predictable and were not similar from group to group, except that they were lucky and picked by the first users of the system.
  • 50. This fly is etched on the urinal as an aiming incentive, and was proven to reduce spillage by 80%. Another example is a social program that gives teen moms a dollar a day every day that they are not pregnant.
  • 52. Mappings means how we translate data about an option into what it actually means for us, like translating kilowatts of energy into dollars on the electricity bill, or translating megapixels to maximum print size.
  • 54. Not new to us - defaults are POWERFUL because of the Status Quo bias. You can default to opt-in, opt-out, or mandatory choice (which is like having yes/no radio buttons with nothing selected).
  • 56. This device is designed to give you feedback about your energy usage AS you are using it. It is also mapping your usage to money, targeting your loss aversion, and it plans to tap into vast social pressures by broadcasting your usage statistics to Facebook and Twitter.
  • 58. Also not new to interaction designers - plan for the errors. This is an example of planning for a (somewhat gruesome) common error tourists make when visiting London.
  • 60. The paradox of choice is reduced if options are grouped. Or use strategies like “collaborative filtering” to reduce options presented. The example above uses many different groupings and filtering options to help you make the very complex choice, “Which of the thousands of songs on this site should I listen to now?”
  • 61. Lots of UX Examples There are lots more examples out there (some of my colleagues will be presenting some now), and now that you know what to look for I’m sure you’ll see them. I’d just like to note that another tool we have as designers that this book doesn’t mention is emotion. Emotion is certainly a strong nudging factor, and many great UX minds such as Don Norman, Robert Fabricant, and Bill Buxton have written and spoken about using emotion in design.
  • 62. Recap Nudges are about designing choices to try to help people make choices more with their rational mind (their inner Spock) and less with their gut. There are certain situations: Benefits now, cost later; decisions we have to make infrequently, places where the feedback isn’t immediate or the outcome is hard to imagine, where the Homer in us has the upper hand, and we can use our knowledge of our predictable psychology in these ways mentioned: incentives, understanding mappings, defaults, giving feedback, and structuring complex choices to nudge our Spock to rebalance the power.
  • 63. PLUG! Join us @ the  UX Book Club! next mee+ng: July 22nd Designing Gestural Interfaces If you like what you saw here, join us! We read Nudge at our last meeting, and we plan to read lots more great stuff in the future. (Come on, all your friends are doing it!)

Editor's Notes

  1. This is just an introduction to the book. If you like what you see here, you should go ahead and read the book, there’s lots more great stuff in there. Both of the authors are economists and professors, and Cass Sunstein now leads the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. In the book they focus on public policy, and situations like healthcare, the environment, and saving for retirement, but many of the concepts they cover have relevance to the kinds of situations and choices we design.
  2. A nudge is any aspect of the design of a choice (“choice architecture”) that alters people’s behavior in a predictable way, without forbidding anything or actually changing the choice at all. The example that went out in the event invitation was the clever internet cafe named their wireless network “Have you tried the carrot cake.”
  3. Many economists (and some of the engineers I know) like to say that we don’t know better than the user/chooser, that we should present all options to people, and let them choose. The authors say this makes the false assumption that almost all people, almost all of the time, make choices that are in their best interest, or at least are better than choices someone else would make for them.
  4. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  5. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  6. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  7. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  8. They are assuming that we are all like Spock. (Or maybe like a true Vulcan, since Spock is actually half human, as we all know.) And like Spock we always only choose the most logical choice. However, while part of our mind really is like Spock, we all have TWO decision makers in our head who battle it out for each decision - our Spock (in scientific terms, our Reflective Cognitive System) and but also our Homer (Automatic Cognitive System).
  9. Here’s a classic example. Spock would look at this image and see clearly that the two tabletops are exactly the same size. But most of us feel pretty sure that the one on the left is longer and skinnier than the one on the right.
  10. So the conclusion the authors draw from this is that SOMETHING is always influencing your choices. People are influenced by small factors in the design of an experience, so even if you don’t consciously design your choice architecture, it is still there, affecting the actions of the choosers.
  11. Here’s another example. In this cafeteria, Spock would only put food on his tray that is good for him, only taking as much as he needs and only what he can afford. But our Homer is in there, reacting instinctively to many things, like which things are at the beginning versus the end, and which things are up at eye level and which are below. In fact, in one study mentioned in the book, the researchers were able to increase or decrease selection of specific foods by 25%, just by rearranging them.
