Wharton FinTech Club hosted a seminar on P2P (peer-to-peer) lending in October '14. Take a look at our key insights and analyses on this fast-growing industry!
2. Agenda
• News and announcements
• P2P Lending
• Lending Club
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
3. What is P2P Lending?
Loan money to individuals (“peers”) through a simple online platform
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
• Online platforms that connect institutional and
retail investors to borrowers, cutting out traditional
FIs
• Use proprietary credit scoring and checking tools to
establish APRs and offer term loans to borrowers
• Borrowers typically use money to refinance credit
card debt or pay off other obligations
• Lenders can diversify their portfolio through P2P
investments
• Loans are unsecured and risk is borne solely by
investors
• Over $6.0B P2P loans issued to date
LENDING
4. P2P Lending: Key Players
Overview and
market share
Founding and
total loans
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
issued
Borrower profile
Minimum FICO
Loan terms
APR range
Most common
use of loan
• Largest P2P lending
platform
• Market leader– own about
70% share of market
• Second largest P2P lending
player
• About 30% share of market
• Emerging competitor
• Likely <1% market share
• Opened to investors in
2007
• $5.0B in loans to date
• First entrant into P2P
lending; founded in 2006
• $2.0B in loans to date
• Founded in 2012
• Likely about 5,000 loans
funded to date
• Has historically attracted
higher-quality borrowers,
with approval rates at
~10%
• Initially catered to more
sub-prime borrowers;
suffered a 22% total
charge-off rate in 2010
• Targeted towards younger
borrowers with less
established credit histories
• 660 • 640 (imposed after high
post-recession charge offs)
• 640, but do accept
insufficient credit
information
• 3 and 5 year terms • 3 and 5 year terms • 3 year term
• 6.78 – 29.99% • 6.73 – 35.36% • 6 – 24.60%
• Credit card debt
• Credit card debt
consolidation / refinancing
consolidation / refinancing
• Credit card debt
consolidation / refinancing
5. The P2P Business Model
Lending Club, and other P2P platforms, make money off two key revenue streams:
loan origination fees and payments made to investors
• 1% - 5% of the borrowed
principal
• Depends on risk assessment and
borrowers’ creditworthiness
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
1
2
Loan origination fee from borrowers
Ongoing payments to investors
$10,000 loan with 3% origination fee
$300
• 0.5% - 1% of all payments made
to investors
• “Service fee” is assessed from
both interest and principal
$10,000 loan at a 15% interest rate
$3.5 / month
6. Agenda
• News and announcements
• P2P Lending
• Lending Club
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
7. Lending Club: Overview
Lending Club is the market leader in P2P lending, showing rapid growth in loan
issuance over the past five years
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
8. Lending Club: Default Rates
Default rates have recently averaged around 3%, but also vary widely depending
on the loan rating
2012 default rates, by loan type
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
12. P2P Lending: Impact
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
1
2
3
• Rapidly growing space that’s attracting huge
numbers of institutional and individual investors
• Ripple effects into student loans, small business
loans, possibly auto + home loans
• Disintermediation of traditional lenders –
big banks, credit unions and other
financial institutions
• How will they react?
• It’s becoming immensely profitable for the first-movers
• Lending Club IPO announced – currently valued at
$4B, likely will approach ~$6B at time of IPO
13. Investment Evaluation
Should you invest?
Opportunities Risks
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION
• Loans are not collateralized –
should a borrower run into
financial trouble, a P2P loan is
probably last in line for
repayment
• Loan performance is incredibly
volatile and subject to overall
economic conditions
• Great Recession default rates
were in the 10% - 20% range
• Unregulated space that can be
negatively impacted by future
financial regulation
• A new asset class that can be an
easy way to diversify your
investment portfolio
• Recent returns have been
positive
• 5% - 8.5% depending on
investment grade
• Opportunity to cherry-pick
investments
• Social impact – e.g. help others
get out of credit card debt