  12. So say you are designing a cafeteria layout. What should you do? Ignore the fact that the layout affects what people buy? Randomly rotate the placement of foods? Set it up to sell the most of the expensive stuff? Or set it up so people choose more healthy foods? The book encourages that last option with what they call “libertarian paternalism” - Nudging the user (through placement, in this example) to make the best choice for his well being - WHAT OUR SPOCK WOULD WANT, while not restricting choice at all. They are not banning junk food, just making it less likely that someone will choose it on their own.
  13. When is our Spock particularly weak and our Homer particularly strong. This happens predictably in the following scenarios:
  14. I enjoy the benefit of this donut now, I pay the cost (to my health, waistline) later. I enjoy coming home to a cool house because my AC was running all day, I pay the costs (both bills and environmental) later.
  15. We get better at everything through practice. If you had to optimize your investments as frequently you have to drive your car, you’d probably be better at it.
  16. Think of the impact digital cameras had on hobby photography, largely because you can see right away what your picture looks like. Making investment decisions is kind of like the old film photography model. You rearrange some stuff, and hope when you go back to see the results you can remember what you did and extrapolate what worked and what didn’t.
  17. Imagine ordering at a restaurant from a menu in a language you do not understand. For many people, this is what it is like to try to decide between investing in a “capital appreciation fund” vs a “dynamic dividend fund.” The language of the choice selection makes it very hard to imagine what the options really mean to you.
  18. So we know that our gut, our Homer, has more influence our decisions in those types of situations. Fortunately he’s pretty predictable.
  19. Say I told you, “the population of Chicago is 3 million. What is the population of Milwaukee?” You might guess something like 1 million.
  20. If I instead told you, “The population of Green Bay is 100,000. What is the population of Milwaukee?” Most people guessed around 300,000. (The actual population is around 580,000.)
  21. ?
  22. We are much more scared of vivid and easily imagined threats (like plane crashes or tornadoes), than we are of mundane but much more common dangers (like asthma attacks). We are 20x more likely to die of asthma attack than tornado, so if we were purely rational, we’d be 20x more scared of asthma than tornadoes.
  23. Based on the beauty pageant contestants you’ve seen in the media lately, you might think that ALL of them are dumb as a post. (That’s not true.) Another example: If you wore your old hat during two games which your team won, you might assume that it’s a lucky hat, and that if you don’t wear it during the next game, your team will lose. (Sorry, there’s no connection.)
  24. In one study the authors conducted, 90% of their students predicted they would finish in the top 2 percentiles in their class.
  25. It does seem that someone who wears this shirt might only have been half as worked up about getting the gun as he is about losing it.
  26. This XBox live offer from Microsoft is banking on people’s personal inertia. You get one month of the gold service for $1, but then every month after that it bills you automatically at the full price. Only 70% of all eligible people ever enroll in their 401ks. Have you adjusted your 401k balance since you first set it up?
  27. Both of these questions were asked in the same poll at the same time of the same people. If the framing of the question had no effect on people, the responses here should just mirror each other.
  28. When a national survey included this question, it increased purchase rates by 35%. Remember the cafe example from earlier. Just by seeing the phrase “Have you tried the carrot cake” when logging in to the wireless network increases the likelihood you’ll buy some.
  29. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  30. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  31. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  32. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  33. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  34. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  35. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  36. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  37. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  38. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  39. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  40. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  41. The authors talk about the Spock-Homer empathy gap. Your planner does not fully appreciate how much your behaviors are altered when you are under the influence of temptation.
  42. You also have a third system... Mindless choosing: your autopilot just continues doing what it’s used to - driving the same route, or continuing to eat when there’s food in front of you. There was one study mentioned in the book where participants were given very stale popcorn, either a large bag or a small bag, and then watched a movie. Participants with the large bag ate 34% more, just because it was there and they were on autopilot.
  43. We like to conform. This is at the root of speculative bubbles, internet memes, and fads. One phenomenon that drives us to conform is the “spotlight effect,” which makes us feel like people are paying closer attention to us--especially when we’re not conforming--than they really are. (I have a feeling this dude with the emover thinks everyone is paying attention to him.)
  44. One particularly interesting ramification of the herd behavior is its effect on popularity lists. One experiment offered different groups of people the same set of downloadable mp3s with visible popularity data. In the end, the most popular songs for each group were not predictable and were not similar from group to group, except that they were lucky and picked by the first users of the system.